1:32 Yulias voice cracks . You can tell she is really hurting just to sing like this to her fans. Her voice was so beautiful. I wish my voice was like that.
Yulia is really hurting herself all through this and just for us, her fans. She loves us so much we don't even know it. And she's trying so hard. I love hearing her true voice before and after the cyst, it's so beautiful and pure.
for me yulia voice more intruiging and dude she's got this amazing voice...:) listen to hardly..lol hahaaha love yuliaaaaaaa her outfit rock always...:love it...so sexy :) so cute soooooooooooooo love love love tatu...lena so pretty darling of course.:)
I love this song and I find that Yulia's voice is amazing more particulary in this song but I I wish that Lena who is a good singer too sang a little bit more in english more in this song!!!!!
I really wish Yulia would have tried and practiced a way to sing that without hurting her voice. It's possible to hit the note that is in this song, I'm sure she tried a lot to do it in studio, but it sounds like it really hurts her hear. But she does scream her parts in here you can hear it under the playback, use headphones if you can't.
But I personally love Yulia´s "raspy" voice, she is so much better now. And this proves that she CAN sing and that she sang all those notes. It make me sad when she tried to sing and her voice collapse, it just didnt come out (a part in anatomy of tatu) She should´ve had a voice trainer since the start
Yulia has a cough if you look at the beginning and multiple other parts you see her cough, and you can hear her cough at 3:07, so maybe that's why she sounds a bit off in this rehearsal.
For all those saying that her voice in not gonna get us is enhanced, that is not true, she is however cleaned up, because if you listen to the russian version, she screams it as loud as she can and her voice actually breaks from yelling it so loud. It's right at the end of Degoniat and it does it repeatedly which means she did hit the note once, but even trying to sing that as many times as they did would damage your voice, especially in sessions to get it.
wow ...I can hear Yulia singing the chorus^-^ ...this makes me fell happy...but she can´t do it anymore , because she got a cyst...poor Yulia =[ ...I love her voice^-^...and I think that her LIVE performances are perfect^-^
A cyst is a deformaty that occurs, in this case on her vocal chords from screaming things for their first record incorrectly. She had to have surgery.
nunka es escuchado en vivo el coro ke griten not gonna get us por ke si hizieron esa kancion no kantan el koro en vivo me enkanta tatu pero kisiera escuchar el koro en vivo
it´s the same problem the german band tokio hotel had. But both rised like phoenixes from the ashes apart of all the problems they had. Besides t.A.T.u. is far better.
a part of the song is PlayBack. Yulia doesn't reach the high notes. Her voice was changed and arranged with effects and others. The voice of Lena also has some effects but not as much as that of Yulia.
@mariussober: There are NGGU vocals for download and you can hear how it sounded live when Volkova was recording her screams. Her voice in album version got amplified just a little bit to sound clearer, but it was already high and strong when performed live :)
no matter how great singer you are, it's impossible to sing this live, 'not gonna get us' screams just repeat over and over and then you have to go higher... it's a torture and no voice can take it, it must've been horrible for Yulia, no wonder her voice was destroyed
It's impossible to sing like Yulia in this song. They did something on the computer that made her voice that loud... But this video is actually the first one i've ever heard she sing live on the choures...
I don't think that it's impossible, she just can't sing like that any more because of the vocal cyst she developed in 2003 due to singing this way, so she doesn't sing the high parts in live performances any more
Yeah they cannot perform it live because it is rumoured singing so high is what caused Yulia's vocal cyst, so the "not gonna get us" part is always lip synced in concert, and sometimes the whole song is.
i've sung not gonna get us alot of times and it sounds like almost as perfect as yulia's not quiet there, but like, i just loosen my throat and sing it, if you tighten or are nervous or something, then your screwed, cuz it really hurts lol, nd yea, its way easier to sing it in russian than the english one
this isn't the hardest song to sing...Malchik Gay is...if you are going to sing it fully chest voice throught out the whole song! TRust me...it like starts off high and goes up and up and up....
hell yea, malchik gay took me like a week to sing, its really hard, not only are you screaming at the top of your lungs, but then you have to go higher, its like, holy shit lmao
They are doing the rehearsing with playback. Singing this song completely live is kinda impossible to the regular song. Like in 1:35 can you really make your voice go THAT high all the time? The song is hard, plus its digitaly enhanced. So its hard to sing definetly. They sing good live. All the things she said, and Not gonna get us. Are the only songs that are very hard.
1:32 Yulias voice cracks . You can tell she is really hurting just to sing like this to her fans. Her voice was so beautiful. I wish my voice was like that.
NomNomIEatChu 1 month ago
WOW
Latiao7 1 month ago
Yulia is really hurting herself all through this and just for us, her fans. She loves us so much we don't even know it. And she's trying so hard. I love hearing her true voice before and after the cyst, it's so beautiful and pure.
Itachiboii9898 7 months ago
love this song, can't sing along, though hahaha
queenfrostine97 10 months ago
i've always had a crush on roman (drummer)..and yes i thought he was naked at first too..hehehe .. <3 t.A.T.u. !
tatufevah 1 year ago 4
en estos tiempos se veia super bien yulia =D asi se deberia poner otra ves jeje
zombieoriordan 1 year ago
Yulia's hot, lena's sweet that's it
BUKKAKE05 1 year ago
Thumbs up if you thought the drummer was naked at first! xD
AxelRoxasluv 1 year ago 12
@AxelRoxasluv
It did look like he was naked at 1st. xD
darkestmercy1 8 months ago in playlist love,rememberance.
now this shit is fucking rare!!! Yulia Volkova singing live!!! wow now i can die happy, ive heard the imposible....luv t.A.T.u!!!
BonusRoll220 1 year ago 4
poor yulia you can hear her voice cracking at 1:35 when triyin to do the chorus... I liked how they used to sound but now they´re great to :)
roboba 1 year ago 2
Cool vid thanks for posting.
CyberStorm74 1 year ago 2
aw you can really hear Yulia :-) she was a VERY talented vocalist....its such a shame what happened to her voice.
AmourLyubov 1 year ago
lmao at lena's face expression when yuia starts singing @ 3:15
jaliscogirl07 1 year ago
for me yulia voice more intruiging and dude she's got this amazing voice...:) listen to hardly..lol hahaaha love yuliaaaaaaa her outfit rock always...:love it...so sexy :) so cute soooooooooooooo love love love tatu...lena so pretty darling of course.:)
yuliaeverluvz 1 year ago
lena is best singer and julia constantly loses her voice
jose8989ful 1 year ago
Yulia sang live °_°
There's the playback, but it's possible to hear her voice during the high notes <3!
ExcellenceOfInnova 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
ExcellenceOfInnova 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
2:44 ME ENCANTAN TUS TETAS! XDDDDDD!! (8)!
t.A.T.u <3
Leo9398 2 years ago
You folks take this crap way too seriously.
80maxshred 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
why are they lipsynching even in rehearsal?? lol
bayislove 2 years ago
they aren't the whole time....u can tell if u listen closely.
AhMunnaEechu 2 years ago
...that right there is the image of confidence in what you do!
AhMunnaEechu 2 years ago
I love this song and I find that Yulia's voice is amazing more particulary in this song but I I wish that Lena who is a good singer too sang a little bit more in english more in this song!!!!!
TheMrcheesecake 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
umm are you dumb? they sang the whole song in english
TheOfficialPopGod 2 years ago
thanks for sharing
prashanthaku 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
They both look like a constipated duck!!! lol
It's just sooo fake!
nonamelooolsrysrysry 2 years ago
I really wish Yulia would have tried and practiced a way to sing that without hurting her voice. It's possible to hit the note that is in this song, I'm sure she tried a lot to do it in studio, but it sounds like it really hurts her hear. But she does scream her parts in here you can hear it under the playback, use headphones if you can't.
LegendaryGerous 2 years ago 2
>:B I really wish someone would've acted sooner on Yulia's vocal cyst..
10 years later.. they still haven't got them xD
BokuNoMel 2 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
they already did
TheOfficialPopGod 2 years ago
i meant i wish they had done something about it earlier.
then the 10 years thing was about the band :\
BokuNoMel 2 years ago 4
@BokuNoMel yeah, same here :(
But I personally love Yulia´s "raspy" voice, she is so much better now. And this proves that she CAN sing and that she sang all those notes. It make me sad when she tried to sing and her voice collapse, it just didnt come out (a part in anatomy of tatu) She should´ve had a voice trainer since the start
But, love them 4e :) <3
NickJonasLover1605 1 year ago
Fazendo playback até eu canto bem rsrs... até a Sandy!
EricaNandha 2 years ago
Yulia has a cough if you look at the beginning and multiple other parts you see her cough, and you can hear her cough at 3:07, so maybe that's why she sounds a bit off in this rehearsal.
ThatBeatCalledLove 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Playback!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
EricaNandha 2 years ago
Yes they have the song playing, but you can hear their real voices clearly behind it, turn your speakers up or use headphones.
LegendaryGerous 2 years ago 3
yulia sounds like she has a cough in this video.
FullMoon272 2 years ago
cool video
vesiana 2 years ago
For all those saying that her voice in not gonna get us is enhanced, that is not true, she is however cleaned up, because if you listen to the russian version, she screams it as loud as she can and her voice actually breaks from yelling it so loud. It's right at the end of Degoniat and it does it repeatedly which means she did hit the note once, but even trying to sing that as many times as they did would damage your voice, especially in sessions to get it.
LegendaryGerous 2 years ago 3
YALL GUYS FUCKING ROCK!@!@!@!
CharmedAges 3 years ago
3:15 WTF! with lena's face??? It seems like she feel pain or something, her face is really strange... I like: " Yulia don't sing that part" xD
oktannuza 3 years ago
lol your right, it is a high pitch
LegendaryGerous 3 years ago
lmao she was "into it " lmao XD
S2RiCeGuRlS2 3 years ago
wow ...I can hear Yulia singing the chorus^-^ ...this makes me fell happy...but she can´t do it anymore , because she got a cyst...poor Yulia =[ ...I love her voice^-^...and I think that her LIVE performances are perfect^-^
AmoYuliaLena 3 years ago 34
I noticed that after the cyst it seems like she doesn't sing as loudly on the new albums. Whish sucks cause I really liked that.
LegendaryGerous 3 years ago 6
sorry,but I dont now what do you mean with "cyst"
aman11022 2 years ago
A cyst is a deformaty that occurs, in this case on her vocal chords from screaming things for their first record incorrectly. She had to have surgery.
LegendaryGerous 2 years ago 3
thanks man :)
aman11022 2 years ago
No prob
LegendaryGerous 2 years ago
what is a cyst?
FullMoon272 2 years ago
It was when a deformaty occurs, in Yulia's case it was on her vocal chordes. They had to remove it.
LegendaryGerous 2 years ago
oh thanx. don't alot of singers have the same problem? i think julie andrews had a cyst.
FullMoon272 2 years ago
Damn Lena is hot. She loves to dance around even in rehearsal
youtert 3 years ago 31
no escucho xD
orianaochoa 3 years ago 2
lol
it looks like the drummer is naked xD
g3cKo123 3 years ago 5
nunka es escuchado en vivo el coro ke griten not gonna get us por ke si hizieron esa kancion no kantan el koro en vivo me enkanta tatu pero kisiera escuchar el koro en vivo
schreirette 3 years ago 3
1:33 yulia se kedo sin voz !!!
xiki619andaluza 3 years ago
so this is how they do it
tomorrow182 3 years ago
tatu is the best!!! Sven Martin is a great keybord player
ppoddge 3 years ago 3
it´s the same problem the german band tokio hotel had. But both rised like phoenixes from the ashes apart of all the problems they had. Besides t.A.T.u. is far better.
franxpunx2 3 years ago 3
you're right, Yulia and Bill both were straining their voices at the age when it was about to change, they didn't wait and got a cyst
but Bill proved he could sing his high parts live before the cyst, while Yulia always mimed her high parts 'cause they're fake, studio product
dannii02 3 years ago 2
Have you a prove for that? I think she sang her parts herself.
franxpunx2 3 years ago 2
who is bill?
ppoddge 3 years ago
Bill Kaulitz, the lead singer of german band Tokio Hotel, they have both english and german songs
dannii02 3 years ago 2
but there is a big difference between Tatu and Tokio Hotel which is that TH sucks and Tatu fucking kicks ass!! Tatu 4ever!
MardyRaspberry 3 years ago 13
a part of the song is PlayBack. Yulia doesn't reach the high notes. Her voice was changed and arranged with effects and others. The voice of Lena also has some effects but not as much as that of Yulia.
jorgekevinkrayewski 3 years ago 3
@mariussober: There are NGGU vocals for download and you can hear how it sounded live when Volkova was recording her screams. Her voice in album version got amplified just a little bit to sound clearer, but it was already high and strong when performed live :)
Barcas666 3 years ago
I've heard the NGGU vocals you mentioned and it's just the extract from the song, vocals were already ''fixed''
you can hear how electronic it sounds and it's unnaturally pitch-perfect for such high notes
and that F#5 is pitched in the song, Yulia could't belt it out in this clip and even makes fun of it on 3:40 :)
dannii02 3 years ago
where can i download that?
wizard244 2 years ago 3
no matter how great singer you are, it's impossible to sing this live, 'not gonna get us' screams just repeat over and over and then you have to go higher... it's a torture and no voice can take it, it must've been horrible for Yulia, no wonder her voice was destroyed
dannii02 3 years ago 5
I feel really sorry for Yulia having to do all of that screaming on pretty much every single song, it's gotta be horrible.
IzzyRARG 3 years ago 5
1:34 no le llega la voz a yulia :S
hahah great :)
xiki619andaluza 3 years ago 2
and plus, if you watch the old vids of when they recorded songs, they used to have yulia screaming the words...
manicoujuice 3 years ago 3
It's impossible to sing like Yulia in this song. They did something on the computer that made her voice that loud... But this video is actually the first one i've ever heard she sing live on the choures...
mariussober 3 years ago
I don't think that it's impossible, she just can't sing like that any more because of the vocal cyst she developed in 2003 due to singing this way, so she doesn't sing the high parts in live performances any more
manicoujuice 3 years ago 4
Really really really really really good, I wish I could sing so good,!!
vesiana 3 years ago
wooooo coolll
xiki619andaluza 4 years ago
they are really good singers
Lauraap91 4 years ago 4
Yeah they cannot perform it live because it is rumoured singing so high is what caused Yulia's vocal cyst, so the "not gonna get us" part is always lip synced in concert, and sometimes the whole song is.
millylollies722 4 years ago 2
i love u julia volkova u r mine <33333333333
lovejulia69 4 years ago 5
i've sung not gonna get us alot of times and it sounds like almost as perfect as yulia's not quiet there, but like, i just loosen my throat and sing it, if you tighten or are nervous or something, then your screwed, cuz it really hurts lol, nd yea, its way easier to sing it in russian than the english one
babygirlkandy 4 years ago
this isn't the hardest song to sing...Malchik Gay is...if you are going to sing it fully chest voice throught out the whole song! TRust me...it like starts off high and goes up and up and up....
picvic7 4 years ago 3
hell yea, malchik gay took me like a week to sing, its really hard, not only are you screaming at the top of your lungs, but then you have to go higher, its like, holy shit lmao
babygirlkandy 4 years ago 3
beatiful song and girls !!! t.a.tu its great from ecuador! latin amercia youve a lot of fans!!!!!!!!!!! love uu
kikokokenvcdvfbf 4 years ago 3
wow ive tried singing not gonna get us and it aint pretty
its hard to yell that and have a perfect note
but who cares the songs good, theyre awsome, and they can sing :]
drshnty 4 years ago 3
im not the best singer but ive tried myself singing
its also easier to scream NAS NE DAGONIAT
then not gonna get us
findyourwayin 4 years ago 6
They are doing the rehearsing with playback. Singing this song completely live is kinda impossible to the regular song. Like in 1:35 can you really make your voice go THAT high all the time? The song is hard, plus its digitaly enhanced. So its hard to sing definetly. They sing good live. All the things she said, and Not gonna get us. Are the only songs that are very hard.
ralley22 4 years ago 4
you're totally right, this song can never be performed completely live
in recording studio, she had to scream ''Not gonna get us'' only once perfectly, and they used it throughout the whole song
''Prostye dvizheniya'' might be even harder to do live, it would probably sound horrible, that's why they never did it
dannii02 4 years ago 4
wow yuls is like really sweaty. and i love her voice
macmanners 4 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
are they really lesbians? xD
Minodor 4 years ago
I love this rehersal! Thank you for uploading :) ...And about Yulia's singing here, she has never been a good singer, or just fine...
Poorlittlegirl 4 years ago
you can see at 3:35 Yulia makes a slightnoise from lipsinging to the really high note.
Independentness 4 years ago 2
1:35, sorry.
Independentness 4 years ago 2
why does julia alsways have papers in her hand? She sounds fine.
taty4ever 4 years ago
if you had to be stuck on a island for 1 year with one of these chicks who would you pick?
badasscummins666 4 years ago 3
the red head
taty4ever 4 years ago 3
Yulia sings over the track :o You can actually hear how bad she sings and how she can't reach the high notes.
btng 4 years ago
hey hey hey that wasnt her fault. she developed a throat cyst or however u spell it n had surgery.
GuitarGirl4ever 4 years ago
Yes, but that cyst appeared on 2003-2004, and this rehearsal is from 2001 i think.
btng 4 years ago
well still. mabey she was just having a bad day. and plus they always sing live now n both of them rr great.
GuitarGirl4ever 4 years ago
Wow there awesome!
Supperoranges 4 years ago
thats weird..how sweaty and frizzy their hair looks like...wow! lol
cwells15 5 years ago
jaja, Yulia moves the papers in her left hand for everywere!!
I have to say that`s a horrible dance!! I don`t like it but yes tatu, of course, jeje(soyy 4 my english)
JuliaTatuya 5 years ago