Added: 4 years ago
From: Froggars
Views: 138,726
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (384)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I prefer the english version. It's not that bad a translation.

  • I like the german version better, however, I like that i can actually understand what they're saying in this version.

  • I think it's pretty good for an english version of a german song. It's not like it "99 red baloons".

  • fuck this video is blocked in Germany...

    If you have a german IP you can't watch this video....

    fuck GEMA

  • iam not german im italian and yes the german version of this song is 10x better but hey lol this is still alright yah know but german version is great lol.

  • maybe the english version better

  • ZAJEBISTE!!!!  :]

  • i love it!! does somebody know when this video was made? thanks

  • Comment removed

  • This is a classic case of overproduction!

    German version was raw, had passion and innocence.

    This reeks of studio mass effects and unoriginal band members.

    Axel Rose syndrome.

    IMHO.

  • i cant belive there are no clockwork shots in the vid???

    jetz ich bin bose!

  • Who better to do a song of their original, than the Toten Hosen, if Campino wants to put a different spin on this..it's his song. I love the german version, and i understand it and feel every word of if in german, the english versions are very different, a lot of jumbled words that have no meaning like the original, but Andreas puts out a different version altogether. They do that all the time..cos they under stand languages and nuances of cultures. TOTEN HOSENARE THE BEST, believe them.

  • Who better to do a song of their original, than the Toten Hosen, if Campino wants to put a different spin on this..it's his song. I love the german version, and i understand it and feel every word of if in german, the english versions are very different, a lot of jumbled words that have no meaning like the original, but Andreas puts out a different version altogether. They do that all the time..cos they under stand languages and nuances of cultures. TOTEN HOSES ARE THE BEST, believe them.

  • I honestly like the german version much better.

  • What the fuck? Sing in German!

  • Hey Hey Hey here comes alex

  • Who sings the english version? I'm not too familiar with Die Toten Hosen...

  • @Rayman304 die toten hosen does

  • the German Version rules , but this isn't that bad .... still the music Rocks !!!!!

  • THE GERMAN VERSION RULES!!!!

  • i love the german version, but this english version is really well done!

  • im seeing alot of david hasslehoff here...

  • Even Though I Dont Understand the German Version... GERMAN ROCKS!!!!

  • 9 justin beiber fans were shot in the making of this film

  • I always liked Hier Kommt Alex, it is just good to be able to understand it in English :D

  • what year was the english version recorded?

  • @nakukaku 1994

  • Original version is way better ;0

    but this one is noce too

  • both english and german versions are good the meaning is deep and it really sounds good this song is great :)

  • @XxwonderfifflexX I agree that both versions sound great. I never understood what the singer was saying in the German version. But when I heard it in English, it still sounded great.

  • Campino, I want a child with you!!

  • @Froggars Hey there where from u

    think comes the right to fuck the Q up,

    the guys have been workin' on so hard?

    I'm a girl Alex used to have this song as

    favourite in my late night program.So pity

    ya earless asshole.As a musician I'll tell

    u don't leave like this,work on it

  • dude the chicks are hot

  • Comment removed

  • Great song!!  strong and powerfull, awesome music!!

    I will return!!

    Alex Signori K.H.

  • Alex shouldn't have bothered returning

  • wow hell no german version way up

  • this is ok i guess, but the german version is still the best no doubt

  • I can't understand the German version but it is way better than the English. 

  • Hey! Hier Kommt Alex! rather than Hey, here come's Alex :)

  • This version's alright, but the German 1's definitely better. Plus all the lyrics are different. If the video with English translated lyrics was right anyways.

  • I prefare too know what they sing but germany version is mutch better

  • i prefer being able to understand what they're saying so this ones better (: in my opinion

  • the guy inthe video is weird xD

  • I rock the hell out to this.

  • hier kommt alex is better but this one is still good.

  • HEY! HEY! HEY! HERE COMES ALEX!

  • german version is way better

    this one is not the yellow from the egg xDD

  • @PureMetalDrummer: If they did a literal translation it would mean something completely different than it does in German.

  • true the lyrics are different but the spirit of the original song is left intact in this version as well :) great song in german or english!

  • All the charm is gone, better in german.

  • All the german people are commenting on this version and all the english people are commenting on the german version...

  • "say it in english please...."^^ hätte nicht gedacht dass man den unterricht auch ins leben übernimmt... das original is immernoch besser!!!!

    dth 4 ever

  • Ich finde die Strophen sehr gut gelungen. But they should have used "There goes Alex" instead of "Here comes Alex".

    Just my Meinung.

  • good use of mixing german and english there

    i think that was gut aber you could have used mehr deutsch, meine meinung nach

  • to be fair, hier kommt alex sounds a lot like here comes alex, so it's alright

  • besser als auf deutsch finde ich

  • sure!!

  • wow i hätt nie gedacht, dass ma des lied auch in englisch singen kann und sichs gut anhört.

    kompliment!

  • I agree that the german version is better, although it's nice to hear the song and understand the lyricsfully for once.

    Great song though :)

  • Well, agreed :P

    What buggers me is that they didn't do a direct translation. Ah well, can't have it all :P

  • Translating songs directly is far harder than, say, translating books. You have to keep the tone and pentamater of the original song.

  • No matter what, the german version is better!!

  • bääm end gail :D

  • wahnsinn dass die des gschafft ham das sich des im englischen auch so geil anhört

  • i have never heard the english version of the song! oO but it sounds really good!

  • The german one is way better !

  • damn right!

  • @ghr456ghr yup.....

  • @ghr456ghr yeah german version is really better. unfortunately:(:(:( i'm polish:):):) buahahaha

  • I will return vengeance will be mine !!!

    777 777 777 777 777 777 777

  • shut up!

  • TOTEN HOSEN for ever

    i lovvve them

    Düsseldorf

    the best city ^^

    FOORTUNA -DÜÜÜSELDORF

  • i think it isn't better than the "new" german version.

  • this is punk ?

  • of course ?

  • I love this song. :)

  • I like what they're singing about... sort of. I like being in the system. Being part of the system. I want to be "the man." To be for "the man."

  • For those of you that don't know Die Toten Hosen's Hier Kommt Alex , Bye Bye Alex and Return of Alex is based on the movie A Clockwork Orange's main character

  • And the movie was in turn based upon a novel of the same name. Alex DeLarge, your humble narrator. What's funny is that my name is also Alex.

  • Fuck the Nwo.... WAKE UP SHEEPLE... Listen to the lyrics

  • que grandes los hosen! los esperamos en octubre y noviembre!!!!

  • What you talk about buddy

  • Comment removed

  • Englisch und Deutsch sind die Hosen einfach geil

  • Ich find mit den Effekten den Refrain in der Englischen Version besser. Ingesamt aber die Deutsche.

  • I agree, even though I'm American. I listened to both.

  • Do you speak German or why did you understand my comment? =)

  • I am currently taking German class. I don't understand everything, but I could understand what you were saying. =)

  • Die toten hosen....THEY ROCK! cool video great song

  • wenn du nur die guten sachen kennst, kennst du alles *g*

  • die deutsche und die englische verson sid beide richtig gut!!! eigentich ist alles was die hosen machen richtig gut, oder ich kenn nur die guten sachen ;-)

  • the dead trousers:D

  • german is better

  • This version is great, even as good as the german version. the text is a little bit different, but both versions are great^^

  • the Video of the english Version is much better than the video of german Version =D

  • Its more interesting... and in some way I like the voice of Campino more then when he sings in germanXD

  • Does this version remove the refrence to the Droogs?

  • Clockwork Orange - Uhrwerk Orange!

    ;)

  • its a lot better in german, especialy unplugged with a piano,that makes the beginning just..damn

  • My candien Friend that is Germany

    ure welcome

  • I speak English and am from Canada, and I prefer the German version of this song. The only thing going for this version is that I can understand it, but hey, that's what reading lyric translations are for.

  • Ihr sollt den tag nicht vor dem Abend loben

    schöne Grüsse eines Onkelz

  • WOOOOOOOOOOOO!!! GO ALEX!!!

  • Ohh,wenn man die deutsche Version im Kopf hat un dann das hier hört,...:D

    Campino?Bitte sing dieses Lied nur auf DeutschxD ♥

  • is that die toten hosen singing ?

  • yes

  • i think they should make german music not english....

  • what about the song pushed again I say let them try something different it will give their music more avenues THEY ROCK!! but the song zein kleine jager meister should be left alone but ther is something called lost in translation to be considered

  • lol the german version is wayyyyy better for some reason

  • FUCK YEA!

    I LOVE ALEXX!!!!!

  • ich find die deutsche vision besser!!!

    aber des is auch gut!!

  • ein bisschen sonderbar, nie? Campino ist besser in Deutsch...

  • I love this song and the german versions "Hier kommt Alex" and "Bye, bye, Alex".

    But: Why is this song named "the Return of Alex" while campino sing "Here comes Alex"?

    Greetings to the international Hosen-Fans from Germany

  • die deutsche version is besser :)

  • joa... eig sind beide gleich gut aber ich find das video hier besser als das zur deutschen version

  • i have no idea wat ur saying BUT I TOTALLY AGREE WITH U XD

  • She said the German version is better XD

    And im pretty sure BlinkDevil is saying "Yeah, but the this video's better than the german version"

  • oh ja :D

  • o and awesome song

  • thats right im back! o, and this not the english version of hier kommt alex, its just one of the 3 alex songs.

  • Eeek! I'm worried...'Alex' now speaks English and he's out for vengeance! *hides under table*

    Nice sequel...I do agree the German lyrics to 'part 1' -if you will- fit so well to the tune...original defo favourite XD

  • Comment removed

  • Mir gefällt am liebsten Hier kommt Alex

  • if you think the song should be renamed thats up to you. just dont embarrass yourselves stupid arguments over youtube

  • pamietarz jak bylismy mloszi

  • Comment removed

  • Hier kommt Alex is in german, this one is in English. I suppose that's the only difference.

  • Comment removed

  • No, the english verision of the song is called Return of Alex. Hier Kommt Alex is the german verision.

  • Comment removed

  • Quiet the opposite, you're probably the retard. See, it's very, very, very simple.

    Die Toten Hosen (that'd be the band we're discussing here) made Hier Kommt Alex, based on A Clockwork Orange's main character. It is in german.

    Then they made Return of Alex, which is a cover, if you will, of Hier Kommt Alex but with english lyrics. Now, unless you're a complete retard you'll notice that the lyrics are in english. Hence, this is Return of Alex, not Hier Kommt Alex (which is in german).

  • yea but heir kommt alex translates to heir comes alex.

  • I'm well aware of what Hier Kommt Alex means, but that's got nothing to do with the name of the song really.

    But Here Comes Alex would be a more sensible name of the english verision, but for some reason they named it Return of Alex.

  • Mehr Horror show bitte!

  • does anyone know where you can download this.

    i require it.

  • google for download youtube vids and then convert the video into mp3 or whatever you need

  • i did not know that there is an english version of the originally song.

    The originaly song is on german and calls "hier kommt alex

  • hey i'm a german and didn't no that die toten hosen are so famous in other countries:D

  • hallo! Ich komme aus England. Ich spreche Englisch, und mein Deutsch ist schrecklich!

    Ja, Die Toten Hosen sind sehr gut im England. =D

  • the german version is better :D

  • ja, naturlich!! ;)

  • At least the lyrics don't suck in English this is pretty cool

  • Oh yes, the german is the best but being english its good to actually here what they are saying, i guess thats why I like Pushed Again too :P

  • Sry but i must say that the german version is better.

  • his guitar looks like one of George Lynch's guitar

  • As a Dutchman, non-English, non-German speaker, I prefer the German version. But hey, by all means, let them take over the world. Which would be easier in English.

    SCHINKEN! EI!

  • the world needs bands like Die toten Hosen!

  • i like it, but still prefer the german version to be honest

  • german is better. it's like "bonnie & clyde". german language is better for this songs.

  • the best Band of the World!

  • Lol i rather the german version, even though you don't know the lyrics it just sounds better.

  • i like ther german version better ... but it is not bad

  • This is such a beastly song

  • return of alex ♥

  • where can i download this song?

  • on youtube

  • Comment removed

  • On Ebay or Amazon. However, I m not sure about any import taxes ...Have it sent as a "gift"! :-)

  • somehow, it loses the power in english

  • Probably because the singer's native language is German, and cannot speak English naturally. I myself like the German version better, but this version gets the job done too.

  • Campino is half german/english

  • In my opinion (I'm german) English sounds quite neutral. That's why for me it is very difficult to understand and feel emotions in english properly. As I often heared German sounds aggressive which belongs to this song pretty much. Also the words in english are to short and you don't need as many as in German so that's why this song is strange in my ears in english. But that's only my point of view.