I think it's a shame we have to compare them at all. I think they're both brilliant, in very different ways, and have both expressed their mutual admiration for each other more than once. Why do we feel the need to make these endless comparisons between female artists? If it's not Kylie and Madonna, it's Kylie and Gaga, or Gaga and Madonna. It's fine to fiercely support one artist, but why do we then have to reject the merits of every other artist who falls into a similar category to her?
The Madonna haters are really pathetic, ALWAYS trying to bring her down for ANYTHING. Yes Madonna doesn't have the best voice in the world, she and her fans are the first ones to admit it. But she's NOT talentless, songwriting and creating music is a BIG talent and it's definitively MORE IMPORTANT to me than having a perfect voice in concert. Kylie is maybe a better singer but her lack of involvement in her career is why she CAN'T be called better than Madonna. Madonna is a COMPLETE artist.
The Madonna haters are really pathetic, ALWAYS trying to bring her down for ANYTHING. Yes Madonna doesn't have the best voice in the world, she and her fans are the first ones to admit it. But she's NOT talentless, songwriting and creating music is a BIG talent and it's definitively MORE IMPORTANT to me than having a perfect voice in concert. Kylie is maybe a better singer but her lack of involvement in her career is why she CAN'T be called better than Madonna. Madonna is a COMPLETE artist.
@jodelleferlandfan1 I don't understand why the fans of either side have such friction.. I mean it's clear Madonna and Kylie like each other if they are at each others shows and doing music together lol
Neither of them have vocals like Mariah Carey, the bitchyness is just silly.
@Breniznit I'm not hating on Kylie in my message, i just wanted to make a point clear. I know they like each other and i know they don't have vocals like Mariah Carey. It's just that the Kylie fans are SO annoying in their way to bring Madonna down for anything. I'm sure most of them doesn't know ANYTHING about Madonna's career.
@jodelleferlandfan1 I know, I am just saying i don't understand. I am not blaiming you, don't get me wrong .I am just saying i will people would stop slagging everyone. I mean who cares.If they both like each other as artists why hate one or the other.Kylie for starters loves Madonna, and everyone knows she loves her including Madonna. I guess because out of the US,Madonna and Kylie are the only 2 major survivors from the 80's and because they are the only 2 females to have no.1 in 80,90,2000 er
@Bannear1 Oh really lol? Call me back when Kylie will be able to write all of her music like Madonna does... Kylie is a good singer but she's definitively not better than Madonna.
Also, Madonna gives kudos to Kylie often, once she even wore a Kylie t-shirt on stage. And in turn Kylie admires Madonna, why all this fighting about who is better? They both have their talents so stfu!
holy fucking shit. i had no idea this song existed! and I thought I had every single Kylie b-side and unreleased leaked songs known to man! wow what a nice surprise this was.
4 Minutes was in 21 countries >number one<, Celebration went to the top 10 in 23 countries, Give it 2 Me in 16 countries, Miles Away don`t have even a video clip and in 8 countries went in the top 10 singles chart, Hung Up number one in more than 21 countries and yes... Madonna is very bad songwritter... Kylie is better: in 13 countries All the Lovers went to the top 10(Wikipedia), The One in 6 countries (top10), In My Arms in 10 countries, WOW in 5, 2Hearts in 10... sorry for my english
I like Kylie and her new album is stellar BUT Madonna can deliver a song without making it boring. Whereas Kylie's delivery here is ZZzzzzz yawn zzzZZz. BORING
Rufus Wainwright wrote: "Madonna subverts everything for her own gain. I went to see her London show and it was all so dour and humourless. She surpasses even Joan Crawford in terms of megalomania. Which in itself makes her a kind of dark, gay icon. I love Kylie, she's the anti-Madonna. Self-knowledge is a truly beautiful thing and Kylie knows herself inside out. She is what she is and there is no attempt to make quasi-intellectual statements to substantiate it. She is the gay shorthand for joy
@craigieboy2001 madonna's "megalomania" (i say it "ambition") makes her what she is: the biggest (female) pop icon of all time and the most successful female artist ever! if she wasn't like this she would be just like kylie: a good artist with a good career and that's all
@mtqop58 rubbish. kylie has been huge in the uk and europe for years, its only now the usa and other pa\rts of the world are realising it. she always seems to outdo herself on each tour and never seems to peak. Madonna seems to have had her peak now. She has her fans and always will but she isnt going to get any bigger. Thats the point. Kylie is just getting better and better :)
@mtqop58 lol, kylie just gets better and better, Madonna is way over that hill and she mimes 80% of her shows. Kylie sings everything life. There is no contest!
@showboyninner madonna sings live, except of 2 or 3 songs because she is dancing like no one and it's technically difficult to sing live every song. i'm not gonna convince you that M is way better than kylie or any other female artist. her career speaks for itself!
@showboyninner Madonna sings live most of the time and at least she writes all her music, kylie started out a some manufactured cheesy pop star and rarely writes her music and the ones she does write are hardly classics, Madonna has written so many classics such as Like A Prayer, now thats good music.
love this song.. love kylie and madonna.. madonna is a kylie fan and kylie is a madonna fan.. and kylie may take some ideas off madonna, but madonna did that to debbie harry, and only becus they like what they do
i tell you what pisses me and the other madonna fans off is that kylie gets too much credit for what she does, which if you look at it is very little...she rarely writes any songs and has not done anything for anyone...and b4 the gay community go up in arms she wasnt the first to embrace them,,,
compared to what madonna does and has done it is sick to say kylie is equal or better than her....thats about the measure of it.
and for the record kylie doesnt have the talent to write a song like this
Well Kylie at lest sings every note live and never lip-synchs unlike Madonna who can't sing live. I like them both but Kylie is way better in concert than Madonna could ever be
untrue...madonna sings LIVE with every concert and has the BIGGEST selling tour of a solo artist ever...no offence but go figure
i have been to every tour she has done since 2001, and she sings live for the simple fact she has made one or two lyric mistakes here and there...which obv wouldnt be there if she was miming.....kylie cant sing or sell records...her anticipated new single barely scraped the top 5...
@Mahoney8T7 Get your facts straight, All The Lovers went to the top 10 in over 20 countries. and peaked at 3 in the UK. If Kylie can't sing or sell she wouldn't have released her 11th album. She's even better than Madonna with her loyalty with fans.
I hate to argue and banter. I love Madonna 2 and I've seen every tour since Like A Virgin back in 84-85. She has admitted in interviews that there are times where the dancing and things she is doing on stage are 2 vigorous for her to actually sing those songs so she has no problem with lip-synching. I didn't say she lip sych's the whole concert. I saw Kylie many times from Front row center stage, & she never lip-synchs.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Madonna didnt write this song for Kylie. Madonna wrote and recorded a version with William Orbit and Rick Knowles for the Ray Of Light album in 1997. Alone Again, Liquid Love, Revenge, Has To Be and a cover of the ABBA classic Like An Angel Passing Through My Room all failed to make the final album. Madonna gave Kylie the song in 2002, it was produced by Rick Knowles. I strongly suggest you seek out the other songs that didnt make Ray Of Light which i have mentioned, especially the ABBA cover!!
Er... indeed a great song by Kylie but it most certainly WAS written by Madonna. She gets writers credit in Kylie's White Diamond documentary.
I am so disappointed this never got a proper release because, quite frankly, it's bloody amazing. I can imagine Madonna singing it but you can't deny that Kylie's delivery is rather lovely.
By the way, why can't Kylie and Madonna fans just get along?
@newplanet they will never egt along i dont kow why gaga fans are the worst i love this song madonna and kylie are teh best and have stood the test of time
it was writtten by madonna look at the credits at vthe end of the white dimond movie madonna is a brilliant song writer and writes and produces all her work
@theredbook wow you sure are thick headed it was specified that it was written by madonna and sung by Kylie it is in bold letters at the top of your screen ... get some glasses
no it doesnt omfg shock value & madonnas willing to do anything to sell is why not talent this song isnt anything earth shattering tbh & i doubt madonna could sing it better then minogue...
kylie and madonna will duetting in 2012, for the 25th year in the business of kylie. lots fans are waiting this from years
MrMATTEOTV 3 weeks ago
wish*
Breniznit 3 months ago
I think it's a shame we have to compare them at all. I think they're both brilliant, in very different ways, and have both expressed their mutual admiration for each other more than once. Why do we feel the need to make these endless comparisons between female artists? If it's not Kylie and Madonna, it's Kylie and Gaga, or Gaga and Madonna. It's fine to fiercely support one artist, but why do we then have to reject the merits of every other artist who falls into a similar category to her?
DesperatelySeekingAz 3 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
The Madonna haters are really pathetic, ALWAYS trying to bring her down for ANYTHING. Yes Madonna doesn't have the best voice in the world, she and her fans are the first ones to admit it. But she's NOT talentless, songwriting and creating music is a BIG talent and it's definitively MORE IMPORTANT to me than having a perfect voice in concert. Kylie is maybe a better singer but her lack of involvement in her career is why she CAN'T be called better than Madonna. Madonna is a COMPLETE artist.
jodelleferlandfan1 4 months ago
The Madonna haters are really pathetic, ALWAYS trying to bring her down for ANYTHING. Yes Madonna doesn't have the best voice in the world, she and her fans are the first ones to admit it. But she's NOT talentless, songwriting and creating music is a BIG talent and it's definitively MORE IMPORTANT to me than having a perfect voice in concert. Kylie is maybe a better singer but her lack of involvement in her career is why she CAN'T be called better than Madonna. Madonna is a COMPLETE artist.
jodelleferlandfan1 4 months ago
@jodelleferlandfan1 I don't understand why the fans of either side have such friction.. I mean it's clear Madonna and Kylie like each other if they are at each others shows and doing music together lol
Neither of them have vocals like Mariah Carey, the bitchyness is just silly.
Breniznit 3 months ago
@Breniznit I'm not hating on Kylie in my message, i just wanted to make a point clear. I know they like each other and i know they don't have vocals like Mariah Carey. It's just that the Kylie fans are SO annoying in their way to bring Madonna down for anything. I'm sure most of them doesn't know ANYTHING about Madonna's career.
jodelleferlandfan1 3 months ago
@jodelleferlandfan1 I know, I am just saying i don't understand. I am not blaiming you, don't get me wrong .I am just saying i will people would stop slagging everyone. I mean who cares.If they both like each other as artists why hate one or the other.Kylie for starters loves Madonna, and everyone knows she loves her including Madonna. I guess because out of the US,Madonna and Kylie are the only 2 major survivors from the 80's and because they are the only 2 females to have no.1 in 80,90,2000 er
Breniznit 3 months ago
@Breniznit I agree with you.
jodelleferlandfan1 3 months ago
Sorry about it guys!! But KYLIE is WAY BETTER THEN Madonna WILL EVER BE!!!
Bannear1 5 months ago
@Bannear1 Oh really lol? Call me back when Kylie will be able to write all of her music like Madonna does... Kylie is a good singer but she's definitively not better than Madonna.
jodelleferlandfan1 4 months ago
Kylie is the QUEEN OF POP!!! Go Kylie, LONG LONG LIVE THE QUEEN OF POP!!!!!
Bannear1 5 months ago in playlist Madonna
madonna is the best...!!!!
madonnamaniac94 5 months ago
kylie and madonna will make a song together
what do you think about it???
will be so good!!
EvoShomar 6 months ago 3
@EvoShomar Have to say that would be kewl, even know Kylie is better!!! But in saying that the only thing near Kylie would be Madonna....
Bannear1 5 months ago in playlist Madonna
this is beautiful.....
vinilla 7 months ago
I love madonna...and I hate all people that thinks that she's only a bitch...LISTEN THISSSSSSSSS ...thank kylie and thank u madonnaaaaaaa
nadiaciccone93 10 months ago
To all the haters U wanna be Madonna but the price is too HIGH!!!!!!
Johnny2thaLO 1 year ago 3
These icon ladies are great!!!
chatrabbita 1 year ago
Also, Madonna gives kudos to Kylie often, once she even wore a Kylie t-shirt on stage. And in turn Kylie admires Madonna, why all this fighting about who is better? They both have their talents so stfu!
Lasher820 1 year ago 5
I don´t like Madonna
But Kylie is the best !...
kingdranoe 1 year ago
Well done girls, good job. x
sean1middleton 1 year ago
Wanna hear Madonna's demo sooo bad...
MadgeVogue 1 year ago 3
It even sounds like a Madonna song :) I love you, Kylie!!!
KyliesMCJ 1 year ago
kylie and madonna are the best of pop i think threy are very good in what they doo but of coursee i prefer kylie
allthelovers56 1 year ago
This is actually a damn good song. Congrats Madonna!!
Hunny1au 1 year ago
holy fucking shit. i had no idea this song existed! and I thought I had every single Kylie b-side and unreleased leaked songs known to man! wow what a nice surprise this was.
GoldenFrog 1 year ago
4 Minutes was in 21 countries >number one<, Celebration went to the top 10 in 23 countries, Give it 2 Me in 16 countries, Miles Away don`t have even a video clip and in 8 countries went in the top 10 singles chart, Hung Up number one in more than 21 countries and yes... Madonna is very bad songwritter... Kylie is better: in 13 countries All the Lovers went to the top 10(Wikipedia), The One in 6 countries (top10), In My Arms in 10 countries, WOW in 5, 2Hearts in 10... sorry for my english
TombLoad06 1 year ago
@TombLoad06 Madonna is a brilliant songwriter, no one writes like her, she writes in such a clever way
madonnaisalegend 1 year ago
@madonnaisalegend i think like you
Madonna is queen and I don`t like when somebody is saying that Kylie is better than Madonna
as you can see Madonna have much more top10 singles than Kylie
Madonna is super songwriter and i think too that no one writes like her
you has not understood my intention
sorry for my english
TombLoad06 1 year ago
I like Kylie and her new album is stellar BUT Madonna can deliver a song without making it boring. Whereas Kylie's delivery here is ZZzzzzz yawn zzzZZz. BORING
marknj1028 1 year ago
Madonnas style!
angelsheart85 1 year ago
Rufus Wainwright wrote: "Madonna subverts everything for her own gain. I went to see her London show and it was all so dour and humourless. She surpasses even Joan Crawford in terms of megalomania. Which in itself makes her a kind of dark, gay icon. I love Kylie, she's the anti-Madonna. Self-knowledge is a truly beautiful thing and Kylie knows herself inside out. She is what she is and there is no attempt to make quasi-intellectual statements to substantiate it. She is the gay shorthand for joy
craigieboy2001 1 year ago
@craigieboy2001 madonna's "megalomania" (i say it "ambition") makes her what she is: the biggest (female) pop icon of all time and the most successful female artist ever! if she wasn't like this she would be just like kylie: a good artist with a good career and that's all
mtqop58 1 year ago
@mtqop58 rubbish. kylie has been huge in the uk and europe for years, its only now the usa and other pa\rts of the world are realising it. she always seems to outdo herself on each tour and never seems to peak. Madonna seems to have had her peak now. She has her fans and always will but she isnt going to get any bigger. Thats the point. Kylie is just getting better and better :)
showboyninner 10 months ago 5
@showboyninner kylie is nothing compared to madonna.
mtqop58 9 months ago 3
@mtqop58 lol, kylie just gets better and better, Madonna is way over that hill and she mimes 80% of her shows. Kylie sings everything life. There is no contest!
showboyninner 9 months ago
@showboyninner madonna sings live, except of 2 or 3 songs because she is dancing like no one and it's technically difficult to sing live every song. i'm not gonna convince you that M is way better than kylie or any other female artist. her career speaks for itself!
mtqop58 9 months ago 4
@showboyninner Madonna sings live most of the time and at least she writes all her music, kylie started out a some manufactured cheesy pop star and rarely writes her music and the ones she does write are hardly classics, Madonna has written so many classics such as Like A Prayer, now thats good music.
madonnaisalegend 5 months ago
love this song.. love kylie and madonna.. madonna is a kylie fan and kylie is a madonna fan.. and kylie may take some ideas off madonna, but madonna did that to debbie harry, and only becus they like what they do
TheTammyw 1 year ago
oh they play this song in the white diamond documentary
rejohnny17 1 year ago
i tell you what pisses me and the other madonna fans off is that kylie gets too much credit for what she does, which if you look at it is very little...she rarely writes any songs and has not done anything for anyone...and b4 the gay community go up in arms she wasnt the first to embrace them,,,
compared to what madonna does and has done it is sick to say kylie is equal or better than her....thats about the measure of it.
and for the record kylie doesnt have the talent to write a song like this
Mahoney8T7 1 year ago
Well Kylie at lest sings every note live and never lip-synchs unlike Madonna who can't sing live. I like them both but Kylie is way better in concert than Madonna could ever be
Lasher820 1 year ago
@Lasher820
untrue...madonna sings LIVE with every concert and has the BIGGEST selling tour of a solo artist ever...no offence but go figure
i have been to every tour she has done since 2001, and she sings live for the simple fact she has made one or two lyric mistakes here and there...which obv wouldnt be there if she was miming.....kylie cant sing or sell records...her anticipated new single barely scraped the top 5...
Mahoney8T7 1 year ago
@Mahoney8T7 Get your facts straight, All The Lovers went to the top 10 in over 20 countries. and peaked at 3 in the UK. If Kylie can't sing or sell she wouldn't have released her 11th album. She's even better than Madonna with her loyalty with fans.
IsothosestrasZephyr 1 year ago
@Mahoney8T7
I hate to argue and banter. I love Madonna 2 and I've seen every tour since Like A Virgin back in 84-85. She has admitted in interviews that there are times where the dancing and things she is doing on stage are 2 vigorous for her to actually sing those songs so she has no problem with lip-synching. I didn't say she lip sych's the whole concert. I saw Kylie many times from Front row center stage, & she never lip-synchs.
Lasher820 1 year ago
@Mahoney8T7 Wow...........you are so full of crap...........so keep your 22-year old opinions to yourself because nobody cares what you think.
Simon5005 1 year ago
MADONNA- RARE & DEMOS эксклюзивные треки и видео певицы Мадонна /vkontakte ru/club14277780
Kolmogorov1985 1 year ago
it's sure this lyric wrote by Madonna. ?
minoguelam 1 year ago
Didn't expect that this song is so good!
7OLGA7 1 year ago
if ur mate came over and played you this song .. saying .. I have just made my first record ... you would love it cause it was ur mate ..
darrenh1972 1 year ago
by not me lmaO...
art1ej 1 year ago
why have the written me madonna its not who gives a fuck who wrote it......
art1ej 1 year ago
awesome song.
theblackash 1 year ago
i think madonna should have sung it kylie doesnt do this song justice
GIRLUNDISCOVERED234 2 years ago
Madonna cant even sing wtf.....
art1ej 1 year ago
mmmm very 'to have and not to hold' luvvvit
ladonnarama 2 years ago
perfection from all standpoints....Madonna is a fabulous songwriter and Kylie has never sounded better vocally!
LikeME1985 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Madonna didnt write this song for Kylie. Madonna wrote and recorded a version with William Orbit and Rick Knowles for the Ray Of Light album in 1997. Alone Again, Liquid Love, Revenge, Has To Be and a cover of the ABBA classic Like An Angel Passing Through My Room all failed to make the final album. Madonna gave Kylie the song in 2002, it was produced by Rick Knowles. I strongly suggest you seek out the other songs that didnt make Ray Of Light which i have mentioned, especially the ABBA cover!!
benjo231 2 years ago
Comment removed
benjo231 2 years ago
love this song!
<3
x
MissAmyBabesx 2 years ago
Madonna wrote this song. for the friend Kylie Minogue!
AleksMFlorida 2 years ago 35
how u can download the songs in mp3?someone tell me please
sensitized1983 2 years ago
I want the MP3 too..........please..........
Evilursa 2 years ago
do u have the mp3 song??
sensitized1983 2 years ago
if you still dont have this song i could i send it you if you want :)
LIANNERW 2 years ago
amazing...
AeroSebastianNn 2 years ago
conspiracy?
mystery?
i dont know why dont you dig it...
but for me yah its pretty much similar in frozen era!
Gpd67010 2 years ago
Lovelyyyyyyyy
GabeLohan 2 years ago
you could tell that maddona had a hand in this song! it's very similar to the frozen era songs. i love it they should do it as a duet!
mjjfan69 2 years ago
it's okay, would love to hear the madonna version, but has never been leaked (:
MsEurovisionfan 2 years ago
i have this song on Mp3
Alexjakyle 2 years ago
Comment removed
jacksonhel 2 years ago
Does anyone have this MP3? I can't find it ANYWHERE!!!
therealslimlady1982 2 years ago
Madonna has written many wonderful songs throughout her career in music...and this is one of them!!!!
In2DarkMen 2 years ago 2
Yes Madonna is a brilliant songwriter and she is never recognised for it enough.
jonsey44 2 years ago 32
@jonsey44 Legendary song writer Rick Nowles had to do more with the writing and production of this song. Don't give it up all to madonna
Natalia89v 1 year ago
@Natalia89v madonna wrote most of it
madonnaisalegend 11 months ago
@Natalia89v actually Madonna is the main composer or lyricist on most of her songs including this one
madonnaisalegend 5 months ago
this was in white diamond and used very well ,i like the song
kyliekrazy16 2 years ago
Love it, its so Madonna, wish she had recorded it.
kizzmad 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
LOL LOL LOL ..er...great song by Kylie but it wasn't written by Madonna! LOL
Where do you guys come up with this garbage?
Cyberschizoid 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
LOL LOL LOL...er...great song by Kylie but it wasn't written by Madonna! LOL
Where do you guys make this stuff up?
Cyberschizoid 2 years ago
Er... indeed a great song by Kylie but it most certainly WAS written by Madonna. She gets writers credit in Kylie's White Diamond documentary.
I am so disappointed this never got a proper release because, quite frankly, it's bloody amazing. I can imagine Madonna singing it but you can't deny that Kylie's delivery is rather lovely.
By the way, why can't Kylie and Madonna fans just get along?
newplanet 2 years ago 11
it looks impossible i don't know why...lol
Charliesque 2 years ago
@newplanet they will never egt along i dont kow why gaga fans are the worst i love this song madonna and kylie are teh best and have stood the test of time
motorolaQ9h 1 year ago
it was writtten by madonna look at the credits at vthe end of the white dimond movie madonna is a brilliant song writer and writes and produces all her work
madonnaisastar 2 years ago
Google it! It's quite apparent that Madonna wrote this.
maxime7 2 years ago
Madonna wrote it tw*thead. check your facts!!
theredbook 2 years ago
fu*k off...it's already specified that madonna wrote it!
Charliesque 2 years ago
@theredbook wow you sure are thick headed it was specified that it was written by madonna and sung by Kylie it is in bold letters at the top of your screen ... get some glasses
lilaries4u 1 year ago
Nice song
BluBel123 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I don´t like it, Madonna not is good
kingdranoe 2 years ago
i would love to hear you music tastes if you think madonna is not good
i am afraid that all her number 1s and hit records show that madonna is in fact good
madonnaisastar 2 years ago 5
no it doesnt omfg shock value & madonnas willing to do anything to sell is why not talent this song isnt anything earth shattering tbh & i doubt madonna could sing it better then minogue...
art1ej 1 year ago
This is a beautiful Song......
misfitmarilyn1980 2 years ago 2
great song bangin beat aswel
1andonlySHADE 3 years ago
r u kidding me is this real did Madonna actually gave this track to Kylie i don't believe it
XX11era 3 years ago
great song
123shukri 3 years ago
i will post it once back home i'm on holidays now.
x
THE ONE
Charliesque 3 years ago
Hi, could I have the mp3 of this please????
lestatsmadness1985 3 years ago