Added: 5 years ago
From: Sirrah78
Views: 157,563
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,642)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This still remains my favourite fanvid OF ALL TIME!!! Nothing will ever compare to this, it truly is amazing <3

  • It's been a while since I last saw this vid. It brought tears to my eyes then and it still does! Wonderful video! Heartbreaking, but beautiful!

  • amazing, this didn't really happen in the books and it still had me on the verge of tears!!

  • well uh the sound is back - AND THAT WAS FREAKING AMAZING!! move me to tears why don't you! :)

  • why do they always mute the best videos?

  • Wait just to clear things up a bit... So all three are dead? Is that why people dont notice her? Great plot!

  • nooooo, this was the first video i ever watched on youtube!!!!! i was fasinated by it and still am it is an amazing video.

  • Had another video with the song still on running in another tab while watching this. I really like what you did with the clips to create this story.

    You get a big like from me!

  • Try putting the song Forsaken by within temptation. I think it may work.

  • Well this sucks! The song you had on here was perfect and the vid is amazing. Freaking youtube going and muting the music...

  • challenge this shit! Tell youtube that Fair Use is on your side, and that they should mind their own fucking business and stop stifling creativity...

  • that was very good...i watched it the first time w/out sound then looked up the song & watched it with it...

  • I love it! So sad in the end. Never Alone.

  • Still one of the greatest vids. Pity about the song (they muted my Saved! vid with the same song, so I feel ya.) Luckily I have the song, so I can sync it on my comp. Still a fantastic vid!

  • Wow... I can't believe that youtube had muted your video... though I really don't need to hear the song to watch it. I have it graved in my mind :D Every time I listen to it I remember your video and it makes it so much better... Thank you very much for sharing this with all of us and it's a shame that the new viewers won't have the chance to watch it as it was before... Just breathtaking...

  • ever since google bought youtube, it's gone to hell.

  • this is very very great.

    the end is so sad

  • I REALLY REALLY HATE WMG!!!!

  • this is so amazingg and i was so shocked by the ending but i loved it-- 5 stars <33

  • I loved it! That was absolutely brilliant!

  • OMG!!! I just realised that i had watched this before, before i even had a youtube account it was such an amazing video and it's stayed in my mins since cus I've never seen anything like what you've done in this on any other video and it's just WOW!! such a shame ur audio got muted tho :'( I can see why u chose to mute this rather than delete it tho, it's too brilliant to waste :D

  • I freaking love this video! I came back to watch it and was very sad to find it had been muted. :/ I know you said you are going to make it to a new song, but I absolutely adore it how it is--do you think you could upload it to dailymotion? I don't think they screw with vids like Youtube does, and it would be a shame to lose a track so perfect for your vid.

  • can you possible re-post the video with an approved form of the song? i know a few other videos have this song on them.

  • arg youtube. don't they know that using songs like this actually helps introduce artists to people who may have never heard of the song? i discovered many bands/artists because i liked songs from vids...

  • You are sooooo right!!!

  • i have tears streaming down my cheeks...

    woah... that was utterly beautiful with a shocking twist! <3

    x

  • wat song did it used to be to?

  • It Used to Be 'Never Alone' by Barlowgirl...its such an awesome song :)

  • Never Alone by Barlow Girl

  • man.. I'm sorry youtube has muted lots of your vids - they were so awesome! the songs fit perfectly with the vids, but youtube is muting videos.

    youtube needs to quit muting vids!

  • Great job. I have the song on my computer, thank god, it fits so well. Youtube deleted all my vids. I hate them, but I'll be back!!!

  • Oh i just loved this vid! And the song was just so perfect.

  • I hope you re-make this soon, it was great!

  • what song was originally used?

  • Never Alone by Barlow Girls was the original song if I remember correctly

  • lucky i have this song on my computer, my timing was off by a second at first but i knew i had the timing right with the last chorus. Brilliant vid by the way ^^

  • this vid was really good.

    therre are so many good story lines out there, that are ruined because youtube is taking away the music.

  • good job!

    well done!

  • Muted?!

    NOOOOOO! This was one of my most favorite HP fanvids... seriously, it is just amazing. So clever, so beautifully done!

    I'm so mad right now... I LOVE THIS VIDEO!

  • hmm please try and put it back on?

    song and vid fitted just perfectly.

    youtube already put some of my best vids down as well.

    as if it wouldn't be advertising for those singers.

  • I agree with you on all those points.

    They deleted a lot of my favorite vids and now this one is muted, I'm disappointed.

  • beautiful, beauitFUL! but theres one thing i'd like to know why does hermione reads the news about the threesome dying i mean does she dies with em too n then there toghether in the end?

  • I'm angry now to! This was sooo damn awesome!

  • so did hermione die as well? this is my first time watching and it was w/o sound :(

  • yes, she did :( I only figured that out like the fifteenth time watching it! xD if you notice at the end they're all together and their in color and not black and white or anything so that means its present. So I'm pretty sure she died as well :)

  • NNNOOOOO !!! it's a great vid !! how can they mute it ?????

    hope they will put the sound back soooooooonnnnnnn !!!!!!!!!!!

  • It was eaten by the copyright monster. Grr.

  • WHAT THE HELLLL!!!!! OH YOU GUYS CHOOSE THE WRONG MOVIE TO MUTE!!!!!!!!!! THIS IS ONE OF THE BEST VIDEOS EVER!!!!! tHIS VIDEO IS SOOO DEEP!!!! I'LL KICK YOUR FUC**** A** YOUTUBE!!! PISSED OFFFF!!!!!

    i hope you can do something ! We love you Sirrah!! Keep up your wonderful job

  • Ditto, ditto ditto ditto! I agree with you completely Hedwig

  • NO NO NO!!!! they cannot of muted this! What the hell! This was such an amazing video! It loses so much without sound!

  • NOOO! they can't mute tis video! it was my first fav it helped me throught a rough patch in my life. they can't do this!!!!!

  • iggle07... I'm hoping to remake it to a song on YouTubes approved list so they can'y mute it again! It won't be the same I know!! But still!

  • YouTube has an "approved list"?? How laaaame. This is my second favourite song out of every other song. F*** you, YouTube!

  • ... They muted it. I hope it's alright without the music, but your vids generally are with the music just addons.

  • amazing

    so real

    it made me cry!

  • omg queenanneboleyn im srry im meant to put a thums up sign :(

  • I loved that one! Wonderful job! The idea was really creative

  • Oh my god, this was amazing.

    The ending was great!

    What an imaginitive idea. Very well put- together!

  • this was so amazing! the end was great!

    It seemed so real!

  • I adore it. I cried inside, it was so... real.

    Thank you for the great job you done

  • Genius! It was absolute genius!

  • AMAZING!!!! wat a plotline!! gr8 job.

  • OH MY GOD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! amazing video that was so cool and you were right i had to watch it twice to make sure i was getting it right hehehehe i love it really awesome video

  • so that's why she saw flashes of them because they were trying to tell her I get it, I never cried before but now I'm crying, It makes soo much sense!

  • *sob*

    It made sense.

    *sob again*

  • Amazing.

  • Gorgeous video

  • really sad but amazing! great work!

  • i love love love this video, i cry every time i watch it! you are amazing at this. i love all your vids

  • wow!!!

    Hermione died to???

    If she did I really didnt expect that at all!!

    Very good.

  • Wow you are so talented!! Didn't expect that ending at all!! Fantastically well made!!!

  • 5/5 I loved it !

  • i loove this video i've been watching it for months, sirrah78 is talented =D

  • wait-so did hermione die too or something? SOMEONE PLEASE EXPLAIN, but i still love this vid.

  • Yes, Hermione died as well, though she didn't realize it until she saw the paper. The last scenes are of her with Harry and Ron facing Voldemort, and she remembers, realizing it, and then she flashes back to all the times she tried showing her grief, or talking to someone, and...they ignored her - they didn't see her. And as soon as she realizes that, she can fully see Ron and Harry again, and off they go...

  • OMG! I'd watched this like a million times before not understanding her being in the paper too! Now I understand! Thank you!

  • That was...wicked awesome! Nice twist, I was completely expecting something totally different. Awesome job!

  • This is really amazing. The ending was completely unexpected, and that is rare. Endings to this kind of vid are usually that he/she/they just move on or kill themselves, but she was already dead. That's soo cool! Faves!

  • Didn't see that coming. Wow! well done it gave me chills

  • Oh my goodness, what a cleverly done video! Good job! :)

  • i was sobbing by the end

    and ive got goosebumps all over :|

    this was just stunning!

  • wow that was realy good! i did not see that coming!

  • I love this video, it's awesome. I like the scene where harry and ron's ghosts sit beside hermione and where she finds out she died too. The trio is still together even in death. Wonderful.

  • Wow.

    Nice.

  • What is this song?!

    It's so cute!!

  • Never Alone by Barlow Girl

    I have a video on this account of me playing it - check it out if you wanna =D [ plz ] hehe

  • wow this is a wicked movie, i love it, cos 6th sence is my fave film and it reminded me of it! ive only just discovered your talent and its wicked! thanks!

  • Whhooaaaa

    Amazing!

    I totally didn't see that coming!!!!

  • hi! 2 all people who dont get the ending, im here 2 explain. hermonie is ded and that is why everyone is ignoring her. she doesnt realise shes ded till the end wen harry and ron tell her. hope that helps! :¬)

  • @ 3:30 Does that mean Hermione dies too?

  • OMG i must have watched this vid atleat one hundred times i play it over and over while doing homework and stuff i turn the computer on just to watch it, so pleeeease change the name back i dunno it feels wierd it's name being changed :(

  • Sorry I changed the name! Someone told me there was less chance of my vids being deleted if I changed the names of them, so that they weren't the names of the song! :)

  • does hermione dies in the end???????

  • oh yeah well i would much rather the name changed than lose it altogether :) is that why the 'may angels lead you in' dumbledor eone went? i loved that, there are supriseingly few dumbledore memorial vids :)

    p.s you are sooo amazing and super taletnted i can't actually put it into words! i need more though! i've seen everysinge one, i'm hoping your likeworking on one amazing one that's taking forever and is going to be the best ever! lol

  • awesome video....lol wick awesome... I love the ending where she realizes she died two and how the three of them walk off and dissappear talking to each other.

  • 10/10.

    amazing.

  • soooooo cool! but in 3:29 says: tragic friends side by side. does that means that she was dead too?

  • Thats what I was wondering!

  • this is an amazing video! How did you get them to disapear? That's soooo cool! Great job! 5/5!

  • Whoa how long did it take to make this video???? This is awesome! One of the best videos I've seen in months!

  • that was brill.....i loved it! the music goes really well with da video... great job! =D

  • Hey you changed the name to this vid! I looked at it and I was like this isn't one of my favs! Then I looked and it was this! BTW I love this song and vid so much ty for making it!

  • Wooww! just woow...:D amazing!!

  • its never alone by barlow girls,

    i like the song too weehehehe

  • I'm a little confused but was the reason Hermione could see Harry and Ron because she died too?

  • awsome i listen 2 this almost every day

  • That was wonderful. Really nice job manipulating the clips!!

  • what's name of music and artist?

  • I think it's never alone-Barlow Girl

  • WOW!

    This was absolutely brilliant.

    I loved it!

    Thanks for making such an amazing video.

    Five Stars & Favorited. =)

  • AMAZING!!! Realy...

    The song is beautiful and the history, uau!!!

    What a surprise!

    I can't imagine how did you have this idea?!!!

    I just love it!!! Thnk you a lot!!!

  • Was the title always named that? Couldn't sworn it was something else.

  • It was...xD

    It was 'Never Alone' before :P

  • i just noticed it too; wasn't it 'never alone' before?

  • why have u renamed all of ur songs? its confusing! :¬(

  • the song is called never alone, by the way. its still gr8, im just saying.

  • wow 5 star

  • why did you re-name all of your vids?! i'm so confused! They're harder to find now.

  • This was AMAZING.

    You're very good!

    this made me cry...another way...another story...

    Very goooooooood!!

  • this is one of ur best yet. i started crying about 20 seconds in and i didn't stop until the last second. :¬)

  • At first I thought this video was going to be a waste of my time but wow ... this is great.

  • what program did u used to make that ????

  • This is amazing!

    I love it!

    I can't stop watching it :)

  • 2 morganrumplefan. i think that hermonies realised that her momeories of ron & harry have kept them alive inside. she realises that harry & ron r always gonna be with her. i dunno if im rite tho. but thats wot i think.

  • what happened is when she looked in the paper it said that the tree friends died side by side so she died also which is why she could see them and why everybody seemed to be ignoring her it was really because she was dead

  • it made me cry. oh leila u r so amazing? how do u make ur vids so touching. i cant stop thinking about this.

  • omg amazing!!!!

  • at the end when they walk together, does it signal that hermiones dead to? cus she disappears aswell lol. dont be sarcy or saink cus my brain doesnt take very well.

  • Well if you read the news paper, the headlines was Tragic Friends Die Side By Side with the 3 picture of them.

  • ok, that was REALLY good! i luvd it so much!!!it was really good and even if u stopped it in the very middle, it wudda made perfect sense. 5 STARS!!!

  • WOW! Haven't seen such a BRILLIANT and AWESOME storyline for AGES!

    I nearly expected it to turn out like that for I know a book with a similar storyline, but nevertheless it's SO great!

    I didn't even know there was an effect like making people vanish...

  • that was really amazing! if i get it right, hermione was actually dead too, wasn't she... just to make sure :-)

    reminds me a lot of sixth sense, but nevertheless it's a great video - congratulations!!

  • that was amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • harry and ron come back to life though

  • WHAT?!?!?! where did Herm go in the end??

    WAIT. was she dead too? :OOOOOO

    anyway, amazing vid (<333 5/5), I only have one guestion, can i make somebody dissapear with sony vegas 7 like you did to ron and harry in that vid?

  • OMG! I've alot of Harry Potter vids here, but this most be the best ever!

  • that was amazing!

  • im crying right now and really not sure why im not one of those ppl that cry at anything lol why am i crying

    x

  • Oh my gawd.... That was so amazing! Truely beautiful, very good! ^_^ I loved it! Deffinately five stars! <33

  • OMG

    Girl

    you're so talented

    So beautiful!

  • good one... i think i understand the ending... good editing with the disappearing act... could you teach??

  • super

    !!!!!!!!!

  • Song?

  • Nvm mind. Thanks Karate!

  • the song is never alone barlowgirl

  • Who sings this song please tell me

  • omg that was so amazingly good! and sad :(

  • Sweetness!!

  • You know I normally don't like to watch videos that are not cannon, however your work on this one is pretty great. The editing was awesome and OMG how in the world did you get them to fade out like ghosts and have the background behind them? Anyway thought it was great.

  • jesus thats talent for you!!!!!!!!! i loved it well done

  • nice twist ;)

    well done mates .

    FAVORITE :D

  • brilliant!!

  • Not an HP fan, but this was brilliantly done.

  • That was brilliant!! I loved it! Very well done!

  • Wow......that's like..wow. Very cool.

  • Very Twilight Zone/Sixth Sense/Outer Limits. Kudos for orginality.

  • so they all died???

  • this still gives me shivers

  • wow, this is really good. I absolutly love this band.. they put everything into perspective for me. I'm also a huge fan of Harry Potter. I know that to many christans, it's sinful, but i don't really see how. JKR wrote a beautiful story, sure with curse words that many teens use... and Dumbledore being Gay, and Voldie being called Lord, but that's like the only things that i'd consider a sin... wow, that felt good. My family is always pressuring me.. anyways lol!

  • Wow, this was really well made!!

  • curioso o meu namorado tem um igualzinho....ironia do destino

  • Amazing :)

  • It's very almost sixth sense like...good job

  • that video was awesome

  • so beautiful ... i love it . can you send me the song?

  • beautiful vid! I never expected the ending! Very nicely done.

  • best video ever

    i absolutley loved and the fading and how video was set was awsome

  • Wonderful story.

    The Neville part was quite amazing... It made it look like Neville didn't care and was caught up in his own grief....

    Once again, amazing.

    5/5

  • A wonderful video. It was so tragic. I think it will be my new favorite!!

    I love the fading btw.

    I got one question... I am kinda confused as to what happens to Hermione... did she die to join them or was she dead the whole time?

  • She was dead the whole time, and she only realize that when she read the Dayly Prophet 3:27 - 3:31.

    And this video is WONDERFUL. The story is great and great edited. it's so touching.

  • sirrah your so cool

  • Wow, this was really, really cool. Awesome song, awesome vid.... The newspaper was a nice touch. :3

  • Wow, This is a great video. Not only do you make a unique story yourself with these characters, but you create a fully believable video. I would love to hear how you made the characters fade, but I'd understand if you don't want to share a trade secret. Fantastic job!

  • OMG,how the hell did you do that fade thing? This video is amazing! And soo sad,three of them actually died :( (in this video)

  • Oh my bad...didn't catch the story line very well. Haha. Sorry about that. =/

  • Hermione did not die! Fred Weasley, Professor Snape, Tonks, Remus, Hedwig, Mad-eye...and a couple others died. Seriously, re-read the book. Kay? Thanks.

  • Silly tart, dis is a AU vid. Love it but don't believe it. :)