@kesakko Many thanks Yuha. I wonder if you heard the recording of me playing the same prelude also on a Steinway. My camera doesn't record well, so I don't have a movie but only the recording with a still photo.
@PickleHead60 Since when did not knowing something make someone a ''fuckwit'' as you call them...so you know everything do you?.... dumbfuck!...what an arogant prick
@PickleHead60 Unfortunately, it is easier to call names than it is to do research. Equally unfortunate are your posts on other videos. Apparently, E flat versus E natural is a point of debate. I have always heard (and played) the E natural, so E flat sounds weird to me. Supposedly, however, Chopin penciled in the flat on one of the copies of the music. I have seen sheet music written both ways. So, the person who posted this video may have been playing it as it was written.
Not bad, not bad. I agree with a previous commenter - definitely a better tempo. Everyone plays the song too fast, and it takes away from the ability to really feel each chord for what it is! Slower tempo really adds to the dramatic nature of the piece. Great performance. :)
Not trying to compare so no" I like arguments" please but I wonder if Pete Townsend wasn't influnced by this piece for the opening chordes to "Pinball Wizard"? I mean, since he was trying to write a rock opera it would only seem likely that he would try to mimic classical structures wouldn't it?
ps.: try still with ur hands at the keyboard till the sound ends... dont let just the pedal working, it afect the sound and if u play in other piano u dont know, can happen the pedal dont work well and have a break in the sound, would be sux this =/ but u did very well, nice job mate...
Thanks for your comment, Renato! This is one of the right techniques to play with pedal. I always check that piano is working right before concert. If piano doesn't work right it's tuner's mistake. BTW, I am a piano teacher by profession =)
Brilliant. More greetings from Scotland!
YellowMangerCalling 3 months ago
Beautifully played. What piano are you playing it on, if I may ask?
DavidLancasterPiano 7 months ago
Thank you very much, David! The piano is D-model Steinway, which has been made 1925 in Hamburg.
kesakko 7 months ago
@kesakko Many thanks Yuha. I wonder if you heard the recording of me playing the same prelude also on a Steinway. My camera doesn't record well, so I don't have a movie but only the recording with a still photo.
DavidLancasterPiano 2 months ago
Ay yo pilot drift tht was kinda funny i gotta admit
1293dboy 8 months ago
Third measure fourth beat is E natural, not E flat, fuckwit.
PickleHead60 1 year ago
@PickleHead60 Since when did not knowing something make someone a ''fuckwit'' as you call them...so you know everything do you?.... dumbfuck!...what an arogant prick
JACKandJILLaok 10 months ago 2
@PickleHead60 Unfortunately, it is easier to call names than it is to do research. Equally unfortunate are your posts on other videos. Apparently, E flat versus E natural is a point of debate. I have always heard (and played) the E natural, so E flat sounds weird to me. Supposedly, however, Chopin penciled in the flat on one of the copies of the music. I have seen sheet music written both ways. So, the person who posted this video may have been playing it as it was written.
johnabyerly 10 months ago
HIenoa työtä, Juha. Tämä on ehdottomasti yksi parhaista versiosta täällä. Hyvä tempo ja kaunissointinen piano. T. Niko
Nikoh76 1 year ago
Your piano has a great sound. and you play quite well for not being a professional video.
mrjkdeyoung 1 year ago
beautiful i love the tempo!
rietta 1 year ago
Comment removed
rietta 1 year ago
I have listened to about 40 or so versions of this preludium to day. Your's other than Tzvi Erez's is the finest version.
teakbridge101 1 year ago
Truly beautiful, the best I've heard it. Well done
DavidObst 2 years ago
brava
rietta 2 years ago
tutorial?
Danburnz1 2 years ago
yeah there's a tutorial. it's called sheet music. LOL sorry i had to.
pilotdrift05 2 years ago 6
fair enough... XD
SuperIby 2 years ago
@pilotdrift05 actually ive never read music before, and learned how to, JUST so i could play this.
SuperIby 1 year ago
@SuperIby Awwwww......that's so cool....
daytonmlivingston 1 year ago
Not bad, not bad. I agree with a previous commenter - definitely a better tempo. Everyone plays the song too fast, and it takes away from the ability to really feel each chord for what it is! Slower tempo really adds to the dramatic nature of the piece. Great performance. :)
necro2607 2 years ago 2
Not trying to compare so no" I like arguments" please but I wonder if Pete Townsend wasn't influnced by this piece for the opening chordes to "Pinball Wizard"? I mean, since he was trying to write a rock opera it would only seem likely that he would try to mimic classical structures wouldn't it?
2vonranke 2 years ago
I like the tempo a lot, this is one of the best versions I've heard on Youtube :) Favourited and 5/5!
naamaraaja 2 years ago
this is great!
zoso445 2 years ago
Beautiful! A pleasure to listen to. Greetings from Scotland.
ArchieWW 2 years ago 4
sweet and sincere.
aquaman300 3 years ago 2
Where is fortissimo?
Dahmer1988 2 years ago
nice interpretation!! congratulations m8 ^^
RenatoABabka 3 years ago
ps.: try still with ur hands at the keyboard till the sound ends... dont let just the pedal working, it afect the sound and if u play in other piano u dont know, can happen the pedal dont work well and have a break in the sound, would be sux this =/ but u did very well, nice job mate...
RenatoABabka 3 years ago 2
Thanks for your comment, Renato! This is one of the right techniques to play with pedal. I always check that piano is working right before concert. If piano doesn't work right it's tuner's mistake. BTW, I am a piano teacher by profession =)
Thank you for all the comments, everybody!
kesakko 3 years ago 2
beautiful =]
CantThinkOfANamee 3 years ago
Heh, I read about this song in Lucky Luke comic "Jesse James". This Prelude sounds really sad. I like J. S. Bach's Preludes more.
AnXare 3 years ago
I really like the way you've actually played it largo: a lot of the videos of this piece tend to play it unnaturally fast.
Anyway, it's very very good. :)
IBeTheBadman 3 years ago
Good tempo and interpretation.
AlsatianCousin 3 years ago
there should br crescendo in the end...
but nice
Shironi10 3 years ago
Very nicely played and you obviously feel the emotion of the piece.
vulcan1948 3 years ago
Nice!
ldc168 3 years ago
Shouldnt the highest E on the fourth beat of the third measure be natural? accidentals carry through the measure... -_-
Penguin122789 3 years ago
I'm looking at the music for it now, and in fact the E you refer to is marked with a flat.
SgtXerogovitsky 3 years ago
amazing :O
enkelix 3 years ago
Thank you, enkelix =)
kesakko 3 years ago
TRSFYJLGAJOL7FLATYCLPC
darigaz1313 3 years ago
FYJOPJNK.JNK.SHSFJDMLÑ K
darigaz1313 3 years ago
Thank you very much for your nice words! =)
kesakko 3 years ago
dude that's the best interpretation i've heard. ever.
13243546abcdef 3 years ago
e-Mazing ! :D
Payam0 4 years ago
i really appreciate ur interpretation !! perfect time betwin each "accords" (in frenh in the text) really good!! thanks
gab2992 4 years ago