Added: 3 years ago
From: CatPowerTheGreatest
Views: 37,899
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (32)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Seriously? This is live music. Of course it's not all going to fit all easy like. It all works really well, don't scrutinise what you love so much. It's just another amazing live song by Chan.

  • Thank you, Merstheman. Sorry, I confused his first name with that of the Dirty Three guitarist, Mick Taylor. Anyway, I wasn't claiming that he played on "The Greatest" (Steve Potts did the drumming). I was merely offering an opinion that I thought Jim White's playing was better suited to Chan's music than Shelley or Grohl

  • ♥♥♥

    

  • Chan needs to just play her own guitar for her songs. This guitar player is so off the first minute of the song, see how she looks back at the band, sayin get it together guys!

  • I don't care if any of them were off beat, they still sound amazing and chans vocals totally make up for it all! :D :D

  • ...umm mon lit est ma lune...trône douillet ummm un oeil encore de coller j'tir ma couverture...replace mon oreiller...baille un peu...redonne un coup sur ma couverture enfille mon chandail et hop !!

  • none of the musicians sound out of tempo to me, they're just switching it up.

    Very very nice.

  • how beautiful. Thanks for posting it.

  • I think it sounds fine. Raw and real

  • That god awful organ!!

  • Yes, I think all musicians are out of tempo.

  • @DANOJEDA couldn't agree more. Sad tho,it's a great song and they actually started well.

    Guess Cat Power sences it too,can see that in her look 00:37

  • The drummer is Mick White who plays in the Dirty Three. He's a highly regarded drummer. Steve Shelley and Dave Grohl are great drummers too, but Mick White's style is better suited for the songs on "The Greatest."

  • @benjaminhayesclark His name is Jim White. And he didn't play on "The Greatest"

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @benjaminhayesclark Jim White

  • its just really slow drums and it gets boring and you go off time a little unless your tight but he's really not messing up he just changes the snare up sometimes and puts it on like 4 instead of 3

  • it's the drummer

  • no me gusto la version, este es el medio tema y es una lastima que un batero tan penkiña las kge tooas, chan le pega el medio tate con la mirada en el 1:00 !!!^^

  • its not the drummer, its the dude on the organ who is out of beat...

  • @MyGoldenGreg Actually neither are "off beat" - it's called syncopation.

  • drummer sucks.

  • you do

  • Anyone have any idea if Dave Krusen played with Cat?  I think he did... He was the original drummer of Pearl Jam (played the drum tracks for "ten") ...

  • Steve Shelly of sonic youth played drums on the first 2 albums and on You Are Free it was dave Grohl

  • @bootyhunter420 grohl did a guest drum spot on he war.

  • this is fantastic so fantastic...

  • if only the drummer could keep the beat... pathetic

  • you are

  • i love that woman...

  • this kicks ass.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more