Added: 2 years ago
From: gagaofficial28
Views: 44,703
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (119)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • it doesnt fit with the melody...

  • i learned it a different way srry but i dont like this 1 but ure a really good piano player :)

  • @puppydoggirl2 this is for people who sing the right hand, instead of play it.

  • what is this?

  • hey can you email me the sheet music? :)

    and your fab! you gret! :)

  • i`m gonna cry T.T

  • could u e-mail me the music sheet plz <3 thanx

  • Hey ure awesome I was wunderin if u cud send me the sheet music plz thank yooooooooou x

  • I like it!

    could you send me the sheet music please?

    TT I am really looking for it :>

  • not bad...i get super confused by some of the chords you play. i try and play them and sing and it doesn't sound good.

  • awesome job, screw the haters :D

  • Doesn't work when played against the song in the background dunno why, shame since it's the only Lady GaGa song I like. (aside from those two before she became famous which were completely different style)

  • your rely good hay im woundering if you could sent me the sheet music please :)

  • notes please

  • actually this is a PERFECT instrumental. its what GAGA plays on piano, not how the whole song sounds

  • this is really good.

    could you please send me the sheet music for this? baring in mind thought that i'm a beginner so i can't really read music yet. if you find something that'd help me though please send it me cause i cant find it anywhere! thankyou.

    bad_dancer_nicci@hotmail.co.uk

    xxxxxxxxx

  • wow ur reali reali gud!!!!!!!!!!! wish i cud be as gud as u!! dont listen 2all those ppl who h8 cuz they dont hav a life so all they can be bothered doin is writting rubbish on other pplz vids cuz if they h8d them so much y da hell watch it?

  • Nice version although if you only practice a bit more you'd be great.

  • nice sound! good playin too but some chords in the bridge part doesnt sound right..or isit just me?

  • can you please give me the sheet music? send me a message on youtube and i'll give you my email =]

  • I am not saying it is bad, really, but it needs a bit more practice...keep it up

  • hi, could you please sing while you play? :D I really love this and would really want to learn it, but sometimes I get lost and can't get what part you are already playing. :) thank you.

  • this is AWESOME! if any of you guys didnt like it, then you shouldn't have even said anything cuz what good does that do if u tell her its not good? she'll feel bad. but hey, I LOVE THIS! you're really talented :)

  • This is exactly what I wanted!!! thank you so much! AND IT SOUNDS THE EXACT SAME AS SPEECHLESS LADY GAGA. if you'd try to sing along then maybe you'd hear it.

  • I LOVE THIS SONG.! haha ignore the haters... your good. curious how you use your pointer and ring finger for chords stead of middle and pinky? keep it up

  • Gagaofficial28, dont listen to those haters.

    U play very well, I love it!

    Keep up the good work!

  • how long have you been playing piano cuz u take ages to get from one chord to the next haha ur crap

  • Well I thought it was great and nice cover :)

    Because I am nice and believe in constuctional criticism only :)

  • she's good like it may not sound liek lady gaga but i am sure if you sing with it it will sound cool

  • I found out how to play this song by ear. but im only good at playing in the key of G. if you Transpose it -7 then the chords are G, G/Fsharp, Em, D, C, D. then the verse goes Em, D, C, D. than the Pre chorus goes Em, B/Dsharp, G/D, A/Csharp. then the Chorus is the same as the intro. its not in the key of the song but i hope it helps

  • Definitely not bad at all. All these people commenting are just drunk or something. Even if it's not the exact way Gaga plays it, a cover is your own version of a song. Nice work. (: I bet half the people playing don't even own a piano let alone play one.

  • people suck, so don't listen to them(: this is reallyyyy good. wayy better then my cover lol. you are a really talented piano player! :D

  • you do really suck really badd :/

    sorry dude (Y)

  • @sazzlexoxo then lets see u do a cover if u think this one sucks.

  • Hey! Don't be annoyed by haters. :)) They're there to help you do better. Take their comments as compliments. Anyway, I haven't completely watched any of your vids, but you give so much effort anyways. :) Bye.

  • Epitome of wrong.

  • good... It's fine. Don't mind them. but your tutorial was kinda really a headache. just in my opinion.

  • i think you taught us wrong .. just for me huh ..

    well as im watching this video .. the chorus is kinda different .. you said that we should play the B,Eb and F# once but you played it twice..

  • nice

  • Yeah no thats not how it goes.. just saying..

  • it sound not like lady gagas spechless sorry

  • @09calle Darling if you think this isnt good, then lets see your sorry ass do a cover of this song and post is on here and we'll see how suckey your is.

    Jealous cunt.

    I thought this cover was really good<3

  • love u kaymagginigga <3

  • @09calle

    This is the accompaniment (The background music Lady Gaga would play while she sings).

  • @09calle its the backround. listen to the actual song

  • @09calle it would song like SPEECHLESS if you sing along :)

  • ahhh! i dont get thee chorus!

    i tried to follow,but it just lost me!

    D:

  • The video's good. The slang in the beginning annoyed me.

  • nawt bad!

  • you're good. i wish that i could see what the left hand was playing.

  • if you would read the discripton you would know she was in a hurry so dont rag on her that much.

  • nice job! :)

  • i think your piano is out of tune... especially when you play the G

  • you should really play it softer. you're pressing the keys too hard. and try not to rush it ;]

  • I wouldn't say it's on "perfect tempo" either.

    sarahseayx was right in that there were a few stops as well as the stumble at 0:51. Generally speaking, piano covers need to sound extremely close to the original piece and in the case of Lady Gaga if it's off it's OFF. I can't follow this rendition very well even with the lyrics in front of me and this is my favorite song.

    HOWEVER, I wouldn't go so far as to say it sucked. It was a nice attempt...and that's all. Thank you for that much. :]

  • @mjt5901 everybodys a critic....

  • Do you know when her singing starts off? Lol, I'm tryna learn this and perform it, but I don't know what point to start.

  • hahaha was those snaps necessary?

  • haha this is amazinggg! im definitely learning piano now!

  • :D thank you

  • this is reallyyy good! lol. it makesme wanna take piano lessons now! is it easyto learn this on your own? lol.

  • thank you:) i bet u could learn on ur own:) theres some online places that wld be good, that wld be so cool if u did!!

  • Try a different fingering for the chords at the beginning. the chord progression in the bass going up, you need to have the F#. Don't leave it out otherwise it doesn't sound right. I don't know where the G# is coming from when the verse starts but it doesn't sound right either. Also unless your going to sing the song while playing it, you might want to add in the melody so it actually sounds like the song.

  • this is how she plays it when she sings it, i didnt want a melody so i could sing to it,

    thx though

  • @gagaofficial28 Okay but the F# has to be in there.

  • amazing. i watnt o take up learning piano so i can play this song after hearing this song. ill make it my new years resolution

  • :) good for u, it only takes about an hour of practicing:) im sure ull do great at it

  • really good, and kudos on learning it yourself! but one thing.. when you get into the "could we fix you if you broke and is your punch line just a joke" are you sure those chords are right? cause they sound reallllyyy funky if you try to sing over them. just take another look at that

  • thank you:) ya i thought that sounded strange when i sang to it, but it matched her MOCA performance so im not sure. ill look at it again :) thanks

  • all u haters u shuld SUCK IT! she is AMAZING! and wont take your shit! love ya MO!

  • Very good!, don't listen to all the negative people, they don't know what they're talking about.

  • thank u so much<3

  • fab!!!! and you are great! lady gaga would be very proud!!! =D x

  • thank u so much<3

  • Lady Gaga would not be ashamed she would love it u r the only one that doesnt like it so back off. if Gaga would be ashamed of anyone it would be u for being so rude and i was in a hurry because i had to be at a funeral try being sad and shaky from crying and play piano like this

  • you were amazing gagaoffiial28. dont take those comments to heart :)

  • thank u so much<3

  • oh my god, really? Only you would think like that, Gaga wouldn't be ashamed of someone playing her song, she loves that kind of stuff. And this girl is like 13 or something, so if you think about it, she's really very good. I bet by the time she's an adult she'll be even better than she is now, and probably tons better than you. Just leave her alone, she didn't ask your opinion.

  • amazing:)

  • hah, thanks. :)

  • Haha 13? I know a 12 year old playing songs you couldn't even imagine someone this little bitch's age. She actually practices and LIKES the piano, unlike the girl in this video who thinks that because her house has a piano in it, mean that she can play it well. Have you even seen someone who practices the piano actually perform? It's a LOT better than this shit. And don't just assume she's better than me at the piano. Besides, everyone's a fucking critic, get over it.

  • Well that's great, but why the hell are you harrassing a 13 year old anyway? And fine I won't assume, but you don't assume she's bad just because she's not as good as some twelve year old you know. And to say she sucks before she's even really lived is sooo disrespectful. She has the potential to be great. Everyone learns differently but that doesn't make a person any less intelligent. I just don't think you need to be such a jerk about it. And

  • And don't act like she can't play at all. Again she's a kid. Did you ever think to encourage her rather than blatantly insult her? Maybe you could tell her what she could improve on, since you're a piano guru. If you're just going to be a creep and tell her she sucks, then why waste your time? I'm sure you have more important things to do. I just think you should be a bit more considerate. There's no contest she's trying to win, she's just playing the piano. Why can't you just let her? O_o

  • whats wrong with u?!?! u dont know me i play piano everyday i play beethoven and motzart pieces and swedish composers that ur prbly 2 dumb to have even heard of before but i love lady gaga o i play her songs but they rnt hard to play so u can back off i dont take ppl like u's crap u mess with the wrong person. i wld be surprised if u have any friends at all because u r a mean inconsiderate rude person and dont try to back urself up because ur comment says everything about u wtfb

  • this is to AttackElves 2 btw not u I HeartMADtv ur pretty amazing

  • i practice all the time and this song is on perfect tempo which shows how much u know. and i practice all the time i bet u cldnt play this song if it wld save ur life so shut up how boutu leave my channel and go bother someone who has time for ppl like u that have no lives at all but to write mean things back off wtfb

  • You can't say this song was on "perfect tempo" There were a lot of spots that you stopped playing or dropped a beat.

    It was a good cover, but you can't say it was on "perfect tempo".

  • c'mon dude.... give her a break.... why don't you post your own version and try to impress us all.... if you didn't like her version, then you should've said it in a nice way... i know how to respect your opinion but please do respect the stand of the girl... all she's trying to do is to entertain, like gaga does... and i'm sure she'll be on the side of the girl with this... she plays the piano and shows excellent standards... standards that you, clearly, do not meet... have a great day, then!

  • ur amazing haha thank you:)

  • @AttackElves2 you are so ignorant....the piano doesn't ahve to sound exactly as lady gaga sings the song omfg u are such a motherfucker

  • it should sound close dumbass....

  • @AttackElves2

    wtf is it really necessary to attack her, i think shes amazing and has helped me learn how to play this song so just grow up and find something better to do with your life because being nasty to innocent people is getting you nowhere so just stfu and leave her alone k thanks.

  • @AttackElves2 oh yah? lets see u do a cover of it then.

  • @AttackElves2 give her a break, wheres ur video then!!!!

  • good job!

  • thank you:)

  • I know you're going to do a tutorial, but, could you tell me where the actual singing would start? ((Yes, I'm stupid and can't figure out which part is the intro! Ha ha.))

  • haha i skipped the intro in this vid because i was in a hurry haha but ill have it in the tutorial tomorrow:) thanks for watching my vid:)

  • the very first chord is "can't" in the first line "I can't believe what you said to me" the I is a pick up note. :)

  • OMG MORGAN!!! i was looking at lady gaga videos and this popped up and i was like hm ill look at this and it was ur i literally SCREAMED!! hahahahaha LOVE YA GIRL! :)

  • LOVE YA 2! For everyone on this page matti5896 is like one of my BFFFFFFLs!! haha

  • plaes make tutorial!! =]

  • Please make a tutorial!!! :D

  • itll be up by tomorrow:)

  • where did you get the music Sheet?

  • i learned it by ear but i can make a tutorial for u if u want:)

  • YES ANGEL GIRL make sheet music actually tutorial i cant read music :(

  • i promise itll be up by wednesday:) i would say tomorrow but i have school and cheerleading haha but then im off for thanksgiving break so ill put up a bunch of more vids:)

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more