Added: 3 years ago
From: pedrocadastros
Views: 730,609
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (268)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • this is the perfect song

  • Stunning!

  • God damnit Chan, after every bad relationship ends I come back to this.

    You have wrote the perfect Country and Western song.

  • Cat could sing the phone book and I'd still love it. Such a wonderful, unique, and very expressive voice. Through her singing she says things I can't even articulate (but understand instinctively).

  • its like this song was written for me cause i had to exactly everything on this song by force with my love Christiaan. i miss his heart.

  • Comment removed

  • :)

  • is that male voice (quiet and soft at the end) by Eddie Vedder?

  • @sententiaS Okay I anwer myself, and who ever want to know it: It is his gorgeous voice

  • @sententiaS yes it is :)

  • ...genre defying...Cat Power! I mean what is it, except for beautiful?

  • she is sympathy

  • DUH. NEVERMIND<3

  • I hope my neighbours like this song too

  • this music make me fly in my mind.

  • MoOn...  mac star loves footy

  • ;'(

  • I want to be a good woman And I want, for you to be a good man. This is why I will be leaving And this is why, I can’t see you no more. I will miss your heart so tender And I will love This love forever I don’t want be a bad women And I can’t stand to see you be a bad man I will miss your heart so tender And I will love This love forever And this is why I am leaving And this is why I can’t see you no more This is why I am lying when I say That I don’t love you no more..........................­.

  • Who is this!!! PERFECTION =D

  • @JasmineBayouth it's pretty obvious that it's Cat Power...

  • this song brings me to tears but in a good way....her voice is exceptional and love the guitar too.

  • She looks like a makeupless kim kardasian

  • for whatever reason, this song makes me think of wolverine&rogue from x-men(:

  • featuring eddie vedder

  • @h879xx is this true?

  • Comment removed

  • @taticastro yep

  • i just stumbled upon this artist! thank god! i love this community! instant quality! thanks for postin, now to look up more!

  • Wow. This song just tears your heart out. Cat Power is an amazing artist.

  • I really,really liked her music since the day first day I heard it, but for some reason,today, I just realized, that her music is among the best I ever heard in my life...I listened to it for some years now...but just now it came to me...'this music is just overwhelming...

  • i love how I'm trying to listen to gorgeous, heart wrecking music and i get shit commercials about shit things I'm supposed to buy and love because I'm an American. not the good ol' strong building man american, just the reality tv money wastin' can't speak the language cock sucker american of these days.

  • hi tarablue i love you

  • My god. this song just rips me to shreds.

  • This song seriously just took so much stress off of my shoulders. I don't want to cry while listening to it, I just want to move on. I want to be the good woman. :)

  • She is a very extraordinary artist. I just love her voice and can't get enough of it. And she's cute, by the way, everything seems natural.

  • essa música é tudo q eu precisava para permanecer limpa só por hoje....

  • @davidjweld all I can tell you is my first love and I are back together after being apart for seven years, and it ONLY happened because I got clean. I know you know she has her own path in life and has to have her own experience, but don't give up hope.

  • MMMMMM BABY

  • @davidjweld bless you. I hope someday your woman realizes how much you love her. Don't let people who don't know you judge your actions because they have no idea of what it's like. Thanks for sharing your experience.

  • I was recently dumped without an explanation. I'm going to assume her thinking was like Cat's.

  • Pretty heartbreaking, isn't it?

  • MY man HAS a good woman to come home to, simply because he is the best man on the PLANET!!! I love him soo much!

  • cat power is simply great.

    This song is one of my favourites.

  • I don't know why, but I started to cry, while I was listening to this song.

    I love music like this. So sensitiv and clarifying.

    O my goodness. I LOVE THIS SONG!

  • She is so much braver than me.

  • i could cry... this song is touching my soul.

  • i love this woman!! i judst heard cross bones style 2 days ago on an xm tv music channel and looked up cat power today. she's gorgeous and has an equally mesmerizing voice!!

  • This song floods over you only to make you wish you brought a fucking life vest.....

  • Wow This is so sad and beautiful... ;-(

  • Soulful and sincere. Refreshing.

  • My name is Agatha which means, 'Good Woman.' Whenever I listen to this song it feels like she's singing to me.

  • Our culture ! Been lissening to CP for 5 years, but only when she did the sound for the car thing and True Blood has she got any attention (as measured by hits. Hope a lotta peeple enjoy her as I do.

  • @MikeDaMuddah Been listening to CP for 3 days. Found her through an Elliott Smith playlist and have been absolutely blown away by her. Just when I thought all the cool indie chicks had disappeared I was happily proven very, very wrong. Amazing.

  • @Chancer50 Nice. Quite different, but equally talented is the group Okkervil River. Recommended: Black, Come Back I am Waiting, Westfall, Blue Tulip

  • i LOVE my good woman!

  • its kind of dischord that i love in this song between the guitar and violin?

  • this is, so touching. I don't wanna be a bitch anymore after hearing this.

  • Everyone sees music and songs in different perspectives. It's not that this person misunderstood the song, it's just you two have different views in the meaning of the song.

  • @Smexy10002 I see music in colours... this is very much a sky blue song. =]

  • @davidjweld...buddy, keep coming back. The toughest, good thing you can do for yourself is stay clean and sober...odd, isn't it, how our human software allows love to be experienced in the most unlikely ways?

  • Great!!

  • this winter, this song...

  • Eddie Vedder backing vocals FTW.

  • This song reminds me of the man that told me I was a bad woman, and I made him a bad man. I want to be a good woman, I left him so he can be the man he wants to be. :(

  • Makes me cry!

  • this song helped me get over a 5 year relationship i had with my girlfriend/drug-dealer. i can't see her anymore because i want to stay clean, no matter how much i love her. just for today, i will be a good man

  • @davidjweld been there man

  • @davidjweld If you loved her so much, and instead of only looking out for yourself, maybe help her get clean too?

  • @Sinvx she knows that i wanted BOTH of us to get clean. she knows it saved my life. she knows where to get help when she is ready, if she survives that long. all i can do is leave it up to my Higher Power. being a good woman/man is tough, this song expresses that.

  • @davidjweld I'm sure she's real pleased to find herself outed as a drugdealer on youtube, linkable to your email without much trouble I'm sure :P

    I'd hate to see what you do to people you don't love/like...

  • @MaeDelima she doesn't own a computer. she has no drivers license/ ID. the last time i saw her she was walking down the highway barefoot. its quite possible shes homeless at this point. i speak honestly and try not to take things too personally, have a nice day.

  • @davidjweld You just made me hate this song.

    

  • @OswaldvonWolkenstein don't hate the song, hate me. embrace your intollerence. i love you

  • @OswaldvonWolkenstein Me too. Sounds lame now.

  • @davidjweld amazed at all the selfish ppl on here crapping on you for how you got clean.

  • @davidjweld Keep up the good work and ignore these people on here.

  • @davidjweld Thank you for sharing. Im glad to know I am not the only one who has been helped by this particular song and heard it the same way as me. I have been going through the same thing. It's been a year since I broke up with my boyfriend of 4 years and got clean.

  • @davidjweld Good for you man! That is heroic!

  • @davidjweld GAGHGHAGHGHGHGHAGHGhghaghgahgh­aghGHAGHAGHAGHAGHAGAHGHGAHGAHG­AHGAHGHAGHAGHAGHAGHAGHAGHAGAHG­AHGHGAHGHGGHAGHAGHAGHAGHGAHGAH­AHGAHGAHGAHGHGAHAGHAGAHGAHGAHA­GAHGGHAGAHGAHGAHGAHAGAHGAHGAHA­GHAGHAGAHGHAGHAGGAHGAHGAHGAHGA­HAGHAGAHAGHAGAHGAHGAHGAHAHAGHA­GHAGHAGHGAHAGHGAHGAHAHGAHGAHAG­AHAGHAGHAGAHGAHAGHAGHAGHAGHGAH­GAHGAHGHAGHAGHAGGAHGAHHAGHAGAG­HAGHAGHAGHAGHAGHAGHAGHAGAAGHGA­GAHGAHGAHAGHAGHAGHAGHAGHAGAHGA­HGAHGAHGAHGAHGAHAHAGHGAHGAHGAH­GAHAGHAGHGHAGHAGAHGAHGAHGAHGAH­HAGAHGHAGAHGAGHAGHAGHAGHAGGHAG­HAGAHA

  • She sure has huge power.

  • Definitely search Brokenrecordsindieheadphones.b­­logspot.com into google if u like this!!!

  • @iShowIPods definitely stop advertising yourself if you want to let people discuss great music and leave them alone!

  • oh my god this song.... it makes me reflect on the "relationship" i have with a man in the navy... i really should be a good woman and let him be a good man... and let him live his life and live my own... "but i will love this love forever" "this is why i'm lying when i say that i can see you no more"

  • beautiful song!! <3

  • Comment removed

  • It's wanting better for the one you love, knowing well that better doesn't involve you.

  • I want to be a good woman

    And I want, for you to be a good man

    And this is why I will be leaving

    And this is why, I can't see you no more

    I will miss your heart so tender

    And I will love this love forever

  • For Jumbolaya...

  • This song is utterly amazing, brings me to tears everytime!

  • i♥it!

    she is so gorgeous,sometime it sounds if she whispers,its great!

  • all i want in life, all any man wants in life is just a good woman to come home to.

  • @disasterpiece112 or a good man!!

  • @disasterpiece112 I don't think you understood the song.

  • @disasterpiece112 c'mon now. what you just said is probably the root of a lot of mental illness these days.

  • @disasterpiece112 i mean no disrespect what so ever, but i think the meaning of the song is slightly different than that. this song is about being seperated from your other half, because its the best thing for you. feeling incomplete, but moving forward anyway. you can not live with, or without this person, but you must. in my case, my very survival depends on it.

  • @disasterpiece112 And to be able to be at the very Least an equally good husband to couple her and make her even more complete. Happiness and joy returned and shared.

  • @disasterpiece112 well put. no hell as real as a lonely life.

  • @disasterpiece112 I am "Any man" but all I want is a Good man.

    

  • @disasterpiece112 that's not true. so many men go breaking the hearts of good women.. just because they were too good to them.

  • @cocouppal What - because girls haven't been known to jerk guys around and break a heart or two? Cruelty isn't limited by gender.

  • @raeganboucher of course, it isn't, you're right. but I simply didn't agree with the statement that all men just want a good woman to come home to.

  • @cocouppal I agree. Chicks are boring.

  • ... beauty...

  • beautiful, so emotional, and she is gorgeous

  • I was 20 years old the summer I first heard this song and I bawled like a baby boy...

  • @thegreatflambino I just turned 20 today, it is the first time I have heard this son, and I am doing just that...

  • Just love it from the bones.

  • I really wanna cry

  • Voice top ,the gitarre scary

  • Uma das mais bonitas dela.

  • beautiful track. love ed vedder's subtle but powerful background vocal too

  • A beautiful song. It's heartbreakingly true for the situation I'm in.

  • power to cat

  • @MrRdub7162 lol. Good play on words there.

  • I am not sure whether it's the lyrics or the rythem that strikes my heart so hard, or both?

  • this song is sweet and sad...

  • Is way to beautiful to only have 289,585 views. Don't you think so?

  • How does this woman know my life???

  • help please! from what cd is it?

  • @diogo1eli the CD is You Are Free

  • @lancekern90 thank you! ;D listening to this thousands of times.

  • i just sent this to my ex fiance who is electively choosing to be mutre with me and not communicate. i just said in the subject line "you"..

  • this is something... :/

  • sounds excellent..

  • listened to this song drunk last night, love it so much more now.

  • .... I need her... lol... I'ma take her out to outback steak house or something :D

  • Eddie Vedder is the backing vocal guy.

  • I love you good woman

  • vuna voce meravigliosa!

  • i cry like a baby over this one...

  • simply stunning vocals. This beautiful woman's talents are unbelievable.  If you aren't moved by her art you must not have a pulse.

  • @maggardja Maybe you could explain to me what is "stunning" about this affected, childlike delivery of words.

  • such a touching song,,,,,,speaks to the heart

  • I don't want be a bad women And I can't stand to see you be a bad man I will miss your heart so tender And I will love this love forever And this is why, I am leaving And this is why, I can't see you no more This is why, I am lying when I say That I don't love you no more 'Cause I want to be a good women And I want, for you to be a good man... Another fairytale gone bad ... Amazing song...beautiful and hurtful
  • great song! :)

  • i love this song, it gives me chills but at the same time, it makes me want to cry... <3

  • You Are Free has to be her best album yet.

  • I'm too selfish to be this kind of good woman.

  • @Opinionated73 Then change?

  • When two people first meet and fall in love, they're perfect in each other's eyes. As time goes on they find more and more flaw in each other. I think the song is about somebody leaving to prevent such a flawless image from being completely spoiled. Such an incredible song.

  • @okremington you cant say this better! 

  • @okremington I always thought the song was about infidelity, in that he was a married man and she was seeing him, and she leaves him because as much as she loves him, the very fact of their relationship means that he is being a *bad man*, and so she ends thing. /shrug

  • @Fraeg That's the beauty of music. Personal interpretation. You cannot be wrong. :)

  • nice job by Eddie Vedder with the backround vocals.

  • Great voice & the music actually allows the listener to hear the singer.

  • I miss my love, wish I could have been a better man...

  • @seathswift u will be. I felt the same way.

  • I agree...beautiful...

    

  • Comment removed

  • Musica perfeita

  • Cool and so way funky.

  • Comment removed

  • wow!!

  • timeless, effortless and a sentiment full of grace x

  • this song is so calming.... :)

  • i lovet his song ...i love KP her voice is unreal...amazing

  • chan marshall is the perfect woman

  • Comment removed

  • Its all true..

  • her best song

  • Wow... just. I don't have words.

  • This song is so beautiful, I can never stop listening to it. Cat Power is amazing!

  • I cannot stop listening to this song. It's unbelievably all-encompassing of emotion.

  • Beautiful song, beautiful voice, beautiful woman. Thanks Cat for your amazing talent

  • I love her more and more....

  • I will love this love forever.

  • Cat & Eddie!!!

    Just GREAT