nightwish- annette versus tarja in live

[geraltofsofia]

Tarja is better.Anette sings too soft for such a song...it kills my ears...sorry just not this song maybe amaranth or escapist but not sich a hard song...and the AHHHH AAAAAHHHH when Marco sings is just...Tarja is better.

[LeiCheAmaJZANETTI]

tarja is the best, she's very good and she's more beautiful, but i like anette too.. :) but tarja is tarja! u.U 

[trezzenger]

simplemente tarja es la mejor ...pero q se puede hacer tarja ya no pertenece a nightwish :_(

[omni56k]

Cant hear voice of Annete behind the music lol.

Tarja is the best for sure.

[nuvolamemole]

TARJA SENZA DI TE SI è ROVINATO UN IMPORTANTE GRUPPO!



[JessicaHeavenBlessed]

Annette is the perfect trained singer versus a more rough Tarja, still Tarja pawns her ass anytime... Please don't use this to bash the poor Annette, she finds herself in unfortunate circumstances right now for being compared to a real queen. Just reflect upon the fact that being perfect is not enough to be an awesome singer, still it's not even needed in some cases....

[MarlaS1979]

Tarja is just a soprano singer.She should better sing classical music,if I want to listen a soprano I prefer Maria Callas honestly hahahahaha.Btw here Annette seemed completely out of tune O.o

[michelonboy]

No manches, la Tarja se come viva von su voz a laannete. incluso, la musica se escuchaba mas que la annete y con la tarja no.

ni modos. lastima por tarja.

[ztlp7]

Tarja es mil veces mejor!!! como comparan??

[raisedtreachery]

I think this comparison is completely unfair. They have completely different singing styles, and Tarja is obviously in her element here, whereas Anette Olzon is not. I'm willing to bet that, if Tarja sang one of Anette's songs, everyone here would be saying the exact opposite. Get over the childish "my favourite left so I'm going to hate the replacement" mentality.

[TheFullmoonTraveller]

@raisedtreachery There is no unfair comparison!!! Annete was aware that REPLACING a singer in a band means CONSTANT comparison! The fact that they gave different training means NTH at all! Compare Tarja with Celine Dion for example.... Celine Dion has NEVER done opera but when you compare them you end up aghast praying for these angels to have a song together!!! And if old-Nightwish isn't Annete's element (certainly isn') she should just do ONLY new-Nightwish and stop killing those masterpieces!

[milla387]

its a stupid question,that who is the best.clearly Tarja is the best for this band.well Anette's voice is good,but may to bands like Black eyed peas.i wish Tarja come back,but i think it wont happen.i miss her too,but we have to accept their decision,and we must be strong.

[AkApRoDuCtIoNs101]

tarja love <//3

[missolivia19807]

GOD I MISS TAJA!!! I WISH SHE WOOD COME BACK!!

[straizz]

Annette sounds like Hannah Montana... Tarja defined NW. Marco has a great voice, but Tarja was the essence. Annette sings ok, but her voice doesn't sound right for this band.

[RobotUnicorn420]

WTFFFFFF!!!! Annette isn't even in the right key!!!! I WOULD NEVER PAY TO HEAR THAT! Tarjaaaaaaa come baaacckkk!

[yasdeli]

annethe o comose escriba su nombre es un asco no para nightwish no sirve

[muratulrich]

tarja is definitely better..

[WoWisRusank]

soon as i heard that Tarja left and a pop voiced singer started singing i felt like nightwish was just dead now but annette has her own style and shes now the vocalist for NW so guy and gals just cope with it we dont wanna be like them faggy emos like Escape the fate who just argue with thier own fans chatting TEAM RONNIE TEAM CRAIG , so stop arguing please . vote this up to keep people awear

[KtangMC]

They both have there own styles of singing. none is better than the other! SROP WITH THE HATING ON ANNETTE!!!!!

[IIBenoII]

@KtangMC idiot

[heltinhow]

Tarja é a melhor, Annette canta pop, horrivel isso. Tarja é a melhor do mundo.

Annette, pede pra sair!!!!

[kingdomheartsss]

Dude Anette Olzon sssssssuuuucccckkkkkssss beiber's undropped balls. Im sorry but Nightwish cant keep this up very long with this chick. Its like watching a legless man walk for a couple fractions of a second.

[tbonejmac09]

I miss Tarja....

[hrtfulofluv]

tarja & anette vocal range r saprano:very true, I have 1st hand knowledge, ya think?lol.both can sing, 1 has more practice & other is a jack of all tradewho's got a deft defying handle on things.if both were equall equip frm the start w/music written for both &not just for 1 or the other then that would be true competition at it's best.add a 3rd saprano singer 2 the mix:sharon den adel & u will get great 'olympic' style musical talent cometition.luv then all.link 2 me,ehh?lol

[carl206rc]

simon simons from epica could be a better replace for tarja, anette can't sing metal

[evanescence9314]

@carl206rc Simone said she'd never sing for Nightwish anyway, so don't bring her up again.

[CaptainKacknup]

@carl206rc

My farts would be a better replacement for tarja.

Anette is terrible, she can't sing anything.

She's a disgrace to nightwish.

[withindarkness]

"now let´s see Tarja singing Bye Bye Beautiful or Amaranth and you´ll know what I talk about."

I don't imagine you listened to much Tarja-era Nightwish if you have any doubt that she could absolutely destroy Annette at her own game.

That style of singing is not hard... a trained singer can ALWAYS sing below their skill level.

[Treesap2]

You don't have the same quality recording on both ones the first sounds like a legit recording and the second like it was off of a cellphone mic. Next time you're going to compare you should at least match the quality.

[moclis]

I love Anette's country versions songs, with Tarja they were too dark, too beauty for me. I am from the village and I love country. Anette please bring pig on concerts, you have to have this to be one of us, voice is only first step to be country.

[M92Alexandra]

tarja <3

[paoasiss]

Anette u better dedicate to sing pop with lady gaga,

for metal ur voice sucks !! come back Tarja pleaseee !!

[OreSama579]

Annette sound like a country hick -____-;;

[PauloScottGreen]

Tarja <333

[MrsLesleyOlivia]

Tarja is singing with all her emotions, Anette is just scearming,it's sad to hear.

[satircon]

Dude!!! ANETTE MASSACRED WHOLE SONG!! FOR GODS SAKE KILL HER!! KILL HER BEFORE SHE RUINS MORE SONGS!!! :O

[raven1119]

They cant even call themselfs nightwish any more!!!!

[TheDskate]

Tarja, Tarja, Tarja !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[pandorarudess]

Anette is only a pop singer, she can't compete with Tarja.

[thekhoval]

Tarja obviously takes the throne

[SopraninoFolle90]

Tarja turunen: voce,eleganza,bellezza...CLASS­E!

[Foc4ccin4]

@SopraninoFolle90 e pure una fissata con i dollaroni! :D

[majomanak]

@SopraninoFolle90 If lady gaga, was as goog singer as Anette is she would be on drugs more as she is now.

[SoFirmoLo]

tarja rlz

[IIFanDeRammsteinII]

I love Tarja's voice

Ich liebe die Stimme von Tarja

J'aime la voix de Tarja

[chloboshoka]

Off-topic but Marco is awesome!

[pandorarudess]

@chloboshoka Yes, he is! *_______*

[psycho1279]

sorry its so long but just my opinion, Tarja will be missed and this is not annettes best performance of the song either but as for the songs made for annette she does those very well live... they could have done much worse than annette

though in answer to this performance comparison tarja

[psycho1279]

granted annette sounds crap on this song and in my opinion you have biased this by using end of an era THE BEST performance of this song by far since it was the last ever song they played with tarja and they put every ounce of thier soul and more into it. this is not Annettes song and filling tarjas shoes is a bloody huge job for any mortal especially since she has such a different voice but the fact remains tarja said the band meant nothing to her and left and she isnt coming back...

[anduca98]

TARJA 4EVER!!!!

[1Krizalid]

lo que sea el chiste es que es mejor tarja y por mucho

[MIKE192rotary]

Η Καλομοίρα θα τραγουδούσε καλύτερα απο την Annette...

[frikirocker7]

Perdona pero te has equivocado, Tarja no es una soprano lírico dramática, es soprano lírica spinto :)

[cole5150]

Meh that's kinda like the whole van halen thing.. If you look at it, that's not super fair to anette to be negative towards her. I'm not a professional singer or begin to claim to know anything about it in depth BUT. There is no way in hell I would want to go try to replace a classically trained opera singer..I mean think about it. She gives everything her own spin if you ask me

[GrissyPink7y9]

If you can't sing well a song, then don't do it, Tarja is a Goddess, her voice is magic, Anette is....... too normal........ her throat is gonna exploit if she keeps screaming like this doing like if she tries to reach the notes

[GrissyPink7y9]

Insisto, si no puedes cantar bien una cancion, ¡NO LA CANTES!!! Canta algo que te quede bien, bye bye beautifull suena muy linda la voz de Anette y es más su estilo de canto. Tarja es una diosa y sus canciones son magistrales.

[xoPRUExo]

I completly agree with kiragekko -she does sound like a falling cat lol!

[HimeAliceDark]

Definitivamente Annete no le llega ni a los talones a Tarja.... la voz de Tarja es fantástica y hace una combinación con el grupo que es increíble... cuando canta tarja es como si un ángel cantara se le nota la presencia, se nota lo buena que es... en cambio Annete es como mas terrenal es como mas ayyy si muestremen y no tiene la voz de Tarja. Que lastima que no este ya en nightwish

[MegaLiopleurodon]

The second half of this video is soo horrible, worst thing I've ever heard! Anette isn't able to stay in tune for more than 2secs, muhahahaha

[MegaLiopIeurodon]

I made dooky in my pants!!!!!!

[KiyoAyavi]

anette is singing that song very good i think. tarja's the original singer, but anette is doing a good job.

[DannoDs]

QUE POPERA SUENA ESA ANNETTE X (

[lapsicopata18]

Bueno, se sabia que la diferencia iba a notarse. La voz de Tarja es incomparable. Creo que la jugada de Nightwish fue cambiar el estilo, aunque gracias a eso arruinaron penosamente varios temas de la banda.

[Wilczasta]

Tarja is the beast, Anette is THE BEST!!!

[docchaos81]

wish i had an angel is a funny song to compare those two and finally proves a point of mine: The comparison isn't fair. Listen to Marco, and you understand what i mean: In the first version he sounds perfect, in the second he sounds horrible...why is that? Because in all those comparisons it's always a refined-for-release version recorded with professional equipment against a bootlegged version. If i recorded my cat with professional equipment and tarja with my cellphone, my cat would win...

[christiantej]

Las disputas entre el vocalista que se fué y el que llega siempre son así. lo mismo pasa con André Matos y Edu Falaschi en Angra, creo que cada quien tiene su estilo vocal y es por eso que a cada una les queda la canción que fueron compuestas para su tipo de voz. Pedir que Anette canté Wish I had an Angel igual o mejor que Tarja, es pedir a Tarja que cante Bye Bye Beatiful mejor que Anette

[thedjdark777]

good bye anette, welcome Tarja

[njcandoit]

Annette is ok and a good singer, but with Tarja Nightwish was unique. Tarja also has a lot beter voice.

[anita2992]

la verdad es que no me gusta para nada como se oye anette en vivo, para empezar, desadina

y por si no fuera poco, su voz termina sin escucharse, se pierde con la voz del bajista y a bateria, en cambio, a tarja no le pasa eso

anette no es mas que una cantante pop

que mejor haga un dueto con madonna o la britney

hahaha

[thedjdark777]

@anita2992 te apoyo en lo que dices, no hay como Tarja

[anita2992]

@thedjdark777 gracias por apoyarme!!!

^^

ahora que lo escucho nuevamete, estoy completamente segura de que hasta iio canto mejor que anette, y dejame decirte que NO SOY NADA BUENA CANTANDO!!!!!

hahahaha

xD

[thedjdark777]

@anita2992

Hasta mi voz que es estilo metal crudo es mejor que la de Anette n.n

[Metalflamme]

id say tarja is better for wish i had an angel but she woudnlt be for bye bye beautiful,wish are theyre two best songs.

[1992DisturbeD]

in my opinio anette is the best

[Xx8902lolxX]

@1992DisturbeD O_O WHAT can't you listen to the diference TARJA is a goddess compare to anette TARJA = angelical voice ... anette = normal

[2yellowdaisies]

anette is good....tarja is good.....MARCO!!! IS BEST! get over the whole annette/tarja war. it's pointless. when tarja was in nightwish, it was nightwish and tarja, that's how i thought of it. in the comments only tarja would get compliments, it's not her band, it's tuomas's passion. she has her solo carrer, go listen to that and quit insulting annette. end of story.

[Speslik]

4:42 hahahahahahaha

[Speslik]

@Speslik hahahaha...it is not possible

[junkerdunk]

I really don't think Annette should be singing the songs Tarja did, their voices are strengths are just so different that it doesnt sound right. If Tarja did Sahara it would sound just as wrong as Annette trying Wish I Had an Angel.

Annettes version kinda sounds... toyed with as Marco's voice feels a lot different as well.

[MrsLesleyOlivia]

Anette get out of this band, before all the Tarja-fans kick you out.

[soraelegido]

@MrsLesleyOlivia no because the real nightwish fans and anette fans don't let tarja fans do that. ;)

Long Life to Nightwish

[midwintertears]

So Opera singer = better singer?? Fuck Tarja is off key so much when she sings.! that makes my skin crawl. Anette proves rock singers can do the job and do it well, she puts so much emotion into the song. it isn't as cold as it is when tarja sings

[Dente18]

Perkele!!!! huehuehueu

[isdafores]

Annette lleva mucho peso, aun es mejor tarja

[basslumper]

whos the ophrah like one?? she fuking rocks

[2yellowdaisies]

@basslumper tarja 

[CzechEliteLamer]

I think Annette is better, but is only my view..

[keinoir]

my ears!!! can't stand more anette, plis someone shoot her!!!

[yagami777iori]

solo escuchen la voz de Tarja del 1:16 al 1:38 y depues la de Annette en la misma parte de la cancion del 5:38 al 6:02 y veran que la de annette de verdad da pena ajena..........Tarja Turunen era el alma de Nightwish!!!!!!

[999CorpseBride999]

oo anette's voice is terrible X(

o.O

[nove9nove]

do you need to ask it?

[interwishmaster]

Tarja, a strong voice classical.

[blackrose1417]

Tarja is the best.

[ViCky281289]

HAAA NO TRAJA ERA GENIAL CON ANETTE SOLO PARECE UN GRUPO POP DEL MONTON RAYOS!!1

[jorgekan]

TARJA THE BEST and ANETTE is a singer pop girlys

[Symphox85]

o.O ese toumas le pifió mal...

[harrawrson]

-sigh- I wish Nightwish fans were more mature than you guys. -__-

[FOrbID513]

Who is the best?

wut the hell kind of stupid question was that?

Tarja is the best by far

[xenassidekick1216]

@FOrbID513 i know! when i first saw the title of this video i was like " what kind of competition is that?"

[miruskaholubova]

Tarja Turunen vede bezkonkurenčně

[MrsLesleyOlivia]

T-A-R-J-A

A voice like an angel.

[BrendenJames13]

@MrsLesleyOlivia

i agree..

i want to hear annate just TRY to sing  sleeing sun.. the original way. the way tarja sang it. with her amazing voice

annate did sing sleeping sun. and she did sing it slowly like it was supposed to..

but tarjas classical operatic voice. made it so much better. whenever i hear tarja sing it. honestly i get chills. but annete. its just another song

[sondapedavena]

Annette shit

[Whufeng]

Tarja is definitely the best

[birthdayspieces]

Dear God, listening Anette was so painful D: My poor ears .____.

[xenassidekick1216]

@birthdayspieces yes, anette quite frequently makes my ears bleed, though i have to hand it to her amaranth is a pretty awesome song... HOWEVER tarja is the one and only NW singer! :)

[Chiyachan13]

Tarja: YAY!!!!!

Anette: cringe. sounds like a dying cat.

[reymondolls]

Tarja!!! 1000 veces!!

[Metalenia94]

Annette doesn't even sound at all...-.-

She sucks!!

TARJA RULEZZZZZ!!♥

[snowwhitebeautyful]

Tarja is singing, Anette is screaming. Anette is terrible! Oh, my ears! Tarja, come back!

[J0Diaz]

@snowwhitebeautyful Dude it´s not fair to compare them by this song, afterall it was written with Tarja in mind,. now let´s see Tarja singing Bye Bye Beautiful or Amaranth and you´ll know what I talk about.

[snowwhitebeautyful]

@J0Diaz

You're right about this one, but in that case, Anette should stick to the new songs she sings very well, because she really sucks when singing the old ones. 

[davidcab1792]

@J0Diaz

So the new songs are not made for real singers right?

[violon212]

Oh My God Anette is in Another key It's Horrible Ouch My Ears :O

[angelmorpheus]

annette would be fine if she can get a little more power in her voice, but give her credit though shes not the same style singing that tarja is and its hard to revocalize the original

[13eautiful13itch]

tarja!

[frostyreynolds]

Tarja

[dancub1]

Is Anette performing the same song as the rest of the band? Off key. Terrible.

[suicidegirlcelin]

Tarja por supuesto !!!! Anette mato, I wish I had and Angel XD, no le va para nada cantar las canciones de Tarja con Nightwish... solo deveria cantar las nuevas... quiera o no Tuomas al darle un cambio a Nightwish con una cantante que no es una soprano debe comenzar desde 0 .

Pues aunq Anette quisiera su voz no se lo permitira, son personas con talentos diferentes no se puede remplazar a Tarja !!!

[MrsLesleyOlivia]

Who is the best???

What a question!

Tarja ofcourse! Loveyou<3

[mindylaj72]

Wish night

[imminence94]

Tarja is the best...she must come back...

[mekapink]

Annette sounded awful in this video :L tarja all the way! x :D

[Myredemption023]

Tarja wins by a 100000000000000000000000000000­000000000000000000000000000000­000000000000000000000000000000­000000000000000000000.........­............

miles.

[pavcon]

ANNETTE...

You have to FEEL METAL TO SING.. SHE WAS COUNTING DOLLAR BILLS

[jeffimelectro]

great tarja turunen.

[JonaylaCronicas11S]

Es que comparar a Tarja con Annette es como comparar un huevo con una castaña. Annette hace lo que puede con temas que fueron específicamente compuestos para una cantante muy diferente.

Aunque Annette me gusta, reconozco que esta canción la canta de pena, pero apostaría a que está teniendo algún problema y no se está oyendo, porque una cosa es no llegar a ciertas notas y otra no dar ni una. Eso suele pasar si la música no te está dejando oírte. Saludos! :)

[akhimakhi93]

annette

[inakifilth]

Anda que tener q bajar un tono pa q la pueda cantar Annette, bua nightwish a muerto con tarja

[egcdim]

100% tarja!!

i miss her voice from the band..

[flanker47]

Anette totally own Tarja!!!!!..... in a poker cards game. But Tarja own aneetet with his voice.

[FelizmenteKarY]

Tarjaa no hay comparacion...anette canta pero por favorr no la pongan mas a cantar este temaso me lo destruyo xD jaja TARJA TE AMO ^^

[udanax8]

Annette goes flat too often...

[kamolkrom69]

I think Tarja is the main factor that make nightwish different form other.

Without tarja nightwish loss a lot of strong point.

[Andresmetallico666]

tarja es mejor es obvio!!!

sin ella

nightwish no

seria lo q es ahora!!!

[sekaiFR]

tarjaaaaa

[vladocsr]

jajja annette esta para competir con hanna montana

[Vuyko1]

tarja is the best!!!

[JilianRose87]

Annette go home!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[szalmapityi]

Wish i had an angel!!!

[QuiNn0225]

what is the name of the song?

[z1bbo]

TARJA!!

[lucymalak90]

¿Por qué comparan lo imcomparable?

Aparte si ya saben la respuesta, ya todo mundo sabe quién es mejor.

Es verdad Anette sale mal parada de esto, pero aún así la respeto.

[angelcaidodearganda]

I love Tarja´s voice ;)

[KiraGekko]

Alright, alright

We all know that Tarja is better

End of story

Anyone who disagrees must not have heard Nightwish in thier prime

Annette sounds like a cat falling off the empire state building. It hurts your ears and is almost funny

[Lipschytz]

@KiraGekko Agreed =) I like your the cat ^^

[TrueSuomiMetal]

At KiraGekko:

A cat would sound much better my dear!^^

And a cat looks better !!^^

[dforceman]

Tarja is best at the old songs, Annette is best at the new ones. But is that really a surprise to anyone?

[LadyBagira23]

u know, it's very bad selection of performances, here pleases only Marco)) but in general girls have their good and bad qualities

[MarianeLee]

Tarja's English is bad here, but she did it better other times... So I still say she's the best!

[KuranDanny]

Tarja is the best!

[DrSlackBladder]

Neither performed well in this comparison.

[gingersnapshard666]

Anette... Tarja sounds like a dying cow :/ sorry, but that's my opinion, just like how Cradle of Filth is better off without Sarah Deva

[nathaniell84]

tarja is uncomparable better OFC, while anette is so cheap!

[TheChaoticCrow]

TArja or annete.. hummm.. FUCK THEM MARCO RULLLLEEEEZZZZZZZZZZzz

[Attifire]

In case anyone's confused, I was agreeing with

angelnekocutie, not

Daidai90. Of course she sucks at singing Tarja's songs! They are two very different singers, Tarja would most likely fallshort with Dark Passion Play songs.

[angelnekocutie]

thank you!!!

it's stupid...i mean annette is pretty good and so is tarja...

and these so-called fans are just making a big deal outta something that happened 4 fuckin yearss ago!!! Get over it u retarded babies!!!

[Daidai90]

omg anette sucks at this!!! XDDD

but i like her anyways.....the old songs doesn't fit her!

[angelnekocutie]

ok can sum1 please tell me wats the deal with this whole "tarja vs anette" thing...? i mean their voices are too different to really be compared...and their both pretty good...? and its rlly stupid how ppl are moaning and bitching about it...i mean tarja seems pretty happy about being a solo artist...so why do u all feel the urge to insult annette cuz she's not tarja?

[Attifire]

Agreed. Apparently the so called fans only care about who the lead singer is. Jukka, Tuomas, Marco, and Emmpu are part of the band too people. The band is also happier with anette, but again, the "fans" can't see past their own shallowness.

[Adaywish]

Anette Olzon and Tarja Turunen, the singers have their own strong and weak points, indeed i have to agree that Anette seriously cant sing with Tarja for just a simple reason o_O they are totally different?