In Indian instrumental classical music is a tusscle between Gayaki and Tantrakari styles. Gayaki anga restrict the performers frm gimmickery and maintain the sanctity of Bandish/raga. Tantrakars are spoiling classical music by such commerciality, and it is easily acceptable by the ppl and the govt today. What happened to the our aesthetics now a days ?
Mr.Djthakur sorry to say Jugal Bandi is one form of classical .May Vilyat Kha Ji,have said some thing . But,still Late Bhimsen Joshi ji had perform Jugal Bandi and Jasrangi another form of Jugal Bandi is very famous now days
P.S. This type of superficial jugglery was invented the days of hippies in USA by the Indian classical musicians. Hippies did'nt know much about Indian music in those days. Ask a serious connoisseur of Indian classical music whether he permits this "jokerai or meerasipan"within the ambit of raga ?
@parimusiclife I have listened to the Indian classical music for the last 50 years and myself been a classical musician. This sawal -jawab muck is neither taught academically nor our great ustads have ever approved it. ILet Indian classical music remain spiritual (at the climax of a recital), sawl-jawab at the fag-end of a recital is unspiritual. Nobody can realize BRAHMA or God after sawal-jawab display. Great sitarist . Vilayat khan never did sawl -jawab and in fact used to criticise it
@MrDjthakur k...frst of all i would like to apologise fr my harsh nature...
i accept that this wasnt taught ....but it is done fr the entertainment , please do not compare western music to hindustaani classical music as it is totally different......even im a fan of real good rock bands like green day , iron maiden, etc and i also hear to bethovens music too......
Sawal-jawab in INDIAN CLASSICAL MUSIC ? How come ? Which Ustad says ? which Shashtra says ? No, this is jugglery of commercial importance invented ( to lure and befool westernes ) by some Indian instrumentalists .....It is a trick to sell bogus stuff in the name of Raga Vidya. Look at the Western classical scene......Westerners have never allowed such cheap jugglery to pollute their claasical music, .Bach is still Bach, Beethovan is still Beethovan., classicality is intact. When we will learn ?
@MrDjthakur Classic apples and oranges comparison. Western classical music was written in the classical period hence the name "classical music". but our music on the other hand is described very loosely by the Shastras. its always open to improvisation. there are no fixed set of compositions. here, hariji and Zakir sahab on purpose missing a cycle alternately, this in no way, goes against the basic principles of sur taal and raga that are the heart and soul of OUR music.
by the way did u see 1:54 onwards...ha ha... he made an expression when hari ji picked up a high pitch.... that is so original..... ha ha ha...Rare on Zakir ji...
In Indian instrumental classical music is a tusscle between Gayaki and Tantrakari styles. Gayaki anga restrict the performers frm gimmickery and maintain the sanctity of Bandish/raga. Tantrakars are spoiling classical music by such commerciality, and it is easily acceptable by the ppl and the govt today. What happened to the our aesthetics now a days ?
MrDjthakur 2 weeks ago
gr8
omkaraapte 4 weeks ago
Comment removed
agnt00007 3 months ago
Mr.Djthakur sorry to say Jugal Bandi is one form of classical .May Vilyat Kha Ji,have said some thing . But,still Late Bhimsen Joshi ji had perform Jugal Bandi and Jasrangi another form of Jugal Bandi is very famous now days
gokhaleshreepad1 3 months ago
Good one. R DVD's available in Market
gokhaleshreepad1 3 months ago
P.S. This type of superficial jugglery was invented the days of hippies in USA by the Indian classical musicians. Hippies did'nt know much about Indian music in those days. Ask a serious connoisseur of Indian classical music whether he permits this "jokerai or meerasipan"within the ambit of raga ?
MrDjthakur 4 months ago
@MrDjthakur go eat western mud!.......this is not a commercial jugglery....its in history of hindustani classical music.....
parimusiclife 4 months ago
@parimusiclife I have listened to the Indian classical music for the last 50 years and myself been a classical musician. This sawal -jawab muck is neither taught academically nor our great ustads have ever approved it. ILet Indian classical music remain spiritual (at the climax of a recital), sawl-jawab at the fag-end of a recital is unspiritual. Nobody can realize BRAHMA or God after sawal-jawab display. Great sitarist . Vilayat khan never did sawl -jawab and in fact used to criticise it
MrDjthakur 4 months ago
@MrDjthakur k...frst of all i would like to apologise fr my harsh nature...
i accept that this wasnt taught ....but it is done fr the entertainment , please do not compare western music to hindustaani classical music as it is totally different......even im a fan of real good rock bands like green day , iron maiden, etc and i also hear to bethovens music too......
parimusiclife 4 months ago
Sawal-jawab in INDIAN CLASSICAL MUSIC ? How come ? Which Ustad says ? which Shashtra says ? No, this is jugglery of commercial importance invented ( to lure and befool westernes ) by some Indian instrumentalists .....It is a trick to sell bogus stuff in the name of Raga Vidya. Look at the Western classical scene......Westerners have never allowed such cheap jugglery to pollute their claasical music, .Bach is still Bach, Beethovan is still Beethovan., classicality is intact. When we will learn ?
MrDjthakur 4 months ago
@MrDjthakur Classic apples and oranges comparison. Western classical music was written in the classical period hence the name "classical music". but our music on the other hand is described very loosely by the Shastras. its always open to improvisation. there are no fixed set of compositions. here, hariji and Zakir sahab on purpose missing a cycle alternately, this in no way, goes against the basic principles of sur taal and raga that are the heart and soul of OUR music.
prithwin 2 weeks ago
waah
LAAJWABMUSICS 4 months ago
Very great indeed. Takes years of practice. They need to be given the highest prize in music.
Milahi1935 4 months ago
kya baat hey the two are the best in their instruments
khankheil1 5 months ago
This video made me very proud.
I am 23 and taking tabla lessons now so i can realise how very good this is!
Thumbs up
Sonam53 7 months ago
I'm also a Tabla visharad from India. but Zakir saab is the PRO.
nirmalpooja 8 months ago
excellent maestro!!!
jerimski 8 months ago
my friend, you need to come a long way.
abegeo01 9 months ago
@abegeo01 this in reply to all the geniuses (or is it genusii) who do not like this.
abegeo01 9 months ago
Does anyone have more footage of this? Thanks.
HovaCarlito 9 months ago
awesm .................!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
jagjotsinghify 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
beautiful.... Thank you...
by the way did u see 1:54 onwards...ha ha... he made an expression when hari ji picked up a high pitch.... that is so original..... ha ha ha...Rare on Zakir ji...
cute...
diabolusX9 10 months ago
Comment removed
diabolusX9 10 months ago
whah mai to aapka bohut bada fan hun i also want to be like u both
i m also a tabala player and i m 12 years old
MultiRajan11 1 year ago
ustad zakir hussain is step brother of legendry actress of pakistan tv RUHI BANO.
tariqsohail1979 1 year ago
excellent!
curiousEngine 1 year ago
i love this... zakir and pandit ji hariprasad are among the most magickal performers of indian music and of all this world... truly "gandharvic".
oxoc108 1 year ago
wah ustad!!!
jasjeetsgh 1 year ago
Awesome!!!!
Wonderfull!!!
Ronaudi7 1 year ago
wow!
Uelogy22 1 year ago
holy shit man........dat woz fuckin amazing
xgenerationboy 1 year ago
Does anyone have the whole video.
gpatelk 2 years ago
@gpatelk
Search for Rajshri productions videos - entire length is posted.
bombaywala86 1 year ago
Beautiful!!!
vedantbhatt 2 years ago