Added: 5 years ago
From: freekorps
Views: 61,422
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (56)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • WHY DIDNT YOU RECORD THE WHOLE SONG??? I dont care if its 12 min long! You dropped the ball!

  • Now this is what I would have liked to see. Her performance in Sweden was awful.

  • @Saesangism no!

  • kissm e

  • wow i wish i had the chance to see her live with a full orchestra

    great clip

  • Love the song. It kind of reminds me of a Neil Young song but I cannot recall which...

  • you do realize that fact and opinion are two different things?

  • Joanna and the orchestra just love it, the songs on the Ys album give me goosebumps :)

  • @NatJane18xx Same here! Amazing album..beautiful. :)!!

  • fantastic. one critique -- why did you record the orchestra getting in tune? that could've been a couple more minutes of 'emily'.

  • I understand you didn't want to record all of it, but you could have recorded /some./

  • I attended this that night... , and she was awesome... love the city halls too... so glad you got even a little bit of it. :D

  • DAMNIT

    MOARRRRRRRRRRRRRRR

  • Actually on this performance, some parts here and there, reminded me of Tori Amos in style.

    Again no comparison, as they are both unique but beautiful like peaches and pears.

  • Cannot compare. The only thing they share in common is their absolute uniqueness, which is beauty in itself. Joanna writes, composes and performs with a Harp. <3

  • she sounds kind of like bjork

  • Please! don't compare she with Björk pleeeeeeease : )

  • shivers down my spine!

  • Have you even heard Ys?

    Part of the magic of the entire album is the orchestral element, and is what made that album different from Milk-Eyed Mender, Walnut Whales, and Yarn and Glue.

    I agree, I love her solo performance, but calling the violin pick and cello performances rubbish....well...

    by the way, she wrote all those parts

  • I'm sure that all involved are excellent musicians.... I'm not about disrespecting their work. I'm just saying that I prefer Joanna Newsom solo.

  • I think Van Dyke Parks is actually responsible for the orchestrations on Ys

  • uh no... that was van dyke parks.

  • i acutally agree. don't know why stupids rated your post so bad

  • "I wasn't gonna record the whole thing cos its flippin 12 mins long." Well that just sucks.

  • This song is so amazing in the studio. Amazing. I wish I could see her live with full orchestra.

  • Excellent work on recording this one too man..

  • can anyone please tell me if she orchestrated it herself?

  • van dyke parks wrote the arrangements based on her own harp arrangement

  • @freekorps How funny. I was reminded of the Inara George album he collaborated with her on while listening to this album

  • ...and she did back and forth with him on the material he submitted. Spoken more in sentiment I'm told than notation.

  • and she did back and forth with him. Spoken more in sentiment than notation I'm to believe.

  • I was there, it rocked. the lights stayed like that the whole time so it was a tad sterile tho.

  • fucking awesome dude. i am very envious of you. i'm going to see her at the royal albert hall on the 28th sept but every live performance i see just blows me away. well done.

  • if only you had the full song.

    but oh well.

    i wish i could see her with an orchestra,

    it's like a production.

    it'd be an honor. =]

  • don't listen to those fools.. thanks so much for the video!

    I wish I could have seen her with an orchestra... mind you I saw her with her band in a church, so it was just as good!

    thanks again.

  • why did you post only 56 seconds of music dude? what a let down

  • not as much of a let down as the video on your profile, which serves no purpose whatsoever. 24 seconds of nothing. i figure its better than nothing

  • @freekorps Now THATS how you pwn a bitch! *highfive*

  • Probably because you don't go to a live concert to watch the entire thing on the tiny screen on the back of your camera... fucking idiot.

  • Thanks for posting!!!

  • Why did you record a minute of tuning?..

  • cos thats alls i got

  • Yeah. That's what I want to know.

  • they didnt turn on the balcony speakers till about half way through this song.

  • I found the barefoot percussionist strangely sexy.

  • I think he's hot too! haha!

  • He looks about 12

  • Excellent work on recording this one too man..

  • I cried during this, on the night. I don't think anyone saw though!

  • I nearly did too but I was on the balcony so I think my eyes were too busy squinting to make tears. It was stunning. Thanks freekorps. =}

  • Great performance! Thanks for posting. :-D

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more