This features some of the best choral singing one will ever hear in this work, but I largely disagree with Shaw's tempi and overall feel for the work; he doesn't hold a candle to Beecham, Scherchen, or even Solti and Boult in this music.
@billyguns2 Shaw's version are the most precise. Beecham's versions were sloppy- raggedy choral attacks, sluggish tempos at times, and generally unprepared sounding. Watch Beecham conduct - you'll understand why!
This is the very best recording of Handel's Messiah there is. I have heard several others, and none are as awesome as this one. Robert Shaw did an excellent work.
Beautiful.
lothiebelle 3 months ago
Resonance good but they are going a bit too slow
magpie4321 9 months ago
Superb.
R.I.P Handel.
Seracinfinity 10 months ago
BRAVO
fastborzoi 11 months ago
Thank you, Christopher
2000flute 1 year ago
I'm a member of the Chorus of Westerly, RI, and we're doing this in a months time. The entire Messiah. It's so beautiful, but very challanging.
keroshin 1 year ago
This features some of the best choral singing one will ever hear in this work, but I largely disagree with Shaw's tempi and overall feel for the work; he doesn't hold a candle to Beecham, Scherchen, or even Solti and Boult in this music.
billyguns2 1 year ago
@billyguns2 Shaw's version are the most precise. Beecham's versions were sloppy- raggedy choral attacks, sluggish tempos at times, and generally unprepared sounding. Watch Beecham conduct - you'll understand why!
jstaudt100 1 year ago
You just cannot improve upon Robert Shaw-perfection of choral music!
choirsinger123 2 years ago 2
@choirsinger123 I think you can improve on this version. And the Glory is too slow..
frank1eb0y 1 year ago
Simplemente precioso
latercerapalabra 2 years ago 3
thanks
csheff1014 2 years ago
This is the very best recording of Handel's Messiah there is. I have heard several others, and none are as awesome as this one. Robert Shaw did an excellent work.
valisisreal 2 years ago 5
I agree with you!
csheff1014 2 years ago
Amen and Amen!
eileenmaryeileen 2 years ago 5