Added: 4 years ago
From: mizzxsillysara
Views: 34,894
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (148)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • "what the hell is going on" is right..

  • yah saying ur just in high school doesnt mean anything im in a 7 and 8 grade choir thats rlly good and the 5 and 6 choir at my skol is amazing too

    and this isnt as bad as ppl are making it it just needs some work

  • I find it funny that there's a conductor, when the original song had was intended to keep no tempo. Whatcha say? It sucks.

  • extreme fail begins at 1:47

  • yikes pure butchery. sorry. I'm sure your all still very good.

  • yikes pure butchery

  • yikes

    

  • Ughh, I can't believe I actually thought they were good when I was in high school

  • eww... lol why choose such a challengiung song if you know it sounds bad... they needed a lto more practice... no balance what so ever

  • 1. Yelling

    2. Balance is off

    3. Pitchy

    4. SHOW CHOIR? Hell no.

  • no offence :( sounds like a funeral song :x

  • My ears are bleeding... Fucks sake, go back to the drawing board.

    The Tenor and Bass needs to be MUCH louder, and you're just destroying the dynamics of this song.

  • Flat!!! Terribly flat! :(

    and the dynamics or just terrible. It's like you shouting the lyrics or something, it has no musicality to it what so ever.

  • Holy crap!

    This is not an agressive song, and this choir is brutally killing the original feel of this song. The conductor, who is responsible for this arrangement, has done so very, very poorly, gotta go back to school, buddy, and take lessons on the original version there.

    And please boys, let the girls get a chance, 'cause you can defenetely not carry this song on your own. Your pitch is all over the place.

    i vote....no!

  • @BlenegLapo I agree completely. Shut up boys. And lay out a little, have you heard the song? It's gentle. You killed it.

  • awful. its sad that this is one of the first listings.

  • no balance whatsoever.....I can hear a few voices sticking out alot and theyre not in key either....yikes.

  • Never again. Just never ever attempt this agian.

  • really bad..

  • Woooow. They need help. Where are the sopranos? And is it me or are the tenors off?

    Not a good song for this choir.

    And to respond to comments below, just because you're only in high school doesn't mean you can't have an incredible choir. That isn't an excuse, it's simply what they choose to hide behind.

  • @BrielynActs the director told them to make the notes clash and to have a train-like quality to the tones.

  • It needs alot of work but it has potential.

    But honestly, This was your top choir??

  • :53 - :55.

    ...No comment.

  • jesus christ... you guys were... not even good.. tbh this is the worst remake i have ever heard of this song.

  • fail

  • Needs more soprano. You cant even hear it untill at least 30 seconds in the song.

    just sounds like a bunch of yelling.

  • no offense... i know once you start in key its easy to lose but when you guys pause and then begin again. i think of tornadoes..

  • im with Pharoron. their only in high school. give them a damn break. i thought it was good

  • good, honest effort. but this was by far a poor rendition of this song. However, I still give you credit. This song is challenging on so many different levels. I have not heard one choir pull of this song to it's full potential. I do believe the men overpower the woman and pitches are are sketch at best. Every here and there you can make out good parts, Overall, I be your choir is pretty good. This song is just not for you.

  • more soprano would be nice.. not balanced and more like shouting from the men..

  • Not the right song for this choir. I have sung in choir, but I've never been in one that was really good, so I gave up, and do solo work now. It's choirs like this that remind me why I stopped. lol!

  • Neeed a WHOLE lot more sopranos. Thats really what carries this songs.

  • This is horrible. It is almost like all the parts are trying to sing the melody, in a major key. I wonn't waste my time on the dynamics =/

  • 2.22 kind of got a bit careless and turned more into a shout. :S off pitch all around right there. lol, but it wasn't BAD bad... its just not an easy song to perform.

  • this is crap...they should have chose a different song instead of ruining a awesome song

    =/

  • dude, what the hell were only in highschool, christ its not like were perfection

  • This version does not retain any of the originality of the song. Too heavy on the harmony. Pure crap.

  • their vowel shapes were all over the place. they sound very imature because their voewl shapes were so disoriented. on the places when they were excited, they let the adrenalen get the best of them and the pitches were all over the place. it wasnt the best...but it was alright.

  • is this Keswick High School?

  • yeah, it's not making me happy. singing too loud and sharping......

  • ouch, some of the men are TOTALLY sharp through the whole thing. *cringe*

  • not the best i've heard, i think it's just that there are too many singing, and turn down those men!!!

  • agreed, the girls are singing the melody quite well, but you cant hear them at all with the loud guys doing the not so good harmony

  • ech o-e;

    no offense xP

  • lots of nasal sound across the board.

    i don't think the 'show choir' sound is quite the right thing for this song.

    some parts felt rushed. like the show choir mentality was pushing them to burst out into song and dance, snapping and clapping with stage smiles abound.

  • This is really nice, but would be better if the singers had a more internal sound - within the head, perhaps more delicate to match the song.

    Gorgeous arrangement.

  • very nice attempt :)

    though it didnt sound the best, at least they tried! and it wasnt THAT bad

  • the men should have been darker and rounder and quieter where as the girls should have been lighter and rounder and should have complimented the guys. they hit everything... but the name "show choir" doesn't mean stand there and sing, there is supposed to be a difference between concert choir and show choir, and the cord at 1:47 was horrible! but great job overall :)

  • yuck. you guys need to find better harmonizing notes. i know it's synced and everything when imogen sings it, but all of you sound like dying cats. and you all sound like you're trying to sing too loud, especially the guys. i'm sorry but i can't listen to this anymore.

  • Very bad, they sound like they're trying to hard to sing loud, especially with the guys

  • they have the voices, but the voices aren't put to the best abilities. bad arrangement

  • um... oh dear. after 1:45 was not good... ouch...

  • i love it. even though it is a little a dark and there is like no sopranos. but, still being mean isn't going to make the people singing this feel any better. as a choir girl myself i can say that you ROCK!!!!!!

  • AHHH too dark and loud i agree with the person below me and wheres the soprano part i can barely hear it...

  • this is horrible. Ever hear of DYNAMICS? or vocal technique? how about round vowels? and how about not straining?

    just a few things we call singing.

  • you hear the soprano not loud enough. but you should otherwise it sounds too dark.

  • Uck.

    Umm. The tone here is way too throaty. Did this choir listen to the original Imogen Heap version of this song? It sounds like they like... are old people in a nursing home. Sorry. I didn't like it.

  • The "you won't catch me around here" bit was really half-assed. They didn't sing it, they just said it. Either way I'd say overkill. It usually sounds better with a handful of people.

  • So, is it their fault for taking on a work they couldn't adjust to? Oh yes; oh yes, it is. When one moves to a difference piece of music, one must ALWAYS keep in mind what the composer had in mind.

    They failed this consideration, failed to feel the song, and failed to respect the work. Didn't even "make it their own" (or, at least, I hope they didn't).

    The only words of kindness I can, in good conscience, offer is the idea that perhaps it was just one of their bad performances.

    - Kevin.

  • I'm afraid the have nots have it - this choir is not a great choir.

    It may be a good choir in that it can perform the old-school, the classical works per se, that many high school choirs are accustomed to performing. However, a great choir is able to apply everything they're trained to do to various OTHER works of music.

    - Kevin.

  • I know thats hard to do.They sound good.

  • Not very good. I don't care if you say it took a lot of work or it's very professionally performed. They were yelling in part of the performance. The balance of the tenors and altos is way to strong against the sopranos. It's just was never pleasing to listen to.

  • i couldn't agree more. this is the worst performance of this song i have seen.

  • The Alto/tenor parts are not too strong because in this song, the Alto/tenor voices are the the melody in the verses. Sopranos just complain if they don't get the melodic lines. So go listen to the original version, and you'll learn a lesson. I will agree that it sounds like they're yelling however...

  • the dyanmics of your choir are all wrong. but otherwise. good job

  • ^This.

    It's backwards.

  • WTF!!!! WHAT HAPPENED HERE ON THE BEGGINING? well i've seen another covers from this piece...maybe they tried to modified some achords but sorry, it doesnt work, i dont feel dynamics and the achords they tried to modified

  • YOU ALL NEED A HEARING CHECK I THOUGHT THEY WERE GREAT NEVER HAVE I SEEN SOO MANY PEOPLE DOING A COVER THAT IS IN SYNC WITH EACH OTHER. THIS TAKES TIME AND A LOT OF WORK IF YOU DONT APPRECIATE THEIR EFFORT THEN GO WATCH SOME OTHER DUMB VIDEO THAT WILL WASTE YOUR TIME. out of a 1-10 points I would give them 100000000000000 gillon points!!! 0_0

  • actually that was pretty bad...

    might want to get your hearing checked.

    out of tune the entire time. i know it's supposed to be dissonant, but it was just wrong.

    and they are yelling half the time.

  • i agree

  • acrually they are hitting the notes ive seen the copy of the choral music and it sounds off because of the digital recording

  • Can't diagnose well with the terrible acoustics.

    However, here's what I could tell..

    Some of the lines that were mumbled by the original artist were bellowed by your tenors, I think. Some volume control is important. Unfortunately, many band and choir teachers ignore this need for the sake of getting their weaker students on-key.. and voice training comes faster with volume.

    Hard piece. Good effort.

  • you guys just need to shut up. we sang exactly what we were taught to sing. we were singing in a church so the accustics of it are loud PLUS, you're hearing from a shitty little camera microphone. but honestly i don't care what you guys say because i know that I am proud of our work...i wouldn't change a thing cause there was nothing to change. it's a challenging song by itself. GO SHOW CHOIR '06-'07!!!

    (2nd SAPRANO/1st ALTO!)

  • I agree with some of what you said. The acoustics didn't do you justice. And to take a line from G.I. Jane, there are no bad followers but bad leaders. Around 1:47, 2:24, 2:31, there were horrible pitch problems. 2:52 settle down guys. Other than that, it was a hard piece for a High School choir. Even professional acapella groups have trouble with this one. IMHO, it wasn't polished enough for professionals, but for you guys, couldn't have done it better myself.

  • Great job. I cant imagine anyone commenting on the accuracy of the performance considering the auido was recored by a video camera.

  • There were waaaaaaay to many people doing this piece, or they were just to loud. and the arrangement was completely off

  • Its not the amount of voices.

    it's the execution of said voices.

    1. they're singing too loud at the start.

    2. the arrangement places the melody with the sopranos only, the tenors should eithe rbe on it, or an an accompanying line.

    3. due to the placement and the volume of the men you can barely hear the melody, THATS BAd.

    ok ill stop for now

  • there are waay to many voices it doesnt sound as good as the original song

  • it's a bit noisy

  • this song is now officially messed up. Its not accented. the pitches are all wrong. AGH

  • plz shut up

  • they like, screamed through the whole thing.

    and the vowels were TOO open.

    naaah.

  • They're pushing too hard from their throats. It has no emotion whatsoever. It's like they don't understand what they're singing. I give them credit for doing as well as they did though. ^-^

  • Tempo was off and the tone was way to cheerful on certain segments

  • They are all trying too hard. They are SINGING the song like Choir Girls. They aren't FEELING the song like artists. Thats why this arrangement failed. It didn't come from the heart, this song is about the destructive effects of industrialization, people forced to accept the pollution. Pain, Hurt, Loss. Very few choir directors understand the concepts of the songs they teach their students. Its sad.

  • They are screaming!! I hate this arrangement and I think that is the problem with most of it. The harmony is off and many sound off key but that again may be due to the arrangement. Its a difficult song, I give it an E for effort. I think if they had toned it down some and work on the arrangement it could be much better.

  • just the diction. very awkward.

  • not very good :/

    i mean. you hit the right notes most of the time on pitch, but it wasnt musical enough

    it started too loud. it was too stiff. maybe its just me, but i didnt like it very much

    you guys are good singers, but this wasnt your thing

  • The main problem with how this piece was performed was the balance between each section in the choir. There were too many lower parts that totally drowned out the sopranos. I do agree, it was stiff and loud, which is definitely wrong for this song.

    I also felt that this song was sped up way too much and was sung to harshly. It's supposed to have a much, much softer feel too it.

  • Frankly, this only sounded good from about 4:10 to the end. :\

    I mean, some parts were decent. But they were really off key a lot.

  • This was really fast and the balance was horrid. Pretty voices, but, thats nothing without proper dynamics, balance and tempo.

  • this is great, you guys are amazing.

  • I liked the balance of this arrangement, personally. Its more faithful to the original sound of the piece. Sure, it wasn't quite right in places, but I can let that go. :) Good job, guys!

  • This wasn't the best....They were off key, and started out WAAAYYY too loud! They didn't leave enough room to build...

  • hmm...not enough of a balance...the males are definitely overpowering the females in this group...pretty good though either way...

  • 2:50 - 2:57 hmmm is that a car accident???

    poor parents..:(

  • VHS' choir did an AMAZING high school version of this song. its MUCH better than most college groups.

    im honest to god, it was amazing

    search this: Hide And Seek (Valencia High School Choir)

    (im not a vhs student or anything. just a youtube listener)

  • I agree. ^^;;

    I was there.

    2007!!!

  • There as in IN the choir itself. Not in the audience. xD

  • awesome!!!!!!

    im not even kidding when i say that you guys were probably one of the best groups to perform it. i wanna try to convince my choral director to do it next year.

    btw, who arranged your piece?

  • This is by far the worst a capella of this wonderful song I've ever heard. Each of the singers are probably talented, but the arrangement and changes to pitch are just awful

  • by far....

  • (1:30) that cough actually syncs in nicely with the music lol. 5 star

  • great. look at cvhs doing it. they did it in chairs without a director and with choreography

  • What choreography? They just stand in one place the whole time. Though they are awesome singers!

  • not this choir. my high school did it for their pops concert

  • great. look at cvhs doing it. they did it in chairs without a director and with choreography

  • ouch

  • hmmmmm

  • ruined an AMAZING song... BOO

  • You were in a church? I find it strange that you sang "what the hell" so loudly, then.

  • very bad.

  • oh way too many male voices and they are too high at that and off pitch... ugh... that was ugly

  • ugh... songs like this should not have perfect phrasing with words....

  • I haven't heard any choir do this piece well. One problem is that the original was produced using electronic harmonizing equipment, not human voices, and thus the pitches are accurate to an inhuman level; sometimes the pitches are quartertones apart. The other problem is that this piece takes A LOT of time to rehearse and perfect, and no high school choir has the time to devote to doing this piece well.

    PS: yodevo, it's "soprano," not "saprano." Idiot. Know how to spell your own voice part.

  • Search Hide And Seek (Valencia High School Choir) They are extremley good singers.

  • I can't agree with you more! The most groups I've heard perform this song either fake or butcher the quarter tones. The human voice is the instrument most capable of producing a quarter tone, but not without IMMENSE amounts of training (how do you check your pitch when no other instrument can produce a quarter tone accurately?). I honestly have to wonder why people keep doing the song. It's a good display of a group's ability to harmonize, but only if they can get the close harmonies right.

  • i think it's crap that you all should point the finger at us and say that we weren't as good as we should have been. we were in a church, those things echo. so when you go from silent to singing in a church, it's gunna be loud. plus, mr hogan was the one directing us. if it's too powerful or american for you...he's the director. and did you ever think that we might just be interpreting it in an american way?

    -Jessica Devon (2nd Saprano/1st Alto)

  • i think it's crap that you all should point the finger at us and say that we weren't as good as we should have been. we were in a church, those things echo. so when you go from silent to singing in a church, it's gunna be loud. plus, mr hogan was the one directing us. if it's too powerful or american for you...he's the director. and did you ever think that we might just be interpreting it in an american way?

  • i've listened and watched a lot of choir 'Hide and seek' versions and this one seems a bit loud so to me.

    Also strange contrast in the loudness of the voices and the complete motionless-ness of the singers.

    Then again; i sing like you guys if i tried, and it must be great to sing a song like this together.

  • where did you guys find this arrangement? do most people do it themselves or can i find it online somewhere or buy it online?

  • the whole point of the song is that its peaceful and quiet

    if they'd just calm down and listen this would sound 20 times better

  • the guys sound like they're screaming

  • well

    I personally think this choir didn't have a good grasp on this song

    but for a high school, it's decent

    I agree with the dynamics being harsh

    there's no piano.. the dynamics are so narrow and aren't dramatic

    it's either forte, fortissimo or OW

  • i really don't like the alto harmony, it sound like they're wailing at the chorus... but otherwise, ya, you should keep the diction the way it is, not american, as titanxcntry says, and really, they were wailing throughout the whole song, it didn't sound like music.

  • Good blend and tone for some of the performance, though I have to agree with maggersyo though with the american diction. What makes a great choir is the ability to adapt to the style of the music. There are several chords that sound wrong, could be the arranger's fault, or just could be the fact that since there are such tight harmonies the various sections aren't as confident on their parts, and have a tendency to "sink" down to a pitch that makes the chord sound more bland and normal.

  • its a little too broadway.

    the diction is a little too american.

    the performance is a little too loud.

    but good job for a high school choir.

  • we werent that loud at the beggining, it had to have been the on camera mic

  • I dislike how loud it is. I mean, starting out with a forte. dyanamics are off, really.

    I don't think it's just the recorder.

  • It's always hard to tell how good a performance is based on a recording, especially if the equipment isn't very good (no offense). I liked it, though it isn't quite my favorite. But nice job, obviously it took a lot of time and hard work to perform as well as you guys did.

  • Every other performance I've heard has this same arrangement or very similar. My school is the only one that I've heard that is different.

  • i just wish they girls were louder. the girls aren't coming through enough

  • nice. :)

    and for the people who think that the song seems like its the wrong pitch, they're singing it the way that imogen would have sung it, its just that she has a vocoder to make it sound distorted.

  • uhh where are all the high pitched parts? it was good, but it was definately missing something

  • Honestly, the two times show choir did this was beyond amazing. They all worked hard, they all really put effort into it, give them credit. Plus it's the sound of the camera thats making them sound unbalanced. Because if you were really there and heard it, you would have been amazed. So save your crap, & show some respect. I'll miss all you guys. Show choir will never be the same.<3

  • wtf. doesn't sound like the some most of the time.

    i think the chords are wrong, or melody isn't loud enough or harmony is too loud.

  • man, im gonna miss show choir

  • this sounds nothing like the song. its not balanced out right.

  • omg the festival was so fun. maybe we'll sing this next year too.

  • sounds***** my bad, lol

  • next year, im gonna suggest we do this song in choir, it shoulds awesome!!!

  • omg omg omg! i remember this omg! wow.. this was my favorite i loved the festival! yay go us kennedy singers! mr. hogan!!!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more