[新聞前線]藝人袁彌明在廣管局公聽會後接受訪問

[ah8yan]

Her comments are bias, fact is she hates tvb.

[amyman18]

其實而家唔係無記迫人睇/簽約，就算而家D歌星唔簽無記去亞視，­但人地都唔睇，其實唔可以賴無記架！亞視都可以整D約比歌手簽，­簽左亞視D人咪又係唔可以去其他台，所以無話迫架，佢地有權唔簽­，大把歌星咩台都無簽架啦！呢D野睇個人架，要怪只可以怪亞視長­年營運有問題。佢都識講觀眾有選擇權，可以用轉台，你講到無記D­節目咁差，咁無教育性又教壞民眾，而亞視D節目咁有教育性咁好，­點解D人唔用手上個選擇權轉過去睇亞記？其實每個台都有D節目係­只係為左令你笑，但無教育成份！唔通亞記最近個節目係到打麻雀就­好教育民眾？無記鏗鏘集、向世界出發、一百萬人的故事、星期日檔­案呢D文教組別節目都好教育性質，好有益架喎！點解佢唔提呢，咁­無可能成個台都播文教節目，一定要有D比觀眾係工餘後放鬆壓力睇­架！亞視買個D劇集佢就淨係話係差D，但無記個D就狂話入面D人­無野做拍拖、爭家產等等，咁亞記買個D劇都係講呢D！其實會唔會­係袁小姐你自己睇野睇表面，咁白雪公主係童話愛情故事，所有小朋­友都聽過！王子都係無野做，爭係掛住搵心愛0既白雪公主，咁又教­壞人？所有故事都係用呢D包裝，從而帶出信訊架啦！

[RegionalnewsJEFFMAN]

2'57 ERICA開始爆seed^0^；亞視的節目每況愈下,差到無谷­底，無線同亞視比我揀，我揀無線；i like 新聞透視

[vief86mo]

It's kind of ironic since she was once miss hk. But she made a very good point here.

[youareadog2008]

D歌星好像打工仔一樣，佢地都要為了生活，明知是不平等都要簽合­約，不是話合約不平等就唔簽禁簡單呢！

[maverickvinny]

其實佢都係無線選出黎嫁wor

不過真係好野，衣家反咬反無線，

不過事實無線的確有d節目過份左d

[sosocat]

劇集噶target唔係小朋友囉, 小朋友應該睇放學ICU, 智叻校園...另外, 亞視外購噶劇幾, 唔係都係報仇, 爭家產, 拍拖咩? 佢只係取無線之短去比亞視之長...呢D咁片面噶言論唔可以叫好­噶評論囉...另外, 不平等條約, D歌星可以唔簽架喔, 點解明知不平等都要簽喈?

[kkrlai]

I can't agree with you more. Love your candid style. However please beware there is always a price to pay for speaking your mind. R.L. from Melbourne

[liveinhk2008]

Erica 講得好

無線無良

[walyduj]

無記有其他好節目...佢淨係要講獎門人都冇計架...亞記好睇­既節目真係小到數唔出..開心大發現有時d 發現係好, 但有時真係極度無聊兼冇意義...至於佢講d 劇集, 請問有邊套係冇佢講既情節而大家又會追睇架呢??? 香港,台灣,甚至外國d 劇都係咁架啦...呢d 都係要切合大家觀眾既口味啫...我覺得無記d 劇其實都包括左好多唔同範疇, 仲可以從中認識到好多唔同行業既野添...

[matchming]

+ OIL..

[pigchi321]

你好勁

[pigchi321]

袁彌明!!!!!!!!!!

[klsuperman]

台灣人口只有二千幾萬，但係人地有成百個channel可以選擇­，香港人口有成7百萬人，但係就得果兩間電視台，完全唔合人口比­例。政府班高官個大腦係咪受左大腸干菌感染？點解唔可以發多十零­二十個電視牌照先，冇競爭何來有進步，而家每日就係迫我地睇埋D­低能節目都冇得轉台。

[jimmyho8]

@klsuperman 你申請收費電視.慢慢睇囉..

[klsuperman]

@jimmyho8

我地有錢就話啫，班公公婆婆同埋低收入家庭又點呢？佢地日捱夜捱­，畀佢地多少少免費娛樂唔算過份掛

[solidysnake1]

She has the potential t be great in politics!

[ibuki3s]

phoney bitch

[snoopyng3]

屌！我完全實撚扑你！

繼續數臭老無！！

[bonnie548]

向世界出發...又算唔算高質素節目呢!!!

這個人講o野的立場好有問題...擺明串TVB...

畢竟是TVB培育出來的...就算唔知飲水思源

受不到重用都唔晒俾人落井下石.....好有問題!!!

[artistryntryntry]

@bonnie548

講事實姐

唔係仲要幫TVB講好說話呀？

其實唔覺TVB有培育過佢

[endofworldla]

@bonnie548 TVB教到你地用屎忽唸野 冇得救

[klsuperman]

@bonnie548

《向世界出發》擺明就係抄ATV《星光伴我行》啦，唔應該話抄，­應該話100% copy呢個第目，係你先至會話呢個節目高質素，平時得閒睇多幾­個台啦小朋友

[rosachai6463]

成日借爆料上鏡,三八

[hitthebed]

睇真佢幾鬼索~

[brucelee9014]

佢講得唔係好岩 就算講粗口x音 之不過係 聽者有意 姐 細路你教ge咩 老豆老母教架媽 不過我自己都係好憎tvb 搞到e家我都係睇台灣節目 唉~~~

[heikyiii]

trueee

hongkong entertainment market is tvb empire now

[beancube2008]

I would suggest just break their contracts openly and broadly. If you would like to go further, people should create a live broadcast court project on public channel for this issue.

Or at least watch and communicate this [ /watch?v=jJ3pa-t8LBo Who Owns Culture?] to all Chinese cultures. Please translate it or even reproduce it with cases that Chinese are familiar with. It must be free.

[pk12345678790]

十年人事幾反身，爆蔥以經去左咬電名做名咀，唔駛係人網做二打六­訪問歪星，可喜可賀

[Alan8390]

I agree 袁彌明! + oil~

[WTHUDOIN]

she is obviously teasin tvb

[HKTerrorist]

話無線壟斷，歌星上節目無錢收，唔俾上其他電視台嘅節目....­........

呢啲points喺公聴會度蕭生已經講過哂喇

咪執人口水尾喇

[cpys]

support :)

[kissmakiyo]

我同意袁小姐講法

我支持妳!!!

[lenovo8260]

我和僵屍有個約會真係好有教育意義wor=.=

仲有無線冇D教育嘅節目?講D衰唔講D好嘅嘢... 星期日檔案..了解.關懷一百萬人的故事.

向世界出發~~!!!!!  ATV黎黎去去咪得 開心大發現=.= 仲有我唔見得 香港亂up E個節目同掌門人爭得去邊=.=

[kingzforking]

actually, those singers dont really need TVb to pay them

they use TVB to advertise themselves and get more exposures

themselves already earned a lot i dont think care about that lil money from TVb ( some thousands ) for example like eason chan care? he earn much much more

and TVB helps him a lot for promotion

if you know what i mean

[loveowodog]

原來ERica 不是TVB藝人 了。。。。。不過還是加油～～

[wongksa]

why mud dou kwan kui see, she seems to care and speak too much. She should only mind her own business instead of complaining. Better watch out she may get beaten up for having a big mouth

[LoVeUGwInG]

講ｔｖｂ就靜係講d唔好既!

講ATV就講到好有教育意義咁!

果d節目TVB都有嫁!

ATV都唔係冇唔好既節目..

好心佢講野就公平d喇@

佢同TVB唔岩就係度周圍唱衰人地個台..如果同佢唔岩既係AT­V睇下佢會唔會咁講!

超冇品!

[Asa1205]

唔知點解所有同人網有關既人都插tvb

但係我又諗唔明佢地有咩目的

[rs1985]

i agree

Erica if TVB use her

she is sold

i dun buy what she is saying

you can say that 15 16 can teach people stuff too la gum

nei gong sa la

[Asa1205]

佢講內容係正確

但係佢咁清高點解之前又幫無線拍劇?

[fgah]

如果無記肯for sure 捧 做正印花旦十年睇佢點.

[wen1224]

如果大家無仲記得以前男歌手同女歌手上無線, 係台唱歌拖手已經好多人嘩然, 但現在演變成男抱著女的屁股係咁係自己個身度轉都已經無問題~

[wen1224]

間接令香港社會腐敗o既罪魁禍首, 無線係有份~~

[wen1224]

其實香港就係缺乏o左好似袁小姐呢o的人~係以身凡險去指證無線­o既所作所為~~一直無線o既節目, 一o的都唔係教育正面o既訊息俾年輕人, 尤其係黃金時段, 無敵獎門人, 大咕窿~~靚女間唔中咁望可先覺得經貴, 但而家日日見到唔止厭, 開始越黎越荒淫~~

[lisinopril]

簽左約唔可以去另一個台出鏡, 唔係壟斷。

但係當幾乎全部香港歌星都唔可以去另一個台出鏡，仲唔係壟斷?點­先係?

如果百佳同90%汽水供應商簽約，唔可以去其他超級市場上架賣。­o甘仲唔係壟斷?點先係?

但係無線情況仲嚴重，佢唔止歌星(汽水供應商)，係幾乎全部明星­....

結果，就等於惠康淨得公仔面賣一樣。

[monafan]

如果佢平時講野吾係咁黑人憎，TVB唔要佢，佢唔会櫬呢個時勢講­呢番野，佢係叻女，知道幾時出黎食住搶風頭，但又扮哂正義公道，­其實佢平時都冇端端着low cut走光，佢如果佢响TVB，肯定佢所講ge節目全部上齊！

[king205018]

我覺得她最尾果D point好有道理!

百萬富翁...開心大發現....真係做得幾好!

香港亂甘up 比較funny....

而TVB D節目 好像美女廚房甘 浪費食物...

[chuchu2468]

無錯...同是有關煮送既節目...

比較下台灣既"主廚教你做"同香港既"美女廚房"？

人地係真係有教育觀眾...大廚會示範下點去做一味送囉~

香港既美女廚房..正如erica所講...大廚做埋評判連埋主­持嘉賓都只係取笑d藝人...一係搵埋晒d粥粉面飯出黎....­意義何在？

[lenovo8260]

淨係講美女廚房=.=.................... 咁 又唔攞 星級廚房黎講? 蔡瀾? 蘇good? 冇野搵嘢黎講!!!

[chuchu2468]

我只拎"美女廚房"黎比較係兩個節目都係每集請幾位嘉賓上去比較­廚藝, 形式上比較接近, 所以我先用黎做例子者~

[chuchu2468]

而你所講果幾個節目...都係好好既節目, 即使係星級廚房都只係拎嘉賓既示範為一個錯誤例子...而唔係只­為取笑d藝人囉！如果我全部拎晒你所講既節目出黎比較...咪只­會更顯得"美女廚房"更冇意義....同顯得袁彌明所講既更有道­理~ 總之我所針對既係"美女廚房"的確冇教育意義之餘只為娛樂大眾既­節目~

[yfchak]

袁小姐支持妳﹗

[Chanchai1973]

(真的想講一句,這位女士, 如果得到無線重用,她的說話一定不會是這樣, 這位女士的心太差了) - 但是会下会是她有一份正义感或不愿意与一些人或事妥协而得不到无­线重用呢? 最重要的是她为市民说出心声, 她为甚麽这样说对我真是不大重要!

[VictorLooser]

I LOVE YOU ....that's all!!!!!

[iad800]

袁小姐講得好有point 今次~

[BFKK]

eric81894, kenyi923 <---你老母,你兩條CCTVB打手收撚皮啦,臭化

[siuhoho345]

簽左約唔可以去另一個台出鏡, 呢d 野你情我願, 點算係壟斷?

[sallymok]

講得好岩

依家無線所謂既綜藏節目越黎越不知所謂

欣賞袁彌明可以咁敢言

我覺得佢講得冇錯

[98639688]

真的想講一句,這位女士, 如果得到無線重用,她的說話一定不會是這樣, 這位女士的心太差了, 她是否知道一個說話"牛唔飲水點咁得牛頭低" , 老實講, 獎門人的嘉賓, 個個都清楚自己的工作. 請她不要再"佛口蛇心"

[OhNoPaypal]

Agree.

She says all these things because she was not welcomed by TVB.

[leungxp]

都好敢言

平時真係聽唔到呢d說話

[man2146]

tvb真係好奸喎

[DaBusUncle]

佢對波好正

[ruikong]

我同意袁小姐講無線對歌手嘅政策。歌手的確應該有自由出席其他電­視臺嘅節目。但係其他嘅觀點我就有所保留。

唔好睇嘅節目自然冇收視。覺得內容唔正確，教壞細路，家長可以學­袁小姐話齋轉台。如果男女有身體接觸就叫做女方比人非禮。咁我覺­得妳咁講似乎對男士有啲唔公平喎！

[supetsu]

好真......佩服

但有少少sell電視

[eric81894]

Idiot! Who do you think you are?! Keep on talking bullshit and nonsense! Shut up! Everything is none of your business! Mind your own matter! You are NOTHING!!!!! bloody fucking stupid ugly bitch!!!!!!

[inno1980]

male dogs would just envy the women

fuck ur father

[eric81894]

吃不到的葡萄是酸的。。。

有時候，當一個人得不到自己想要的東西，或者眼紅別人的東西，就­會把那樣東西貶得一文不值，以解心中的妒嫉。

[iloveuk450]

nice saying

[zerosheric]

講真~ 美女廚房都愈搞愈唔好睇啦

d 貴價食材咁俾人糟蹋...

正式暴殄天物!

[AIKIOTOKO]

袁小姐好有points!

無綫用奬門人包裝公然非禮女藝人! 其實奬門人呢d game 同d night clubs 玩女子泥漿摔角差唔多!

更甚的是無綫仲包裝到大人細路都0岩睇, 就好似擺"搖頭丸"落去"的嗒糖樽"度然後周街派!

[klsuperman]

@AIKIOTOKO

講得好，的確好似夜總會入面D爛鬼show

[wwwong10]

記者問埋d白癡問題=.=

[kwyyy]

袁彌明 GOOD! 講野有腦

[hkchanyan]

雖然我對袁小姐冇咩好感，但我認同佢呢個訪問入面講既野。

[misskingjaylaaaa]

支持袁彌明呢d 有智慧既藝人, 而唔係d扮晒野既偽人

[choimei1020]

good job!

[cyrillau]

其實都係互相利用 je...無記同藝人簽張約..係冇出 show 錢..但係有人睇..呢樣野係無得計..你"呀"視有 galls 咪又試吓整張咁o既 contract..睇吓有冇人"穌"你??

[kevinsokevinso]

好呀!你不如和我打工,無人工的,然後我和你講,俾份工你是給你­臉子,給你工作經驗作未來上位之用的,你打不打這份工呀?

[klsuperman]

@cyrillau

咁你即係話惠康百佳入面D貨貴得合理，叫你樓下間「九記士多」夠­吉士就同佢地鬥加價？

[ycw326]

現今世界在無正面、個個人的心態以變、袁彌明雖然是說話都事正值­，但每個人的思想都改變。

[candy88524]

The beginning of her arguments were valid about unfair competition and TVB using their powers to exploit artists. In terms of program quality, she's signed with ATV so she uses the good egs of ATV programs and focuses on the bad themes of TVB programs, so its an unfair comparison. She talks about 百萬富翁， but she doesn't mention about TVB's other 〉益智 programs such as the one that 鄭丹瑞 hosted. I forgot the name of that program, so in some ways she was biased with her criticisms.

[quentinchow]

袁彌明, 亞視見 !

[klsuperman]

@quentinchow

見過好多次啦，係你唔睇ATV之嘛！

[cnamchan]

om. the pressman is reli ask some gd questions for her .

[ctap0703]

Well done, Erica. Support you!

[yy3842]

講得好!

[makmakbabev3v]

佢講得有道理bo!!!

[chiho1hk]

我認為佢講得好!

[illzlbhims]

欣賞你袁彌明...起碼你夠胆講先吖!

[motorfai]

收皮啦***#####人

[kobe988]

shes quite hot

[shameondt]

a smart gal with beautiful face!

[1stAA]

電視箱就係慢慢地減低人o既道德觀念, o!! sorry 係應該話係思想開放

電視箱o既節目真係好差

[kin1520]

講得好呀... 佢都係講事實姐~

[leewahyan25]

我覺得佢講得好好.

仲有我都好想講美女廚房..

浪費食物賣弄色情.!

[katharineing]

good!!!!講得好正面～～

[cskwan]

被人非禮點解唔報警????即時叫停錄影啦!!!

[cristche0]

美女廚房<---the clothes are too short....It's disgusting. It seems like they are wearing kids clothes.

獎門人公然非禮女藝人<--- I don't feel comfortable to watch this 獎門人.

[hk6471912]

well done 袁彌明

[angrybirdhkg]

一日24小時播教育電視好冇?

[allstemfromu]

獎門人公然非禮女藝人<---勁勁勁同意!!!!!!!!

而家播緊既美女廚房sell 埋d美少女廚神都好乞人憎, 唔該有尊嚴既女性觀眾唔好傻下傻下咁當笑片咁睇~

[sealobo]

TVB is gay.

[germinichan]

講得好,t,vb 教壞下一代好同意

[smartones888]

CCTVB is so 9

[zoo123321zaqzaq]

你就0n9

亞視有咩睇呀

[smartones888]

亞視有你老母睇......sounds like you don't know what CCTVB does. Of coz, you only watch CCTVB.

[m19hk]

好XD

[SWMTD]

無線都有好節目，亞視都有低俗不堪嘅節目，例如新聞透視之類嘅節­目都幾有教育意義，亞姐選舉比港姐侮辱女性之處有過之以無不及。­節目質素唔應該成爲維護亞視嘅論點，因爲冇人逼到市民睇某一個台­，唔好睇嘅可以轉台。反而我覺得選擇太少就真，事論節目太少，所­以好多人有時寧願睇字幕都轉英文台。

[Kevster21]

no horse racing on tvb too bad

[cskwan]

我已經好早發現無記劇集千篇一律...內容不外乎爭產, 三角戀....但又整到好似好大制作咁....除咗新聞外, 晚上都冇睇電視好耐....

[ncwken]

袁小姐講得好，敢作敢為，唔似其他偽人

[mkrhiorh]

老實講,我之前唔係好中意佢!

但係佢講d野好夠point,同埋佢比我更清楚

娛樂圈係點先!

[yeahpig2006]

講真，堅撐袁彌明(我唔係袁小姐fans)

講真，唔鍾意袁小姐還唔鍾意，一單還一單(可能佢講得真係好有八­婆feel)

之但係諗深一層，佢講既野全部都好有point，相比現時娛樂圈­大部分藝人(甚至男藝人)，佢既比達力、說話組織性都算數一數二­，袁小姐佢起碼叫做敢言、肯鋤強扶弱！

[pigpig1985]

免費電視台..........無論做多少個小電視台，都無用，­根本無人睇，無人知，無法回本，最後又自然淘汰啦！

而合約就幾不合理，起馬有得揀唔簽。

而內容，亞視除左佢講o個兩個種目，就無人識其他了吧！而tvb­有教育意思的，也有很多，要比就應該整體比。小朋友原本就無必要­看劇集，早睡早起吧！ 早上有很多比較有營養的節目，不過現今小朋友根本沒有空閒看吧！

[henryngan]

Don't you know broadcasting market in HK is definitely not a free market!!!

1st, you need a license in order to broadcast in HK. therefore, TVB is the giant monopolist in HK 2nd, the reason why TVB cannot only stand on a private firm stand point because they are using our public resources to broadcast because they are broadcasting in HK area that making other people cannot broadcasting in those broadcast frequency. Got it?

[chifung82]

乜香港有競爭法咩？

[lock10002006]

電訊廣播條例入面特別寫入反壟斷既條例

[garypaul0821]

外形思考都ok.

[chishingjai]

係呀 每個人都有自由 你唔鐘意係無線做咪走囉 冇人迫你架 獎門人公然非禮女藝人?你咪唔好上囉

[keisre889]

其實本來我對袁彌明冇咩好感同埋覺得佢成日博出位咁

但後來睇返佢做訪問覺得

佢都好真

5會好虛偽

佢都係講返事實出黎

好地地袁彌明係5會3安8撞去抹黑其他藝人

所以人地憎佢都係因為佢敢言姐

[dawokgum]

袁彌明話"......獎門人公然非禮女藝人.........­" 奇怪,我剛剛上星期日先從PS3下載了她在"高清寶寶"中的水着­節目及專訪, 看得不知幾咁開心. 咁sony HK又是否公然非禮她呢?定還是指那些毒男(如我)呢?

[dawokgum]

俾錢,免費,你買ps3就可D/L ga la, 就等如你買电视就可以看cctvb一樣

[bibiancheng]

我未見過佢 佢唔係好靚 不過佢dee point都岩

我覺得係整個傳媒 現代文化一直互動, "viewer discretion is advised" (觀眾請自行判斷) 呢放面無做到好足 好多人 人講乜就聽乜 電視有咩就睇乜 報紙有咩就睇乜 一睇唔多唔少都入左腦 無時間自信去獨立思想 判斷邊dee係自己想要既...

[Sing10114]

我超僧佢,,成日就到做代表~都吾知佢想點,,又吾係靚過人,,­收喇

[wongmanfai]

袁彌明好波!!

[s8mores16]

ATV dramas, TVB dramas, and basically ALL the dramas in the world, whether they be Japanese, Korean, English, etc. have the same themes and guidelines that they are based upon. Why? Because they follow modern themes; whatever is going on in REAL life. Does she want dramas to be about happy perfect lovey-dovey families, with ideal kids and happy couples?

[s8mores16]

Life isn't like that nowadays and probably never will be, why should you lie to your audience by showing themes which would never happen in real life? You cannot film a drama without ANY DRAMA, it's not called a 'drama' for nothing -.-"

[yinaeris]

我唔係好鍾意佢, 不過佢好有道理

[dinerdisaster]

袁彌明, 請繼續努力。

[pweyot]

支持啦~

[iammichaelkui]

erica 好靚呀!!!

[Rodneyshek]

erica好野,敢爆至好聽

[akcw429]

Very good points!