Garbage - When I Grow Up (Live)

[FuckTheWoman]

I really enjoy Garbage but to be honest, their records are overproduced studio pieces so the songs, its really hard to play them live even for Garbage guys.

anyway, been listening garbage since the first record, and still love them

[Mitsouko01]

That is still so good! :)

[rudeboy215fno]

Reminds me of big daddy i was 7 , i miss adam sandler movies old school one though

[josephzz06]

48 justin gayber fans

[Idjitz]

I like this video even better than the studio version.

[namizmo]

So Who is going to be viewer # 400K? :-D

[Gleis68]

Voice better then live cool

[MaxPFC]

It's sad to see her TODAY, given that she was so fucking awesome. Remember sarah connor cronicals? Funny thing about the interwebs is that they preserve peoples age in a way. Because of this vid her hotness will last forever.

[silversplender]

@MaxPFC I think she is still hot today. She may be 45 now, but such an graceful ager. Oh yeah.

[Onespellpro]

46 people won't ever grow up

[1tomwest]

god can i die and just see her eyes

[morudi]

Who the Fcuk is Justin Bieber? who cares for that young punk who cant sing?

[Gleis68]

I love you

[MrJoaolayne]

Awesome

[adamnfoool]

wish garbage was more raw.. especially drums

[namizmo]

@adamnfoool

Yup, this version isn't exactly "live" I think only the vocals, still good though.  ;D

[punkdisorderly]

@namizmo I think she recorded the vocals on the soundcheck, cuz her mic wasn't on.... 0:40 if it was we could see a red light and could have some crowd and drums leakage.... :) but like you said, still good though.

[namizmo]

@punkdisorderly

You might be right! I try not to over analyze it. Makes me happy. :D

[EgorCentipede]

Damn - the perfect female + she's insanely talented and performs like a seasoned professional - absolutely charming! 'The stupid part' - Garbage wasn't detected on ye radar soon enough - 'crap', anyway - Garbage rocks despite tuning to them so freaking late, plus 100 incredibly painful lashes as punishment for not paying close enough attention.

[controlgovernor]

She owns the stage ,, so sexy .. Can't wait for the new album this year!!!!!

[UkliberateGB]

if this dont make you feel good

not even depressants will

[rooboy5575]

Love her work, and she can sing live.

[rooboy5575]

Love her work, and she can sing live.

[LUCASDNO]

46 Justin Bieber fans

[TillieFilth]

Give us back the 90s! Garbage rocks!

[Sweatification]

god i love this woman

[CHUCKLOVES1969]

nice vocals..dubbed over a studio recording of the band.

this is not a live performance...

but i still absolutely love the song.

[ItsASecretShutUp]

She is so amazing! I love her.

[ItsASecretShutUp]

She is so amazing! I love her.

[LOLOfandoly]

great song

[jetcityjimi]

There isn't enough tissue in the world. Just sayin'.

[itsGerbilsworld]

BaBaBaBa...

BaBaBaBA..

BaBaBaBa..BaBaBaBaa

BaBaBaBa...

BaBaBaBA..

BaBaBaBa..BaBaBaBaa

My favorite part..

[19pieman]

Hey justin bieber fans this is real talent.

[rockisbetter]

when i grow up ill turn the tables!!

[DURecords]

Just ONE backup vocal would have really made it sweet.

[clashcityjohnny]

brilliant live, but then again the band were all top musos and producers, shirley had a great voice even if it was heavily reverbed and drenched in echo

[q7winq7]

Hey Nutsack - Shirley's bod looks like what most women used to look like before asses like you thought up silicone and doughnuts. Actually she looks a lot like women that DO work out a lot. If you had ever been in a gym, you'd know this. Shirley ought to wright a song about you. Let me see....ok...got it: "Stupid Boy"

'...All your brains you wasted' , 'You suck on pop and pastry - you stupid boy!'

Sorry to be so harsh, maybe you're just having a brain fart or something.

[PALEGRE3N]

@q7winq7 LOL!

[fatz96]

@MrNutsack101 hey moron! shirley doesn't need any boobs! her face and talent make up for everything else lacking. i love garbage! are they still together?

[TheBieneGrrl]

That Shirley and the boys do as well as they do in a live setting tells you something about how good they *really* are.

[MrNutsack101]

Seen Garbage twice now...very good performers live...

Shirley has a hot face (with red hair) but her body is lacking big time.  Tiny boobs and out of shape bod...If she worked out and got implants it would help alot!!

[marimer33]

gran video lolo

[LOLOfandoly]

great song ! five stars !

[kellyg1971]

Shirley is HOT!!!!!!

[TR1PACE5]

top of the tops dont do live performances lol oasis are one of the few bands who told them to fuck off and they let them play live......anyhow, the song, shirley is so sexy and this song is without doubt garbage' finest moment

[CHUCKLOVES1969]

you are all a bunch of total morons for thinking this is a live recorded session,,,, it isnt,,it's a voice over the groups recorded music...to hear what a real live recording sounds like ,,,go listen to the same song on sherwinrobb 's channel...same song..

.and IT IS LIVE ... there's A BIG DIFFERENCE.

ur all young punks and dont know the tricks yet..you will learn,,,,once ur older.

[RepublicaRSGB]

Your an idiot its not the same,Need your ears checked if you this so.:::ty

[PALEGRE3N]

@CHUCKLOVES1969: I think it needs to be said already that you are a prick. All of your comments here prove it, and believe it or not - you don't need to be such a fucking ASS!! You can hardly type an intelligible line, so I don't think your in the position to be calling anyone a moron...and let me assume that I'm not the only one here who doesn't give a flying fuck how much of a musical genius you think you are.

[CHUCKLOVES1969]

@PALEGRE3N you said alot of nothing.

my prose may not be the best, but my eyes & ears work perfectly. fact is, you failed to address my main complaint. the use of the word "live" on this video is not true. it is produced for release, with action to match the audio, which was done at another time, another place, BUT her vocal seems to be live,,, over-dubbed on top. now... unless u can prove me wrong, i suggest..shutting-up?

[windchimex]

Shirley the Delicate Rose from Bonnie Scotland! ..she fabulous!

[PALEGRE3N]

Garbage are one of the best live bands ever.

[mmmmmmmmm95]

esto si es musica

[jacktheripped]

The 3 main guys is this band are some of the best studio musicians around and if you think they can't pull off this song live your very much mistaken.

And if they do tour in 2010 I'd like to play bass for them at Union scale ;)

[LOLOfandoly]

this song is one of the best songs of the 90's !!  fantastic song ! beautiful ! also because the female singer (shirley) was very very prety ! and her voice incredible !

[blitzaxis]

pero-WHAAAAATTTTT?????

[ChesterMolested]

yeah like lady gaga is any better..........douche!

[PureHateFor]

the instruments sound like playback, tha voice is for real! but dont give a fuck, its still an awesome song. praise the 90´s for a lot of good music...

[LOLOfandoly]

in the 90's the shows in programs music of tv,the sound was playback ever (also in the 80's). this is for me the best song from garbage !! miss eyes cat !! shirley beautiful manson !!

n_n

[LOLOfandoly]

shirley is very pretty !!

she have eyes of cat !! 

n_n

[LOLOfandoly]

is playback !!

the sound is very good.

[CHUCKLOVES1969]

this is NOT a live track...i wish it was.

her voice is, but not the band...no way.

[TaKeItLiKaMaN]

I can distinctly hear the bass. The bass is live,

[CHUCKLOVES1969]

listen u kids can listen to anything u want and like it...and believe in Santa Claus and the tooth fairey all u want. but when people who are in the business,,,in hollywood, like i am..and i tell u this is not live. i dont care anymore, i know the truth, i merely made a factual statement, if u don't like it fine. all producer's and groups love ignorance when they do these thing's..it makes their job a hell of a lot easier. and the sound is perfect when they use a studio track, have fun kids.

[blitzaxis]

thanx dad!!!

[CHUCKLOVES1969]

ur welcome,,,angel.

[blitzaxis]

err.. that was sarcastic comment?

[CHUCKLOVES1969]

sarcastic reply? no i actually simply said thank you to you for recognizing the truth.

but i do think urs may have been in the sarcastic vein. BUT,,,it's ok...i can take it as well as dish it out...so no worry. ( and the video u had of da 2 violins and the chuck drummer..is unreal. i have seen alot..but that drummer thrills me.)

[blitzaxis]

oh com'on!!! dont you have eyes??? ive had a band too you know and i know basic drums... wadaya think they have fake it? why dont you post a comment like this there and well see what the people has to say Mr. Know It All?

[CHUCKLOVES1969]

just cause u had/have a band..has no bearing on ur ability to know pre-recorded dubbed over tape for release. sorry.

and yes,,i have eyes.... have u ever seen a magic act?....isn't it just fabulous and great how that rabbit,, all of sudden appears in that empty hat.. i love it...don't u.

[blitzaxis]

ok.. that settles it... your a fag... i knew it all along!!! damn, why do i bother anyway?... shesh... ciao lover rabbit boy....

[iCBOK1969]

just to put u idiots to bed....my girlfriend is the bass player on the video of allison irahetta playing on GMA on dec.1 st.. she's playing the white fender bass..and believe it or not ...THAT IS A LIVE PERFORMANCE....but last time...this of garbage is not..she agrees...not because of anyhting tother than,,if ur a studio musican,,,they can easily tell the difference...99% of u common people...can't.

[Packy2B]

If she was any prettier I'd melt.(i'm melting)

[jossamis]

jaja cuando cresca quiero ser como ella!!!

es mi heroina!!!!

[luliKido]

muy buen abanda como muchas bandas lideradas pro nosotras , lo maxxxxxxxxxxx

[StephenTatumActing]

So much energy! This song is STILL bumpin'.

[SkaCha0s]

Shirley..I LOVE YOU

[supersoulrythim]

definitly go to my playlist for the day

[Adammartini]

they sound good live

[Packy2B]

i love her more than i love my next breath.lol

[cycleryder]

The club looks like DNA in San Fran. Yes if they tour in 10 you will see me there.

[krizanya]

i have her hair and earrings now.. but i still need her voice, attitude, skin color, beauty.. then i will be like her.. xD

[puacino]

Wow! Great video! I love this song!

[GeorgeCoreNukka]

A lot of bands sound shitty live. Definately not Garbage.

<3

[mattyboyx]

if they are on tour in 2010 im there!!

[acidcherrylemonade]

Stunning. As perfect as the recorded track. Shirley Manson, I love you!

[joseluisxr27]

Exelente cancion de esta gran banda que es una de mis favoritas y que presiosa se ve sherly Manson...

[Zhuniverse]

I used to listen this song with my girlfriend when I was a teenager... Them fuck... Great times...

>D

[dropxdeadxdinosaur]

Your girlfriend? Enjoy your hand, kid.

[Zhuniverse]

LoL, she used to like Garbage too, idiot.

[dropxdeadxdinosaur]

I didn't deny whether she liked them, I just doubt that you had a girlfriend if you have to talk about getting dirty with her on youtube. LOL

Either she broke up with you or she's imaginary.

[eyl38]

wow what video sherly is so pretty

[puacino]

I agree!

[HakiroJimmy]

Pfffffff...

huge huge huge

[telourdas]

her voice is nothing special.....

[rigso321]

neither is madonna or britney's they're still huge, its not all about being able to sing 10 ranges fool do you get rock n roll at all?

[marguitar1]

There's something very hot about this woman! Great musicianship and vocals here too.

[Nell440]

Shirley's vocals are fantastic, as always.

[Snoiz]

"Happy hours,golden showers..." ;)

[gashilariante]

Pá Pá PáPá, Pá Pá PáPá,

[NovakSA777]

Suuuuper. I love this song.

[losthighway89]

i loveee shirley

she kicks some serious ass!

Garbage rocked

[blitzaxis]

the crowd totally sucks!!! damn if i was there!~!!!

[losthighway89]

maybe the crowd's chanting has been muted

otherwise we wouldnt had been able to hear shirley's voice

[alllovecat]

NEVER EVER GROW UP:)

xx

[TheCarmenp43]

just as good live. gotta love shirley

[101RedandBlack]

worst band

[crowdsurfer77]

so why you´re watching, dick?

[fernandock2]

Best singer ever!

[jimboester83]

SHE ROCKS !!!

[kissmetick]

Doesn't shirley play on the terminator series now????

[Idjitz]

She did till it was canceled!

[moonwave99]

hottest girl ever, even if she's not a girl anymore.

[FoulOwl]

Just in case all you teeny-bobber,Miley Cyrus,Taylor Swift wanna be's don't get it....this is how it's really supposed to be fuckin done!!!!Take some notes.

[Zengx]

favorite of this band!

[PlasticFrog]

she's amazing

[neo4596]

did she use effects on her voice?

[andrea111292]

Beside the echo on the Papapapa... no I think there isn't any major effect on her voice

[aamylt]

she is really good

[Lightsydephil]

She's a terminator!

[cougar9991]

shirly manson is a hot scottish lass if yo u watch some interviws with her she looks so skanky.

[josh86mb]

she does great live

[zaxis01]

Shirley Manson looks so ridiculously hot in a skirt.

So talented and yet so deliciously sexy!.

[theSTAR70]

Goddess...

[subtle59]

lov this song !

[philtripe]

omg i only wish shirley was real shes to perfect to be real

[cazteland]

aww how can a person be so beautiful and be talented that makes her look unreal?

[laupadil]

I'm sorry but she really looks like she has fetal alcohol syndrome...maybe not severe but its there.

[andrea111292]

Carefull , you're totally encouraging people to get themselves a fetal alcohol syndrome...

[xfuckingdisasterx]

its the paleness. I'm super pale like her too and i admit sometimes im like i dont look real.

[jesuisemeraude]

pa pa pa paaa

[Najlepszy88best]

I love it!!! ;) it's so real :)

[cjsobo]

I like her as a terminator.

[Ryuuji91]

I only just found out she was the signer of Garbage xD to be honest I haven't listened to Garbage much but I remember hearing this song when I was a kid!

Lol I won't be able to watch her in terminator without picturing her like this now xD she's amazing now I found this out!

[bandiito16]

And in the episode before the last of terminator series 2 her daughter was teaching John Henry to sing because her mother (mis Weever) said she can't sing. Great one :)

Btw I already knew about her then

[fretlessbass26]

I wish they'd make the old Metroid game into a live action movie, and have shirley play her.

[theHoustonStrangler]

welcome to the world, young padiwon

[jesuisemeraude]

pa pa pa pa pa pa

[amjxray]

garbage is a GREAT live band...absolute musicianship at it's best. KICK ASS!!! Love them!!

[sentharia]

You can always tell if modern artists have any actual talent by watching their live performances. I'm glad to see Garbage actually does have talent.

[sinnermeister]

yah wht i always dream abt IS back to 90s alternavite rock back...:)

[bloodyhell1969]

Garbage is absolutely amazing live. Definitely one of my favorite bands. I have seen them live about 5 times and they never disappoint. They actually sound better in concert than on the albums.

[CapNoShura]

damnit¡¡¡ this is aclassic one .

[Panther593]

Very Great video!

Thanks a lot for sharing.

Shirley is still so beautiful and her voice...

Really too much excellent!

[venec]

fuck i miss 90s

[MeggyRippiUrHeartOut]

i like.

[luco1488]

Man they did this song very well playing it live

[tsadyan00]

damn! wish i was in here..

[tsadyan00]

loooove this song and them foreverrrrr!

[adris64]

ohh good ol' 90's.. now's such a shitty time for music :(

[teholdgreg]

Good ol 90's this music isn't that old. And Shit music? The Mars Volta is new and isn't shit. So be more specific. Like saying; Avenged Sevenfold is gay.

[adris64]

well yeah.. i meant for popular music :(

indie has some promises.. i right there with you about mars volta

[TithonusSyndrome]

When was this?

[mrfatboy559]

about 2 years ago

[andrea111292]

Hard to believe but this was in the old 1999...

[TithonusSyndrome]

That's what I thought, man, this isn't really the kind of music I listen to but did it ever hit home. Thanks for uploading!

[idontgive17]

ba ba ba ba ba ba ba ba~i loooove this song.

[SoulCruncherZ]

good emo song

[videojudge01]

WTF r u talking about??

[galactica04]

what a gimp.

[funkymusicluvr]

umm no. not emo. grunge. see, this is clever and talented, emo is lame and morbid. you don't get it.

[ZeroTides]

douche

[andrea111292]

This performance made my love for garbage

[samlikekitties]

I love this song I think they had the best songs on this album!

[vasvers]

favorite song too

[nooseindustry]

very nice song

[J2E2W2]

i like this song

[rissablnd21]

i wish all her songs were on rock band.......

ecpecially this one

[nadiacalat]

Shirley kicks ass in so many ways... Those songs will never age for sure, and what a pleasure to sing them, too!!

[MaryJamesMurdoch]

My god, no one can deny this album had some of the greatest hooks ever written! ;-)

[ZeroTides]

true

[Jennelyn0021]

why you comparing the song of pcd "when i grow up".. only the title is the same?duh..

[violet8383]

My favorite female singer

[CantBanMySkills56]

this song is off of big daddy

Shirley sounds great and looks gorgeous in this clip.