This song is my anthem, and it is amaizing. It may be odd, but it perfectly captures the characteristics of my ED's. I am trapt between the love and hate of my disordered eating. Please be kind to this. It has taken me months to be able to post this. I just want to know if anyone feels anything similar? I feel I am "not strong enough to stay away."
The lead singers (both John and Korey) from Skillet singing for Apocalyptica... The thought gives me shivers! Is there a way to beg Apocalyptica to do this collab?!
I KNOW THAT! I was saying that the lead singer of Skillet and Apocalyptica would be pretty cool TOO....please read my comment again....i know who this guy is my God
Did anyone else notice that this one is literally shot almost like a reflection of the Doug Robb version? The woman's body in the beginning and Doug are on the left in that version, and the body and Brent are on the right mostly on this one. There are a few scenes that are the same, but it seems like everything with a vocalist was reverse angled.
@bumboy5687 *orchestra. And yes they are. They play left handed in this video. look at 0:42 their doing to probably for aesthetic purposes. I would know... I'm a cellist.
ive been in orchestra for a long time you usually finger with you left and play with your right, it doesn't matter if you are left handed or right. Maybe occasionally you will play with your right hand but your supposed to play with your left hand or at least thats how all of the musicians even my orchestra teacher who plays the cello does.
Weird how two people singing the exact same song can sound so different. I think Rob sings it with more pain and Brent is more angry I love them both!
I believe that both versions of the songs are great however, Brent Smith has always sang with such power and passion in all of his songs, and this song is no exception. You can see it in his face such power and emotion brings the song that extra something that takes it slightly over the top over doug. Great Song
personally i like brents better, he gives it the right amount of anger to really appeal to me. the other guys is good but to me he seems out of place... probably because i heard that one 4 minutes ago after hearing brents for months and months... lol
Somebody said this on the Robb version so I'll say it here too, both sing with great emotion, difference is that Robb sings with sadness, Smith sings with anger. Honestly each gives a different meaning to the song.
Are all the parts with Perttu, Paavo and Eicca being mirrored since it looks like they are playing with they left hand? None of the guys is a lefty (bow in the left hand)..
I personally prefer this version since Brent has an amazing voice, I love all his songs and he still sounds awesome live. Apocalyptica always choose the right vocalists for their songs
Don't like the Doug Robb version, I feel his voice doesn't suit the song. Love Brent Smith though, amazing voice to go with an amazing song. Can't get enough of their cellos :D
@LORDUnLuCkY13 Yea that would of been better then two videos that are the same, It would have made it easier to understand that they are being cheated on with the same girl and they both can't let her go.
@DsOwAn no.. i think they just did it two ways. and the song is about being in love with girl who isnt for u.. and knowing it but she owns ur heart... its about being in love with a hurtful lover.... thats it. and im glad they did it both ways.
@ladydie1234 I'm glad to I love both their voices for this song and I saw the possibility of both and either way I like the idea because they are both scenarios that people can relate too. Thanks :)
Doug Robb is an excellent singer, but this song was written for Brent Smith's voice. That's why it fits better. They should have just written a different song for Doug, something that fits his voice.
Doug Robb has a very passionate sound to it but brent has much more powerful commanding voice the really works beautifully with this song. my vote is for brent smith
You know this is perfect for Jacky and Jenny on the Darkness games and comic books look them up :)...
jessedrew45 4 days ago
he sounds kinda like elton john at points in this. (that's not an insult)
gothshinobi 1 week ago
OMG! The video makes the song even more awesome! Sadly it says exactly what I'm goin through right now ¥_¥
GuruMiester1 1 week ago 2
@GuruMiester1 ditto....its sucks.......i know how u feel :/
girgirlrc625 13 hours ago
This version is so much better than Doug Robb's IMHO.
Evilbitch666 1 week ago in playlist Favorite videos 3
@Evilbitch666 Amen, the only reason they would do it with him is if they go touring and brent is busy with shinedown....well they have a backup dude
hohnermode11 6 days ago
he is from shinedown
anarchyangel8888 1 week ago
other version is better
555metaltapp666 1 week ago
@555metaltapp666 nope
jessedrew45 4 days ago
This song is my anthem, and it is amaizing. It may be odd, but it perfectly captures the characteristics of my ED's. I am trapt between the love and hate of my disordered eating. Please be kind to this. It has taken me months to be able to post this. I just want to know if anyone feels anything similar? I feel I am "not strong enough to stay away."
HelloXXXLonely 1 week ago 2
Apocalyptica + Adele?
That would be awesome
ryancz9997 1 week ago
awesome
slager4ever 2 weeks ago
Brent just has that voice.... it makes you want to listen, you feel the words & the music!!
beffiesue2384 2 weeks ago
@beffiesue2384 Brent Smith from what band?
seanw23 1 week ago
@seanw23 he's from seether-an AMAZING group ^^
daedra454 1 week ago
@seanw23 @daedra454 no, Brent Smith is from Shinedown
vmipsychmajor 1 week ago
def better then the doug robb version. but both r amazing
ThisisLies97 2 weeks ago 2
did they use the same model for this song that they used for Flyleafs w/ apocalyptica?
hynata15 2 weeks ago
dave grohl and apocalyptica would be interesting
KurtCobain4Life100 2 weeks ago
This video is like
A mirror; the images are turned around. Have you noticed it?
EnkeljI 3 weeks ago
@EnkeljI yeah thats because the copyright pal :) but after all doesnt matter just enjoy it as is due ;)
akaded1 3 weeks ago
Está en espejo el
Video... Se dieron cuenta?
EnkeljI 3 weeks ago
xD thiis song iis de best iis more best than mtallica xD
SImndez11997 4 weeks ago
Brent Smith freakin' kills this song.. LOVE IT!
MissChikki777 1 month ago 2
My life
CaylaLovesYouToo 1 month ago
The lead singers (both John and Korey) from Skillet singing for Apocalyptica... The thought gives me shivers! Is there a way to beg Apocalyptica to do this collab?!
Wolkeyfentah 1 month ago
@Wolkeyfentah Not sure if I'd like it much, but that would be very interesting to see...
Paragon468 4 weeks ago
This says it all!!! 17yrs of my marriage one song.
scttcorn 1 month ago
awesome song
sasquatchinheadphone 1 month ago
I do like Doug Robb better for this song, but whoa; Brent Smith is so handsome! And Brent fits better with the over-all look/feel of the video.
rogueathena 1 month ago
the people who clicked "dislike" obviously don't have speakers
SixthSol 1 month ago in playlist Favorite videos 5
This song really makes me cry... But i love it
tangrinelml 1 month ago
Never thought I'd prefer a music video if they took the women out...
Tantalus017 1 month ago
I never thought I'd prefer a music video if the women were taken out...
Tantalus017 1 month ago
I like the way tht guy's hair blows in the wind (:
pinkchocolate0418 1 month ago
apocalyptica and Amy lee would be awsome^^
PeasyAirsoft93 1 month ago 44
@PeasyAirsoft93 there is a song with apocalyptica and amy lee...
PureMoodsByPurple 2 weeks ago
@PeasyAirsoft93 OMG I soo agree. Their voices are so different, It would be amaizing!!
HelloXXXLonely 1 week ago
@PeasyAirsoft93 Just saying, with the amount of orchestral stuff in Evanescence already, I feel like that would be a little redundant...
TheDrock75 1 week ago
@PeasyAirsoft93 So would Apocalyptica and Jacoby Shaddix
quagmire19 1 week ago
@PeasyAirsoft93 i agree!!!!!!!!!
vntSvnt 4 days ago
Amazing Vocals :D
TheMikua 1 month ago
I love this song, and Brent looks really good too.
lovelygolucky 1 month ago
This song really hits home for me. I love it!!!!
ldallas5 1 month ago
Such a special song to me... I'll always love you E
LadyBella27 1 month ago
Brent looks so comfortable with them...i think he should do his own song with them
Purepwns3234 1 month ago
Excellent!!
95m26 1 month ago
this is amazing, the video was creepy but the song and the lyrics its just WOW!
michiemagana 1 month ago
This is the first time ive heard this an i have to say...AMAZING!!!!!
lips2324 1 month ago
i luv the way brent does this song...dont like the way doug robb does it @ all:(
nanook1955 1 month ago in playlist Liked videos
My GOD!! ya casi!!!!!!!!! :DDDDDDDDD
rockGirlGuilty 1 month ago
I KNOW THAT! I was saying that the lead singer of Skillet and Apocalyptica would be pretty cool TOO....please read my comment again....i know who this guy is my God
blazertide92 1 month ago
I think it is the lead singer of Shinedown
Angidngelic1 1 month ago
@Angidngelic1 Yeah it is
XxXemobabesXxX 1 month ago
I am now confident I can play cello, get laid, and be totally awesome at the same time lol
TheMetalmaker1 1 month ago 36
@TheMetalmaker1 Join the club
Fantasydude14 1 month ago
@TheMetalmaker1 yes but u gotta a complete badass at it xD
wowhead0123 3 weeks ago
@TheMetalmaker1 but u have to head bang at the same time its key :3
RejectJohn 3 weeks ago
this song is beautifyl, sexy and amazing :)
ariel1c65 1 month ago
Can someone find me a link where this guy don't sing it
RaveKandiWaffles 1 month ago
I like it better with this singer..lemme change it..
laguerais1 1 month ago
fuuuu
MrKornporn 1 month ago in playlist favorites
Loved it and the song"Broken Pieces"I also think the drummer is HOT!! :D
LucindaPrice14 1 month ago
went to type something awesome for a comment, but I'm at a loss for awesome words...
hockeygirllovesjesus 1 month ago
Epic
lordshadow552 1 month ago
I think he is too
Heather5789 2 months ago
I think hes the singer for Shinedown. Freaking awesome, love his singing
tpm1868 2 months ago
mi cancion favorita <3
damageetern 2 months ago
Did anyone else notice that this one is literally shot almost like a reflection of the Doug Robb version? The woman's body in the beginning and Doug are on the left in that version, and the body and Brent are on the right mostly on this one. There are a few scenes that are the same, but it seems like everything with a vocalist was reverse angled.
RavenBlacke 2 months ago
@RavenBlacke after seeing u say that i kinda noticed the same thing. Everythings basically going in opposite directions.
backozzfest 2 months ago
@RavenBlacke If memory serves this is the original verson but they had to redo it with Doug Robb due to copyright problems or somesuch
KHDraxos 2 months ago in playlist Metal
They're playing their cellos... wrong?
TheUntouchablezzzzz 2 months ago
@TheUntouchablezzzzz Not at all. It's an orchastra band.
bumboy5687 2 months ago
@bumboy5687 *orchestra. And yes they are. They play left handed in this video. look at 0:42 their doing to probably for aesthetic purposes. I would know... I'm a cellist.
TheUntouchablezzzzz 2 months ago
@TheUntouchablezzzzz
ive been in orchestra for a long time you usually finger with you left and play with your right, it doesn't matter if you are left handed or right. Maybe occasionally you will play with your right hand but your supposed to play with your left hand or at least thats how all of the musicians even my orchestra teacher who plays the cello does.
kanime021 2 months ago
@kanime021 The video itself is actually flipped. If you look at the other version of the song it's the same footage just flipped the right way.
TheUntouchablezzzzz 2 months ago
@bumboy5687 Actually, the video's flipped.
TheUntouchablezzzzz 2 months ago
Weird how two people singing the exact same song can sound so different. I think Rob sings it with more pain and Brent is more angry I love them both!
Grima3773 2 months ago 3
i prefer this version
jipjipjip2 2 months ago
i like this version more than the other version
nascarfan199 2 months ago
Im not sure which one i like better, this one, or with Doug Robb
aXXomaster 2 months ago
how bout krysta cameron? :)
Donovanarchy 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
they need 2 have m shadows, jacoby from papa roach, billie joe armstrong, john cooper, david from disturbed, chester bennington, and lizzy hale
Greendayboy01 2 months ago
@Greendayboy01 I just died a little inside from the amazingness of your comment. 8D
JohnnyXFay 2 months ago
@JohnnyXFay thanks! i wld love if they did any of those people, also hollywood undead
Greendayboy01 2 months ago
Awesome!
CMariaPia 2 months ago
Apocalyptica + Jerry Cantrell
27kg 2 months ago
@27kg why not?
27kg 2 months ago
James Durbin+Apocalyptica=JIZZ
FlamingPineapples1 2 months ago
M. Shadows + Apocalyptica.
TodaysApocalypse 2 months ago 2
i love both versions of this song
NinjaChick373 2 months ago
pow essa musica e phoda d+...
diogenes975 2 months ago
serj tankian and apocalyptica would be beastin!!!
Bhutan97 2 months ago
shinedown...like a boss
fightintexasaggie1 2 months ago
@NiranGs lol me to
XboxPlayer134 2 months ago
Amazing shit. Unreal talent.
TruthUnderFire 2 months ago
I LOVE brent smithhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh <3 gah!
MsWandeezy 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
Ive only just listened to this song for like a minute and i already love it !
NiranGs 2 months ago
I believe that both versions of the songs are great however, Brent Smith has always sang with such power and passion in all of his songs, and this song is no exception. You can see it in his face such power and emotion brings the song that extra something that takes it slightly over the top over doug. Great Song
viper324 2 months ago 2
OH NO! If those girls keep hacking at their throats with those bowstrings they may get some mild irritation or even possibly a rash of some sorts!
sHr3DMaSTA68 2 months ago
I feel so fucking touched by this. I want to play this for the rev.
bumboy5687 2 months ago 59
Justin Beiber and Apocalyptica
jearegood 2 months ago
@jearegood No. Do not do that. It'll be the 3rd top disliked symphony artists. JK.
bumboy5687 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@jearegood No. Do not do that. It'll be the 3rd top disliked symphony artists. JK.
bumboy5687 2 months ago
@jearegood
Whatever.
TruthUnderFire 2 months ago
Brent has the deeper heavier voice than Doug does. That's why the song sounds so right with him singing it.
jearegood 2 months ago
And i'd like to see a duet of those two, if i had both versions i'd totally do that :P
IsThis4Entertainment 2 months ago
personally i like brents better, he gives it the right amount of anger to really appeal to me. the other guys is good but to me he seems out of place... probably because i heard that one 4 minutes ago after hearing brents for months and months... lol
IsThis4Entertainment 2 months ago
Apocalyptic ft lil Wayne
Brookekrei90 2 months ago
james hetfield and apocaliptica
sgunzalez 2 months ago
Somebody said this on the Robb version so I'll say it here too, both sing with great emotion, difference is that Robb sings with sadness, Smith sings with anger. Honestly each gives a different meaning to the song.
PunkBaller23 2 months ago
@PunkBaller23 ur totally right, both are very good
alexcendre1988 2 months ago
lead singer from Skillet and apocalyptica? that would be good too :)
blazertide92 2 months ago 65
@blazertide92 seether not skillet
brontosaurious 2 months ago
@brontosaurious WRONG. Shinedown not seether.
AlexVendetta360 2 months ago
@blazertide92 he's the lead singer of Shinedown not the sissy crap band like Skillet..
najamkhn 1 month ago
@blazertide92 both of the singers from Skillet Both him and his wife would be comepetely amazing!!!! <3
bleachnote63 1 month ago
Ke rola (Y)
clemm999 3 months ago
id like to see apoctalyptica and m. shadows do a version of so far away on cello. thatd be sick
TheBlyzzrd 3 months ago
Lol
noturbizniz 3 months ago
He looks like Graverobber from Repo! The Genetic Opera
noturbizniz 3 months ago
Apocalypica (ft. Ivan Moody [five finger death punch]) would be awesome!
goneover 3 months ago 3
Does this follow the storyline to Broken Pieces? Looks like the same girl.
MissCaitieSunshine 3 months ago
@MissCaitieSunshine
It is her, Lacey.
Mythans 3 months ago
Are all the parts with Perttu, Paavo and Eicca being mirrored since it looks like they are playing with they left hand? None of the guys is a lefty (bow in the left hand)..
tiidanhe 3 months ago
@tiidanhe good point here!
ProphetCassandra 3 months ago
ahhhh makes me miss playing my cello :'( dont have the money to get it fixed
brittanyrclay 3 months ago
isnt this the guy that sings with shinedown?
arcadeidiot3 3 months ago
@arcadeidiot3 yup.
slipknotowns23 3 months ago
@arcadeidiot3 Yes, yes it is.
demonlegato123 3 months ago
@arcadeidiot3 no duh
ladydie1234 3 months ago in playlist the good stuff.!!
This has been flagged as spam show
I find both Brent and Doug awesome! I'm going to overplay both of them.
sexyangel421j 3 months ago
videos in reverse.
sheamus316 3 months ago
I personally prefer this version since Brent has an amazing voice, I love all his songs and he still sounds awesome live. Apocalyptica always choose the right vocalists for their songs
ZurriTheElysianLemur 3 months ago
Sooooooooo Awesome!!!!!!!!!!!
TheNancyh333 3 months ago
this version is so much better . . . the song actually has more power to it with brent but with doug i felt like it was too weak
AshleyToxicAndTheRev 3 months ago
Don't like the Doug Robb version, I feel his voice doesn't suit the song. Love Brent Smith though, amazing voice to go with an amazing song. Can't get enough of their cellos :D
tc1ndy 3 months ago
I definately like both versions, both vocalists have great voices, I prefer Brent's version simply because of the power of his voice.
It would be awesome is Apocalyptica could re-record this as a duet like with Max Cavalera and Matt Tuck or Lauri Ylonen and Ville Vallo.
Regardless Apocalyptica is always awesome.
LORDUnLuCkY13 3 months ago 2
@LORDUnLuCkY13 Yea that would of been better then two videos that are the same, It would have made it easier to understand that they are being cheated on with the same girl and they both can't let her go.
DsOwAn 3 months ago in playlist DsOwAn's favorites
@DsOwAn Well it never implicitly stated to be cheating, just a really bad relationship.
LORDUnLuCkY13 3 months ago
@LORDUnLuCkY13 Yea that true it's not in the song but making two videos with Brent and Robb with one girl it's kinda implied.
DsOwAn 3 months ago
@DsOwAn no.. i think they just did it two ways. and the song is about being in love with girl who isnt for u.. and knowing it but she owns ur heart... its about being in love with a hurtful lover.... thats it. and im glad they did it both ways.
ladydie1234 3 months ago in playlist the good stuff.!!
@ladydie1234 I'm glad to I love both their voices for this song and I saw the possibility of both and either way I like the idea because they are both scenarios that people can relate too. Thanks :)
DsOwAn 3 months ago
@DsOwAn their music keeps me alive.
ladydie1234 3 months ago in playlist the good stuff.!!
Personally I think Doug did a better job, a much stronger but also smother voice.
GellieIsHere 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Can we all just shut up about who is better? They are both good.
maddogmayfield 3 months ago
both versions are really good. i think Brent has the power, but doug has the emotion if that makes sense
Slaughterbound 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Zombieacostv said"And who said playing a cello wouldnt get you laid?"
LMFAO!!!
DanieVargas 3 months ago
bitemywife she really knows how to hurt guy the bitch
jokenater1 3 months ago
I like Dougs voice more for this song just because he adds more emotion Brent would have done better in a song like "Im not Jesus"
Kane13Emo 3 months ago in playlist Happy Sad IDGAF Music
anything featuring Brent Smith is gold
dazzydaz89 3 months ago
i love this song <3
Miggaaa1 3 months ago
I love both versions but I like Brent's power in this one. The range fits his voice much better as well.
cpthornman 3 months ago
fucking awsome!!!!!!!! Staight to the heart of all our domestic violence problems.
dkunz1012 3 months ago
Comment removed
matthewczerny 3 months ago
They need to do a song with Myles Kennedy and Benjamin Burnley!!!
KieronJConroy 3 months ago
@KieronJConroy I'd looooove that! BEN<3
tc1ndy 3 months ago
Doug Robb is an excellent singer, but this song was written for Brent Smith's voice. That's why it fits better. They should have just written a different song for Doug, something that fits his voice.
iminfected 4 months ago
Hahaha, the video is inverted, Mikko ain't a lefty as well as Eicca, Perttu, and Paavo.
utapau235 4 months ago
Both singers are great but I do agree brent puts more power and force in this one
ManLikeYou 4 months ago
i like both versions.but i personally like this one more
jeffhardylover1992 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
... this video makes me jealous ...XD
2:40- nuff said
Animalcrossing95 4 months ago
Comment removed
Animalcrossing95 4 months ago
Props to both brent smith and doug robb!! keep on rockin fellas!!
06wordlife 4 months ago
Why are there two versions again?
KHDraxos 4 months ago
omg... im torn btw Doug Rob and Brent Smith! there bothsoooooooooooooooooo great!!!!
NinjaKiwiBat 4 months ago
\m/
samuraikata 4 months ago
this song always makes me tear up a bit...Brent's voice is so powerful and emotional.
redrhyn0 4 months ago
best song ive heard in a long time
cokeandwhiskey 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Doug Robb has a very passionate sound to it but brent has much more powerful commanding voice the really works beautifully with this song. my vote is for brent smith
Alexgarrison009 4 months ago
They need to fire doug and replace him with brent smith... I think I just had an eargasim listening to this song.....
Allinballzout 4 months ago 2
@Allinballzout 1st half- VERY true. 2nd half- No comment
SpawnHell137 4 months ago
Why don;t they have a version with both Brent and Doug? Come on, just why not?
itazurazukina 4 months ago
=D
fabiopereirascp01 4 months ago