When he says "broken my own word", my ear always hears it as an audio glitch, in both this, and the reg. vers. I always have the urge to go to the cd player and examine the cd for scratches.
There's a Michael Angelo Batio song that has a touch of Jimmy Page and a touch of Nick Kershaw. Doesn't swipe directly and is actually original, but at a quick listen it sounds similar in parts.(but someone else thinks it sounds like Classical Gas which it sounds nothing like)
but u wanna hear highway robbery? listen to the stones. constantly stealing from one dead guy or another.
@NolitaDenise You mention Page...LZ were the real robbers. The Stones always give credit to the blues masters they love. And Idol rocks :) He got the idea for "Rebel Yell" while partying with the Stones! Mick, Keith, and Ronnie were taking swigs from a 'Rebel Yell' bottle of bourbon whiskey.
It's a tough call, but thinking Mitch's is stripped down with a Mellencamp touch(big time, of course Mellencamp produced it, but still might as well be a Johnny Cougar track)
Problem is, outside of sampling, there's a whole bunch of stuff that's fair game. Chord progressions, scales...it's not what you use but how you use it, and this is a different song from Prince's and Mitch Ryder's.
I think it's just a couple of strokes(I'm pretty sure up strokes) on the guitar where they sound kind of alike, but they're not the same chords. Listened closely(this time on Prince's original) and they sound like minor chords on his.(and lower) On this one they sound like major chords(and higher) + it gets weirder cuz everything else makes this song sound sad but Prince's sounds happy.(tho the lyrics are sad, but words & not music)
Mitch Rider didn't copy it verbatim. However he did build on the bass and guitar big time and you don't need perfect pitch to hear it.
I like the demo of Catch My Fall better than the originally released version.(maybe something's wrong with me) This is timeless. When You Were Mine is classic but soooo dated. I think it's all the keyboards. Really meh if you're listening for anything besides the guitar, bass, and Prince's voice...so yeah Billy & Steve owe Mitch an ass kicking.
@fhdsik what song do you think this was taken from originally by prince,i dont think it sounded like any of princes hits maybe one of princes album songs i never heard please reply and please log on to equip.org
@fhdsik i listened to about 2 minutes of princes when you were mine and it didnt sound to me like catch my fall by billy idol but nirvanascome as you are does sound like it was ripped off from killing joke song eighties and i read nirvanas drummer now foo fighter played drums for free to pay killing joke b
@fhdsik i listened to about 2 minutes of princes when you were mine and it didnt sound to me like catch my fall by billy idol but nirvanascome as you are does sound like it was ripped off from killing joke song eighties and i read nirvanas drummer now foo fighter played drums for free to pay killing joke because he said kurt cobain told him he wrote it himself
@soulkiss1001 - it's below the surface. ignore the synth on Prince's song. ignore the vocals and melody. When You Were Mine definitely sounds like it was built on Catch My Fall.
It's like how Vanilla Ice built that song on the bass line and a bit of keyboard of Under Pressure by Queen and Bowie. It's not exactly the same at all, but it's blatant thievery nonetheless. it's okay to build on someone else's song if u have permission and pay royalties. otherwise it's just plain stealing.
@soulkiss1001 - i take it back. listened to mitch rider's version(sometimes prince collaborated & thought they were referring to a collaboration) - it's stripped down and rocked up. Prince wrote and performed the song first but...
two different songs. When You Were Mine sounds a lot like this when it's got all those layers of sound on top. Once they're stripped...two different songs...but if anybody's stealing they're stealing from Prince.
@yourfartter correction....ALL ARTISTS TODAY REQUIRE tuning and glitches to there voice... Billy is pure and raw talent..it doesnt get any better! and it never will!
Thanks for posting this. I came across this looking for the bass line but this adds a whole other layer of awesomeness. I have always been a Billy Idol fan, I can even remember the times I spent listening to this song growing up.
Billy's voice is actually better today than it ever was!! And he doesn't do a damn thing to take care of it (so I heard from a bandmate).....LOVE THIS! Thanks for posting.
One of the few era artists demos,that could of been successfully released as is. A perfect toned,great voice matched with old school rock & roll. Add image,great mixing = # 1 Hit. RV.
this pared down version rocks out!!!!! Idol played the image for all its worth...knowingly sneering....and had the music to punch it out into your face....one and only Billy Idol will always burn me.
saw billy at riverrock casino july 08 blew me away girlfriend surprised me with tix took me back realized what a good act billy is and steve is as much billy as he is
The other version is overproduced, but this version seems like it's definitely missing something. I actually liked it with the saxophone, for some reason
Mitch Rider literally "copycat" it and named it "When you were mine". Billy Idol is just a music genius. Listen to the 2005 CD, "Devil´s playground", it is just majestic. No one, and no band like Billy and Steve Stevens. It is sad that these guys need to keep playing and writing because new bands are useless pricks.
Billy Idol's "Catch My Fall" was released the same year (1983) as Mitch Ryder's "When You Were Mine" so it's hard to say who was the copycat.
Ironically, Mitch Ryder's "When You Were Mine" (1983) is itself a remake/copycat of Prince's song "When You Were Mine" (1980) released three years earlier.
@fandepucca When You Were Mine was written by Prince, and released by him in 1980, well before Catch My Fall appeared on Rebel Yell and Mitch Ryder's version of When You Were Mine was released in 1983. I enjoy both.
Mitch Rider literalmente copió la estructura de esta canción y le puso "When you were mine". Billy Idol es simplemente un genio. Escuchen su nuevo CD Devil´s playground. No van a escuchar nada tan bueno, menos en los grupitos nuevos sin talento. De lo bueno, poco. De México, sólo Fobia.
cad vez me sorprendo yo naci en 1978 haci que creci escuchando parchis,chabelo,cepillin y al escuchar musica ochentera como que vuelvo a renacer en la mejor epoca del mundo me la perdi porque amis jefes les gustan ranchera y norteñas forever `80 s i love.
Billy Idol & Steve Stevens are fucking awesome
MargueriteAMB 3 days ago
This the real shit here. steve stevens playing is awsome on this and billy is a true star.
kncklesandwich 5 days ago
This really is steve stevens enjoying playing . Hell of a guitar player
kncklesandwich 6 days ago
amazing!!!!!
skorpion990 1 month ago
SIMPLY F A N T A S T I C
marcioemailcom 2 months ago
JUST.......TOO COOL.THIS IS THE BEST VERSION OF(CATCH MY FALL) I'VE EVER HEARD.
desamator11 2 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Happy birthday Billy. You are not growing older, just sexier. Long live Billy Idol!!!!!!!!!
sendrix123 3 months ago
Fuckyeah, Billy Idol!!!!
lere8 3 months ago
fucking amazing!!
whitiedave 3 months ago 2
Those seven who disliked this would rather hear and see American Idol instead of the great Billy Idol. LOSERS!!!!
braindead69x 4 months ago 2
7 dead people
marafane87 4 months ago 2
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa.........XD...great.....!!!
Patricia6177 5 months ago
<3
sheelalia 6 months ago in playlist billy idol
When he says "broken my own word", my ear always hears it as an audio glitch, in both this, and the reg. vers. I always have the urge to go to the cd player and examine the cd for scratches.
mowgli2071 6 months ago
@necrofury - THANK YOU!!!!!!!!! Billy is very amazing! I saw him in concert many years ago and that man ROCKED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
TheScarlettdragonfly 7 months ago
There's a Michael Angelo Batio song that has a touch of Jimmy Page and a touch of Nick Kershaw. Doesn't swipe directly and is actually original, but at a quick listen it sounds similar in parts.(but someone else thinks it sounds like Classical Gas which it sounds nothing like)
but u wanna hear highway robbery? listen to the stones. constantly stealing from one dead guy or another.
NolitaDenise 8 months ago
@NolitaDenise You mention Page...LZ were the real robbers. The Stones always give credit to the blues masters they love. And Idol rocks :) He got the idea for "Rebel Yell" while partying with the Stones! Mick, Keith, and Ronnie were taking swigs from a 'Rebel Yell' bottle of bourbon whiskey.
Mr2009Truth 5 months ago
It's a tough call, but thinking Mitch's is stripped down with a Mellencamp touch(big time, of course Mellencamp produced it, but still might as well be a Johnny Cougar track)
Problem is, outside of sampling, there's a whole bunch of stuff that's fair game. Chord progressions, scales...it's not what you use but how you use it, and this is a different song from Prince's and Mitch Ryder's.
This stuff happens so much...
NolitaDenise 8 months ago
Sorry still working through comparisons...
I think it's just a couple of strokes(I'm pretty sure up strokes) on the guitar where they sound kind of alike, but they're not the same chords. Listened closely(this time on Prince's original) and they sound like minor chords on his.(and lower) On this one they sound like major chords(and higher) + it gets weirder cuz everything else makes this song sound sad but Prince's sounds happy.(tho the lyrics are sad, but words & not music)
NolitaDenise 8 months ago
Take it back. No ass kicking required. Two different songs...
Vaguely similar under layers but once stripped, totally different.
NolitaDenise 8 months ago
Mitch Rider didn't copy it verbatim. However he did build on the bass and guitar big time and you don't need perfect pitch to hear it.
I like the demo of Catch My Fall better than the originally released version.(maybe something's wrong with me) This is timeless. When You Were Mine is classic but soooo dated. I think it's all the keyboards. Really meh if you're listening for anything besides the guitar, bass, and Prince's voice...so yeah Billy & Steve owe Mitch an ass kicking.
NolitaDenise 8 months ago
Pay the royalties you bastard, half of this song was written by PRINCE!!!
fhdsik 9 months ago
@fhdsik what song do you think this was taken from originally by prince,i dont think it sounded like any of princes hits maybe one of princes album songs i never heard please reply and please log on to equip.org
soulkiss1001 9 months ago
@soulkiss1001 check "when you were mine" by Prince
fhdsik 9 months ago
@fhdsik i listened to about 2 minutes of princes when you were mine and it didnt sound to me like catch my fall by billy idol but nirvanascome as you are does sound like it was ripped off from killing joke song eighties and i read nirvanas drummer now foo fighter played drums for free to pay killing joke b
soulkiss1001 9 months ago
@fhdsik i listened to about 2 minutes of princes when you were mine and it didnt sound to me like catch my fall by billy idol but nirvanascome as you are does sound like it was ripped off from killing joke song eighties and i read nirvanas drummer now foo fighter played drums for free to pay killing joke because he said kurt cobain told him he wrote it himself
soulkiss1001 9 months ago
@soulkiss1001 - it's below the surface. ignore the synth on Prince's song. ignore the vocals and melody. When You Were Mine definitely sounds like it was built on Catch My Fall.
It's like how Vanilla Ice built that song on the bass line and a bit of keyboard of Under Pressure by Queen and Bowie. It's not exactly the same at all, but it's blatant thievery nonetheless. it's okay to build on someone else's song if u have permission and pay royalties. otherwise it's just plain stealing.
NolitaDenise 8 months ago
@soulkiss1001 - i take it back. listened to mitch rider's version(sometimes prince collaborated & thought they were referring to a collaboration) - it's stripped down and rocked up. Prince wrote and performed the song first but...
two different songs. When You Were Mine sounds a lot like this when it's got all those layers of sound on top. Once they're stripped...two different songs...but if anybody's stealing they're stealing from Prince.
NolitaDenise 8 months ago
m7sto
azram67 10 months ago
This is a nice version of one of my favourite Idol songs. I didn't even know this version existed. Thanks for posting!
KingHaggis 11 months ago
I'm dying, wow.
nanogirl 1 year ago 2
LOVE THIS VERSION.
desamator11 1 year ago
uuhhh sexyyy!!!! Billy♥
JAmoguSve 1 year ago 2
göttlich!!!
PuZeAu 1 year ago
Talent, PURE TALENT
yourfartter 1 year ago 3
All the REALLY GOOD artist don't require all the gimicks like some of the musical artists today!
yourfartter 1 year ago
@yourfartter correction....ALL ARTISTS TODAY REQUIRE tuning and glitches to there voice... Billy is pure and raw talent..it doesnt get any better! and it never will!
AlexisLee13 1 year ago
One of my favorite Billy Idol songs....and this version is even better I think than the one initially released....except for the slow part...
yumimer 1 year ago
Thanks for posting this. I came across this looking for the bass line but this adds a whole other layer of awesomeness. I have always been a Billy Idol fan, I can even remember the times I spent listening to this song growing up.
dreprince 1 year ago
Thanks for sharing this. I've been an Idol fan for 26 years. Never heard this demo. Very cool.
ldzppln2 1 year ago
hes still hot :)
winirfred222222 1 year ago
this the best music and the world
klootzak123ful 1 year ago
this version i the best! (according to me)
emwjmannen2 1 year ago
buy the remastered cd of rebel yell, its on that with a couple of other little gems as a bonus.
mrniblet 1 year ago
MMM, nop HufflePuffDaddy, Rebel Yell, 1983, not 1985. And in any case, this version is much more solid.
fandepucca 1 year ago
the best since the 80's
fjz0112 1 year ago
MUITO BOM... DOUGLAS KONOPA ... braSil... são paulo * sp
konopa67 1 year ago
love this version!
emwjmannen2 1 year ago
Billy's voice is actually better today than it ever was!! And he doesn't do a damn thing to take care of it (so I heard from a bandmate).....LOVE THIS! Thanks for posting.
staceyswo 1 year ago
never heard this version of catch my fall (till now) like it.
fragz666 1 year ago
KERI GAY JE TA BILLLY EJ !!!!
r173y 1 year ago
One of the few era artists demos,that could of been successfully released as is. A perfect toned,great voice matched with old school rock & roll. Add image,great mixing = # 1 Hit. RV.
rovinvideo 1 year ago
This song still does its job after all this time.
unmedication 2 years ago 2
mmmm he was sooo sexyy :) love him i really do x
JazmineKateee 2 years ago 4
how i love this guy
snowwhitekiller 2 years ago 6
I have loved Biily for almost 28 years and I will always love him
ninarudy2007 2 years ago 16
@ninarudy2007 Nothing is more true!!!
F3D375 1 year ago
this pared down version rocks out!!!!! Idol played the image for all its worth...knowingly sneering....and had the music to punch it out into your face....one and only Billy Idol will always burn me.
exzealient 2 years ago 4
Don't you mean Billy F....ing Idol?
I got another jar of jam for your mutter...
dasframedagain 2 years ago
Don't you mean Billy f...ing Idol? ( :
dasframedagain 2 years ago
super-also enjoy: maja gille-catch my fall
bergketten 2 years ago
einfach nur geil...............
scader11 2 years ago
You know this what GenX would have sounded like if they continued into the mid 80's
Wehategod 2 years ago
I love the song..I love Billy Idol..sweet,sexy and funny..incredible combination..Incredible singer..
Bea290375 2 years ago 4
this is one of his great songs he did.
Mysterymusicgirl 2 years ago 2
THANK YOU! This is amazing!!!!!
Whoozinga 2 years ago 2
i would stumble on Billy still. my total fave from the 80s...
valerie1969 2 years ago 5
ohyeah billy idoool!!!!
emwjmannen2 2 years ago 3
saw billy at riverrock casino july 08 blew me away girlfriend surprised me with tix took me back realized what a good act billy is and steve is as much billy as he is
best concert i seen
TheJimmyidol 2 years ago 5
good version :)
NeighbourElaK 2 years ago 5
the best of punk music! BIG IDOL!!!
brotherloui1999 2 years ago 6
Thanks for posting this! awesome.
1600music 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
billy idol is the greatest
54spiritedwill54 2 years ago 4
Much better.
octodor 2 years ago
Comment removed
mar1amb2 2 years ago 3
This is a great version of one of my favorite songs of his. I loved this in the 80's
Justme1543 2 years ago 6
luv it now!!!
mar1amb2 2 years ago 3
billy idol fue el verdadero creador de luis miguel
bambam0986 2 years ago
great! super billy
vandamme84 3 years ago 2
The other version is overproduced, but this version seems like it's definitely missing something. I actually liked it with the saxophone, for some reason
roothands 3 years ago
hey I love this song,billy idol rules!
Maureennopubes1 3 years ago 4
Oh, my... it's a gorgeous, breathtaking version. He's so much more of a prolific artist that he gets credit for.
Mmmm... I love Billy.
spiralheartmoongirl 3 years ago 5
Alot of people only see a rockstar image. They don`t open their ears or their mind when it comes to Billy Idol. He`s a true talent.
kevhar12 2 years ago 26
Love the sound of the guitar on this version!
oingofan 3 years ago 2
The restraint overall makes this a much better version. You wouldn't even think it's an old song. Thanks for uploading! Never knew this existed.
arroyus1007 3 years ago 2
Esta muy bien esta version.
alex944 3 years ago
estoy de acuerdo ;)
canybasa 3 years ago
Che figata! Billy Rocks on every age!!!!
6louiscyphre6 3 years ago
amazing! is that steve stevens on guitar?
punkrockefeller 3 years ago
This version is pretty cool!
Roadrunner440 3 years ago
Awesome!!!!!!!!!!
I love this version , very nice.
Whoozinga 3 years ago
Que lindo!
djnahoo 3 years ago
OMG!5*
cslolcs 3 years ago
good song :) beautiful
Saldainiukas77 3 years ago
Sympa cette version :)
Fabrice69000 3 years ago
So strange to hear it without the sax.
talkingpie99 3 years ago 2
diese version is einfach unglaublich...
ich liebe diesen kerl!!!
$-ever BILLY IDOL!!<33
Rammi696 3 years ago
Mitch Rider literally "copycat" it and named it "When you were mine". Billy Idol is just a music genius. Listen to the 2005 CD, "Devil´s playground", it is just majestic. No one, and no band like Billy and Steve Stevens. It is sad that these guys need to keep playing and writing because new bands are useless pricks.
fandepucca 3 years ago 9
TRUE.. IDOL AND STEVENS ARE .. CLASS !!!so were idol and JAMES MIND YOU
ASSASSIN07731 3 years ago
Comment removed
HufflepuffDaddy 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@fandepucca
Billy Idol's "Catch My Fall" was released the same year (1983) as Mitch Ryder's "When You Were Mine" so it's hard to say who was the copycat.
Ironically, Mitch Ryder's "When You Were Mine" (1983) is itself a remake/copycat of Prince's song "When You Were Mine" (1980) released three years earlier.
HufflepuffDaddy 1 year ago
@fandepucca Mitch Ryder's song was a cover of Prince's "When You Were Mine", which was actually written and released in 1980.
jblaede 1 year ago
@fandepucca When You Were Mine was written by Prince, and released by him in 1980, well before Catch My Fall appeared on Rebel Yell and Mitch Ryder's version of When You Were Mine was released in 1983. I enjoy both.
ktpinnacle 1 year ago
@fandepucca agree
emwjmannen2 1 year ago
Mitch Rider literalmente copió la estructura de esta canción y le puso "When you were mine". Billy Idol es simplemente un genio. Escuchen su nuevo CD Devil´s playground. No van a escuchar nada tan bueno, menos en los grupitos nuevos sin talento. De lo bueno, poco. De México, sólo Fobia.
fandepucca 3 years ago
thanks
hianda 3 years ago
cad vez me sorprendo yo naci en 1978 haci que creci escuchando parchis,chabelo,cepillin y al escuchar musica ochentera como que vuelvo a renacer en la mejor epoca del mundo me la perdi porque amis jefes les gustan ranchera y norteñas forever `80 s i love.
guadalajara1978 3 years ago 2
It's cool that at the end of the song you can hear where the song is heading.
qthinker 3 years ago
This version it's a killer!! I used to have the rebel yell cd, no longer have it, but, Did actually Billy played Bass on this song?
santiago2u 3 years ago
you have no ideal how much I love this song. he is fucken cool.
jmwhite33 3 years ago
BILLY IDOL = MAXIMUM....
GOINGGONING01 4 years ago 4
Wow! This version is awesome! I like that more than the second!
demonica18 4 years ago 2
Go Go Bill Broad!
chrysslyn 4 years ago
I don't know where you found it but Thank You.
Idol is my Elvis
Stormy3467 4 years ago 2
WOW...how in the HELL did you come across THIS??? Love it. GOOD JOB! Thanks for sharing.
Skoben2000 4 years ago 10
lol im glad you liked it xD
necrofury 4 years ago
@Skoben2000 it's on Billy's album "Rebel Yell"
emwjmannen2 1 year ago
billy idol is the greatest
Pellepluttskrutt 4 years ago 7
so true :D
necrofury 4 years ago
great
captainevita 4 years ago 3
i love this song!
villesangel69 4 years ago 4