Yeah, bayside covers the song well they just, much like the man himself, have no soul. He had it when he wrote the song, but now it's gone to a another place. RIP brilliant man.
the intro to the Lucky3 was part of my favorite sounds elliott smith ever created, I listened to the 1min version again and again. this version with lyrics is so gorgeous thanks so much
yeah this version is way better than the XO version. That's one of my least favorite songs on XO. I can see how I should like it more I just don't for some reason. Not abstract enough on XO. I also like the piano version "I Didn't Understand" better than the XO version. It's all steak though, some are filet some are t-bone either way it's fine dining.
Stop arguing over the original vs the cover. Elliott wrote it and it's a fantastic song. Bayside put a different spin on it and it's a fantastic cover for that reason. There's no use in disrespecting either party - especially John Holohan (Bayside's deceased drummer). Being on Elliott's side and insulting John just because it's easy? No, just give it up. Elliott Smith is my favourite solo musician. Bayside is my favourite band. If it wasn't for them and that cover, I wouldn't know Elliott Smith.
Demon chill out. You obivously care more about dissing people you don't even know with overly hyperbolic statements than aquiring good music taste. If you're defending a punk band or punk music for that matter by saying you have a higher taste in music, you do need to grow up. When I was heavily into punk and metal it was because I hated what constitues "good" taste. I'm not dissing punk or even metal. I still rock the occasional Napalm Death and Nofx, but seriously, chill out. RIP ES
too right, i am a huge elliott smith fan yet also a bayside fan and i feel i can take something away from both of elliott smith's versions and bayside they all sound so different, Smiths were lo-fi (just like much of his work), but i also enjoyed bayside's realization of it as a punk rock song, If anything the fact bayside did manage to translate it to that only reaffirms how good a song smith has written in the first place, Bayside's was never meant to appeal to smith fans
I'm going to have to disagree with Demonslayr666. The Bayside cover is truly, truly awful. Although, it wouldn't be so bad if the guy hadn't screwed up the vocals.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
dude FUCK ALL YOU FAGS who are talking shit about bayside's cover u all are faggots and they're version PWNS this FAG version so Shut the fuck up and respect a better band
Why would you call Elliott a fag? Did you ever meet him? Do you know how disrespectful that is? You don't hear me calling Bayside's dead drummer a "fuckin' fag pussy" and shit like that. First of all, there wouldn't be the Bayside cover without this version first, so know what to appreciate idiot. Also, Elliott Smith is a FAR better musician than ANYONE is Bayside.
Dude Calm down have respect for other peoples music taste as i have respect for yours, even if i prefer the original. Just me saying it's better doesen't make it so.Why do you think bayside covered it?
Because they hate Elliott and think he's a "fag"? It's because they liked and respected his music, appreciating music and showing a level of respect is what covers are about.Try and think about what your saying before you type in future.
Sorry for the fans, but even if this version isn't better than the original (how can we compare ???), this cover is good, the voice and guitar playing are goods anyvway, we must admit this !
oh my god! kim yung fucking soo! u havent seen you since spring break mexico 98! oh my god! hows the wife man? i heard she got i na rough orgy with you and that monkey from metro zoo
Yeah! hahaha! It's been awhile man! Shannon... She's in a better place right now.. All I got is my monkey Donna now... *sigh* oh well.. Donna's been keeping me acompanied :)
haha thats great to know man! im married to my long time boyfriend willington now! its hard looking for yoga techers here! im tried of my bulging dick just popping out in public ^.^ but you know :D
oh man! I hope everything goes great! You know what works by keeping your penis tucked in!? Wear tights without underwear! It' works great. Tell Your husband I said hello.
Oh... My... god.... I'm sorry for your lost... Darn Kids... My son got ran over by an 18-wheeler 4 years ago... Shannon and Jack both died... Only my monkey is left... Oh well. Guess that gives you a lot more time for you and your husband. ;)
youngmill, i hope u never try to make a career as a music writer. that was the worst statement ive heard since patrick stump's version of love will tear us apart is better than joy divisions or jon foreman's version of rebellion is better than arcade fire's. your an idiot.
this is the original, baysides can suck my dick. a cover of elliott that is proclaimed to be better than the man himself is like a penis with no balls. you got no balls kid.
I've thought for a long time that the greatest gift God could have given me was to have motivated Elliott Smith to record acoustic versions of every one of his songs. Baby Britain from XO is a delight, one of my favorite songs, some of his best work on the bass guitar. But, I love this cut! Thanks for posting.
i disagree...i dont know if youve heard his speaking voice in interviews or whatever but thats what he sounds like...plus i think he tries to imitate lennon a bit and its just that sound in their voice...not nasally at all..its just sharp and soft...fuck who cares
Bayside is my favorite band, and I can tell you that their cover is nothing compared to the real thing. Its a great cover, but you cannot compare it to the original
um. yes elliott is the fucking shit, this man is an amazing artist who has affected the lives of many, including me, so you should... i dont know... shut the fuck up because no one likes ignorant people like you.
@kman3000000 Oh wow. Eff off. I don't know how long you have been around Youtube, but that comment was posted over two years ago when the comments were still displayed as threads and not this @ business. My comment was in reply to some kid who thought Bayside's cover (who the eff is that anyways?) was just so much better than Elliott's original. That's crazy - Elliott is a musical God. So maybe you should...I don't know...shut the fuck up because no one likes douchebags like you.
but I mean personally, with the kind of like, poppier upbeat music I like, I think the bayside version is better but I think realistically this is better.
Besides, its the original so, it kinda stands alone.
Oh someone covered this song? Do yourself a favor and do not listen to it. I love Elliott.
Gasolinealley00 2 months ago
Comment removed
stevieboy4 3 months ago in playlist Liked
And I'm on my bros account :o
MrShadowSpider1 4 months ago
Really gorgeous song, that raw sound, my favorite. I love the guitar, amazing, real music right there. I love how I'm only eleven. (:
MrShadowSpider1 4 months ago
I got my three year old sister loving this song(:
stainedglasseyes1 4 months ago
I never wanted this song to end
stevieboy4 4 months ago in playlist Liked
this is so much better than the studio version in my opinion
stevieboy4 4 months ago
Sensitive, melancholic, creative, this is beautiful. For me, best musician of all times.....
guadalquibeat 4 months ago
to someone half as smart, bayside would be a work of art
thestudlybudly 6 months ago
Heard The Biggest Lie and googled Elliot Smith. Knew I heard the name before, forgot it was on the Bayside Acoustic Album.
MxOxRxRxIxS 8 months ago
no one was better.
djcarro 10 months ago
its ok to cry
villasixx 11 months ago
Yeah, bayside covers the song well they just, much like the man himself, have no soul. He had it when he wrote the song, but now it's gone to a another place. RIP brilliant man.
Redsparrowe123 11 months ago
the intro to the Lucky3 was part of my favorite sounds elliott smith ever created, I listened to the 1min version again and again. this version with lyrics is so gorgeous thanks so much
Butor91 11 months ago 2
Oh my word. You are so kind, @sixxers. Thank you so much.
Milesosaurus 11 months ago
Can anybody give me the tabs to this please?
Milesosaurus 11 months ago
@Milesosaurus hi. I couldn't post the link in the comment section so I updated the video description with the tab and chords. cheers.
sixxers 11 months ago
yeah this version is way better than the XO version. That's one of my least favorite songs on XO. I can see how I should like it more I just don't for some reason. Not abstract enough on XO. I also like the piano version "I Didn't Understand" better than the XO version. It's all steak though, some are filet some are t-bone either way it's fine dining.
grandmabilly2000 1 year ago
Miss you everyday buddy.
kinkykane0607 1 year ago 2
i can play this : p
utarefsonmetushelac 1 year ago
@utarefsonmetushelac
but you cannot compose this :p
amigojcole 1 year ago
Stop arguing over the original vs the cover. Elliott wrote it and it's a fantastic song. Bayside put a different spin on it and it's a fantastic cover for that reason. There's no use in disrespecting either party - especially John Holohan (Bayside's deceased drummer). Being on Elliott's side and insulting John just because it's easy? No, just give it up. Elliott Smith is my favourite solo musician. Bayside is my favourite band. If it wasn't for them and that cover, I wouldn't know Elliott Smith.
stillleftdreaming 1 year ago 3
ELLIOTT IS KING
utarefsonmetushelac 1 year ago
this version fucking rocks
ganuenen 1 year ago 2
His brilliance paralyzes me.
JeffWilsonMusic 1 year ago 2
Demonslayr666 Is a Prime Example of whats happing to kids these days. Just another brain washed mind.
chapitos555 1 year ago
what a wonder man!
utarefsonbeetlebum 1 year ago
Very loveable
pressureofdays 1 year ago
I still like his piano version better.
OdinA11Father 1 year ago
Demon chill out. You obivously care more about dissing people you don't even know with overly hyperbolic statements than aquiring good music taste. If you're defending a punk band or punk music for that matter by saying you have a higher taste in music, you do need to grow up. When I was heavily into punk and metal it was because I hated what constitues "good" taste. I'm not dissing punk or even metal. I still rock the occasional Napalm Death and Nofx, but seriously, chill out. RIP ES
OdinA11Father 1 year ago
why is everyone arguing over you tube. its disgusting who cares!?! agree to disagree. i like both versions.
when bands do a cover its because they like a song not to make a better version so quit the pointless shit talking.
you'll never see the people your arguing with so why waste energy
samwhich15 2 years ago
too right, i am a huge elliott smith fan yet also a bayside fan and i feel i can take something away from both of elliott smith's versions and bayside they all sound so different, Smiths were lo-fi (just like much of his work), but i also enjoyed bayside's realization of it as a punk rock song, If anything the fact bayside did manage to translate it to that only reaffirms how good a song smith has written in the first place, Bayside's was never meant to appeal to smith fans
LGFUAD21 2 years ago
bayside sucks. their drummer sucks.
elliott is king
r00tabeggas 2 years ago
Absolutely phenomenal. Simple as that.
Radiohead54321 2 years ago
I'm going to have to disagree with Demonslayr666. The Bayside cover is truly, truly awful. Although, it wouldn't be so bad if the guy hadn't screwed up the vocals.
fightbait 2 years ago
this version is great! looks like some idiots don't even know that Baby Britain is written by Elliott... that Bayside cover is awful!
kostikannu 2 years ago
new favorite
boredshitless2003 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
god ur an idiot just shut the fuck up you obviously don't have ANY taste in music so go kill yourself asshole
Demonslayr666 2 years ago
@Demonslayr666
grow up, kiddo :)
dpgera18 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
dude FUCK ALL YOU FAGS who are talking shit about bayside's cover u all are faggots and they're version PWNS this FAG version so Shut the fuck up and respect a better band
Demonslayr666 2 years ago
Why would you call Elliott a fag? Did you ever meet him? Do you know how disrespectful that is? You don't hear me calling Bayside's dead drummer a "fuckin' fag pussy" and shit like that. First of all, there wouldn't be the Bayside cover without this version first, so know what to appreciate idiot. Also, Elliott Smith is a FAR better musician than ANYONE is Bayside.
evancasto 2 years ago 25
@evancasto The second part of your comment is personal opinion, which I dusagree with, sorry. The rest is fact rhough
Fishilisation 11 months ago
@evancasto anyone who calls Elliot a fag is just a self-conscious piece of shit. Fuck 'em.
1014jakey 5 months ago
@Demonslayr666
Dude Calm down have respect for other peoples music taste as i have respect for yours, even if i prefer the original. Just me saying it's better doesen't make it so.Why do you think bayside covered it?
Because they hate Elliott and think he's a "fag"? It's because they liked and respected his music, appreciating music and showing a level of respect is what covers are about.Try and think about what your saying before you type in future.
kinkykane0607 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
1014jakey 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the bayside cover is better
swimmer71192 2 years ago
considering the Bayside cover sucks.. no its not better..
youarealoser0007 2 years ago
na were just really high, we love elliott smith. please ignore our stupidity
thenicestguyonyoutub 2 years ago
lol no worries
sixxers 2 years ago
Honestly I have to listen to this song at least 5-6 times a day, I can't stop
Help me...
OscarSheridan 2 years ago
Sorry for the fans, but even if this version isn't better than the original (how can we compare ???), this cover is good, the voice and guitar playing are goods anyvway, we must admit this !
Leerouille 2 years ago
any one who says that gaycover of bayside is better than the original, deserve a 15 foot dick lodge into theyre asshole.
TheCantthinkofaname 2 years ago
the song is originally from Elliott smith dickhead, I think this says all about how much you know about music
MisterPrimeMinister 2 years ago
are you retarded? hes sayign the bayside cover sucks you retard
thenicestguyonyoutub 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the bayside cover is better than this...
swimmer71192 2 years ago
hehe yeah! bayside sucked! they ruined this great song! have a nice day ^.^
thenicestguyonyoutub 2 years ago 2
oh my gosh. Nicestguyonyoutub. I can't believe I found you by total coincidence! How are you doing!?
KimYungSoo 2 years ago
oh my god! kim yung fucking soo! u havent seen you since spring break mexico 98! oh my god! hows the wife man? i heard she got i na rough orgy with you and that monkey from metro zoo
thenicestguyonyoutub 2 years ago
Yeah! hahaha! It's been awhile man! Shannon... She's in a better place right now.. All I got is my monkey Donna now... *sigh* oh well.. Donna's been keeping me acompanied :)
KimYungSoo 2 years ago
haha thats great to know man! im married to my long time boyfriend willington now! its hard looking for yoga techers here! im tried of my bulging dick just popping out in public ^.^ but you know :D
thenicestguyonyoutub 2 years ago
oh man! I hope everything goes great! You know what works by keeping your penis tucked in!? Wear tights without underwear! It' works great. Tell Your husband I said hello.
Hows Jamie doing? ^_^
KimYungSoo 2 years ago
she died, i told her not to go near the pool! oh well rip jamie 2008-2009 kids never learn, even if you beat them! oh my god!
thenicestguyonyoutub 2 years ago
Oh... My... god.... I'm sorry for your lost... Darn Kids... My son got ran over by an 18-wheeler 4 years ago... Shannon and Jack both died... Only my monkey is left... Oh well. Guess that gives you a lot more time for you and your husband. ;)
You guys gonna make some babies?
KimYungSoo 2 years ago
i havent*
thenicestguyonyoutub 2 years ago
shut the fuck up, ok? take your dritty fuck self out of here "cantthinkofaname" only uncreative retards have names liek that.
thenicestguyonyoutub 2 years ago
any one who says that gaycover of bayside is better than the original, deserve a 15 foot dick lodge into theyre asshole.
TheCantthinkofaname 2 years ago
Can you send me the MP3 of this song file please?
pinkfloyd90 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Baysides version of this song is much better
Youngmill08 2 years ago
this isn't the studio version. this is just how he played it acoustic.
sixxers 2 years ago
@sixxers this version is really good man it's the same from lucky 3 but the full version... thanks alot for the upload i loved it
utarefsonmetushelac 1 year ago
@sixxers this isn't the studio version.. this is how sounds a angel smiling :)
Crackman34 1 year ago
you're a fool
pacrock123 2 years ago 3
youngmill, i hope u never try to make a career as a music writer. that was the worst statement ive heard since patrick stump's version of love will tear us apart is better than joy divisions or jon foreman's version of rebellion is better than arcade fire's. your an idiot.
buxmont1110 2 years ago 4
this is the original, baysides can suck my dick. a cover of elliott that is proclaimed to be better than the man himself is like a penis with no balls. you got no balls kid.
Tarusquee 2 years ago
so glad i found this
Maadspaceape 2 years ago
The lyrics of this song are so good.
AcousticMusicianESWS 2 years ago 2
oh this acoustic version is the business.
whitestripebuzz 2 years ago 17
i know right.
sixxers 2 years ago
where can i find a video of this??
SeikoPsycho 2 years ago
probably doesn't exist, but possibly out there somewhere
sixxers 2 years ago
♥Elliott Smith. You are amazing.
bballlove10hm 2 years ago 2
YES!
isolationeitheror 2 years ago
Lovely in every way.x
rosiemckay 2 years ago
i love this song so much
akgal122 2 years ago 2
I've thought for a long time that the greatest gift God could have given me was to have motivated Elliott Smith to record acoustic versions of every one of his songs. Baby Britain from XO is a delight, one of my favorite songs, some of his best work on the bass guitar. But, I love this cut! Thanks for posting.
Solomoreno 3 years ago 2
Comment removed
potentialcarnie 3 years ago
favourite guitaristist
ginonix 3 years ago
he sings through his nose i have to say its quite annoying. but besides that good songg
CJ0rti2isTh3m4n 3 years ago
i disagree...i dont know if youve heard his speaking voice in interviews or whatever but thats what he sounds like...plus i think he tries to imitate lennon a bit and its just that sound in their voice...not nasally at all..its just sharp and soft...fuck who cares
wandmug 3 years ago 2
Comment removed
potentialcarnie 3 years ago
yep just increadible!!
charlyhebdo 3 years ago
elliott smith is ....all i can say is increadible
estebansaidanything 3 years ago
btw if this is live what show is it from so i can go get it...ps bayside is fking terribad
jeo616 3 years ago
it's from end sessions in 1998.you can find it on the elliott smith internet archieve.
xomum 3 years ago
archive
xomum 3 years ago
thanks I actually found it this morning and came back to follow up and I saw your post, and im so glad I got the full set its amazing.
jeo616 3 years ago
I'll fuckin kill you dumb shit. If you don't like a band keep it to yourself, nobody cares about your negativity.
trolm3 3 years ago
good job
you fail at life.
TonyAndHisAcoustic 3 years ago
X D
masterassasn 3 years ago
Miss you Elliott. I'm glad I don't even know who Bayside is.
tag12345 3 years ago 3
Comment removed
potentialcarnie 3 years ago
Great audio quality! Thanks for posting this.
vedder12 3 years ago
Bayside is my favorite band, and I can tell you that their cover is nothing compared to the real thing. Its a great cover, but you cannot compare it to the original
LastYearsBest 3 years ago 8
bayside plays a terrible cover of this song.
smpl187 3 years ago 4
its cool bcuz i hadn't heard this version b4. thanx for this
ParaleticAmity 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the Bayside version is better
ACityTheSeaAssaults 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I agree. 100%
DestinationJacob 3 years ago
um.
no.
CrownJules 3 years ago 5
@CrownJules
um. yes elliott is the fucking shit, this man is an amazing artist who has affected the lives of many, including me, so you should... i dont know... shut the fuck up because no one likes ignorant people like you.
kman3000000 1 year ago
@kman3000000 Oh wow. Eff off. I don't know how long you have been around Youtube, but that comment was posted over two years ago when the comments were still displayed as threads and not this @ business. My comment was in reply to some kid who thought Bayside's cover (who the eff is that anyways?) was just so much better than Elliott's original. That's crazy - Elliott is a musical God. So maybe you should...I don't know...shut the fuck up because no one likes douchebags like you.
CrownJules 1 year ago
nope
liquidpyramid 3 years ago 4
like this is ammaaazzziiinnggg
but I mean personally, with the kind of like, poppier upbeat music I like, I think the bayside version is better but I think realistically this is better.
Besides, its the original so, it kinda stands alone.
Judge the remakes.
Changed my mind since that comment.
^-^
ACityTheSeaAssaults 3 years ago
Comment removed
potentialcarnie 3 years ago
ha and you sound so much better.
kaytizzzl3 3 years ago
Comment removed
potentialcarnie 3 years ago
when i read this i hadnt heard the bayside version so i was like "come on it cant be that bad"
but dude. holy shit. this wins by a mile.
ringosteve21 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
no fuckin shit asshole he wrote the song bayside sucks my bawls
jeo616 3 years ago
i dont think you read my comment properly.
ringosteve21 3 years ago 2
anyone know which show this is from?
Spox 3 years ago
♥♥♥ elliott ♥♥♥
mymayapapaya 3 years ago 5