This gets (even) better with each listen. This is an incredible re-mix, hats off Modesto. A stunning piece and an intelligent, well considered re-mix.
Its a nice listen but I can not take the lyrics serious with this version. The original takes you to another level. This version will only benefit those who can not grasp what the amazing Sylvian experience is all about. Well done anyway Modesto...
Snow Borne Sorrow as well? Interesting, while I agree that it's rather experimental, I found it to be accessible music. Especially when you compare it to Manafon and Blemish.
Sorry, i forgot about Snow Borne Sorrow and meant Blemish & Manafon (although i never really got into SBS either) the last album i adored was Dead Bees on a Cake. It's a shame as Sylvian is my all time musical hero.
thanks for your comments Koriza. I agree, it's far more accessable. My life is so busy at the moment I don't have time to play Sylvian's CDs enough to really give them time and get into them like I used to.
Interesting remix. I guess it makes the song more accessible :)
Nevertheless, I like the original version better :) There's a sense is quietness in there that I like.
I actually started really liking the Manafon album. I started out finding it strange and disappointing.. But I kept it on, because something in it got my attention somehow. I realized my expectations weren't met. I just got something different. Something very interesting. Strangely attractive, too.
This remix is stunning. I actually can't listen to the original now. Can you remix the entire Manafon CD please. This is my fave track of 2009, surpassing Pet Shop Boys Yes CD. Thought of any PSB remixes? Cheers
Bellísima versión Modesto, muy diferente a la original, es cierto, pero quién dijo que no está permitido volar con alas propias? Felicidades y gracias por compartirla.
we have written to each other a few times already.... it's a privelege to enjoy your work, once again a fantastic, very different view of Sylvian's song, well done ! Keep up the wonderful work Fr. :O) S.
That's a great work, indeed, but I like more the original version , because David wanted to achieve ( and he did it ) a new form of song, a new way of expression, without distractions...his voice is the main and principal thing...don't even try to touch the perfection of a 'naked' song...less is more...I'm ordering the Deluxe Edition of Manafon...I can't wait! Thanks David!
Modesto, this is an utterly breathtaking re-working of the 1st track from Manafon. It has only been 10 - days since the "teaser" release.... and without any hesitation this is the most engrossing, complete and utterly compelling remix you have come up with so far..... But, where you reworked songs from 25+ yrs ago in the past, I feel a bit shocked listening (and replaying) this remix on a number that is not yet officially released....
I believe the world could live with the whole of Manafon being remixed by Modesto Muniz and released by it's fathers side, judging by this version. Love it.
This gets (even) better with each listen. This is an incredible re-mix, hats off Modesto. A stunning piece and an intelligent, well considered re-mix.
stateforce 4 months ago in playlist stateforce's Favourited Videos
Stunning!!!!
aaronbok 6 months ago
Wonderful
merci
UandMisterG 6 months ago
Fantastic as always Modes!!!
You have filled the atmosphere that most of us missed in Sylvian´s original.
Deja los huevos y dedícate a esto!!.
majortom142 1 year ago
...... it`s a sylvian work ............
marcymarcish 1 year ago
@marcymarcish ...... We now .............
supercavalierotto64 1 year ago
Beautiful beyond words to describe it...i just play Modesto's tune over and over.....
A thousand thanx for the music and the videos Modesto.
lotreamon01 1 year ago 2
Its a nice listen but I can not take the lyrics serious with this version. The original takes you to another level. This version will only benefit those who can not grasp what the amazing Sylvian experience is all about. Well done anyway Modesto...
skof2002 2 years ago 3
Wonderful music. Reminds me of a fantastic film "Planet Pizza tell me", I recommend.
Thanks for the inspiration.
MrLongvictor 2 years ago
I love this remix much more than the original. Sadly, this has been the case over the last 2 Sylvian albums.
sylvian66 2 years ago 2
Snow Borne Sorrow as well? Interesting, while I agree that it's rather experimental, I found it to be accessible music. Especially when you compare it to Manafon and Blemish.
Demoras 2 years ago
Sorry, i forgot about Snow Borne Sorrow and meant Blemish & Manafon (although i never really got into SBS either) the last album i adored was Dead Bees on a Cake. It's a shame as Sylvian is my all time musical hero.
sylvian66 2 years ago
that's because this version is much more easier to comprehend
koriza101010 2 years ago
and this is not an offence neither to you nor to this version in any way
koriza101010 2 years ago
thanks for your comments Koriza. I agree, it's far more accessable. My life is so busy at the moment I don't have time to play Sylvian's CDs enough to really give them time and get into them like I used to.
sylvian66 2 years ago
@sylvian66 I agree ,what you said about DS.But this remix ruins the song completely,it sounds very boring,with all the ''fruity loops'' bits.
zenobowie 5 months ago
Interesting remix. I guess it makes the song more accessible :)
Nevertheless, I like the original version better :) There's a sense is quietness in there that I like.
I actually started really liking the Manafon album. I started out finding it strange and disappointing.. But I kept it on, because something in it got my attention somehow. I realized my expectations weren't met. I just got something different. Something very interesting. Strangely attractive, too.
Demoras 2 years ago
remix the whole album modesto,you got the feeling,this is awesome.i'm a fan.
k732092 2 years ago 2
This remix is stunning. I actually can't listen to the original now. Can you remix the entire Manafon CD please. This is my fave track of 2009, surpassing Pet Shop Boys Yes CD. Thought of any PSB remixes? Cheers
MrConnco 2 years ago
Bellísima versión Modesto, muy diferente a la original, es cierto, pero quién dijo que no está permitido volar con alas propias? Felicidades y gracias por compartirla.
qmono 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
with the greatest respect, yes the video is cute...but what the hell has it got to do with the song?!
klausdantes 2 years ago
Hi Modesto! very well done my friend!! I really enjoy your remix, as usual, great work.
docmontecristo 2 years ago
we have written to each other a few times already.... it's a privelege to enjoy your work, once again a fantastic, very different view of Sylvian's song, well done ! Keep up the wonderful work Fr. :O) S.
THIRV 2 years ago
Wicked remix!! should be released as the first single!!
Dobro123 2 years ago
Comment removed
Dobro123 2 years ago
Comment removed
Dobro123 2 years ago
That's a great work, indeed, but I like more the original version , because David wanted to achieve ( and he did it ) a new form of song, a new way of expression, without distractions...his voice is the main and principal thing...don't even try to touch the perfection of a 'naked' song...less is more...I'm ordering the Deluxe Edition of Manafon...I can't wait! Thanks David!
analoguesynths 2 years ago
a great re-interpretation Modesto! you gave to smg the atmosphere of time passing
BRAVO!
cri
bulucette 2 years ago 7
Modesto, this is an utterly breathtaking re-working of the 1st track from Manafon. It has only been 10 - days since the "teaser" release.... and without any hesitation this is the most engrossing, complete and utterly compelling remix you have come up with so far..... But, where you reworked songs from 25+ yrs ago in the past, I feel a bit shocked listening (and replaying) this remix on a number that is not yet officially released....
Power of the Web, I guess.
Bravo.
lubinallan 2 years ago
i like it better than the original :) - you should contact David .... who knows :)
roby30 2 years ago 3
Nice job, Modesto. To be honest though, I prefer the original, as it was intended to be....
The sparseness of the composition brings forth the power of the vocal.
darkgrace 2 years ago
very nice!
strange how the vocal shifts from spoken words to sweetly sung when you compare this version to the original one. most obvious from 3:58 onwards.
huehnerklein 2 years ago
wonderful remix! Gives it a real warm beauty
Leepy100 2 years ago
A masterpiece!
gerrithillebrand 2 years ago
I love this remix! Thank you!
x3dgime 2 years ago 6
would love to hear a version w/o the clapping sounds
slowfire71 2 years ago
I believe the world could live with the whole of Manafon being remixed by Modesto Muniz and released by it's fathers side, judging by this version. Love it.
Whiterthanwhitey 2 years ago
Wow! I actually prefer your mix to David's!
suki9533 2 years ago 4
Very, very nice treatment, Modesto.
The4712mizzou 2 years ago
Oh this is really just beautiful the way you've remixed this...I can't figure out which version I like better.
indiareed 2 years ago 2