Its very good. She has a style of her own. But Zhou Xuan is Zhou Xuan.In the 1938 movie you see Zhou Xuan singing happily and slower sadly crying when her boyfriend looked down at her for being a singing girl.At 19 years old,she was and still is the best with this song. Why was i born so late....love her.....
In my opinion, this version has the right singer, unfortunately the music is " modernized " in a wrong way, this song was written for Chow Hsuan and erhu, like a fifty years old brandy, has its own kind of flavor that none of the other wines could have. It's always hard to reject the new comers who did try to do their best, but the facts cannot be ignored. Just my two cents.
her voice is so sweet and the song itself is so, too. but still i prefer the Suzhou dialect version even better. because Mandarin singing gives me something unfitting the sceneries.
I really love her voice, What is her name and does she have a CD to this song she is singing?? I would really love to buy her CD if she has one. It is hard to find a CD like this one, I would really like to get this song. What is her full name?? Also where can I find a DVD like this one she is singing?? Thank you!
what u mean here? are you commenting the singing skills? or it is ur discriminal behav? :) please tell me what 'rural china' should sounds like please...
wow! Nice voice. I agree with the previous poster: rare to find this type of voice these days. I think I have heard the original singer singing this song before (I "think" because I did not confirm the singer true identity) and it sound very much like this singer here.
chinese228... very well said. I agree with you 100%, although i didn't bother to "watch" the mv, the sound alone was enough to disgust, which is exactly like you said 只剩一堆沉重的鋪陳... giving some facade exterior of "傳統中國"特 色 without the real thing, and even worse, pretty much raped 周旋's classic version. It's a disgrace.
to hing 1378. I like french as well. what matelotgeek mean is that you should not consider "China" simply as "the East"... because many eastern countries have their distinct culture.
He didn't mean to insult you as ignorant. Just the idea of "east" is somewhat unacceptable for us.
Qui, l'anglais est une langue non civilise.....So do those people!
Thanks info. I admire people who can read the many symbols of the Chinese Script.
On the other hand: still there are people who even cannot read the 26 letters of the Roman Alphabet. Even in my country ( Holland ) there are people who cannot. A striking contrast.
Nice. A voice with piercing clarity, quite unlike anything I've heard before. I wonder if that's her natural singing style or is it an affectation of Zhou Xuan?
This is an excellent cover! Her voice is so lovely and amazingly expressive. I just wish that they also release a minimalistic version where erhu is the only accompaniment, as in the original, or maybe even "a cappella". Rock-n-roll style or techno style drum beats are just so out-of-place with this song for me.
I'm so happy to see modern singers still interested in the beautiful art of traditional Asian vocal technique. Zhou Xuan had a softer sound, which is what made her so unique and famous - no one will ever be able to emulate her voice - but this artist has a clear, confident sound that is gorgeous as well! What a lovely tribute to the legend. *^_^*
Well said! A voice that's trained to traditional rendition. Indeed, absolute wonderful to know the present generation appreciates Zhou Xuan. Such classics must perpetuate...
Her voice is high tone as well as Zhou Xuan's voice ,but Zhou Xuan has a more sweet voice.and My faverite singer,Teresa teng was singing with softer range .
Well done on video and music edition. This music has different interpretation than the Miss Zhao's oriinal and Teresa's CD. Thank for posting. I enjoy it.
民族美声唱这个不合适。这歌味道全没了
kozlowsiki2000 1 week ago
lovely video
Masterbeanson 3 weeks ago
i totally love the crystal clear pronunciation
jradetzky 1 month ago
我很喜欢
skywalkerami3 1 month ago
真甜 嫁给我吧
skywalkerami3 1 month ago
ชอบอ่ะ
Yaimaijunior 1 month ago
@Yaimaijunior put jin ben le?
YawmZajlaug 1 month ago in playlist จีนโบราณ
Comment removed
michi1229able 2 months ago
Comment removed
michi1229able 2 months ago
เพราะดีครับ...
KMITLKraithong 4 months ago
天涯歌女は、日本にこんな素敵な歌があったのかと、いや、中国のソングかね。
これほど、歌われていながら、しかも素敵なメロディーではないか。
なぜ、知られていないのだろう?。
oyaji2935 5 months ago
but 編曲有一點不習慣
erevase 5 months ago
精彩的演出 出色的嗓音
erevase 5 months ago
Such a beautiful voice and language:)
chambver 6 months ago
Pretty girl in a very pretty remix.
Zarkovision 6 months ago
I like the the way its been arranged
juschill08 6 months ago
had this on an old album thank you for this
juschill08 6 months ago
omFG.. This is beyond godlike!!
XimXaiFung 7 months ago
民族唱法的天涯歌女,找到些许周旋的影子
sunnie2011 7 months ago
她的女大學生造型少了嬌嗲,多了清秀,也是很美。
Mrekst 8 months ago 3
I don't understand what the song means
But
I love this song since I was young
werakiatthailand 8 months ago
i love this song and her voice. so beautiful
Yellowfirefly 8 months ago
this is the CULTURE
Idorun100 8 months ago
amazing voice,,like my wife, when she was younger , but the voice will never change
Idorun100 8 months ago
@Idorun100 You are a lucky man, cherish her.
Mrekst 7 months ago
17people are totally stupid)
Arthur85is 8 months ago
17 people are haters!
geek1O1 9 months ago
李香蘭唱的也很好
matthewycso 9 months ago
周璇、鄧麗君都己作故,張燕唱得也不錯啊。少了滄桑感是因為經歴不同吧,總不成每首歌都只有一個人唱,珍惜眼前人,多給年青歌手鼓勵吧!
Mrekst 9 months ago
very moving ,,great voice
Idorun100 9 months ago
It should have a "Love" button as well ... just beautiful!!!
InDaSpotLight4Life 9 months ago 10
love this,
SandyKellymtv2 10 months ago
李紅蘭?
mrcrocent 11 months ago
Beautiful!! why is there 17 ppl dislike this song?? crazy!
CodyYaj 11 months ago
@CodyYaj Maybe because there is an other version of this song they prefer ;)
666IsoldeBaden666 10 months ago
so beautiful!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
AIKOAIKOSAN 1 year ago
omg she's so pretty!!!!!!!like her very much
olivier828 1 year ago
wow.. the "classic" vocal is the most beautiful.
dennisbbb 1 year ago
very nice
khatpandwa 1 year ago
Its very good. She has a style of her own. But Zhou Xuan is Zhou Xuan.In the 1938 movie you see Zhou Xuan singing happily and slower sadly crying when her boyfriend looked down at her for being a singing girl.At 19 years old,she was and still is the best with this song. Why was i born so late....love her.....
ahhingme 1 year ago
I like this version & singer.
netelsg 1 year ago
if you actually think this sounds good listen to 周璇, it is clear who sung better.
邓丽君 sounds better too :\
MrBigEnchilada 1 year ago
excellent one can not resise the voice,,
Idorun100 1 year ago
mira no se nada de este tipo de musica, pero la escuche y me gusto mucho...!
microeconomia123 1 year ago
In my opinion, this version has the right singer, unfortunately the music is " modernized " in a wrong way, this song was written for Chow Hsuan and erhu, like a fifty years old brandy, has its own kind of flavor that none of the other wines could have. It's always hard to reject the new comers who did try to do their best, but the facts cannot be ignored. Just my two cents.
255duck 1 year ago
少了沧桑的感觉呢....
wlwlnana 1 year ago
her voice is so sweet and the song itself is so, too. but still i prefer the Suzhou dialect version even better. because Mandarin singing gives me something unfitting the sceneries.
ayanuhito 1 year ago
very rare lady,,so sad the way she died,,
Idorun100 1 year ago
@Idorun100 OH NO!!! Did she die? How? When? T_T
jradetzky 1 year ago
@jradetzky ,,read some history of China,,,
Idorun100 1 year ago
@jradetzky not this lady in MV. the died one was born in 1920's.
theme520 1 year ago
Love this song, thank you so much!
chininha1949 1 year ago
Beautifull song.
vangborrie 1 year ago
Superb!
dannypig71 1 year ago
I really love her voice, What is her name and does she have a CD to this song she is singing?? I would really love to buy her CD if she has one. It is hard to find a CD like this one, I would really like to get this song. What is her full name?? Also where can I find a DVD like this one she is singing?? Thank you!
Fallyne2186 1 year ago
Comment removed
Fallyne2186 1 year ago
I really Love this song, what is she singing about??
Fallyne2186 1 year ago
A timeless classic!
rgb555 1 year ago 2
@rgb555 Hi guys , I liked the music but I can't understand Chinese can you tell me what this song is about ?
Thank you !
rhtbapat 1 year ago
@rhtbapat Just go to Wikipedia and search under: "The Wandering Songstress", you will find all the answers better than I can offer. Have fun.
rgb555 1 year ago
@rhtbapat About a girl looking for true love.
democracy4cn 1 year ago
Hypnotically beautiful. Thank you.
yumgnoc 1 year ago 3
Love this melody . So cute.
acheungwhitecrane 1 year ago
我热热心心的赞美你!
真好听!
fupenjiu 1 year ago
另一種風格,效果還不錯!
TheSmilecosh 2 years ago
加了太多电子音乐 少了周旋唱得质朴
cushing2002 2 years ago
@cushing2002 又怎可以這樣說了, 時代進步, 要配樂好, 要效果好, 那當然要添加色彩和
花巧, 現今做到了, 但不代表周那時不好, 回想一下, 那時的流聲機不是很偉大的發明了嗎,
莫非那時或要說流聲機或不似人聲, 都是叫人在旁唱的好嗎????????
lcsthomas 1 year ago
very nice song i enjoyed to listen
khatpandwa 2 years ago
請問這部影片裡的水彩畫是誰畫的呢??畫的主題是江蘇嗎??很美呢.
ayumiayu01 2 years ago 3
enchanting...
andromedananda 2 years ago
变味的天涯歌女。
20090S 2 years ago 2
還是周璇 唱的最有感覺
orz0430 2 years ago
@orz0430 金嗓子呢, 誰人可比. 但她郤真的唱得不錯. 別具韻味. 現今比周璇唱得好大有人在,但周唱的韻味郤沒人可比, 可是她也有缺點, 就是咬字不清, 要明白她唱什么的就得要全看歌詞. 但這不就是她的與眾不同嗎!!!!!!!!!!!!!
lcsthomas 1 year ago
@lcsthomas
You are so right! the real Zhou Xuan is INCOMPARABLE.
Also though this girls sounds good, one cannot deny the voice is enhanced a little by a flattering echo
thepalacemaid 1 year ago
切少了那份沧桑
mecekho 2 years ago 5
excellent!!!
funnyperson200 2 years ago
Comment removed
williamlew777 2 years ago
天籟之音.很出色.
safarihk 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
She sounds like some peasant from rural china.
fafeifa 2 years ago
what u mean here? are you commenting the singing skills? or it is ur discriminal behav? :) please tell me what 'rural china' should sounds like please...
CYK84 2 years ago
Her name Is Chow Hsuan.
S600CA 2 years ago
wow! Nice voice. I agree with the previous poster: rare to find this type of voice these days. I think I have heard the original singer singing this song before (I "think" because I did not confirm the singer true identity) and it sound very much like this singer here.
smithwood233 2 years ago 3
It's so rare to find this type of voice these days...
SMKTS 2 years ago 22
@SMKTS
not rare,but the youth in China dislike the kinda. they think it's out of time.
22572008 1 year ago
@SMKTS
You must be outside of China for long time, my friend.
kalasend 1 year ago
@kalasend I haven't been to China.. LOL
SMKTS 1 year ago
@SMKTS it sounds like she's trying too hard to sound soft or high pitched, that's different from the old days....
MrBigEnchilada 1 year ago
Her voice is very very close to Zhou's voice. and I enjoy listening to it.
S600CA 2 years ago 6
The vocal and music arrangement here are unique and outstanding.
wingklow 2 years ago 16
too much good
180mill 2 years ago 3
唯独高亢处还比不上周璇。
neversword 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
這首歌真有夠難聽了
porkhere 2 years ago
this is wonderful for me
glovetailor 2 years ago
谁能告诉我怎么录进电脑?
soloho989 3 years ago
天涯歌女 Lyric (your welcome!)
天涯呀 海角, 觅呀觅知音, 小妹妹唱歌
郎奏琴, 郎呀咱们俩是一条心 爱呀爱呀 郎呀
咱们俩是一条心 家山呀 北望 泪呀泪沾襟
小妹妹想郎 直到今 郎呀患难之交恩爱深
爱呀爱呀 郎呀 患难之交恩爱深 人生呀
谁不惜呀惜青春 小妹妹似线 郎似针 郎呀 穿在一起不离分
爱呀爱呀 郎呀 穿在一起不离分
Wodz30 3 years ago 2
糟粕啊....
alexghz 3 years ago
是不是她的声音太明亮了? 没有忧郁柔弱的感觉?
jill198751 3 years ago 3
真是糟蹋了原作。如果周璇地下有知,大概會氣得直跳腳吧!
chinese228 3 years ago
为什么?
jill198751 3 years ago
i think zhang yan sang better than zhou xuan,
she would be delighted with such type of modern computer imaging and setting.
aliowhk 2 years ago
哪點比較好?
這部mv無論是唱腔 裝扮 或拍攝手法
無不刻意模仿周旋的版本
可是時空隔閡相差70年
以致於這手法只是畫虎不成反類犬
不但沒唱出新意 連原作的簡單感都沒了
只剩一堆沉重的鋪陳
如此 不說糟蹋了原作 要說啥??
chinese228 2 years ago 5
thanks your comment.
life should move on with computer imaging and setting, and lest not compare those era back 70yrs ago.
She's really great vocal and sweet voice.
she's selected to perform during Bill Clinton official visit to China. and later,
the president ask for her CD to take home
aliowhk 2 years ago 3
為何不要與過去的版本比較?
如果說這隻mv有獨特之處,我當然會說好,問題就在於沒有.既然沒有,這支mv除了仿古,就是仿古.可是又仿的非常不自然,以至於不比的話講不出特色ˇ,一比之下卻會有糟蹋原作之嘆.
至於洋人,除非是漢學家或中國通,不然只要是帶有"傳統中國"特色的東西,10個有8個會說好,更何況是需要做面子的一國元首.既然如此,又何必拿洋人的標準評斷中國的藝術?
chinese228 2 years ago 3
chinese228... very well said. I agree with you 100%, although i didn't bother to "watch" the mv, the sound alone was enough to disgust, which is exactly like you said 只剩一堆沉重的鋪陳... giving some facade exterior of "傳統中國"特 色 without the real thing, and even worse, pretty much raped 周旋's classic version. It's a disgrace.
briefbrief 2 years ago
sugoi song i love it n_n
hinatashygirl1 3 years ago
Beautiful!
obbytoo 3 years ago
i think this is the best version of the song
kaoklaibb 3 years ago 6
張燕唱的這個版本也很好聽,好喜歡!
leen0backery 3 years ago 5
我还听过一首用苏州话唱的版本,也非常好听!
tobeornot00 3 years ago
beautiful video, nice move and powerful voice.
jjasuc 3 years ago
i like this mordern twist to a classic golden oldie..!!
9yippy 3 years ago 5
跟周璇一樣可愛(小巧玲瓏)聲又甜.
happywa 3 years ago
wooh! i love zhou xuan's song..la vivre la chanteuse.
IMpinokio 3 years ago
me 2
tEnKaIcHi03 3 years ago
she's gorgeous !
matelotgeek 3 years ago 2
beautifull woman!!!!
Almuada84 3 years ago 4
Can't have enough of this! Great girl, great song. So sweet.
rogerlovesjenny 3 years ago 3
我这里的一个白人小子爱的不行,不过这就是中国歌曲,没办法翻译。东方就是着么神秘。
hing1378 3 years ago
I think he can take a look at the subtitle of this part in the Chinese movie "Lust.Caution (Se Jie)".
aqixinzz 3 years ago
So this is the song the actress sings in the japanese place?
1Haraadoll 3 years ago
Right.
aqixinzz 3 years ago
> hing1378:
> 东方就是着么神秘
ummm...what are you ? the typical "American tourist" ? ("Do you speak English ?")...it's not the East is "mytical", it's your fucking ignorance.
matelotgeek 3 years ago
no , i don't speak english.
parce que l'anglais est une langue NON CIVILISE.
mes ignorances sont totales , alors ? alors?
hing1378 3 years ago
de la France?
tobeornot00 3 years ago
to hing 1378. I like french as well. what matelotgeek mean is that you should not consider "China" simply as "the East"... because many eastern countries have their distinct culture.
He didn't mean to insult you as ignorant. Just the idea of "east" is somewhat unacceptable for us.
Qui, l'anglais est une langue non civilise.....So do those people!
jill198751 3 years ago
Unacceptable? Yes we care what you racist idiot think.
dgfpat 2 years ago
i think you are retarded.
zhengwng 2 years ago
棒極了!那兒可買到?
catpan2008 3 years ago
i like this version a lot, it is simple and clever to put it together like this.
kenluikhing 3 years ago 2
Do she have i English name?
Srnty28 3 years ago
和周旋声音还蛮像的呢!
jossygu220 3 years ago
Comment removed
tw19710820 3 years ago
Is she Chow Shien? I am from holland cannot read the chinese script.
Very good voice and surrealistic.
field68 3 years ago
This singer is Zhang Yan.
seitch 3 years ago
Thanks info. I admire people who can read the many symbols of the Chinese Script.
On the other hand: still there are people who even cannot read the 26 letters of the Roman Alphabet. Even in my country ( Holland ) there are people who cannot. A striking contrast.
field68 3 years ago
歌家是谁啊?
Bodafon 3 years ago
Not only great song but also grat singer!!
Everyone loves originals better...but we should admit tht's really an amazing revisitation
zhongguo jia you!!
brubapink 3 years ago
she has a lovely voice,and the vid is really fancy。但是导演和歌手都把这首歌的味道把握错了。。。it should not be fancy
mariecurierocks 3 years ago
Thanks, Nice old style setting.
field68 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this version is gay, the original is better, the singer is pretty though
dan020350 3 years ago
its nice ^_^
IchigoRingo1982 3 years ago
Nice. A voice with piercing clarity, quite unlike anything I've heard before. I wonder if that's her natural singing style or is it an affectation of Zhou Xuan?
pervertt 3 years ago 6
是不是浙江人啊!跟周璇,邓丽君,李香蘭她們不同!
engles2008 3 years ago
amazing ... gave me the shivers
peggyzoewong 3 years ago 2
Wonderful song!!
OfraHaza1957 3 years ago 3
so sweet
onegoodman66 4 years ago 2
oh god bless chinese music. i like teresa teng sing this song but this new version is sill great too and the voice is pure.
moutaz from saudi arabia
javlover666 4 years ago 3
This is an excellent cover! Her voice is so lovely and amazingly expressive. I just wish that they also release a minimalistic version where erhu is the only accompaniment, as in the original, or maybe even "a cappella". Rock-n-roll style or techno style drum beats are just so out-of-place with this song for me.
ReanimatedFeline 4 years ago
Great Old Song!
Horseshoebender 4 years ago
I like this Chinese girl. She sounds so sweet, and music sounds from her heart.
tonybostonian1234 4 years ago 3
好美的声音呀,人又长得漂亮!!!
knightcrusaders 4 years ago
可能需稍緩衝
songyang19850617 4 years ago
周璇固然出色,号称金嗓子,我们看看作曲 贺渌汀。贺渌汀,原名贺安卿,又名贺抱真 、贺揩等。1903年出生于湖南邵阳东乡为左翼进步影片《船家女》、《乡愁》、《都市风光》、《压岁钱》、《十字街头》、《马路天使》以及话剧《复活》、《武则天》等配乐,创作了《摇船歌》、 《春天里》、《秋 水伊人》、
arielhe 4 years ago
周璇是江苏常州人,混迹上海滩,可是真的 江山北望了。。。 我们是家国东望。。。
arielhe 4 years ago
金嗓子周璇,老歌新唱,顶一下!
arielhe 4 years ago
はたし ぞっとした!!!
bistruc 4 years ago
thank you.
arielhe 4 years ago
Wow, they really brought this classic song to a whole new level! Excellent vocals and decent music arrangment.
Mayonaise21 4 years ago
good song,
sweet voice,
good composing,
good animation,
traditional Chinese painting art blended with computer animation,
good job,
good uploading
I had a good time
ShuaiJiaoY 4 years ago 2
老歌新唱
別有一番韻味
重要的是
這位歌手也很有江南佳麗的風韻
她叫什麼名字啊??
vosswang 4 years ago
張燕
songyang19860617 4 years ago
[天涯歌女]新舊唱....新出耳油,舊盡癡纏!
gmhk 4 years ago
what a beauty..
lazylus 4 years ago
ni shuo putonghua le! wow!
serxiong 4 years ago
She did a splendid job. Her voice is perfect for singing traditional chinese folk songs. I love her rendition of one of my best beloved songs!
mansee 4 years ago 2
(REPOST) She let me feel a traditional sound and am splendid.
shiguma2k 4 years ago
very good singing wow good job
emmanuel763 4 years ago
Very Sweet voice indeed . a fabulous new talent.
hakkalow 4 years ago 2
I'm so happy to see modern singers still interested in the beautiful art of traditional Asian vocal technique. Zhou Xuan had a softer sound, which is what made her so unique and famous - no one will ever be able to emulate her voice - but this artist has a clear, confident sound that is gorgeous as well! What a lovely tribute to the legend. *^_^*
UreMezzo 4 years ago
Well said! A voice that's trained to traditional rendition. Indeed, absolute wonderful to know the present generation appreciates Zhou Xuan. Such classics must perpetuate...
kindface 4 years ago
thanx for posting, hao ting, xie xie.
northpine 4 years ago
meiyizu ting, qingshen kai xinde rizi! :D
zhonghua2006 4 years ago
Her voice is high tone as well as Zhou Xuan's voice ,but Zhou Xuan has a more sweet voice.and My faverite singer,Teresa teng was singing with softer range .
shiguma2k 4 years ago
中国唱民歌的我最喜欢的就是她了!
hualushui 4 years ago
wonderfull music
zhonghua2006 4 years ago
張燕,人靚歌甜,出身中國音樂學院三年的訓練,是我的摯愛
johnnysdu 4 years ago
she has the beautiful voice.
pf112233 4 years ago
Very good, I like her.
johnnysdu 4 years ago
Zhou Xuan's voice is much sweeter than this show's. She was an extremely beautiful singer.
lllmusic 4 years ago
Good reperformance of Zhou's voice.
chankath 4 years ago
Like it, pretty.
dosnmatter 4 years ago
Hi seashadowx,
Well done on video and music edition. This music has different interpretation than the Miss Zhao's oriinal and Teresa's CD. Thank for posting. I enjoy it.
millridge 4 years ago