Pt1 Some truth about Afghanistan, India, Pakistan, & the West. "ERIC MARGOLIS"

[WeaponDesign]

IN INDIA MUSLIMS DONT SUPPORT PAKISTAN, THIS ERIC DOES NOT KNOW!

[PNACATTACKdotCOM]

GREAT  JOURNALIST!

[pogularocky]

LOL... The Hindu King wanted to join India? What is this guy smoking? Seriously! That jackass of a King created this Kashmiri mess for India precisely because he did not join the Indian Union when he was supposed to. He wanted to have his own kingdom, until Pakistan invaded his little shit-hole. He then panicked and asked for India's help. It was then, that India put forward the condition that help will come only if he joins the Indian Union.

This guy is either ignorant or on ISI paycheck.

[hankstom123]

its a incorrect view.

[robaspiring]

Continued.... Kashmir. The intellectuals are happier with india as they recognise their benefits well enough. Eric overlooks the kashmiri pandit genocide motivated and funded by pakis. No doubt abt ISI STATEGIC wing sponsors such work.

[robaspiring]

Eric margolis has a very superficial idea of kashmir problem. Sad he has been called an expert. It is only the brainwashed paki bred kashmiri muslims that are against india. They too want independdnt

[shahjee273]

@gophalraj, Eric Margolis is the most Knowleledge Political Analyist in the west about India and Pakistan.

[kokoinmars]

A very simplistic and half baked description of the south asia situation. I am not saying India, my country, has no contribution in this problem, but this margolis guy's explanation are simply amateurish and do a great disservice to any viewer who is actually interested in learning more about this topic. Viewers, please do try to look for a second opinion.

[TAMILIMAT]

crap..this insane guy should be in a mental asylum...or was this filmed in a mental asylum? BS

[PAKLANDRAND]

mr margolis is ass hole ,, he is favoring paki terror ,

[camzidan]

Pakistan is a failed state whose socio-economic collapse is on the corner. India is one of the fastest growing superpowers. India doesn't need nuclear weapons to decimate Pakis. India's population is 1.3 billion and Pakistan's population is 180 million. Do the math? Indians can literally beat Pakistani with blows into annihilation.

[understandingicse]

He is an idiot  ..........those terrorists......WERE FROM PAKISTAN...........AND THE MUSLIMS ARE MORE HAPPY IN INDIA THAN IN PAKISTAN

[understandingicse]

BULLSHIT!!!!!!!!!

[anuhpd]

Mr looser dont comment on something that you dont know we dont deals Muslims like you do to blacks,51 Pilgrims are burned alive in gujrat that cozed gujraat riots ,and pakistanis were behind mumbai attacks they wre fm raavalpindi,multan and islamabad you idiot

[gophalraj]

This idiot does not know what he is talking. The turnout in this election in Kasmir was 60%. If they dont believe in democracy and the leaders that stood why do you think they vote.

[shahjee273]

@gophalraj Election in Kashmir 60% turn out was for Local, Municipality election. Its Idiotic to portrait as plebcite of the UN Resolution. If U stop drinking Cow'sPee, only than U can see the real picture.hahaha

[XBestXWorstX]

Spot on Mr ERIC MARGOLIS. This is really an EYE opener for those who want to know about Kashmir.

Israel oppression in Palestine = Indian oppression in Kashmir

[tubeb151]

Similarly now the whole world knows & even Pak has accepted that Mumbai massacre was carried by its citizens. Indian govt has provided text msgs, voice samples of the perpetrators to Pak Govt & asked them to arrest the leaders. Pak govt has taken zero action against them. They are roaming freely in Pakistan under the state protection. And this Margolis guy is a supposed analyst who cannot even connect two dots & draw a straight line. I wonder how such gullible people get on TV?

[tubeb151]

Could this Eric Margolis guy be any more "clueless"? Pakistan sent their soldiers into Kargil(Kashmir) in 1999 & claimed they were not their soldiers but mujahideen. India won that war & sent the pakistani army dead bodies back to them. Pakistanis were so two faced liars that they didn't accept the bodies claiming that they were not their military personnel. Now after 10 years, Pakistani army website updates their "killed in combat" list & awarded medals to their posthumously. Never trust them.

[drprasad79]

what about kashmiri pandits and the muslim insurgence from pakistan. why is this person called an expert.he has no sense of the history

[drprasad79]

wrong map. why is pok not highlighted

[widluvrohit]

The guys is talking superficially on some of the very complicated issues. And is somehow depicting India as the evil in Kashmir which is not true.

[bandhurey]

Mar... Golis... a self appointed expert on South Asia. He can smile all he want, but what he says makes him a hate monger, propagandist, and a supporter of terrorism.

[neil7711]

dick head This Canadian... first tell us what you guys did to aborigine people in Canada and still doing ..., what about the holocaust of aborigine people when your church minister was involved and when 1 of your minister stood up your govt. make his life miserable... first talk about your thing then talk about India. ass hole

[mit11365]

This man is a fake. Muslims in India have equal rights. Except for Gujrat riots. That was an exception. Mumbai massacre wasn't doen by Indian muslims. This guy is trying to please the audience back home in Pakistan where he lives. Obviously he feels insecure there so wants to please people there.

[mit11365]

By way of background, Eric calls Pakistan his home and has been living there for years. BUt I love to read his writings.

All 3-4 wars were started by Pakistan which was not informed in this program.

India does not use strong arm tactics as being said in this program. Where there is a war, there has not been any war in any part of the world where human rights allegations have not been there. The soldiers are under intense pressure of comming under attack from terrorists hiding among reg ppl

[mit11365]

Most violence in India is Pakistan ISI inspired. They have cultivated some 12-15000 sleeper cells in India

[mit11365]

contd... Indian police take the beating but don't shoot unless it becoems really bad. If students throw stones, they also throw stones instead of firing rubber bullets or anything else. This is all about mindless injection of religion as has been happening with Muslims over the centuries.

[mit11365]

contd... Taliban to attack Kashmir and occupied 1/3rd of it that the Kashmir ruler signed up with India and asked India for protection. Currently only Muslims are protestings, there are no protests from other communities. Muslims also began protests when Pakistanis started sending their leftover terrorits at end of Afghan war to Kashmir from 1987 onwards for next 10-13 years. Most killings happened by the terrorists occupying houses and fighting the Indian authorities. Today Indian police..

[mit11365]

contd... protesting inspite of equal tretement by Indians and inspite of special facilities accorded to Kashmir (unliek what Pakistanis have done- allowing Pakistanis to buy land, giving away a chunk of land to China) is because the illeterate elders imbibed in their minds when they were young that being Muslims they should be with Pakistan. India did not forcibly occupy Kashmir. The ruler wanted to retain his kingdom so he didn't choose India or Pakistan. It is only when Pakistan sent tribal ..

[mit11365]

This guy Eric Margolis didn't do any justice to the stroy of Kashmir. he summrized it so much that he distorted the history. I read this guys columns so I am dissapointed at either his lack of understanding or unnecessary brevity in explanation.

The real story- Kashmir is not just Muslims but also Hindus, Ladhakis, Buddists etc. Muslims whevever they are on the borders of a nation will create problems in any nation. An elderly Muslin told me that the reason Muslins in Kashmir are....



[Slayerfan84]

Even with that map in front of her, Sarah Palin would still have a difficult time locating Kashmir.!

[mark12345678965]

mumbai drama fake.

[pakhtonalak1947]

One simple question for all indians and to those who think Pakistan is a terrorist country. You never hear Paki soldier killing raping or arresting innocent kashmiri ppl. How come in media even in indian media you always get to hear all these allegation from indian media too innocent kashmiri gets killed rapped or arrested by Indian soldiers? Y there is 500,000 indian soldiers in Disputed kashmir not in kashmir which is under Pakistan?

[pakcannon]

Millions of ppl in india are living subhuman lives. These ppl are called Untouchables and Dalits. Their sole pupose in life is to clean the excrements of their fellow high class indians who enjoy superior and luxirious life styles. These same high class indians live in Canada and US and talk about democracy and freedom. funny isn't it.

[Famousx81]

@ziz

And yr giving Pakistan too much credit for the unrest in Kashmir. Kahmir has never been peaceful, what book have u been reading? And I knw abt india's obsession with secularization...it's more like a race to be like the west.

[Famousx81]

@zizpong, India is also knwn by the name Hindustan, which means a Hindu state. India, a democratic state, has a large population of Muslims that are subject to discrimination, oppression and treated like dirt. Does democracy not apply to them? What abt the human rights violations within India of Indians and in Kashmir of Kashmiris? It's a great image of democracy they r selling, holding a country at gun point.

[sthapanam]

@Famousx81

India had been a successful country since 1947 compared to Pak. Firstly how many military dictators have u seen by now who ruined your country for their personal gains? Not a single democratic govt. full term in office. Secondly how many non-Muslims r there in your govt. machinery while India has always given the non-Hindus especially the Muslims a greater chance to play in the mainstream govt. machinery, many of them famous personalities u know. What do u want to say about that?

[sthapanam]

@Famousx81

Pakistan was created on simply religious grounds and declared itself as an Islamic state while India never hesitated to declare itself a secular state, for all religions to thrive. Pak split immediately into 2 in 1971. Just compare yourself. India has the most complex caste and subcaste system in the world, still it stands distinct. Why? Because we know what a country means. Your army raped and killed thousands of Bengali Muslims in 1971. Were they not human right violations??

[shahjee273]

@sthapanam It was UR Indian army dressed as in Pakistani uniform raped the Bengali women, just as India send in ,indian army as MUKHTI BAHANI. Dirty Hindu played a dirty game.

[sthapanam]

@shahjee273

ha ha ha ha....our army dressed in pak uniform??? that is another of your govt's false propaganda to hide the truth. Your govt. always told u that u were winning the war in 1971. When the pak public came to know the truth of their 90,000 soldiers surrendering before the Indian army and signing the surrender between Gen. Niazi and Gen. Arora, riots broke out in Karachi against your govt due to frustration. Just see how every time your military govts. have put in dark....

cont.

[shahjee273]

@sthapanam U call India SECULAR.But ithas another name Hidustan, a Hindu Mother land, whereHindu extremist operate openly and with the blessing of ruling class.They carry out masacre of Muslims in Gujrat , Sikhs in Delhi, Christians in Orisa. RRS, Balrangdal, Hindutva,Balthakaray. These criminals never brought to Hustice.Cuz UR national policy is lies and Deception.U make a noise of Secularism, but U practice Hindu Domination and deny the rights to minorites, even Hindu Dailet.

[sthapanam]

@shahjee273

I will tell one more example of how your govt. deceives u every time. During the Kargil war, your govt refused to accept the dead bodies of pak officers saying it as mujahideens. This was to show the world that the pak army has not crossed the LOC....do u think we r fools?....what a pity!!......at last with the permission of our govt. our army gave a decent burial to them covered in your flag and according to the Islamic tradition by our Indian Muslim soldiers...go and search facts

[shahjee273]

@sthapanam B4 1947, Punjab, Sind, Blauchistan, N.W.F.P, Kashmir, Bengal, Asam were Muslim Majority states.Hindu Congress denied the rights of muslim majority and forced the partition.Read the Book JINNAH published in India.Partition was on the basis that muslim Majority area will be Pakistan.With lies and deception Hindu invaded Kashmir and occupied. Where indian stste terrorism is going on for the last 63 yrs. Killing half a million kashmiris since 1947. This is DEMOCRACY indian style.

[Famousx81]

It was quite amusing that as soon as the attack hapnd, India pointed its finger at Pakistan, not hesitating for a bit to think abt the unrest within its own home, the brewing oppression that cud be responsible for it.

[Famousx81]

@zizpong,

Pakistan is not an extremist state. It's another story that it's facing a compromising situation. No matter how secular Kashmir is or becomes it still has stronger ties to Pakistan and the wide sentiment there is to join Pakistan. If they want to be a separate state, all the power to them. But india is a big fat hypocrite bec it claims to be tolerant and respectful of human rights and dares to sell this sophisticated image overseas while the situation is diametrical to this claim.

[zizpong]

The guests is an outsider so I do not blame him, but I wonder how some one so famous (I think he is) and knowledgeable person thinks the solution is so simple. Muslim majority = Pakistan or Hindu Majority = India. Unfortunately its not such a simple solution. India is not a Hindu country but Pakistan is a Muslim country. There are more Muslims in India than in Pakistan. India is struggling to maintain its status as a plural, secular country.

[zizpong]

@zizpong You can not just divide secular countries based on religion, color of the people or the language etc. If that was the case then Qubeq in Canada would have been a separate country by now.

Kashmiri's and Indians are basically secular people and historically Kashmir is always part of India for thousands of years. The fact that Kashmir was peaceful till late 80's speaks about sudden jehadist support from Pakistan and its propaganda based on religion.

[zizpong]

Part 3 - The formula of Muslim = Pakistan and Hindu = India is a perfect recipe of a great blunder. The way ahead is force Pakistan from meddling and supporting in Kashmir and India, give 5-10 years to Kashmir to improve its socio-economic conditions and then hold elections (even India successfully conducts elections now). Kasmiri's being secular people will never opt for Pakistan.

[shahjee273]

@zizpong Secularism is cleverly invented term for the domination of Hindu and Hinduism.As a community Muslim , Christians, Sikhs, even Dailet R third and Fourth class citizen.Muslims , Sikhs, Christians, and Dailet R attacked by the Hindu Extremist and they R never brought to Justice .This is a Democracy of Indian Style.

India had election for adminstration of Local Bodies.They never asked them the where they like to be with, as Nehru went to united nation and decleared.

[shahjee273]

@zizpong Before 1947 Areas ,which is now Pakistan was part of India. Inspite that muslim Mojority in Punjab, sind, Blauchistan,N.W.F.P, Kashmir, Bengal, Asam, UR Hindu Congress was not ready to declear as muslim mojority states in India.Thus sepration took place.U have half a million Militry and paramilitry forces in Kashmir to supress them.This is a secularism and Democracy INDIAN STYLE.

[fun435]

indian accept thiz they were indian stop playing blame games!!!!!!

[rajeevrp]

Wow ... everybody else in the world does human-right violations except America. What US has done in Iraq in past several years was so good and humanitarian, I am immensely touched by their great work there.

Mr. WhoverYouAre, Don't cook the stories about the history of Kashmir, and exaggerate casualty figures of Gujarat riots and muslims conditions in India.

You're factually wrong in your analysis.

[desicanadiano]

Eric Margolis is wrong to suggest that young muslims who attacked mumbai were indians. It's been abundantly clear that they were all pakistani muslims who sneaked into mumbai using the ocean route. But he is right about the pogrom in Gujarat and world needs to do more to bring the chief minister of gujarat, Mr. Narendra Modi, to justice.

[fun435]

@desicanadiano oi hello they were indian how can tht be possible stop blaming pakistan now your navy was red alert and our navy too those didn't came from pakistan bz if they would have been detected they were from india nt pakistan!!!!!!

[desicanadiano]

@fun435 You own government has admitted to mumbai attackers being pakistani and has even charged 7 individuals including Zaki-ur-Rehman Lakhvi (LeT commander). Also David Headley (aka Daood Sayed Gilani), a US citizen, was charged for mumbai attacks and he plead guilty. He testified that he worked on instructions from ISI & Pak army officials alongside with LeT in facilitating attacks on India. US has also charged Tawwahur Hussain Rana, a canadian citizen, for these attacks.

[fun435]

@desicanadiano really u think so our government iz kind of puppet they can accept if America said it and as for the terrorist they given money to speak aganist pakistan tht and they will ofcourse say tht we cam from pakistan!!!!! look mumbai and karachi iz far very far away cities and they can't come at night they would have started their journey in the morning if they have came from pakistan which i doubt it then even pakistan navy would have noticed and aswell for indian navy!!!!!

[desicanadiano]

@fun435 So your gov't is a puppet and everyone including terrorists and the world are lying!! I guess so did the over 650 ppl who testified at kasab's trial including FBI, foreigners, Thruya satellite phone officials etc... My friend, what is more likely that there's a worldwide conspiracy or you are in denial?? Please read your ambassador Hussain Haqqani & Ahmed Rashid's book which details the long history ISI has in nurturing jehad.

[fun435]

@desicanadiano u had only 26/11 bt we in pakistan have a lots of 26/11 happened in which lots of pakistani ppl lost their lives and when ISI and police collected the evidence its was proved tht indian RAW was involved on sri lanka attack and many more in lahore how would u feel now when i say tht your india have done lots of 26/11 to pakistani!!!!of course u will denied and bt i don't i only say tht those were terrorist nt pakistani!!!! pakistani don't kill innocent ppl!!!!!!

[desicanadiano]

@fun435 If india is involved in anything like that then it should be made public with evidence. Now India has done that with 26/11 and I am glad pakistan has charged some of the culprits. It's a step in the right direction.

[fun435]

@desicanadiano right bt we made it public and i only want to see keshab death bz ppl like him don't deserve to live in thiz world!!!!!!

[desicanadiano]

@fun435 You would be happy to know he's been given death sentence. But I lose you when you don't take seriously what he's said and done.. There's volumes of testimony & evidence but you so conveniently overlook them all in favour of some far fetched self serving conspiracy theory...

[fun435]

@desicanadiano i know tht its nt ISI or pak army who did thiz and if india media say tht its ISI then its feel bad u know!!!!!i am nt sure its conspiracy theory or nt bt i know tht true pakistani was nt involved in thiz act!!!!

[desicanadiano]

@fun435 How do you know that? You saying 'i know' is not good enough in face of all the available evidence. I see you live in UK, even in your country the 2005 london train bombing & 2006 transatlantic aircraft plot had pakistani connections. Now you may not want to call them 'true pakistani' but they were pakistani nonetheless. This 'jihadi culture' emanating from pakistan can not come to such prominence without official patronage.

[fun435]

@desicanadiano look i know my country well thiz all conspiracy by CIA and Mossad to destablize pakistan and prove it the pakistan iz exports terrorism and its nuclear arsenal iz nt safe and we should attack pakistan take out its nuclear arsenals!!!!!2005 was nt link to pakistan its was link to afghanistan and as well for 2006!!!!!RAW CIA AND Mossad want to prove pakistan and ISI as terrorist agency so they can take our nuclear weaposn!!!!! and the evidence u are saying iz all made UP!!!!

[fun435]

@desicanadiano AND has u said jihadi culture in jihad mean peacefull rally aganist the bad happing in world jihad doesn't tell us to kill ppl and do suicide bombing!!!!the suicide bombing happening in pakistan iz done by RAW CIA and Mossad to destablize pakistan take its nuclear arsenal so no muslim country in the world have nuclear weapons!!!!!! i know wht happening and i don't want to disclose it bt i will tell u tht in thiz year 20 RAW agents were captured in pakistan!!!!

[fun435]

@desicanadiano some of them in NWFP and some of the in punjab apart from tht 5 american and british nuclear scientist agent from captured and they said tht they came to pakistan to search its nuclear storage sites!!!!!!! lots of CIA agents were caught in pakistan all of them were to destablize pakistan and had connection with suicide bombing and killing of innocent ppl!!!! there are hundreds suicide bombing in which 1000 of ppl has lost their life and children too!!!!

[fun435]

@desicanadiano wht wiil u say abt tht!!!!u had just 26/11 once we had it all the time done by foreign nations!!!!! if UK bombing was link to pakistan then why british attack afghanistan!!!!!bz its was afghanistan who carried out the bombing even they said it in their website!!!!so its all afghanistan!!!yes pakistan ppl hate america bt they will never do act like this!!!!!

[fun435]

@desicanadiano if one pakistani fisher men comes in indian waters he iz captured and if one indian fisher man comes in pakistan waters he iz captured how can tht be possible tht ten men cross the pakistani and indian waters without even be detected impossible!!!!!!! look no hard feeling for the one who die feel sad for them bt thiz mumbai attack was a drama to framed ISI and pakistan in it so world thinks tht ISI supports terrorism!!!!! they were all given money to speak against ISI!!!

[desicanadiano]

@fun435 They left karachi in a pakistani boat Al-hussaini, then they took over indian boat kuber. And yes it is hard feeling when you trivialize the deaths of 173 people by calling it a drama. It is because of this denial attitude that pakistan has become an epic centre of terrorism. Today any terrorist action anywhere in the world is found to have some connection to pakistan.

[fun435]

@desicanadiano wow nice first i feel sorry for them who lost their life's and secondly i support indian for killing of these terrorist now to the point first they never came from karachi they might have came from rajhastian border and ISI was never ever involved in the bloody massacre i am saying tht these ppl are nt pakistani and don't deserve to be called pakistani bz pakistani ppl wants peace with india!!!!This was a drama to framed ISI in it!!!!to show pakistan iz involved

[desicanadiano]

@fun435 Why would india kill so many of its own citizens just to frame ISI? You are not making any sense. Pakistan has got a jehadi problem and it must be acknowledged before it can be cured. Even afghanistan, china & iran have expressed concern at terrorists coming into their territories.... And most of the terrorists caught after 9/11 have been captured in pakistan. Even today pak army is sheltering the likes of sarajuddin haqqani and hafiz saeed as terrorist assests.

[fun435]

@desicanadiano ISI iz been framed by your RAW and Mossad believe me man ISI or pak army was nt involved in thiz act!!!!and of they had from karachi side the pak navy would have captured and if missed then indian navy probably would!!!!i am 100% sure tht they came from rajhastan and they are nt pakistani even they are nt muslim and human!!!!!

[anzakhn]

thank God......some one is speaking the truth about kashmir and pakistan............

india should be freed from hindu extremists.

[sanajeya]

conveniently ignores several facts to put a spin against India... typical....

[parthsna]

1. 1300 people died in Gujarat 'pogrom'. Of which 350 were Hindus. So Hindus have as much to be disappointed as much as Muslims.

2. India has mostly paramilitary central police forces in Kashmir. You can't call them 'troops'. And it's 300,000 not 500,000. Not to mention india is withdrawing troops.'

3. Obama is doing jackshit.

[wekashmiri]

Hi Everybody,

To find more truth about Pakistan and Pakistan occupied Kashmir, please search "TheKashmirNews" and POST YOUR COMMENTS THERE which will matter a lot for us.

[karma10pa]

yeah sure!!!! Hurriat Confrence!!!

[gokulbutail]

What the Hell is this man talking.

He has idea what he is talking about.

India has had many Muslim Presidents and Prime Ministers.

Muslims are treated with respect.

Mumbai attack was done by Pakistani's. This is a Universal Truth

[pranays]

Hey the Pakis making stupid comments here you need to move to Afghanistan Pakistan is stolen Indian land and at least they are Democratic.

Once Pakistan falls apart it will be Indian land again.

India is Canada's traditional ally.

[gamemystro]

@pranays why would the afghans want the paki's? They hate the paki's as much as the indians and some of their land is stolen by the paki's to. They might as well go to sri lanka cause neither iran, india, china, or afghanistans wants them or likes them.

[laline72]

truth hurts bitch kashmir is part of paikstan

[jawadmahar]

every nature loving or truth loving man would sound anti-indian on earth

[jawadmahar]

its really sad that there are so many indians on earth

more than a billion

u c them in every country ,, u c there comments online , u c them everywhere

i wish for an earthquake that wipes out this billion

or a nuclear war between us pakistanis and them,,, we will clean sweep them

our missile range is more than 1000km,, they only have 250km

now theyr working on cyber warfare

Shaheen Missile is the on solution i c

[maddympkv]

congratz on ur hatred..you should not be considered as a human being for even thinking such thoughts.

[fun435]

@desertstormmovies some ppl will never accept the truth and are jealous!!!!!! some have said it rite the truth hurts alot!!!!lol

[centrino987]

this man seems anti-indian

[boskinator]

Interesting

[NPegasus]

India and Pakistan came close to a peace deal in 2007 on Kashmir. Musharraf could not sell that deal to the people in Pakistan and asked for more time. Soon thereafter he got engulfed in political crises and lost office. (Ref: Steve Coll's article in the New Yorker)

[ahmedshah1990]

Awesome Insight...India really is an oppressive regime forcing people to be its part

[NPegasus]

The Kashmiris want independence not Pakistan or India. We hear similar cries of independence in Baluchistan where Pakistan has oppressed the Balochis using gunships and fighter jets.