Wonderful singer Pinza was. Such a rich and noble voice, bravo to him for taking on such a difficult and dramatic role. Boris Godunov is a masterpiece, full of beautiful and haunting melodies. Pinza just then proved that he can sing the role just as well as Chaliapin and Boris Christoff, and considering how phenomonal both were in the role, that is saying a lot.
I have heard the recordings of Christoff doing Boris and they are fabulous. He had an interesting vibrato that wasn't offensive - but rather - intriguing and seductive. However, this is great singing by a great voice - don't take anything away from Pinza, please.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I do agree with you, He might have been good for seducting women and playing don giovanni, but when it comes to Boris Godunov it just doesn't do it for me...
I saw Pinza as Boris at the Met in 1946. It was sung in Italian. There were two other singers at the beginning of their long careers in that performance: Richard Tucker as Dimitri, and Jerome Hines as the police officer in the Inn Scene. He later sang Boris.
It is, isn't it? He was a champion cyclist before he became an opera singer. What's more he was a total natural, apparently. So good to hear a bass who doesn't make any effort to sound impressively "deep", thus robbing the singing of any expression.
I believe this was the only time Pinza sang excerpts from Boris in Russian; nicely done. His Italian recordings of the part, made about 10 years before this, are definitely worth a listen, too --
all the more amazing that Pinza was sixty when he recorded this.
hafizullahchishti 6 months ago
Wonderful singer Pinza was. Such a rich and noble voice, bravo to him for taking on such a difficult and dramatic role. Boris Godunov is a masterpiece, full of beautiful and haunting melodies. Pinza just then proved that he can sing the role just as well as Chaliapin and Boris Christoff, and considering how phenomonal both were in the role, that is saying a lot.
Beth29252 2 years ago 2
voce poco bruna per questo repertorio...
Pinza aveva una bellissima tecnica vocale ma questo non basta per porter interpretare Boris ...
bodiloto 2 years ago
Pinza's Russian is better than Chaliapin's Italian!
(I say that with total love for both artists. :) )
BorisGodunov 2 years ago
Listen to ALEXANDER KIPNIS
796824 3 years ago
Wow, so fine, thanks for a good post.
pearlmuth3 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Anyone who has heard Boris Christoff sing "Boris" would not bother with Pinza and what is more, in Italian...??
rahavatilan 4 years ago
I have heard the recordings of Christoff doing Boris and they are fabulous. He had an interesting vibrato that wasn't offensive - but rather - intriguing and seductive. However, this is great singing by a great voice - don't take anything away from Pinza, please.
cantorandopera 4 years ago 5
Ma le orecchie ce l'hai? Se questo è italiano io sono Babbo Natale.
canegracehasettevite 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I do agree with you, He might have been good for seducting women and playing don giovanni, but when it comes to Boris Godunov it just doesn't do it for me...
hologramlink108 3 years ago
This IS in Russian, you idiot. You don't even know what you're talking about.
VinylToVideo 3 years ago
LOL. I can understand someone mixing up languages, but *Russian*? He must not have even listened to the clip.
masonbarge 2 years ago
Yeah he made his mind up before even listening, the jackass.
VinylToVideo 2 years ago
I saw Pinza as Boris at the Met in 1946. It was sung in Italian. There were two other singers at the beginning of their long careers in that performance: Richard Tucker as Dimitri, and Jerome Hines as the police officer in the Inn Scene. He later sang Boris.
Onegiin 4 years ago
Very nice. Too bad they cut the Bell Campanario Madness, though
sagalat 4 years ago
I got an old record where Pinza sings italian arias, he was a very good bass.
Moffolover 4 years ago
beautiful
girardje 4 years ago 2
It is, isn't it? He was a champion cyclist before he became an opera singer. What's more he was a total natural, apparently. So good to hear a bass who doesn't make any effort to sound impressively "deep", thus robbing the singing of any expression.
sorbino9 4 years ago 2
EXACTLY. Compare his "Some Enchanted" with Cesare Siepi's on YouTube. One is a human being, the other is a singer.
liedersanger1 3 years ago
I believe this was the only time Pinza sang excerpts from Boris in Russian; nicely done. His Italian recordings of the part, made about 10 years before this, are definitely worth a listen, too --
stevevandien 5 years ago
This is charming!
coryisasleep 5 years ago