梁靜茹 誘惑的街 原唱林憶蓮 (2007李宗盛理性與感性作品音樂會)

[ee123ox]

梁靜茹聲音很鬆~ 真的很會唱!!!

[ufozhai]

赞赞赞...

[TheSiber2011]

又回来听了 前面几句话美和凄凉到骨子里了

[bibiworm]

这个，，，，少了点感觉，，，，

[faye351100]

就是這首了...金典

[diarytzy]

Fish Leong's voice is not strong enough to pull this one off. And she comes out feeling very flat. The original is much better.

[gescheitgyy87]

梁靜茹真是越來越棒了。同一場的為你我受冷風吹更是厲害。

因為非常喜歡陳淑樺的關係，首先聽到梁靜茹唱問和夢醒時分是有些­排斥的，覺得是眾多翻唱作品之一。但是後來越聽越認為，原唱陳淑­樺和林憶蓮都是太有特色的殿堂級歌手，翻唱她們已經需要莫大的勇­氣，還能現場表現的這麼好，梁靜茹真的很棒了！

[axl5432]

怎麼有辦法唱的比林憶蓮好!!!

我覺得梁靜茹好適合唱林憶蓮或陳淑華的作品

[marcochung]

喜歡林憶蓮

可梁靜茹真的毫不遜色

後段唱得激動, 超COOL...

鬼才李宗盛

[agnes1432]

我不喜欢梁静如，但是亦不得不承认她唱的实在很棒~~

[chonghengloong]

赞。。靜茹，加油加油加油

！！！

[ben065566]

@chonghengloong 吃雞雞阿

[binghsin]

梁靜茹是我很愛的女歌手 李宗盛是我很愛的詞曲創作人 也是很愛的男歌手

兩者一起 真的覺得相得益彰~~~ I was there in the 演唱會 現場的感覺超讚 幾度熱淚盈眶

[tidytang]

真好听，

[alexgjy]

唉 我只能说李宗盛你太懂了

[fionman6]

我諗靜茹本身都好鐘意或者好熟識呢首歌，感覺上呢個歌好似係佢自­己既歌咁唱，很好

[f30924]

靜茹唱得很棒 梁文音的版本感情還沒這麼濃厚 就只是唱歌而已 靜茹跟林憶蓮的感覺已經是一場表演了

[314329885]

太好聽了！

[skomy123]

1:14那個轉音太讚了!

[romain666137]

awesome

thx for sharing :)

[Junolynn]

靜茹果然厲害，有唱出跟林憶蓮不一樣的味道，比較了幾個版本，還­是梁靜茹唱的「誘惑的街」最令人印象深刻。

[will520430]

的確是..

[djngdhn]

really nice

[lattelovegapas]

静茹果然厉害！！

[josephinewu870303]

梁文音唱得最难听，轩仔那个也唔错

[highburycatherine]

梁静茹唱现场太稳了！歌词也都记得很好！very impressive^^

[luckysepgirl]

I am so impressed by this performance too, it is outstanding and totally different from Sandy's style, but in a good way. I love both of the versions and this sounds a lot stronger while Sandy's sounds a lot more hurt and sad. Well done!

[sholo35265]

Thanks your penetrating analysis!

[clio0930]

好听。。。

[king2gd]

好好聽....比起梁文音唱的好太多了....

[sholo35265]

好歌值得更多人來傳唱。

[jwangphp3]

cut her some slack please....she was only a competitor in a singing contest at that time. she has improved a lot since then!

[wensu7779]

梁靜茹唱的真好~~~

[myjianghu]

翻唱林忆莲的人多了。

但是唱的这么丝丝入扣的真的很少。

好好听。

[sholo35265]

这首歌将那种隐隐作痛的感觉表达地很淋漓尽致。

[shenbojung]

林憶蓮的歌...

一向是眾多歌手翻唱的首選...

我個人感覺梁靜如最能唱出其中的味道...

真的有唱出一些都會女子的心聲...

[sholo35265]

在充滿誘惑的時代，的確需要更多醒覺。

[2122988]

唱得好!!!

[idolyeung]

很好很好很好啊

我好驚訝.....

原本沒有興趣聽其他人唱的

可是我沒有選擇錯

梁靜茹唱得好好啊!!!!

[sholo35265]

希望林憶蓮的歌迷也會喜歡喔！

[flamecell]

這首歌靜茹唱的十分投入，很有感覺。

[sholo35265]

「誘惑的街」跟林憶蓮的另一首歌「愛上一個不回家的人」，可以說­是姊妹作呢！

[rock812012]

唔~~每次聽都是很動人~~靜茹的翻唱個人認為都很成功~有個人­風格

[palv]

Agreed! (sorry, I'm not very good at writing in Chinese). I think Jing Ru does a wonderful job with her beautiful renditions of all these classic songs as well (thanks to sholo35265 for sharing them!). The best tribute to classics is often to sing them with one's own interpretation and style, so it's both distinctive from, and at the same time pays homage to, the original. And I think Jing Ru accomplished this with great success. Looking forward to Jing Ru singing more classics in the future!

[sholo35265]

Your message reply is really too appropriate.

[sholo35265]

的確，尤其這首歌應該算是靜茹在李宗盛大哥演唱會上最賣力的演出­呢！

[mliu100]

林憶蓮!!!!

[sholo35265]

華語歌壇的典範。

[firel1jp]

好歌，好性感！！

[sholo35265]

靜茹這首歌用心唱出了自己的味道出來。

[ngoyashiro]

不知该怎么说，静茹唱歌总有她自己的味道，而且总是那么的好听。­。。一级棒。。。

[sholo35265]

翻唱经典歌曲不免与原唱拿来做比较，不过能唱出自己的味道毕竟是­一件相当不容易的事。

[raytw888]

靜茹帶點哭腔的聲線

雖然與Sandy 完美的詮釋不同

但似乎更貼近現實

很喜歡靜茹的版本^ ^

[sholo35265]

感謝您用心聆聽出原唱與翻唱兩種版本的差別唷！

[sholo35265]

對呀！還好有李宗盛大哥的演唱會，得以讓靜茹演唱這些經典好歌。­

[Littlefox630]

比较有难度的一首歌 所以后面整个高音区都没有唱上去 sandy的版本听到让人心痛 梁静茹的版本稍微嫩了点 总体来说还是蛮不错的

[sholo35265]

感谢您非常用心的对原唱与翻唱做了比较喔！

[yvette74731]

整個音樂的氛圍,佈景,服裝,靜茹的歌聲,真的非常棒!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!!

感覺是很用心的演唱會.

很可惜那天有事不能去,如果靜茹有要再辦演唱會,一定要去~

[sholo35265]

感覺得出來靜茹要翻唱這首歌的壓力應該不小，事前一定花了不少心­思準備呢！

[Cattytea]

This one sounds so similar to the 今天情人節 concert live version... even at the high pitch

[Cattytea]

Ignore my previous comment...I was not aware tha the CD featured the song from this concert :D

I love this song from the album, it's great to see the video finally!

[sholo35265]

This song has the special charm, and causes the listener to be fascinated deeply.

[absentgrace]

I think Sandy's version is better but I can see Fish can try her best to perform this song in a nice and emotional manner! A good attempt.......:)

[sholo35265]

The classics are may imitate by the human, but is actually unable to substitute.

[sholo35265]

療傷情歌總能觸發人們內心深處的共鳴。

[celestelys]

oh my god..it is perfect...

[sholo35265]

Really difficult to make one believe that this is the edition which the scene sings!

[malicekaiser]

oh my god.... 好好聽喔

[sholo35265]

真的是一首要投入很多感情進去，才能唱得好的歌呢！

[spadayhouston]

唱得很动情，但是说句实话，口齿不清。

[sholo35265]

Sorry, possibly is because MV has not added on the lyrics captions.

[sholo35265]

Very happy you also like this song.

[lupga]

amazing!! she sings it so beautifully :)

[sholo35265]

The scene sings can sing such well, really lets the human admire very much!

[sholo35265]

affascinato!

[lingtok]

I like Fish version!

[sholo35265]

Thanks your response, I thought that two kind of editions are very both good!

[sholo35265]

Others will usually compare turn singing and originally singing, but Fish should be must express the respect to the senior.

[beta10002]

addicted to it! =)

[sholo35265]

I also am fascinated deeply for this song!

[sholo35265]

A touching classical song!

[gobycat]

好聽~佢好岩唱e種歌......但原唱更有feel

[sholo35265]

的確，經典好歌真的是歷久彌新呢！

[marcogf0313]

超好聽~~

[sholo35265]

對呀！越聽越好聽~

[peaceguyz78]

Fish is the closest singer i found that is of Sandy's standard and prowess. However, when direct comparison is done esp on this rendition, can easily tell Sandy is far mroe superior is all aspects of emotions and range. good job nonetheless!

[sholo35265]

You said are really good! Fish turns sings the classical song is for salutes to the super idol!