Added: 4 years ago
From: chrispak
Views: 38,581
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (180)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • your in a major sweetie

  • it was great guys, but please, someone PLEEEASE tune that cello.

    but still very creative! :D

  • I loved it!!! 

  • u guys ROCK!!!!!!!!

  • it's absolutely not a good idea to play pachelbel's canon in D with cello

  • @hanafisama

    It kinda is the piece was written for a full orchestra or a quartet but can be adapted all kinds of ways. The cello part is crucial. It really helps set the song.

    The problem really is the way that guitars are sounding a little sharp.too much twang. Maybe if they tuned to the A and the cello was on an electric pick up. Or if the bass guitar was more active to balance out the sound of the other guitar.

  • @hanafisama

    It kinda is the piece was written for a full orchestra or a quartet but can be adapted all kinds of ways. The cello part is crucial. It really helps set the song.

    The problem really is the way that guitars are sounding a little sharp, compared to the cello, which was often a little flat....too much twang on the guitar. Maybe if they tuned to the A and the cello was on an electric pick up. Or if the bass guitar was more active to balance out the sound of the other guitar

    Cool idea.

  • @hanafisama

    It kinda is the piece was written for a full orchestra or a quartet but can be adapted all kinds of ways. The cello part is crucial. It really helps set the song.

    The problem really is the way that guitars are sounding a little sharp, compared to the cello, which was often a little flat....too much twang on the guitar. Maybe if they tuned to the A and the cello was on an electric pick up. Or a bass guitar was there to balance out the sound of the other guitar..I dunno

    Cool idea tho

  • where did you get the music for cello

    

  • LOVE THIS SONG.. AND YOU GUYS R DEF ON TO SOMETHING.. A BIT OF TUNING AND SYMPHONY NEEDED BUT KEEP PRACTICING...

  • not entirely sure everything was in tune haha but nice and original :D i like it!

  • massa!!!

  • practice ur vibrato

  • what people dont realize is that cello is much harder than an instrement *cough cough guitar* with frets

  • @musicwithin43 it is definitely harder (I play both). Still, Poor fingering choice, bad vibrato, and bad intonation just aren't acceptable on any instrument especially string instruments. I have played the melody on cello many times before, and I sound good enough. Just some advice, use a reference pitch while practicing

  • Khá hay.

    Good!

  • guys, for the last 6 months i'm tying to find a way to get a hold of you to find out where you are. i live in colorado and my wedding will be this july. i have listened to many different bands and the cello is mine and my fiancees favorite instrument. we'd love for you guys to play at our ceremony. how do we make that happen?

  • Awesome Job ! <3 i like the sound ... ^_^

  • omg! that electric guitar is so cool :o

  • I think the cello dude should work a little more =] But otherwise he did uber good, so did the rest of them =]

  • you guys r all some!!!!!

  • lordoftheusernames is right..the cello needs to go learn some rithm........it really stinks thanks to him..and soo out of tune.

  • Not bad, you should get a pickup for the cello so you can amp it.

  • Cool arrangement, but the cello was pitchy and finger movement uncoordinated.

  • ive been playing cello for 8 years and im only 13 and srry to be a critic but your cello is a little out of tune and your time is off...and your fingers too...just practice a little bit more then i promise you will get good :)

  • the cello guys out of rythm he ruined it D:

  • yall was great idc that the cello wasnt tunned maybe u like it that way u was great no matter wat they say

  • the rhythm,, got a bad strams,,at 1st mild,,then after that they made a rock,, what an ugly sound...

  • i hate to say this i think he was just playing out of tune, although i know how difficult it can be to get the cello note dead on since i play too. keep practicing nice sound alround though, got the levels right and i like the way you combined the canon rock with the original proper version :)

  • ok ur tuning is a bit off, hehe im trying to play the cello cuz im going to be a string teacher so far with the violin, viola, and cello but whatever you tuned it with its wrong cuz i the F# waz a little down

  • ive been playing cello for 5 yeras no, and u guys sounds great, but tune it up a bit cello. great job!!!!

  • i also play cello, what ever you recorded it with put it out of tune from what it actually was, but i definetly liked your modern twist!

  • Cello guy, you look strangely like you know how to handle a cello. So I'm assuming the awfulness of the sound is due in part to your recording devices (or lack of)? I'd like to hear this with better sound quality. Show some professional pride, man.

  • omg omg omg tune it tune it

  • its either tune it or put your fingering right

  • yo cello dude tune your c string 2 or 3 notes up and d is flat so is a g is 3 notes down hope ill help

  • idc if the cello wasnt tuned, that was bad-ass!!

  • lol there's like 5 comments below about how the cello isn't tuned, i agree i play cello

  • I don't play it, I even I can hear that (Avid music lover)...but still, the composition as a whole was pretty well done. Given if the cello were tuned, it would have been that much better! No?

  • Tune the friggin cello! Makes my skin crawl. LOL!

  • Tune the Cello man!

  • woa!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!tune that cello

  • XD haha he decided to become asian :)

  • It was OK not perfect not terrible, but ok.

  • tune that thing haha

  • Great job guys; keep up the good work!

  • The guitar chords weren't distinct enough. But other than that, not bad.

  • you just ruined the cello in this

    sorry but its true......

  • this song ruined cello lol

  • not good at all

  • you were bouncing your bow too much.other than tht your guys were good

  • good job ... more videos for guitar + cello

  • gd but i didnty really like it the cello needs alot of work

    maybe try violine and guitar .....

  • its not violine its violin. I play the viola! XD

  • nice very nice

    congratulations =D

  • The cello could have been A LOT better...

  • gurisada parabéns é isso aí, esses aí sabem mesmo fazer música não são como esses brasileiros que só sabem fazer creu.

  • yo cello guy u did pretty good but you were out of tune alot

  • Wow you disgrace the cello, guitar, and a good song. try posting a version that doesn't suck next time!

  • in with you man...

    make a better video next time...

    not sayin my vids are any good but yeah this was pretty bad...T.T

  • WOW! That was AWESOOOMME[; Cello rocks;D

  • great job good shpeep guys

  • loved it guys

  • the electric guitar it´s so good, the distortion is beautiful, but the cello is sometimes out of tone and time

  • the cello player is sometimes out of tune,but nice^^ the guitars are fucking good!!

  • really nice, It could be more powerful, more planned

  • That was pretty good for what appears to be an imprompy#tu jam. Good luck guys.

  • Wow that was awesome! I thought that was realllllly amazing

  • The cellist needs to work on intonation.

  • Agreed, however those C# and F#s pop up outta nowhere.

  • its basically a scale i started playing it in 7th grade, and i have it memorized in the 9th grade!

  • i knoow i am a cellist my self ( dis aint hungry d its his cuzz) but he needs some freakin rosin lol XD it sounds scratchy

  • great

  • Not bad!! Not bad at all!!

  • thats what i call harmony

  • The cello was awesome.

    Where did you guys find the music for this?

  • the cello could be better

  • hahaha...

    i think the man in the middle done poor skill compared to the other two..

    he should practice more..

  • he didn't have anything to do

  • muy original

    felicidades weisjajanos vemos

  • Oh and xfordguy18 and blahblackblah it doesn't matter how old or experienced you are. I was 3rd chair All-State cello and 1st chair GDYO. Either way you need to be humble and not complete asses.

  • GREAT!

    A few recommendations for the cello.

    On the chorus try holding the notes longer and not cut them off. Also try to play with a straight bow. My teacher used to get at me everyday because i didn't play with straight bows. It will make the tone quality much better And also when playing open A try putting a little less pressure on the bow so it doesn't squeak.

  • The guitars were good to me.

  • you 2 previous noobs are the ones who suck, this vid owns :)

  • um.... that sucked

  • you suck.... my fast sweaty hairy ball sack

  • wow...

    that cello was way out of tune! well, i actually play the cello in 6th grade i can play it in 4th and 5th position, i think the guitars ruined the whole thing, but he still has to tune his cello!

  • yall so rocked it! and ofcourse there is always room for improvement.....ew...ignore the overly critic....they have nothing better to do.....

  • the cello is out of tune. out of time. generally you need more practise.

    try some bowing and finger exercises.

    Christopher Bunting books with help you.

  • Gotta get rid of the white boy. He's ruining everything.

  • wow the cello was like really out of tune like not to be mean but im in 9th grade and i can do that in 4th and 5th position, the guitars ruin the actuall sound of this piece tip: dont play open strings 2/5

  • GUYS!! read the notes!! they were boared..

    the cello's still bad..

  • cello was amazing

    i think its funy that everyone been giving the cello guy tips on how to play his own instroment (when he clearly knows what hes doing, cause he can play such an advanced peice) but no one has even told the guitar gus to keep their eyes off their fingers while they play... not a critisizm of the guitar guys, i just thinking that everyones being somewhat more picky about the guy playing cello... you know, double standards and stuff

    anyways

    GREAT JOB!!!!

  • bad

  • The cello really makes this sound horrible. It's eight simple notes for that instrument and it carries the whole piece.

    It's not completely horrible, well, almost.

    Pieces like this have boundaries; and that guy is way over the line.

  • It's more than "eight simple notes", maybe we shouldn't believe everything that comedians tell us, hmmm? It still wasn't good though.

  • Holy shit, didn't know you guys were on youtube. And Ingu, I'm confronting you about this video tomorrow. I had no idea you played guitar. Oh, and good job Chris, better than I could do.

  • teh full bar chords with dist. sounded to much :O. gj though. odd combination.

  • the cello = bad

  • wow its good

  • "G-Rant: just lives 2 seconds away and decided to become asian." LMFAO

  • erm cello keep your elbow high when in higher positions. That should help with tuning. Otherwise, really good guys

  • this is indeed a very odd combinations of instruments, i tihnk they woudl sound much better seperated not together

  • I play cello, been playing it for 7 years and won't give it up, I am working on buying an electric cello. Keep up the good work, that song is kinda tough but you got the hang of it.

  • The cello was a little off tune a little and as someone already said bow hold was a little messed but keep trying your doing good =)

  • i play the cello too, its nice that you are playing together but i think a little more studing before you show it in the internet were better

  • yehh i play the cello too.. nd man ur holding ur bow wrong, kindah was bothering me. && sortah ease up on pressing down so hard when ur doing vibrato. and also u were outta tune some. && try playing closer to the bridge, not so close to the finger board.

  • really good!!! i play cello too on your vibrato dont press so hard and you will get a smoother sound! you guys sound awesome!!!!!!! you should do weddings

  • amazing but sometimes out of tune

  • I lost the cello sometimes. And I'm not sure which one held the melody. But that was the only thing that I didn't like. I think it should have been going a little faster donno it just seemed to...slow for me...

  • Pretty cool

  • nice - but not professional of course. rock on cello!!!!!

  • that was good... anyone who is experienced in music should know that this is better than average youtube crap. cool

  • rock on chris pak represent

  • that actually sounded pretty good.. just work on it a bit if you guys really wanna' play it.. the combination of instruments was good,

    the first minute was really good

  • whoa, that was scary.

  • but its hard to learn T_T i cant to the shaking finger thing..T_T

  • do u mean vibrato...?

  • i think so? O_o i just learn cello this yr.

  • its deffinetly vibrato

  • Hm :-$

  • I play viola, hence always sitting next to the cello players-your notes were a bit off, but keep practicing. You're doing great

  • cello players rock. ;]

  • Wow. People really are mean. Cello is NOT an easy instrument. Though the guitars were a little off. Keep working on it and soon enough you'll have it down perfectly.

  • duudee i think that was pretty kewl

    & i like ROCK at the cello

    but man.. ur bow hold is WRONGG

  • the main guitar and the cello arent in tune with eachother at all

    but otherwise good performance

  • you guys did a good job, i have to say that the original song, sounds better, but i think you tried to make an own song... it was good, but, cello, you are out of tune in a lot of parts, i know it's hard, i am cellist too, but keep working on it ^_^ the acustic guitar, was boring... and the electric one slowed i some parts

  • Cello, you're pretty good. Intonation's a little out on some parts, but otherwise you played great.

    Nice acoustic accompaniement =]

    Electric was a little slowed down but clean cut as well.

    Good job!

  • wtf yooure fuckin terrible

    you should give up life you SUCK

  • i really want to see you do better.

  • wtf? dont listen to these people! you kick ass at cello! keep playing

  • dude you really need to practice Im azn practice make perfect. Azn good, not bad at play instrument. You practice evewy minuute of life.

  • u suk at the cello i wil say that the guitars were doin pretty good but the cello u suk like hell annd im not saying this without any experience like i play the ello and i played for 2 years and stil am and i played that like 6 months ago and i was still better

  • you guys were pretty good. ppl are just being mean. I play violin and that song is pretty hard. The cello part is pretty hard too. I cant play it very well... on cello. Some of the notes were out of tune, but other than that good job.

  • wtf yooure fuckin terrible

    you should give up life you SUCK

  • i really want to see you do better.

  • You guys kicked ass!!!

  • you need to work on your intonation i think this song is to advance for you but the rest of the players did prity good.

  • it´s  grate

    because play´s this song with out the original song. BRAVO

  • You there playing the cello! Play in tune, You have like 8 notes that you play right and the others are just way off.

  • u bet me to it

  • people need to stop marking this comment down... I think it was less than 8 notes though... but then I stopped listening

  • Ok. Well, first of all, the dude playing the cello, you need to raise your elbow higher. Second, the guy playing the electric guitar needs to do something about how he plays-there's just something about how he's playing that doesn't thrill me, and sometimes it seemed like he was just playing a totally different tune. The guy playing the acoustic was OK-I guess... Third, you need to work on timing. So, sorry to say it, but I didn't like it at all. . . o.O

  • Orribile oO

  • u suck balls =]

  • Good job I liked it

  • CHIDOOOOOOOO MANTOSDE LA GUAYABA

  • Oh Lord. -.-

    You with the cello. Move towards the bridge, and bring your elbow up more so that you can get your fingers and posistioning in the right place. Shifting can use some work too.

  • For all the people saying that this was good...I guess your not really musicians. Intonation was horrible...

  • totally agree with you. I am not a musician but I can easily see that this is not good, three pieces are not in harmony...

  • ingu the amazing? he should tune his guitar first:O

  • awesome!!

  • on the cellist,i suggest you practice on the vibrato..i think it would be better if the guitarist would use plucking...remove the electric guitar..

  • That was really good, just work on your intonation, and cello play a little slower. keep the same rhythm. :-)

  • I don't like the electric guitar part...

  • keep it up. i suggest checking your bridge though, or just the tuning, if the bridge is a bit off it can make things sound out of tune. but besides that it was a good job all round

  • the cellist has a very odd bow hand..the whole thing was cool but felt feelingless :\

  • panira yung rhytm

  • to the guy on the cello, work more on your intonation as well as your vibrato. put some feelings on your playing too.

  • arg you were really out of tune and it would have been better to have played the open a on the d string and play smoother

  • Great job guys. :DD

    It would sound a lot better with vibrato from the cello though.

  • hey nice work with the cello the guitar need to work on it more be more creative, and also for the cello check your intonation on your higher positions and work a little bit more on your vibrato.

  • Wow! Pachabel sounds so different with guitars! Reminds me of the time a friend of mine looped me into playing the "William Tell Overture" with his metal band. Good job guys.

  • sounds cool with guitars

  • AWESOME! :D

  • you make a pretty good group

  • cello man! hello. yea, i agree the others (whom are probably cello players as well as i) that playing harmonic A isnt the greatest idea ever. and you're intonation, not the best ever. i dont mean this to insult you or anything. you guys are good, but keep working on the cello part. and bring the elbow up, it should help with the higher notes.

  • i concur with azn n jut, also flatten ur wrist, n to help with the intonation, play chords whenever you can during practice. you should be able to tell whats right and whats not. when you had the melody, i couldn't hear you too well, play more towards the bridge and really try to get a good connection with your right hand - helps ur tone. also work on your vibrato whenever you get the chance.

  • Sorry dude, i play the cello and performed a concert with canon. You're not that good. The cello part is suppose to be smooth and connected you make it choppy. And don't use a harmonic, bad sound. Also you play really flat. Which means bring your fingers down, especially in high position. sorry man, 1/5. Also raise elbow, that will help you play in the higher position, that's why you play out of tune. Sorry if i sound harsh, i just hope you can do better.

  • i wouldn't play the high A as a harmonic. I tried to play it, too and the change of position is worth its difficulty^^

  • not bad, but cello player plays out of tune some times

    (me self play on cello. listen like tallaznboy plays

    Canon, it realy coool)

  • Looks like a pretty good cello player (i dont play the cello so i dont really know -_-)

  • awesome

  • oh my gosh! You guys are like the best pple who played canon on youtube!!!!! (Check out the other videos they suck!!!!) I play violin, piano, guitar, recorder and i'm gunna play cello soon! Oh My God! This makes my cello future so exciting!!!!! YOU ROCK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! =D