Israel draws new criticism

[wind4watts]

EVERY SINGLE BUILDING SCHOOL HOSPITAL (even their football stadium) IS METHODICALLY BOMBED & DESTROYED BY ISRAEL AS SOON AS IT IS FINISHED a few pathetic homemade fireworks that land harmlessly in Fields are NO EXCUSE FOR 1450 CIVILIANS MURDERED IN 2009 ISRAEL & USA !..... FACT!

[wind4watts]

What he FAILED to mention here is that the UN Food-Aid onvoy was attacked by ISRAELI FORCES, nice ommision hey!

[radomaxx]

bush killed 3000 americans whit the zionist and masons like you

skulls and bones kabala talmud devil dick suckers too kill more muslims

for the new world order america wake up

and muslims the jews is not the samme as the zionist or the israelis

[MiraginXXX]

It is silence Obama ! .. Institutional constraints ? .. We can take that to mean the Pro israeli lobby in the US ! ..

[bashie34]

Imagine being in house party and some drunk comes up to you and says BRO I am gods chosen , god loves me and not you. You would fuck this person up, but yet our government helps them kill innocent grandparents and children while giving them welfare checks which they won't do for there own country. United states of ISRAEL NEEDS TO BE DEMOLISHED and if WW3 comes of it SO BE IT. You want to be slaves for the rest of your life's or do we want the freedoms our forefathers fought for ?

[QUINTUSMAXIMUS]

Israel and some American right wing (not left wing) Jews who are blind to its human rights violations say Israel is being treated with a different standard. Israel calls itself a democracy but seems to be want to be treated when it comes to human rights like dictatorships that get away with indignities... As Americans, no one should say that regardless of their background. It's stupid.

[QUINTUSMAXIMUS]

Hamas said it would agree to a very long term peace with Israel based on the 67 borders, and it's up to the Palestinian people to keep up that truce based on how Israel behaves towards them, and it's up to the Palestinian people to recognize Israel, and Hamas as a political party doesn't want to. I think that's fair, even though I prefer them to recognize hamas.

[xgotfiveonitx]

tell me something should blacks have seperate country carved out of the united states? and if so would you recognize that if the holocoust is an excuse for a solely jewish state, what about the other victims of the nazis? what about slavery and the blacks? so i just dont see why the world must accept a jewish only state.

[QUINTUSMAXIMUS]

Well, the argument is that Jews are originally from there.  Blacks are not originally from the US. However, it's one thing for Jews to have immigrated to the Middle East in a peaceful way rather than trying to displace another people to create a state. However, most Jews didn't do that consciously. They were fleeing from Europe and Palestinians and Jews are victims of the West in a way, but the Israelis have the favor of the West, the Palestinians don't at all.

[wind4watts]

@QUINTUSMAXIMUS If you look on Wikipedia or similar you will read that in 1948 7&immediately afterwards there were AT LEAST 9 recorded Massacres by IDF & well armed Zionist extremists-settlers against Arab Farmers-villages , why did so many 1-2 Million Arabs run away and lose their Lands Farms everything BECAUSE THEY WERE IN FEAER OF NEWLY ARRIVED HOMELESS AMBITIOUS JEWISH TERRORISTS.

[mzkaddah]

Both are israeli shit in different colors and clothes just playing a debate to confuse the public...Hamas said it miilions of times that they can negotiate something with israel on a long term basis 100 years may be but they WILL NOT EVER NEVER IN THIS LIFE OR ANY OTHER LIFE DO U HEAR ME>>>"RECOGNIZE ISRAEL"...they say this decision is not ours to make...it is actually the decission of future generations who will live athrough that "100 Truce treaty" and decide for their own.

[mzkaddah]

fuck all these three in the clip...pretending angel while in facts it is the devil in tuxedo...I am imagining them skewered on my dick like a shish kabob with lots of onions and tomatos in between...heh

[killumianti99]

Fuck Israel they can suck my gentile dick

[Saladdin65]

I weaken nothing you moron!

Tell me how long did the roman empire exist???

Where is it??? Show it to me on the map???

1.5 billion muslims strongly beliefe in the destruction of Israhell!

Nothing rests forever!

I will inherit my children the destruction of Israhell!

Yeah: Long live Israhell

IN THE HISTORY BOOKS

[Saladdin65]

1/4 of Turkey is kurdish

1/4 of China belongs to Uigurs and Tibeteans and other ethnics

1/4 of Russia belongs to different ethnics

Nothing is forever!

Israel will ALWAYS live in insecurity untill the criminal atate of Israhell will vanish!

[Saladdin65]

Sderot is a former arab village stolen by fucking Zionists, who were drove away to Gaza!

SDEROT IS PALASTINEAN!!!

I bet American media is hiding this very effectivly

But in Europe the medias do the same!

America will loose his economic 1 place soon to China and India!

[Saladdin65]

Explain me why Hamas has to recognize Israel and Israel don't want to accapt a Palastinean state???

By the way the "jewish" village which was shot by Hamas was formaly a arab village. The arabs fleed from Sderot to Gaza and now they live in the greates jail in the world!

But it will have a HUGE backklash on jews!

[whauffend]

Peace and securtiy just aren't the goal of Israel. Buchanan is brave here. You don't often hear the facts. If you want to learn everyhing (no propaganda, 100% academic stuff) in one lecture from the scholar that knows the sources,

watch?v=MON2HL02mec

It is almost two hours, Skip the lady, start at 10:00 and for the first time in history,be schooled on the FACTS. Please visit and respond!

[waqas202k]

60 years of Misery & Ethnic-cleansing 6 wars 4 million Palestinian Refugees 3 million Occupied 1.5 million Abducted-hostages 254 km of an Apartheid- Wall 562 Humiliation-check-points 20K Political-prisoners 400 Children held in Israeli Dungeons 468,831 new settlers on an Occupied land Disappearance of Palestine World Leader in UN Violations- 69

[nural666]

Israel withdrew from gaza because the demographic state,gaza is small area the main area is west bank witch not under hammas control,israel continue to build in west jordan ,waht israel done is like the British pull out from new yourk and say we gave the amirican freedom

[Keyboarder7]

the reason i said it was interesting MSNBC had a controversial conservative speak a position that is spoken by millions liberals is because the network's target audience is liberals, so they will naturally disagree with buchanan, even though he is taking a viewpoint that is more so associated with the political left.

[Keyboarder7]

interesting how there are millions of liberal voices and liberal intellectuals who say exactly what pat buchanan said in this video but MSNBC chose to have a controversial, conservative voice speak on this position. dude on the left is full of crap. "Palestinians can leave Gaza whenever they want", right, do we really think he isnt aware of the blockade on Gazas borders?

Jews for a Free Palestine.

End the Israeli Occupation.

The only way to a two state solution.

[canadiansusan]

We must use terror, assassination, intimidation, land confiscation, and the cutting of all social services to rid the Galilee of its Arab population.

quoting david ben gurion, one of the founders of ISRAEL

[xgotfiveonitx]

nice post

[zkraani]

60 years of Misery & Ethnic-cleansing 6 wars 4 million Palestinian Refugees 3 million Occupied 1.5 million Abducted-hostages 254 km of an Apartheid- Wall 562 Humiliation-check-points 20K Political-prisoners 400 Children held in Israeli Dungeons 468,831 new settlers on an Occupied land Disappearance of Palestine World Leader in UN Violations- 69

[ImagesByDavid]

Hamas respected the last ceasefire. It was IDF who at the time of Obama's election victory. Ventured into Gaza & killed 5 Palestinians hence the rockets. Gaza 22miles in length, 1.5million people locked in. Not allowed to come & go by the Israeli government. Look at my vid & see Jewish Israelis siding with Palestinians & they live in Israel. Crazy that u think that Zionism has nothin to do with it. Really a bad opinion from u. If this was a political debate on tv u be laughed out of the studio.

[ImagesByDavid]

Terrorist sympathiser,lol Thats a first! George Washington and Nelson Mandela were considered terrorists. The French Resistence were also a terrorist group. So were the Irish who fought for Independence from Britain for 800years. Nelson Mandela (u mite not respect him) but he called the situation in West Bank Apartheid. Israel were the only country in the world to support the White South African government. Irgund the Zionist militants committed the first act of terrorism of the 20th century.

[ImagesByDavid]

The Jews were not the majority in 1948, please first of all learn the facts and go and witness the situation. Its not about givinh land to the Palestinians. Its about withdrawing from the land they occupy and the stopping of more settlements. Your obviously a Zionist apologist. What i see is the oppression of one group of people by another. Radical Islam need to be destroyed and Zionism which is has nothing to do with Judaism. Zionism is a nationalistic racist movement. Stop condoning murder!!

[ebutuou123]

Buchanan is contradicting himself. ISRAELI'S ARE LOCKED UP IN BOMB SHELTERS BECAUSE OF HAMAS. THEY CANNOT COME OUT.

[ImagesByDavid]

Hamas dont do the Palestinians any favours or themselves. However the fact is Hamas are a product of Israeli occupation of Palestinian people. I say this from someone who has lived with both Israelis and Palestinians and from a Christian viewpoint. Palestinians are a people without a State. Until they get a just peace settlement from the Zionist regime alot more innocent Israeli's and Palestinians will be killed.

[Oligarch2006]

lol...two jews and Buchanan...and people wonder why our media is biased.

[oldjoe5]

It's all so obvious.  Yet so few can see

[sunshinebutmorerain]

I love the way May vilifies the Palestinians by accrediting them with Jewish views -- i.e. supremacist Jews, within their ethnic state and without (by way of domination of US infrastructure), believe that the only lives that matter our Israeli, and that the rest of us, not just Palestinians, are base and animalistic slaves to be treated as they see fit.

[sunshinebutmorerain]

Israel is constantly characterized as a part of the west, yet the same Jews that push for the ethnic state of Israel cry "Holocaust" any time European whites look to protect their culture -- i.e. the west, period.

There is no more destructive or hateful group than Zionist Jews.

They killed untold millions in the 20th century (Jewish Bolshevism, has over a 100 million lives to answer for, and that is only one example) and are well on their way to the same outcomes in the 21st.

[xgotfiveonitx]

well your forgetting one thing - 60% of isreali jews, are themselves are of arab descent, and were never victims of the nazis to begin with. yigal amir to the late singer, ofra haza comes to mind. the irony is, if you look at isreali politics, most of the left-wing supporters of the peace party, meretz, are european jews of isreal.

[Zero2024]

Very good discussion and i have to tell you Pat has the Guts!!

[EmeterioBetances]

The guy that says that Hamas should stop rockets being lunched into Israel is absurd. Israel continues to expand into their land and expansion. Israel expects its population to grow and maintain the strangle hold of gaza and than the West Bank. Only that Hamas has seen the future Israel will hold for their people. "Settlements" "Expansion" and a ruthless blockade. Is that Freeedom?! Dropping bombs on the general population is civilized? Does Israel have Nuclear Weapons?

[xgotfiveonitx]

not to mention why did bush force america to foolishly invade iraq? on behalf of the isreali masters thats why. who is pushing for an american war with iran? its the isrealis and that idiot olmert thats who.

[pfsdetroit]

Pat speaks the TRUTH and its apparently the TRUTH enrages zionist child murders.

[2rate1]

Cliffard May - You have no idea what the fuck you're talking about. Israel has been doing this since 1948.

Hamas was formed in 1987.

You stupid idiot.

[Oligarch2006]

He knows it...don't worry...and he's not an idiot...he's a cold and calculated manipulator.

[2rate1]

I used to be on Israel's side... NO MORE.

Now I hope someone destroys the entire Israeli government.

RISE UP AGAINST THE ISRAELI KILLERS - ALL AROUND THE WORLD - NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[M3minusGrowth]

Nazi Germany + Genocide = Israel 2009

[treysparker]

It's funny cuz its true.

[BubbaGump332]

+100 for Pat for actually having the balls to put up an argument AGAINST Israel on the mainstream media.

[mickeysears]

This is unbelievable. Can it be that I totally agree with Pat Buchanan on everything he's said here? Didn't think it was possible.

[NotOurCause]

Clifford May uses

Foundation for The Defense of Democracies

to give people the impression he is human,

But is a Israeli puppet giving

dis info ,first by the name of his org,it is very deceiving and bias ,he uses that org

to perpetrate he is reasonably,he is not telling u facts at all ,but he is getting powerful air time under that guise,Israel

is committing a genocide and this worm is

spreading hate and false info ,how shameful

that mainstream media is putting that person and org on TV !

[WashMitt]

pat buchanan...I am very proud of you!

[WashMitt]

Fuck AIPAC supporters starbucks

[xgotfiveonitx]

please refer to my link about aipac in the info box at the top right of this page.

[r3s3t063]

pat buchanan steps up!

[taichicult]

I wonder whether neo con such as Foundation for Defense of Democracies is funded by Christian Zionists.

my question is that "Are they are religiously nuts also?"

[xgotfiveonitx]

you know i never underestood these people. most mainstream protestant churches support the palestinian cause. palestinian christians are also victims here who cant even celebrate christmas with thier relatives. and while american christians can travel to a little town called bethalahem, the palestinian christian himself cannot due to zionist blockades. why dont they care about them, if they claim to be soo religious? hannan ashrawi is herself a christian, so is george habash, and suha arafat.

[xgotfiveonitx]

not only that, palestinian christian leaders, such as the priests at christianity's holiest site, the church of the holy sepulcher, are not only opposed to the occupation but are critical of isreal. why not put them on tv for the religious right wing? let them hear what they have to say. broadcast thier church sermons on tv every sunday, vs idiots like pat robertson, and jerry farwell.

[medaa25]

I never thought i'd say this but Pat is right on the ball. Hamas is firing rockets in occupied cities and the Geneva conventions allow them to strike the occupation. Israel is using the settlers as Human shields.

[thomaserossi]

Pat Buchannen is trying to pretend that Hamas is created by conditions in Gaza. But what about Muslim Brotherhood? What about Wahhabism?

These were created by conditions within an Arab state. They are directly related to Hamas yet were created before Israel existed and terrorized any opposition before Israel existed.

Epic Fail Pat!

[xgotfiveonitx]

you dont seem to know about about your isreali brothers. they created hamas in the 60's as a political rival to the plo and arafat. they got what they wanted in the end. thats a fact. not to mention that isreal is founded by terrorists, from ben gurion, to yitshak shamir and golda meir. many terrorists groups in south america and europe based themselves on the haganah. wahabism is a sect based on puritancial beliefs, but the fact is hamas was created by isreal and now they cry 'terrorism'.

[JesseKantstopolis]

American media is a joke.

[PongGod]

Sure, Pat sucks on economic matters, but I love it when lambastes these neocons and their maniacal foreign policy positions.

[xgotfiveonitx]

i agree. my favorite line of his was this: "capital hill is isreali-occupied territory!" - pat buchanan.

[66605]

Go Pat! Israel creates their own terrorism problem just as the USA does. It is time the civilized world forces Israel to follow International Law and give up the occupied territories and illegal settlements built on them. Israel doesn't have the right to exist on other peoples land.

[healthhavencom]

Obama is THEE most savvy politician of ALL time.

Buchanan is fun to watch. I never know what he is talking about but he believes with all his heart every word. Gotta love that.

[xgotfiveonitx]

you just said the key word there, politician. analysts can say whatever they want without political reprucussions. but i love buchanan's take on palestine, he speaks from the heart for sure. if you read his analysis you will notice he rarely gets to criticize isreali policy on msnbc the way he does in his writings.

[Repoman23]

Buchanan just owned Israel. Why does the jewish owned MSNBC have so much hate for US foreign policy, but so much love for little Israel.

Double standard?

[Epic878787]

Why does MSNBC continue to employ Buchanan?

That other guy should stop pointing.

Certainly, Israel shouldn't be allowed to control access to Gaza of food and medicine and other basic materials.  I hear that that is exactly what they were doing, basically starving them.

[xgotfiveonitx]

because he is not a neo-con and often blasts them daily. its no wonder you never see him appear on fox news channel, a neo-con mouthpiece channel.