It must've been such a hair-splitting decision making for Sir John Elliott, between Bonney and McNair. In the studio recording with McNair, I find her a bit on the cool and detached side, despite her warmer voice; she definitely wins on the trills, though! Bonney is more mellifluously ethereal. Her boy soprano-like appearance kinda helps, I suppose. LOL... Truly, both McNair and Bonney represent the absolute peak as long as this part goes. Perhaps, Arleen Auger could join their rank.
This, of course, is brilliantly beautiful. However, am I the only one who senses that all this wonderful warbling is a tad bit gratuitous? Mozart was many monumentally great things, but he was also a little too much of a "show-off" sometimes. A few too many notes. Mozart always gets his requisite "A". Beethoven, on the other hand, always gets the "A+"!
The great soprano Elizabeth Schwarzkopf instructed her student in one masterclass to sing this aria like the way a person is talking about a big secret. It's what Barbara doing here! Her rendtition is mysterious but enlightening , serious but tender , not to mention the sheer beauty and perfect breath control.
@carosaxone Thankyou for your kind response. Perhaps I am stupid but I can't find any "more information" tabs under any of the videos of this performance.series.
The soprano is surely Sophie Von Otter?
I also wonder why 'Gloria in Excelsis' seems to be lacking from the series.
I am grateful to you for posting this splendid performance of a truly inspired work in which I participated many times as a bass chorister.
It must've been such a hair-splitting decision making for Sir John Elliott, between Bonney and McNair. In the studio recording with McNair, I find her a bit on the cool and detached side, despite her warmer voice; she definitely wins on the trills, though! Bonney is more mellifluously ethereal. Her boy soprano-like appearance kinda helps, I suppose. LOL... Truly, both McNair and Bonney represent the absolute peak as long as this part goes. Perhaps, Arleen Auger could join their rank.
vitellia 3 weeks ago
barbara è semlicemente un angelo!!! grazie per questi splendidi momenti. viva la musica e il bel canto.
bruno81073 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Well now that's just lovely. Bravo.
literarycode2008 3 weeks ago
She sings even better than she plays golf.
PlatoJaspers 2 months ago
Εκπληκτική φωνή και υπέροχα τραγουδισμένο, χάδι στ' αυτιά μα και στην ψυχή. Νομίζω η καλύτερη εκτέλεση ever ! ! !
19822mark 2 months ago
Quelle magnifique interprétation, tout en finesse, fraicheur et sobriété. Quelle belle leçon de chant! Voyez les regards admiratifs des choristes!!
une voix qui sied à merveille à Mozart! Merci Mme Bonney
viruviru81 2 months ago 2
Barbara is a very good Bach singer, too.
artois54 2 months ago
This, of course, is brilliantly beautiful. However, am I the only one who senses that all this wonderful warbling is a tad bit gratuitous? Mozart was many monumentally great things, but he was also a little too much of a "show-off" sometimes. A few too many notes. Mozart always gets his requisite "A". Beethoven, on the other hand, always gets the "A+"!
ryanfan1967 2 months ago
@ryanfan1967 Yes.
magpie212 in reply to ryanfan1967 (Show the comment) 2 months ago
Man everywhere I go to find performances of 18th cen music lately John E. Gardiner keeps turning up. Where is Herreweghe? Suzuki?
Wolfgang1782 3 months ago
This is a masterclass in singing. There are other great performances but this is so very fine. The best!
ajhiflyer 4 months ago
touching!
mresper 5 months ago
thanks, it is one of my favorite moments in music, I listen to it whenever finding the balance..
sergeyost 5 months ago
NO ONE sing this Mass better than Barbara Bonney.
opricnik 6 months ago
That woman has the most beautiful, soft and sweet voice I've ever heard.
RideTheLightning316 7 months ago
@RideTheLightning316
"That woman" is Barbara Bonney, one of the greatest lyrical sopranos of all times in my opinion.
And I do agree with you, a most amazing voice. <3
zehnterapril in reply to RideTheLightning316 (Show the comment) 6 months ago
@zehnterapril And a voice at its best here, methinks. Never heard her sing more perfectly.
P1B1U1H1 in reply to zehnterapril (Show the comment) 4 months ago
The great soprano Elizabeth Schwarzkopf instructed her student in one masterclass to sing this aria like the way a person is talking about a big secret. It's what Barbara doing here! Her rendtition is mysterious but enlightening , serious but tender , not to mention the sheer beauty and perfect breath control.
mozarthaydn 11 months ago
@mozarthaydn
According to Barbara, not every voice is right for every aria and/or piece.
Barbara's, however, is definitely right for Mozart.
zehnterapril in reply to mozarthaydn (Show the comment) 6 months ago
maravilloso
PedroViaud 1 year ago
Che bello.
hymnal777 1 year ago
she is Barbara Bonney... Anne Sophie von Otter is the mezzo... both wonderful!! :-)
LadyAnnuska 1 year ago
This is sublime singing. I'm proud to be a human being! Yes--I am from the same species! : )
Jonakimoo 1 year ago
Please tell us who the conductor, choir and soloists are in this great performance.
I am filled with admiration for the choristers who perform the entire mass from memory (ie. without any music books to wave around and distract!)
hughwyles1 1 year ago
@hughwyles1 Everythings is written under "more information" right after the video frame
carosaxone in reply to hughwyles1 (Show the comment) 1 year ago
@carosaxone Thankyou for your kind response. Perhaps I am stupid but I can't find any "more information" tabs under any of the videos of this performance.series.
The soprano is surely Sophie Von Otter?
I also wonder why 'Gloria in Excelsis' seems to be lacking from the series.
I am grateful to you for posting this splendid performance of a truly inspired work in which I participated many times as a bass chorister.
hughwyles1 in reply to carosaxone (Show the comment) 1 year ago
@hughwyles1 more information on the video are to be seen if you click on the double arroe near the number of views of the video itself
prreterosso in reply to hughwyles1 (Show the comment) 1 year ago
@prreterosso Thankyou very much. Got it all now.
I hope Carosaxone will download "Gloria in Excelsis" to complete this series.
hughwyles1 in reply to prreterosso (Show the comment) 1 year ago
@hughwyles1 I am quite sure it is not Anne Sofie von Otter ! but sorry don't know at the moment who she is
berniewa2008 in reply to hughwyles1 (Show the comment) 1 year ago
@hughwyles1 Conductor: John Eliot Gardiner; Choir: Monteverdi Choir; Soloists: Soprano - Barabara Bonney, Alto: Anne Sofie von Otter - Tenor: Anthony Rolfe-Johnson - Bass: Alastair Miles; Orchestra: English Baroque Soloists.
adelaarmen in reply to hughwyles1 (Show the comment) 5 months ago
Comment removed
hughwyles1 1 year ago
Sublime.
yourforte 1 year ago
Thank you so much for posting Mozart's masterpiece. Beautiful performance and beautiful music. The number of viewers say all. - a music lover
ace165nj 1 year ago
Thank you so much!
lovehaendel1 2 years ago