@ChairmanChu Tasteless comments from you too. Nothing concrete, just something superficial.
I don't even understand what you really mean by 'tasteless singing'? As a matter of fact, I love both Jacky and Danny dearly and they both sang with a lot of emotions. So, if your 'tasteless singing' means lack of emotions, I totally disagree!
@ozalice96 My pleasure! I'm sure there are many more people here who would disagree with me, too! And whilst I respect Jacky's reputation and skills as a singer, this cover, like the many others he did in this concert, is not as good as people say it is, in my opinion. Having said that, my opinion is not any more or less authoritative than any others here.
@ChairmanChu I am afraid I have to disagree with you one more time. I actually have both the DVD and CD of this concert because I loved Jacky's covers so much! Anyway, I can't change your opinion and you can't change mine. I guess we have to agree to disagree. As for me, it's refreshing to see someone who can respond with an intelligent post. Even though I disagree with you but you do have my respect!
Nobody can sing this song as well as Danny Chan. Danny's voice adds such a melancholy to it. Danny's version tugs at your heart's strings. What's made even sadder is knowing that Danny died at such a young age. What a tragic loss!
D 拉的音乐的节奏 咁快嘅~zzz
好似好赶咁~
lukchat87 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
學友唱得很有感情, 唱到心坎了...好感動
funnybunny9396 1 week ago
呢首得喎
steventube 1 month ago
學友伯伯唱得很有感情
kkkkkkkkkk955 6 months ago
Tasteless singing from 歌神... 根本沒有陳百強那種深情，唱的很漂浮，只唱了表面的含義。
ChairmanChu 6 months ago 3
@ChairmanChu Tasteless comments from you too. Nothing concrete, just something superficial.
I don't even understand what you really mean by 'tasteless singing'? As a matter of fact, I love both Jacky and Danny dearly and they both sang with a lot of emotions. So, if your 'tasteless singing' means lack of emotions, I totally disagree!
ozalice96 6 months ago
@ozalice96 My pleasure! I'm sure there are many more people here who would disagree with me, too! And whilst I respect Jacky's reputation and skills as a singer, this cover, like the many others he did in this concert, is not as good as people say it is, in my opinion. Having said that, my opinion is not any more or less authoritative than any others here.
ChairmanChu 6 months ago
@ChairmanChu I am afraid I have to disagree with you one more time. I actually have both the DVD and CD of this concert because I loved Jacky's covers so much! Anyway, I can't change your opinion and you can't change mine. I guess we have to agree to disagree. As for me, it's refreshing to see someone who can respond with an intelligent post. Even though I disagree with you but you do have my respect!
ozalice96 6 months ago
@ozalice96 Thanks for the compliments!
ChairmanChu 6 months ago
請問這首歌是不是以前某部港片的主題曲或插曲 ?? 感覺很熟析
lowdabow 7 months ago
@lowdabow that was 'Merry Christmas'
yusumnn2007 7 months ago
Nobody can sing this song as well as Danny Chan. Danny's voice adds such a melancholy to it. Danny's version tugs at your heart's strings. What's made even sadder is knowing that Danny died at such a young age. What a tragic loss!
lightspeedv 8 months ago 5
聽完張學有友的演繹再聽陳百強現場的演唱 說也其妙 聽著眼淚忍不住掉下來
陳百強的歌聲真的太打動人了 動容! 唱到心坎 百聽不厭 傳唱30年還是danny 是天生的歌神
yrebecca100 1 year ago 9
其实歌唱最能打动人的是感情的投入
这些人比较起来只有陈百强感情投入的最真挚 也许和他的性格有关系
学友太注重技巧了 演唱的也太完美 所以也就失去了这支歌的感染力
louiech73 1 year ago 3
陳百強(原唱者)己第一身的失戀者演譯，所以唱得較淒美；張學友的演譯就像向一位失戀者訴說愛情之道的感覺，所以唱得較成熟 ，各有千秋 。
張學友的假音位實在不俗！
tomted02 1 year ago 5
整体上各个版本各有千秋各有特色。都满分。
但最尾时，陈百强、克勤、Eson 的假音都好似“谷”唔上去geh！
只有张学友的假音最好听最顺畅！
（绝无偏帮。其他人唱最尾假音时太勉强喇！）
zhikai83 1 year ago
我未有資格將他跟陳百強比較, 但係我覺得比起李克勤及陳奕迅的版本, 有感情很多,真的能打動人心......
cancer0721 1 year ago 3
佢唱假音既時候將個咪拉到咁落都收到既?
chantaidoi 1 year ago 5
DANNY同學友都係兩種唔同既味道..
DANNY係有種此生亦得不到個段情,一種傷心既感覺
而學友係有一種大男人概嘆既感覺..
wai296 1 year ago 8
张学友唱陈百强这首歌有另一种感觉~苦涩慢慢向着心里渗。。。。
cheriemilk 1 year ago
真的是聴到 苦涩慢慢向著心里渗。。。 T_T
cheriemilk 1 year ago
真的超好聽 雖然我部會廣東話 也沒學過 都聽得出他的感情
還有樓上說的陳百強 他是原唱對吧?
真的都各有特色 好聽好聽
gn01881106 1 year ago 3
這位美女那位野獸
123addoil 2 years ago
個假音唱得好正 好過克勤同eason
Cantoner 2 years ago 8
Jacky 唱功就唔洗批评啦.....但佢的确唱错咗唔少歌词!
jing713 2 years ago 5
果然係歌神.. 聽完幾個唔同人ge version. 都係歌神唱得最有感情.
jayccool 2 years ago
太感人了 唱到心里了
khandura 2 years ago
我是学友的歌迷，但还是觉得陈百强的好听很多。
TengkuIskandar 2 years ago 7
@TengkuIskandar
maybe this song is more suitable for a singer with a young/ teenager type of voice
Jacky's voice is too mature for it
wongkit2006 1 year ago
歌神@_@~~
vinlon123 2 years ago 3
还是陈百强的原唱 更好听
underearthy 2 years ago 5
好聽到動L~一聲
dwongrock 3 years ago 16
唱得很好聽呢~
歌曲本身也有些傷感~好歌~
Crowpan 3 years ago 7
好好聽!
225749a 3 years ago 6
好感動
ahhe1 3 years ago 20