although i can't see silver and jim past the father-son dynamic, i think it is within the rights of ppl to interpret however they please the characters's relationship with one another. i applaud for whoever made this because this person made it for their and others' imagination and happiness. i am not against happiness, so therefore i see nothing wrong with this. :)
again, good job! so therefore, nay-sayers, if you don't like it then don't watch. that simple.
Dude, the reason this seems so wrong to me is because the other guy is like...twice his age. I have no problem with same-sex/homosexual/gay/whatever the hell we want to call it relationships, but I always saw their relationship more as father-son and this sort of ruins that for me. :(
@fairyslight then... why did you push this movie?? just wondering, I mean, you DID see the yaoi word when you clicked on this video, right?? I agree with you on that "I always saw them as a father and son" but I'm just curious ;)
@airachica I would blame my poor cognitive skills at three in the morning...but I am naturally curious I suppose. The same reason I guess I feel the need to read an argument that goes entirely against my personal beliefs...I guess I just wanted to see what the video creator had to say via this art form in that case...?
I love Treasure Planet. I love what's in Treasure Planet. What I don't love is people changing the sexual orientations of the freakin' characters, especially those in a DISNEY movie. I know I'll get hate comments for this saying that people are entitled to their own opinions, but there is something incredibly wrong with all you guys for doing this to a kid's movie. Stick to Fanfiction, stay away from Disney movies. And I'm all for gay people, but you guys are sick bastards.
How the heck are we sick bastards? There is no evidence in the movie showing that these two are straight now is there? When do we ever see Jim or Silver attracted to women. And it's our own interpretations, there is evidence there that this could've been more than just friendship- but a kids movie would never go into the homosexual aspect of the relationship. And by turning the characters gay we're not doing it just for the sake- most yaois are based off evidence giving in films
@Pinkberrythecat 1st its pedophilia and 2nd its no evidence that there is love as a couple, is it hard to accept that this movie isnt about romance but about father-son bond?
@Fackinfine I know the movie ain't about romance, I knew that all along. I was just pointing out earlier that there was no evidence to give that Silver and Jim were straight. And I can see it as both a father son relationship or something more. But I know what you mean by the pedophilia thing, I'd forgotten how old Jim is, but on my behalf, I did originally think he was 18.
although i can't see silver and jim past the father-son dynamic, i think it is within the rights of ppl to interpret however they please the characters's relationship with one another. i applaud for whoever made this because this person made it for their and others' imagination and happiness. i am not against happiness, so therefore i see nothing wrong with this. :)
again, good job! so therefore, nay-sayers, if you don't like it then don't watch. that simple.
ThouWindowShatters 6 months ago
HOLY FUCK.
Okay. Why is everyone making such a big deal over what people interpret Jim and Silver's relationship as?
If's it's a disney movie why the hell is it such a big deal to you nay sayers?
If Silver is a fatherly figure, fine, if he's a boyfriend figure, whatever floats your boat.
i'm just saying, why is everyone getting their panties in a bunch about this? It's a fucking movie.
Get over it. Please.
MsRuffledfeathers 6 months ago
good video
scar504 6 months ago
nononononoooo pleasee!!! not in the Treasure Planet!!! TT_TT i have nothing against the yaoi! but...why do people have to put yaoi everywhere!?!?!??
and ...bleee Jim and Silver???? their relationship is more like father and son! XD
fantalimone3991 9 months ago
Read the book this movie was based on. Loved it sooooo hard because I kept imagining yaoi left and right xD
Comchiki 10 months ago 2
Dude, the reason this seems so wrong to me is because the other guy is like...twice his age. I have no problem with same-sex/homosexual/gay/whatever the hell we want to call it relationships, but I always saw their relationship more as father-son and this sort of ruins that for me. :(
fairyslight 10 months ago 12
@fairyslight then... why did you push this movie?? just wondering, I mean, you DID see the yaoi word when you clicked on this video, right?? I agree with you on that "I always saw them as a father and son" but I'm just curious ;)
airachica 9 months ago
Comment removed
fairyslight 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@airachica I would blame my poor cognitive skills at three in the morning...but I am naturally curious I suppose. The same reason I guess I feel the need to read an argument that goes entirely against my personal beliefs...I guess I just wanted to see what the video creator had to say via this art form in that case...?
fairyslight 9 months ago
I love Treasure Planet. I love what's in Treasure Planet. What I don't love is people changing the sexual orientations of the freakin' characters, especially those in a DISNEY movie. I know I'll get hate comments for this saying that people are entitled to their own opinions, but there is something incredibly wrong with all you guys for doing this to a kid's movie. Stick to Fanfiction, stay away from Disney movies. And I'm all for gay people, but you guys are sick bastards.
PonchoJose0750 11 months ago
@PonchoJose0750
How the heck are we sick bastards? There is no evidence in the movie showing that these two are straight now is there? When do we ever see Jim or Silver attracted to women. And it's our own interpretations, there is evidence there that this could've been more than just friendship- but a kids movie would never go into the homosexual aspect of the relationship. And by turning the characters gay we're not doing it just for the sake- most yaois are based off evidence giving in films
Pinkberrythecat 11 months ago 7
@Pinkberrythecat maybe when he flirts with captain amelia, im just sayin'
Fackinfine 6 months ago
@Fackinfine I think Silver was just cushioning up to her to get her off their backs. But I never got flirting from that
Pinkberrythecat 5 months ago
@Pinkberrythecat 1st its pedophilia and 2nd its no evidence that there is love as a couple, is it hard to accept that this movie isnt about romance but about father-son bond?
Fackinfine 5 months ago
@Fackinfine I know the movie ain't about romance, I knew that all along. I was just pointing out earlier that there was no evidence to give that Silver and Jim were straight. And I can see it as both a father son relationship or something more. But I know what you mean by the pedophilia thing, I'd forgotten how old Jim is, but on my behalf, I did originally think he was 18.
Pinkberrythecat 5 months ago
cute <3
Haruhi072 1 year ago
I really liked this video, very good job.
Pinkberrythecat 1 year ago
I liked it very much :D!
Evelyenn 1 year ago
That was awesome!! great job! can you tell me what the name of the song is?
brokensoul335 1 year ago
He-he, nice! ^^
LeAnaOrKankura 2 years ago
loved it! ^.^
TwistedAlchemist 2 years ago