Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (240)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • James is so fucking gay now. They should have broken up after "and justice for all..." or at least gotten rid of Kirk Hammet

  • Imagine Metallica with both bassists! :D

    Nah, too epic to be true...

  • Comment removed

  • If u want a reminder that u are still alive on a level that u have never felt before.....go watch them preform live!! And if this music doesnt make u move and bang ur head then by god ur dead lmao And as the ole rock saying goes, "if its to loud then u are to old my friend" lol

  • wyruchała bym ich wszystkich !!

  • This is like porn for me!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • YYEEEEEAAAAA TURN YOUR FUCKING COMPUTER'S VOLUME UP

  • metallica with two bass players would awasome

  • It's like they have come back from a boring job... and just grab their instruments, to make themselves a rockstars..... NOW THEY KNOW HOW WE FEEL!!!

  • they play this song way too fast. sounds like crap. nonetheless, newsteads backup vocals are downright insane.

  • What the fuck Kirk is playing through Marshalls? o.O

  • Why the fuck is newsted there fuck him rob rocks

  • @ddude1595 Because he did write and perform most of metallica's best bass line's and he was inducted and they all got up and performed and had a good time.

    It's people like you who are one track minded that piss me off, jason is a great bassist and deserved to be in metallica and perform with them one last time.

  • @ddude1595 because Newstead was Metallica's long serving Bassist that's why

  • pinche publico muerto

  • Comment removed

  • Kirk rocks with his suit !!!

    Kirk was thinking: MMM I´M PLAYING LIKE A SIR JAJA

  • Jjajajajaj kirk is cool !!

  • lol Rob looks so funny playing in really nice clothes.

  • I miss Jason very much, he suits metallica MUCH BETTER THAN ROB! In means of vocal and everything else, this whole situation saddens me.FOR GODDS SAKE ROB CAN NOT SING.stupid crab

  • rob...let jason sing man...better live metallica and bring back Jason!!!!!!

  • jason did a big mistake leaving metallica, but i love to see robert and jason togheter in one music, sounds better and they are bouth great but damn metallica is the best world heavy metal band, everybody knows and fell's that, metallica deserves to be the best!

  • James looks like a hectic cunt in this video

  • They played like shit LOL. Cliff is rolling over in his grave right now. He would of quit them anyway on the black album.

  • You're the best Jason!

  • This is the song that listen all the people who doesnt like metallica. Boring.

  • rip cliff burton metallica died whit him.

    cliff burton = metallica.

  • 2 guitars and 2 bass guitars, HELL YEAH !

  • lo adoro

    

  • but can they play smoke on the water ???

  • in 4:49 FAIL JASON!

  • To abatzkon you are full of shit,the day that you play like him or are in a band like metallica you would be talented so from now on FUCK OFF!!!

  • two guitars, two basses all a fan can ask

  • this is real music here

  • kick out that fucking gorilla and replace him with the mighty jason again :) and grow long hair .)

  • ROB fuck off from the mike!! let jason sing :p

  • I grew up seeing Jason on bass... So.. It's my heart talking.. I prefer Jason. :-)

  • imagine if cliff was here... a true metallica james kirk lars clirr jason and rob... i bet hes thrashing his head out somewhere out there!

  • but sorry i must say that robert plays better the bass guitar than jason the reason is robert plays without a plektron, so the bass come´s louder to the audiance ( sorry for my english, i´m a german guy) :D

  • holly shit jason and robert performs the bass, thats fucking great. thanks for uploading

  • i think everyone should have been in a tux, would be frickin funny!

  • Killah Sound!

  • I like Rob and Jason, but I think Rob can play circles around Jason easily. That being said, Cliff even on his worst of days could out do the both of them.

  • @Darsidus How does one "play circles around" the other on bass? You obviously have no idea of what you're talking about

  • @KingOfParrots It's a figure of speech, Rob is definitely a much better bassist than Jason ever has been, and Cliff in his time period was better than either of them.

  • @Darsidus Actually if you're talking about skill, Robert is easily the most skilled and experienced bassist of the three, just see what he did with Infectious Grooves for example, something that the two others only could dream about. I get why you think that Cliff is the best, every fanboy here on youtube does (not saying you're a fanboy), but I've heard it so many times. Nontheless he's the one with "out of the box"-playing, and Jason is a "steady" bassist, not too much nor to little.

  • @Darsidus The thing I wanna say is that you really can't compare musicians at this level, because there are so many factors that play in their skills, they're so different. Sorry if my very first comment came out a bit harsh, I read it and it's really stupid haha :P

  • @KingOfParrots No worries at all, I didn't take it harshly. I just wasn't sure if you knew what I mean, considering everyone on youtube comes from different parts of the world it's easy to forget at first that not everyone is going to know the same phrases and slangs, reguardless of whether they know the same language or not.

  • sexy shoes kirk!

  • Why it's Jason at the bass and not Rob'?

  • @Aretureuh its both

  • amazing and epppppppppiiiiicccc

    

  • METALLICAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAAAAA!

  • 0:00 - 5:49 EEEPPPIIICCCC!!!

  • if stupid metalcore bands have 2 vocalists ... why cant Metallica have 2 bass players !

  • @pxSANTIIpx great idea!!

  • @pxSANTIIpx Yeahhman ! myself and the rest of the world agree with your comment ! Thumbs up for Metallica! Jesus , i wish my grandgrandgrandgrandgrandgrand­grand children knew that Metallica was the best Heavy Metal Band ever !

  • ENTER FUCKING SANDMAN!

  • I give Jason Newsted all the credit in the world... he stepped into a sh*tty situation, joining an established group that had just tragically lost their bassist ... he was pooped on by fans because he wasn't Cliff, he was pooped on by critics because he perhaps didn't have the "chops" that Cliff had and he was pooped on by Lars and James, who didn't see him as as an equal. He dealt with that throughout his time in Metallica, and it wasn't until he left that everyone realized how talented he was.

  • @HlotSfan tbh i like him better than cliff

  • @HlotSfan I don't always log in to Youtube, but when I do I prefer to thumbup the fucking truth.

  • @HlotSfan and 10 years after his departure, look where this talent brought him too huh???? I'm tired of hearing people sympathizing with Jason about how he LEFT the band he loved and connecting that to talent. I will agree with anyone saying how he was mistreated but don't get talent in there please. If he had major talent or was a great song writing I'm sure he would be in a great band or would have created a great one himself...

  • @HlotSfan I'm not really sure about that jason was pooped on by fans. Their peformance in Seattle in 89 was totally the best fucking rock Concert that Metallica gave and Jason was the best in my opinion. The fans who were there Give Jason a lot of attention and respect.Jason wasn't Cliff but beacause of that he created his own style and was a perfect bass player for Metallica.Burton can never be replaced but i was not born when he died so in my opnion Jason Newsted was the best!

  • @HlotSfan and then they got Rob whos even more talented and more fun

  • @HlotSfan ^^^^^^^10000000000000000000000­000000000000 likes on your comment... JASON rulzz.. \m/ METALLICA were at there best when JASON was in the band

  • Jason Newsted is da Shiiiiiit!!

  • i miss jason,he was such a amazing performer,and had such a great stage

    presence,alot like cliff,i'm not a big fan of rob ,he just dosen't fit in metallica,

    the way he performes and acts on stage,he has a nu metal vibe to him

    i think he fits more in a band like korn,limp biscuit etc..it just looks like its

    3guys + 1

  • I love the bass sound here.

  • Bass actually sounded with both of them playing.

  • JASON!!! but why robert

  • Kirk's sound is always so thin and out of tune.

  • gotta love kirks white boots lol

    

  • Haha watch the crowd at 3:40. They seem so neutral...

    DAMN, its fucking Metallica!

  • that guy on the FUCKING front row!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I miss Cliff :(

  • @CaptainAustus we all do buddy....we all do....

  • kirk FUCKING hammett <3

  • 2 Amazing Bassist!!!! AHHH THIS IS BADASS!

  • i cant wait to get my explorer

    

  • 4 people didnt get tickets for this concert...

  • epic...........

  • They have never played that well dressed before. :D

  • metallica with two bass guitars sounds better

  • Now if only Cliff and Dave were there. Then it would of been nice.

  • EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEENTER SAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAANDMAAAAAN

  • Always liked Jasons bass tone and basslines. Lots more mid-range and low end then Roberts clanky sterile sound.

  • Comment removed

  • i think all bands should have 2 bassists. it just sounds better, doesnt it?

  • happy birhday metallica <3

  • Now I lay me down to sleep .,, pray that Jason would be in the band TOO! He brings so much energy and grit that they miss without him, oh and with Jason and Rob playing you can actually HEAR the bass :)

  • yep it would be ideal if they went out in this lineup. Ozzy would have to find a new guitarist though

  • that's nice to see kirk hammett in that outfit

  • They should keep Jason and tour as a 5 guy MetallicA. Thatd be soooo frickin epic. And no, Cliff isnt missing, hes right there, split between their hearts and playing a bass solo only those who truly love him can hear.

  • @PEZEMILIO indeed but jason should be a rythm guitarist that would be ass kicking riff =)

  • @PEZEMILIO i hear tht !! i deeply love him....

  • Comment removed

  • Gollum!  2:14

  • If this lineup went on tour (including Newsted) the world would just implode from sheer awesomeness.

  • i wish James picked up Castor (his son) from the audience and let him do the kid parts with him.

  • JASON!

  • how is it 2009? With Jason?

  • @siul170195 he came back for this one event because his Ex-Band Metallica was inducted into the Hall of Fame and he played with them for years. why wouldnt he be there to play with his now Hall of Fame ex-band? hes still friends with James, Lars and Kirk, he just left to start his own thing.

  • This sucks.

    Metallica sucks.

  • dude. 0:46 i was thinking the same thing then i saw your comment.....FUCKING EPIC....just yeahhhhhh

  • I wonder if Jason regrets quitting the band... Seems like it.

    

  • @CIngstrup dunno about that. Maybe the money but not the toll on the body and the in house fighting that was Metallica following Black up until he quit.

  • Something tells me that James had a flu xD

  • @fcu423 no shiiit.....

  • DOUBLE BASS!!!

  • Enter Sandman with Trujillo & Newsted D: fuck yeah.! |m|

  • robert sounds like a sjimpansi !

  • They are doing it in suits! I salute you guys!

  • yeah thats best metallica line up, with jason back up vocals

  • i wish they would get rid of that ape thing and take jason back

  • @bestsr i guess u want an pop metallica. rob = best bass player in the business

  • look at james's face 0:46 XD

  • What a sucky crowd!!

  • JASON FUCKING NEWSTED!!!

  • @shima123 YEAAAAAAAH!!

  • 0:46 Thats so FUCKING epic!

  • @Invisonable

    So lame lol

    Whats cool about a string bend?

  • @wewantgore666 Did anyone ask for your opinion? If you don't agree thumpps down and it's all right, k?

  • @Invisonable

    This is youtube right?

  • @wewantgore666 Yeah

  • @Invisonable

    Good

  • Shit crowd. Amazing song.

  • Finally, when there are 2 bass players I can hear the bass!

  • Metallicaa needs Jason to be Perfect

  • Ye swirl your hair robert <3

  • Guys, everyone who likes Metallica argues on bassists. What is wrong with you? Cliff was great, very original using both pick and his fingers. Then Jason who used pick, and played a mean bass, one of my inspirations to play bass. Then, he left, on his own, wasn't kicked out, he LEFT. Now we have Rob, who is amazing in his own way of having god's fingers. GET OVER IT.

  • Shut up: Rob is a great bass player!!!

    I still miss the hell out of Jason though...

    Cudos to Rob for sharing the stage and even letting Jason be on there first!

    And cudos to Jason for shoving his pride aside, accepting this Hall of Fame thing and performing with Metallica (it feels sooo wrong even typying that, performing with.. he's part of the fibre of the band!!!)

  • Comment removed

  • JASON is motherfucking better than Robert!!!!

  • James! You rule!

  • why the fuck are the people sitting down..... famous or not they should be standing for this messiah

  • Come back before I die Jason..

  • kirk - should we get changed before we play?

    james - NO F**K IT

  • every single member of Metallica whether they are alive or dead is the soul of this fucking beasty band that kicks ass!! they couldnt have done it without jason or cliff but im glad to rob is there because he is so badass. thanks metallica for being so kick ass and making music!!

  • hahaha rocking out in suits!!

  • lol 4:36

    kirk: wait im not a vocalist.........

  • metallica...... when one bass isnt enough......

  • 4:10 "FUJ!" xDDD

  • All guys round here argue about who the better bass player is Rob or Jason.

    I tell you guys both are great, I prefer Rob but NO ONE OF THIS TWO WILL

    EVEEEEEEEEEEEEEER BE MORE METALLICA THEN CLIFF BURTON WAS!!!

  • I never liked Jason in Metallica... I know that people will want me to die a horrible death for saying it, but thats my opinion. Rob is such a better player. I have been following him since Suicidal Tendencies "Lights, Camera, Revolution" He is so talented, and more talented than Jason. More to offer than Jason, musically. Im sure Jason is a nice guy and all, and has a level of talent, but not as much as Rob!

  • James' hair is just... BEAST!

  • Jason was like Eric Carr in KISS it just fit

  • "Join us!" hahaha

  • Jason Newsted is the best! Trujillo no

  • @Chelopollo i agree 100000000000000000000%, he made the bass line, i want the people to look at jason attitude, the song fits him still same back in the black album era, miss u jason

  • This has probably been asked alot on this, but why is Jason performing there???

  • wah wah wah wah waaaaah wah wah

  • Metallica should be like this

    5 members

  • i love this 'yeah yeah'

  • Only thing this picture is missing is Cliff..

  • @10laughungtears and dave

  • @hk19950329 No, Dave's doing his own thing, his own thing that is equal to this. Do you really think this is Mustaines style? :]

  • @10laughungtears ..and Dave ;)

  • @10laughungtears WTF?? This is not a Cliff era song !!

  • @MrAndreSChr So? I don't get your point...

  • @10laughungtears Theeeen... theres no possible way he is missing from this performance..

  • sorry should be 'TWO' ofcourse...

  • I think that should be the new band standards having two bass players

  • @alwaysRocknRoll4ever yeah I was thinking the same, why not to fucking awsome bassplayers instead of just one!!

  • @rockGNRolles respect for cliff and jason, so i think rob is still better than jason jason can play very good thats right but i think and alot of metallica fans that rob is still better and has more feeling

  • Ok maybe its bad for jason that he was left but rob is alot of better than jason and he fucking rocks more! Who hate that rob is a member of this band he isnt a fan from this band and that one just sucks!

  • @Robin1646 respect for rob and cliff, but jason was (in my opinion) the best one

  • @rockGNRolles cliff was mine

  • @rockGNRolles i agree