Walking In The Air - Chloë vs. Hayley vs. Tarja

[ManuelBelmont100]

hayley westenra the best

[oakgrasssib]

Soon Jackie Evancho can be added to the comparison's. She has recorded this song for her upcoming X-mas CD (01 Nov). It will new a song for most in the USA.

[Hannahorse715]

u should do a vieo chloe vs hayley vs aled jones (the one who sang it in the snowman movie)

[jaazcollier]

tarja! <3

[MikeJ532]

Chloe is #1 Tarja 2, and I'm sorry, but Hayley doesn't even sing all the words to the song.

[SharenTiger]

I personally like Chloe better for this :)

[HayleyDeeWestenraCW]

I can't choose between Hayley and Chloe! Usually I don't like Chloe's voice because it's too breathy, but it really goes with the song, and of course I love Hayley no matter what song she sings!

[potterclubtv]

Tarja is the best! Her voice is much more powerful & operatic.. Just wow!

[Lizfan2]

Tarja has a beautiful voice, but her voice sounds more suited to opera & this song is not an opera song. Her version is interesting, but I prefer Chloe's.

[MsMusicspaz]

i know of chloe and hayley from celtic woman, but i'd never heard of tarja before this. All 3 versions are good, but i think hayley's is the best if i had to pick. i love chloe though

[liamthedream]

I knew right away that it was the West Coast of Clare and Chloe Agnew. Thanks for posting

[katuskitkatus]

Since I love rock music I'm well aware of Tarja and I appreciate her. Yet until today I never knew Chloe or Hayley even existed. So I searched and listened to a couple of Hayley's songs and I must admit she has an amazing voice. One thing is damn frustration though - she simply CANNOT pronounce the words entirely! She always chops them and slaughters them. I'd love her completely, but this word-slaughtering style simply kills me... :(

[kiekendiefje]

CHLOE for sure!!! I just love her!

[aholinka]

Tarja Turunen is the former lead singer of Nightwish, who published "Walking In The Air" on their album "Oceanborn" in 1998 first. One year later they published a single with the same name.

[Karen21242]

Hmmm... Let's c, Hayley is the best singer of all time but I absolutely adore Chloe upon all aspects and I've never heard of Tarja. I've heard of this song but am listening 2 it 4 the 1st time. Listening 2 this I like how Chloe has such a, 4 lack of better words, "child-like" sound that she adds 2 this song. I noticed Hayley just doesn't sound like her. Tarja sounds like she's trying 2 hard, although I like her voice. I'd have 2 say that my favorite is Chloe Agnew! : ) I love u Chloe! :D

[kallekaskas]

Tarja owns this one. Her voice is so deep and powerful.

[Marcusrafaelfet]

Tarja, her vocal is strong and versatile, when she started singing was like I woke up lol, she is insuperable

[lovelycelticopera]

If Hayley were to record this song again, I'm sure I would have to choose her over the others, hands down- She being my favorite singer and all- but I'm not a big fan of the backup music. Tarja I don't like. I think my vote will have to go to CHLOE even though I find her singing to breathy at times. Overall, It's the prettiest of the three.

[popinfresh]

definitely Hayley!!

[jdittmer34]

They're are all very good versions of this song. CHLOE's has an innocence to it as if a child were singing it; HAYLEY"s version sounds like a more mature version; TARJA's has a VERY dark GOTHIC feel to it.

[Kairuka]

Definitely Hayley, hands down, but the other two are very talented. I would never deny either of them that simply because I prefer Hayley's version.

[rockferryluv66]

I enjoy all three but I have to say that I enjoy Tarja's version the most. I love everything about her voice and what she puts into it so she would be *my* chosen one out of the trio. That's just my opinion, though, so hopefully I won't get anyone going down on me for stating it. ;]