It's just not working for me. It's too muddled. I don't think it works with that many singers - and I would never have had someone singing into a mic. A good singing group can project without that. The problem at it's heart is the attempt to carry the rhythm vocally. This might be better served with nothing at all - trusting the audience to "get it". I dunno. This was too Glee for me.
The background is pretty good, especially for highschoolers. The lead singer has a decent voice but he's singing it all wrong: you can tell he's trying to bring a Patrick Stump esque tone to the song.
Some things are great together, some better alone. Metallica keeps choirs and flutes out of their music, and there should be a certain tone to this song.
The singer sounds like he's singing AT the 'girl,' not TO her.
The lead singer is pretty good, but he definitely has trouble with some it. Also I didn't really like the Christina Aguilera-ish twisting of some of the notes.
sux.
Cal4ripkin 1 week ago
he sounds pretty forced
Icix1 3 months ago
good idea
but the girls yells too much.
52b17 3 months ago
skinssss
NICKJFAN195 1 year ago
way to go!!! a nice version people... and don't complain the original version is better!!
AthClaith 1 year ago
umm we did it with 24 and it worked find but it wasn't poppy like this
Mimiroo 1 year ago
Boo
half12less2 2 years ago
took him 6 notes to sing out of tune
Shineillegal 2 years ago
It's just not working for me. It's too muddled. I don't think it works with that many singers - and I would never have had someone singing into a mic. A good singing group can project without that. The problem at it's heart is the attempt to carry the rhythm vocally. This might be better served with nothing at all - trusting the audience to "get it". I dunno. This was too Glee for me.
bruhe 2 years ago
im dumb
kittycatluv98 2 years ago
ehhh...............ouch. ur kinda sharp......its suppost 2 b "pop" voice. it sounds like ur screaming it. but over all, not bad...
wallymamouth 2 years ago
Fabulous!
belladeballe 2 years ago
The background is pretty good, especially for highschoolers. The lead singer has a decent voice but he's singing it all wrong: you can tell he's trying to bring a Patrick Stump esque tone to the song.
Some things are great together, some better alone. Metallica keeps choirs and flutes out of their music, and there should be a certain tone to this song.
The singer sounds like he's singing AT the 'girl,' not TO her.
C33Four 2 years ago 5
@C33Four ......you should listen to Metallica's album S & M, with the San Francisco symphony orchestra. lol.
ruideng111 2 months ago
Beautiful, anyone know where i can get the choral score for this?
Amy5155 2 years ago
That was not that bad for amateurs. I say nice :)
tlaloc92 2 years ago
not great are you kidding, I'd like to see any of the rest of you do better. this is awesome. singing acapella is lot harder than you think.
jdreyer65 2 years ago
come on guys, its a lot better than you give it credit for. He actually has a really good voice, and the bgv's are great too!
ludofriend 2 years ago
i agree
crackdown235 3 years ago
not great, the guy struggles with the higher parts
batchelorboyere 3 years ago
Come on, Carl Wilson was flipping to his falsetto as well. They have the spirit right.
reinpost 2 years ago
it was ok.....
QuiemVile 3 years ago 2
The lead singer is pretty good, but he definitely has trouble with some it. Also I didn't really like the Christina Aguilera-ish twisting of some of the notes.
scaylor 3 years ago
nice voice of the guy, although sometimes he has to force his voice, but for the rest :o
JayBe666 3 years ago 5