This is kind of the worst thing ever. It's Help with an 'ugh' noise where the explantion mark should be. I think I'm going to have to go watch the film (Help!) to recover. It's times like this when only John, Paul, George and Ringo can make it better.
She is not that talented. No where in the same league as Rebecca or Cher. When she puts out (another) album, then her true talent will be reflected in record sales.
We can then truly compare her to 'duffy' 'adele'... etc...
I couldn't care less what anyone thinks about her.. I think shes amazing and doesn't deserve all the hate she gets - the press can make or break somebody and they chose to break her. She is my idol.. One day I want to be able to push off peoples comments on me like they are nothing! She should of been on the final.
And if you hate her then why waste your time looking at her videos?
@perfectlyjust you dont have to believe evrything you read in the paper, she has a great voice and is talented, and shes not gonna be forgotten and rejected and shes defo. not a slag. shes done really well on this show, and now people know who she is she can go on and do well in the future.
Just shows that even a talented singer will be rubbish when the wrong songs are picked for them to sing... she has the potential to be a very good artist and should have been fighting it out with Rebecca/Matt/One Direction for the win. Hope she gets a chance to record some songs that suit her subtle, interesting and also powerful voice. I called the fact that Diana Vickers would be successful and I'm saying now, Katie will be too... just watch. 1:20 - 2:23 best on this years show...
I'd hated Katie from the first moment she walked on stage in the auditions. But this performance was fantastic. She actually deserved to not be in the vote off and I'm glad she wasn't. Thank god Cher's finally getting to see what people really think of her shit performances as it's her turn to get voted out very soon.
@perfectlyjust maybe you should get in touch with her granny seeing as your not the one performing to millions every saturday night. shes a great singer and doesn't get the credit she deserves, it's people like you that ruin it for her.
katie's back. the new image and persona are inspired. and that delivery was well controlled. i don't claim that she's the greatest singer...who comes to x-factor for that? but considering what she's been going thru, that was fucking heroic. death threats ffs. we haven't progressed much from our savage ancestry.
The worm is turning - and about time too. Katie has always had great potential but has never been given the chance to really display it until last Saturday. Matt, Rebecca, Katie, Mary, Paije, Treyc and to a lesser degree, John were the only real vocalists in this year's competition and out of that list it's Katie who has the most celebrity potential. Matt & Rebecca will make great recording artists, Paije will also be a great performer whilst the other three will be good for studio sessions.
For me personally she has the best voice in the competition. I'd buy her album. I'd want to meet her. I'd want to go to her concert.
Even though Matt and Rebecca have fantastic voices.. Quite honestly they would bore me to tears in concert. Watching them perform is like watching paint dry.
Katie entertains me so much.
Cheryl only cares about Rebecca & Cher.
Katie deserves better from the public and Cheryl.
At least people are starting to accept Katie more.
wow the astroturfers are working overtime with the fake comments of support for this talentless ugly fake turd. this was absolutely shit, she cant sing at all, her voice is pathetic. she looks like a bloke in drag most of the time, last night she looked like a full bloke, fucking puke. the judges comments were so fake it was nausiating. now shes made the tour she will probably get the boot tonight or next week. this show is a sham. go fuck urself simon con man cunt cowell you ugly piece of shit
@canagligana Errr don't be rude no need to get personal... I'm British and think this girl is a beautiful singer.... Don't tar us all with the same brush please..
I always liked her voice and I can see she is a nice person but I didn't like all of her performances. However, after listening to her tonight I have to confess I think she would even deserve to win this show if they'd let her pick the songs. I've been watching this particular performance for 6 times and I love it more every time. Honestly the best of the night in my opinion.
she has such a great voice.. but nobody sees that?! I cannot understand... She is quite one of the best singers in that competition,, But Cheryl just gives her bad songs... She cares more about Cher and Rebecca -.-
i'm not from UK and i don't know what bad stuff is written about her, so can someone explain me, or give me a link where can i read? thak you.
nucisfan17 6 months ago in playlist x factor
Anyone who says leave her alone she can sing?! WTF not bein funny or nothin but i love the beatles and this is just a pile of shit!
Kevo123ist 7 months ago
i like katie vogel ALLOT
1LilMegz 8 months ago
Cheap? It's a fucking Beatles song.
CosmicHobo2 9 months ago 4
In fact, better way of putting it; she looks like she's in a child abuse infomation film! I'm suprised she didn't bring on a cuddly rabbit!
mousesandwich 11 months ago
This is kind of the worst thing ever. It's Help with an 'ugh' noise where the explantion mark should be. I think I'm going to have to go watch the film (Help!) to recover. It's times like this when only John, Paul, George and Ringo can make it better.
mousesandwich 11 months ago
LOL..
cmomofilm 1 year ago
THIS IS ONE OF MY FAVE PERFORMANCES BY HER (l)
BlackStar1200 1 year ago
She is not that talented. No where in the same league as Rebecca or Cher. When she puts out (another) album, then her true talent will be reflected in record sales.
We can then truly compare her to 'duffy' 'adele'... etc...
jimnebob 1 year ago
she looks ugly with her hair like that...her ears pop out aswell lol
NinaLuvsFriedChicken 1 year ago
I couldn't care less what anyone thinks about her.. I think shes amazing and doesn't deserve all the hate she gets - the press can make or break somebody and they chose to break her. She is my idol.. One day I want to be able to push off peoples comments on me like they are nothing! She should of been on the final.
And if you hate her then why waste your time looking at her videos?
I LOVE YOU KATIE
mollymoore123 1 year ago
she is so amazing, she is so good! wauw
13714 1 year ago
I like the way she sang it but i dont like her
SuperGeo52 1 year ago
This woman is ten a penny. Do we really need another fame hungry idiot willing to selling her soul to be on TV?? Also have you seen her jaw line???
dantastic15 1 year ago
not really a fan of katie. but this is by far her best performance
xemmathedilemma 1 year ago
her hair looks ugly on her
waterdoll300 1 year ago
flat
LucysDrowning 1 year ago
Why did she change into an Elf!?
coopsacola 1 year ago 2
@coopsacola i hear the elf votes were a major factor in the results. She needed to appeal to a wider audience ;)
underfirefly 1 year ago
I came to watch this again because this was the week where Katie got the 2nd most votes :O
Not a fan of her btw.
LegendKillerWWE 1 year ago
@perfectlyjust you dont have to believe evrything you read in the paper, she has a great voice and is talented, and shes not gonna be forgotten and rejected and shes defo. not a slag. shes done really well on this show, and now people know who she is she can go on and do well in the future.
espirantha 1 year ago
@espirantha well said :)
Zuleika997 1 year ago
Her Best Performance
MsAnnabel360 1 year ago
I am not a Katie fan but even I can admit that this was a great performance.
richiewest90 1 year ago
I love katie D:! Best out of the x factor 2010
joetri10 1 year ago
wow AMAZING!
IrishEurovisionFan 1 year ago
She looks like Stine from Alphabeat
skintrade 1 year ago
Just shows that even a talented singer will be rubbish when the wrong songs are picked for them to sing... she has the potential to be a very good artist and should have been fighting it out with Rebecca/Matt/One Direction for the win. Hope she gets a chance to record some songs that suit her subtle, interesting and also powerful voice. I called the fact that Diana Vickers would be successful and I'm saying now, Katie will be too... just watch. 1:20 - 2:23 best on this years show...
cfrobbo 1 year ago
1:20 - 2:23 awsome
Deejaytj12345 1 year ago
I've always found this bitch so annoying, but that performance was definitely one of the best I have seen on x factor.
lampard554 1 year ago
hope she gets the opportunity to get an album out. personality wise i think shes the British version of bjork who is incredible
daveduznotrull 1 year ago 3
Comment removed
daveduznotrull 1 year ago
i love her version of this song...think she's realy good. There's something special about her ...
people should give her a shot....she could go far in music...and do it her own way
Jahyanna 1 year ago
I'd hated Katie from the first moment she walked on stage in the auditions. But this performance was fantastic. She actually deserved to not be in the vote off and I'm glad she wasn't. Thank god Cher's finally getting to see what people really think of her shit performances as it's her turn to get voted out very soon.
chocolatesoup09 1 year ago
She should get in touch with her Granny and try whoring instead of murdering the crap out of every song she sings.
perfectlyjust 1 year ago
@perfectlyjust maybe you should get in touch with her granny seeing as your not the one performing to millions every saturday night. shes a great singer and doesn't get the credit she deserves, it's people like you that ruin it for her.
espirantha 1 year ago
@espirantha
Actually fame hungry media whores with little talent ruin it for themselves.
FACT- It's back to oblivion for Fakie Katie.
She so deserves to be on the xfactor reject slag heap which is exactly where she now is and will stay forever more.
perfectlyjust 1 year ago
i love this performance... she is a natural talent and an entertainer! Go Katie.. haters will hate... peace!
swattworld 1 year ago
When she said about an image change then this came on I nearly spat out my food laughing. Didn't know the WW2 POW Shindlers list style was in fashion.
Great voice but can't help notice the ears now. Shes like a tobby jug with two handles.
person8203 1 year ago
@kentstrongtommy1 Agree absolutely.
MCForty 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
katie's back. the new image and persona are inspired. and that delivery was well controlled. i don't claim that she's the greatest singer...who comes to x-factor for that? but considering what she's been going thru, that was fucking heroic. death threats ffs. we haven't progressed much from our savage ancestry.
sybyly 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ruined that song.
Beth1705 1 year ago
I miss her hair though :(
elizerxoxo 1 year ago
and i totally loved her new look, she's not hot, she's beautiful!
i love her personality, the way she sings a great song, sincerly, i feel her and thta's all about in MUSIC, about feeling.
kentstrongtommy1 1 year ago 2
LOOK, SHE'S TALENTED , UNIQUE AFTER REBECCA.
BUT SHE'S NOT A POPSTAR AND NEVER WILL BE!
SHE'S A SOULSTAR!!!!!!!!!! GIVE HER SOUL SONGS, SOMETHING WITH LYRICS, FEELING, A SONG WITH A MESSAGE AND SHE'LL SHINE JUST LIKE IN THIS COMPETITION!
PEOPLE NEEDS TO SEE THAT NOT ONLY POP MUSIC SELLS!
TAKE A LOOK AT AMY WINO, DUFFY, ADELE, ETC, THEY ARE MUSICIANS NOT POPSTARS LIKE RIHANNA, MILEY OR GAGA STILL THEY'RE SELLING RECORDS EXPLODED!
so don't judge katie for not being able to sing cheap songs ok???
kentstrongtommy1 1 year ago 59
@kentstrongtommy1 Ur exited u puff
chrislivia12 1 year ago
@kentstrongtommy1 You think Help! is a cheap song?
mousesandwich 11 months ago
Shes Crap
Tashai247 1 year ago
The worm is turning - and about time too. Katie has always had great potential but has never been given the chance to really display it until last Saturday. Matt, Rebecca, Katie, Mary, Paije, Treyc and to a lesser degree, John were the only real vocalists in this year's competition and out of that list it's Katie who has the most celebrity potential. Matt & Rebecca will make great recording artists, Paije will also be a great performer whilst the other three will be good for studio sessions.
MCForty 1 year ago
For me personally she has the best voice in the competition. I'd buy her album. I'd want to meet her. I'd want to go to her concert.
Even though Matt and Rebecca have fantastic voices.. Quite honestly they would bore me to tears in concert. Watching them perform is like watching paint dry.
Katie entertains me so much.
Cheryl only cares about Rebecca & Cher.
Katie deserves better from the public and Cheryl.
At least people are starting to accept Katie more.
Btw, this is my fave Katie performance
CherryCraze 1 year ago 2
she was amazing im more of a rebeca fan but she was the best of the night with rebeca =D
abbyrosef 1 year ago
love katie, she has an amazing voice :) this was my fave performance of her, cant stop watching it
natb55 1 year ago 2
Totally agree with what junisor1 wrote.
cotacotchi 1 year ago
Oh God..
angeliesings 1 year ago
Amazing performance!! Many kisses from Greece!!
ComeAlong28 1 year ago
Please give this girl a break for once
little1intheuk 1 year ago
Seriously, what the FUCK were the producers thinking letting this horrific piece of "music" put on prime time TV? It's AWFUL.
wikichris 1 year ago
wow the astroturfers are working overtime with the fake comments of support for this talentless ugly fake turd. this was absolutely shit, she cant sing at all, her voice is pathetic. she looks like a bloke in drag most of the time, last night she looked like a full bloke, fucking puke. the judges comments were so fake it was nausiating. now shes made the tour she will probably get the boot tonight or next week. this show is a sham. go fuck urself simon con man cunt cowell you ugly piece of shit
smithdave2237 1 year ago
i don't care for her either way.. i've loved some of her performances but i thought she was out of tune and her nervers were really showing
dco1987 1 year ago
i thought her version of this was staggeringly good
Joersvids 1 year ago
lol she reminds me of Mia Farrow's Character in Rosemary's baby... and no that was not a compliment
LoloSparks2009 1 year ago
One of the best and original singer. But british are sick and kinky. They can't appreciate the true talent.
canagligana 1 year ago 3
@canagligana Errr don't be rude no need to get personal... I'm British and think this girl is a beautiful singer.... Don't tar us all with the same brush please..
biscuitnrabbi 1 year ago
This is a lovely performance, and she's so pretty as well!
I don't know why people don't like her :S
This and her week 2 performance of 'I'd rather go blind' are the songs that have showed off her voice best :)
AmbitiousOutsider1 1 year ago 2
Can't stop listening to this!!
Vsmets 1 year ago
Comment removed
Vsmets 1 year ago
Amazing! I didn't like her before but I think after that she can win.
12345636124 1 year ago
thats absolute brutal you guys are tone deaf sums up the public really when she is still in
xaar81 1 year ago
I always liked her voice and I can see she is a nice person but I didn't like all of her performances. However, after listening to her tonight I have to confess I think she would even deserve to win this show if they'd let her pick the songs. I've been watching this particular performance for 6 times and I love it more every time. Honestly the best of the night in my opinion.
junisor1 1 year ago 11
Love this performance!
jlegg66 1 year ago
she has such a great voice.. but nobody sees that?! I cannot understand... She is quite one of the best singers in that competition,, But Cheryl just gives her bad songs... She cares more about Cher and Rebecca -.-
WomanizerKai 1 year ago 36
@WomanizerKai no she has a crap voice
chrislivia12 1 year ago
I wish people would stop judging Katie! They don't even know her..
tara1993 1 year ago 2
@tara1993 It's a judging show :O
damein01666 1 year ago