@navonab It seems like when Bono is able to rest his voice for long periods he is at his best. During his world tours his voice always seems to struggle from the constant back to back nights of rehearsals and performances. Take for example , when he did the SNL show in 2004 and did this song. It was by far the best I have heard and for some reason I suppose copy right laws , It is not on you tube.You tube can go to hell! lol But seriously, If you are able to see it, its great!
I love this song. I am a tough guy with anger, but working on myself. Even tough guys have a soft heart and a great respect for a great love song like the beautiful song Nicolette sang. Lotta Love.
the song tuned down a bit and creating some memory or emotion for many, how can you beat that.
for me, being at one of the first concerts after 911 playing "one" while the names scrolled down. i just happended to be wearing a fdny shirt. not a dry eye in the house.
Fortunately I talk to my father, and he is still alive, but the emotion Bono puts to the song, lyrically and vocally, brings tears to my eyes, I can really feel what he is saying, it's a powerful feeling. One of my fav. songs.
goose bumps on 3:28 awesome, ''u are the reason why the opera is in me''. well hey i still got let u kow a house just dont make a home, don't leave me here alone''!!! , great dedication for a father, i miss my dad as well bono
U2 together since 1976...Pioneers of their own sound...signed a deal with LIVE-NATION until 2020...22 Grammys...YOUNGEST band to be inducted into the ROCK & ROLL HALL OF FAME on first nomination! Golden Globe Winners, 130million records sold...SELL-OUT TOURS that cant meet demands for tickets...Most influential band of recent times...
yea the SNL version was unbelievable! Bono hit it that night! Its seems when bono does the first concerts of the tour his voice is amazing but so many nights after awhile i could see how it would ravage your voice. SOMEONE FIND THE SNL VERSION AND POST IT!
Ouf ... his voice is perfect at 3,29 min. ... I have a strong and deep feeling everytime I hear this part of the song ... during all the song also ... thanx U2
U2 have locked down a date for one of the first big releases of 2009. The veteran rockers have announced that they will drop their 12th album, No Line on the Horizon on March 2 in the U.S
16th release yes but only their 12th studio album. americanpitbull04 wasn't inlcuding the 2 best of albums, U218 the singles or Under a Blood Red Sky.
If you all think this performance is good, have any of you seen the Saturday Night live performance they did of this song? It is by far the best and it used to be posted on here and since has been taken off. Bono's voice was unbelievable that night! I think thats because it was very early in the tour and his voice had not been ravaged by three concerts a week. A must see very very good live version!!
goose bumps on 3:28 awesome, ''u are the reason why the opera is in me''. well hey i still got let u kow a house just dont make a home, don't leave me here alone''!!! , great dedication for a father, i miss my dad as well bono
It's a 1960's Rickenbacker 12-string, and trust me it's a 12-string. It has six standard tuners and six slotted head stock tuners that you can't see from the front.
If you want a similar sound without the huge price tag you can try something like a $350 Dean Boca, they have a little more power than a Rick though.
It's the first time they ever played it live (I believe), he only took his shades off for the Vertigo Tour ones. Although at the Milan concert he left them on.
Maybe as a band. I'm sure the first time it was ever performed live in any form was at Bonos father's funeral in 2001. Not sure how it was performed though but Bono did sing it at Bob's funeral.
Aye I knew that, he's sang it many times before but not with U2, I'm sure on one of the fan-clips of the Elevation Tour he murmurs bits of "Sometimes" after With or Without You.
He alaways says he ahs bits of lyric floating around his head :P
My favorite song, from my favorite album. Their work just keeps evolving. Brilliant. No other word necessary. Bono opens his soul about our fathers. And the Edge's melody-- a tapestry of genius. Watch his DVD interview. He's got so much humility describing his creative process for this masterpiece. He makes the world proud.
very personal song for bono but it somehow transcends the meaning of it to a lot of people. awesome lyrics and guitar. nice vocals for bono and edge together.
1:52 the look of that girl tell everything I want to know about U2...just amazing how they are....God let them play forever......
Dad,U were never here but remember,I will never forget U......
LostShadow901 4 months ago 2
U2 the best!!!
salvatore050965 6 months ago
see the expression.......he really means alot.....he's one of my number one inspirational musicians.....hail bono and u2......
LyricistHeshan 9 months ago 2
the best live performance, great vocal..thanks bonoU2!...
esorena17 10 months ago
sometimes.....sometimes,
i can't make it on my own.
great song
pvdberg8 11 months ago
Why did this sound so amazing here but not during the concerts in 2005?
navonab 1 year ago
@navonab They did? Watch the live @ chicago 2005 videos?
DKViola 11 months ago
@navonab It seems like when Bono is able to rest his voice for long periods he is at his best. During his world tours his voice always seems to struggle from the constant back to back nights of rehearsals and performances. Take for example , when he did the SNL show in 2004 and did this song. It was by far the best I have heard and for some reason I suppose copy right laws , It is not on you tube.You tube can go to hell! lol But seriously, If you are able to see it, its great!
ou812BD 10 months ago
@navonab maybe because it was a smaller crowd.
sgenn99 7 months ago
this song makes me cry its so beautiful.
ClassicRock93 1 year ago
Ok Bob Thanks for the big note, don't Fuck up now :)
flossy411 1 year ago 10
so good. and it would have sounded even better live!
gamezky 1 year ago
You can't do anything but love Bono when you watch this! :)
DKViola 1 year ago
which type of guitar is it ?
kubabecks7 1 year ago
@kubabecks7 It's a 1965 Rickenbacker 330 Fireglo, 12 stringer
tobalable 1 year ago
there irish :)
TheDrummerGuy101 1 year ago
Wow nothing short of amazing
COLR13 1 year ago
A living Angel......
maxxunn 1 year ago 2
The greatest background for any concert, anywhere in the world: NYC and the B/B.
rafalweb 1 year ago 2
this is pure magic
supermazzi 1 year ago 4
besser gehts eigentlich nicht ... ich liebe diese version von sometimes. selbst auf dem studio album nicht so genial ;-)
Fliegile 1 year ago 4
one of the best u2 songs ever - i love it
Fliegile 1 year ago 5
Thanks !!!! U2 is one of my very very favorites
janemarie927 1 year ago
give him a call to too now
ziongo24 1 year ago
If i hear this song i want to cry because my dad died in same year as bono's dad
vikinator821 1 year ago 2
super super video from the greatest band ever
shaneoace12 1 year ago
Emotional song love it <3
Europe1992 1 year ago 3
The lyrics hit the spot.
10brownblair 1 year ago
Good! Very, very good...
0177964 1 year ago
he cries alot in this song.. behind his sunglasses... damn, it gives me chill, shakes my heart,, great Performance!
m0tiii 1 year ago 4
love it
eyewitnesful 1 year ago
I love this song. I am a tough guy with anger, but working on myself. Even tough guys have a soft heart and a great respect for a great love song like the beautiful song Nicolette sang. Lotta Love.
Rest in peace Angel. See you in Heaven.
Shapinaot 1 year ago
Thanx Bono........amazing song
Miss you mum
helena601 1 year ago 3
the best vocalist on the planet, what a preformance. Im amazed he can keep his emotions in check when he sings this beautiful song, I cant!
nicksnow74 1 year ago 4
This song reminds me of my father :"" Love u2 :')
crazynewsboysfan 2 years ago 3
best
ocarruil 2 years ago
In a few years this will be an U2 classic
con2mms 2 years ago 2
bono never fails to amaze me with these tunes.awesome.
MegaTrainspotter 2 years ago
Man, I miss my father...
gcornielje 2 years ago 58
Just amazing. One of their best.
Vinderville 2 years ago 5
the song tuned down a bit and creating some memory or emotion for many, how can you beat that.
for me, being at one of the first concerts after 911 playing "one" while the names scrolled down. i just happended to be wearing a fdny shirt. not a dry eye in the house.
44FAST 2 years ago 2
3:47 he was like gonna scream and cry and...
the song is so emotional
pl4typuses 2 years ago 4
Fortunately I talk to my father, and he is still alive, but the emotion Bono puts to the song, lyrically and vocally, brings tears to my eyes, I can really feel what he is saying, it's a powerful feeling. One of my fav. songs.
AngeliqueZombified 2 years ago 4
klrijg altijd kiekevel alsk da liedje hoor, zo emotieneel liedje
newA309 2 years ago 2
La passione nella voce e nella musica,i gesti...Questa canzone è sempilcemente travolgente...
Ildebranda1908 2 years ago 2
Bono sang this tune for his DAD....BOB...Bless.X listen to me now.......ahhh:) X
shazandbono 2 years ago 2
The end is very emotional
EAGLESDeventer7 2 years ago 2
What a voice.......... U2 the best band around the world!!!
BoNoYzIdAnE 2 years ago 50
its well sad... But a good song well done
galwaycityraverz 2 years ago 6
i think he says "...still looking for....."
cinabu 2 years ago
he says " see you later bob" bob is his father!!
truexercise1 2 years ago
does anyone know what he says at 3:51? it doesnt sound like "still gotta let you know"
Greenwave247 2 years ago
awesome song great band
conrussell 2 years ago 4
awsome & so perfect live
ThaG0DFATHER 2 years ago 2
bono is greet ilove him
bouke
bouke008 2 years ago
3:28 awesome voice
Hubertoooso 2 years ago 2
goose bumps on 3:28 awesome, ''u are the reason why the opera is in me''. well hey i still got let u kow a house just dont make a home, don't leave me here alone''!!! , great dedication for a father, i miss my dad as well bono
americanpitbull04 2 years ago 10
God bless the wee burd fae west belfast i was drinking with in the parlour she was superb
galso 2 years ago
The atmosphere near the Brooklyn Bridge is fantastic....Very emotion....
AlbyRn89 2 years ago
bono put his own soul in this song...
a house still doesn't make a home...
truceboy18 2 years ago 3
does larry mullen jr. realise how handsome he is?
HornyLee19 2 years ago 2
Damm i love that band !!!!
krisser45 2 years ago 2
sono davvero i più grandi.... davvero....
freddysinf 2 years ago 2
This is apsolutely wonderful!
bakosspyr 3 years ago 3
WOW
U2 together since 1976...Pioneers of their own sound...signed a deal with LIVE-NATION until 2020...22 Grammys...YOUNGEST band to be inducted into the ROCK & ROLL HALL OF FAME on first nomination! Golden Globe Winners, 130million records sold...SELL-OUT TOURS that cant meet demands for tickets...Most influential band of recent times...
Greatest Rock Band Ever
lazarush1980 3 years ago 20
The ultimate version of this song, IMO.
MrJavish 3 years ago
I actualy think the performance on Saturday Night Live was the best for this song. I'd put this second though
Hallucination 3 years ago
i agree i loved the version from SNL but i can't find it on youtube.
unraveled76 2 years ago
yea the SNL version was unbelievable! Bono hit it that night! Its seems when bono does the first concerts of the tour his voice is amazing but so many nights after awhile i could see how it would ravage your voice. SOMEONE FIND THE SNL VERSION AND POST IT!
newradfan9 2 years ago
Ouf ... his voice is perfect at 3,29 min. ... I have a strong and deep feeling everytime I hear this part of the song ... during all the song also ... thanx U2
aulav26 3 years ago 5
U2 have locked down a date for one of the first big releases of 2009. The veteran rockers have announced that they will drop their 12th album, No Line on the Horizon on March 2 in the U.S
americanpitbull04 3 years ago
it´s the 16th album....
U2 rocks
Fullra 3 years ago
16th release yes but only their 12th studio album. americanpitbull04 wasn't inlcuding the 2 best of albums, U218 the singles or Under a Blood Red Sky.
Hallucination 3 years ago
Roger That. But it doesn't matter. U2 rocks. Tomorrow new single released : )
Fullra 3 years ago
oh yeah i didnt know the hits was includes lol,
peace
americanpitbull04 2 years ago
no comment.....n 1
gffmario 3 years ago
...oh my God!!! It's wonderful performance!
Wallacely 3 years ago
i only came her to check this version from listening to the original achtung baby on myspace,i cant believe how similar the sound is wow
blueey1 3 years ago
They're a great live band.
sketchyillusions 3 years ago 2
What could you possible say about this glorious song and my all time favorite band whom I have followed since the beginning hence I Will Follow!
austexukrainka 3 years ago
Oh my lord they are beautiful!!!!!!!!
I'm soooooo happy and proud that they are my favourite band EVER!!!!!
bakosspyr 3 years ago 5
BTW .. what is Bono doing at 2:05? .. it looks like a rough movement, more rough than usual ....
JJmsfw 3 years ago 2
Looks to me like a kid trying to hide from a beating...Might be the memory of all those times the quarrel with his father resulted in violence.
Such a great song.
HacjienceYukona 3 years ago
Is such a beatiful song ... so emotional that fellings comes through the screen . i like the version at Milan to .. that concert is very special..
JJmsfw 3 years ago
I think this version is better than the one on the Chicago concertfilme
Eichibombeichi 3 years ago
Phantastic song. Deeply impressed by the lyrics.
Bono is a great songwriter and I like Edge´s guitarsound.
delphisOrakel 3 years ago 3
this is my favorite u2 song
dkrakovski 3 years ago 2
If you all think this performance is good, have any of you seen the Saturday Night live performance they did of this song? It is by far the best and it used to be posted on here and since has been taken off. Bono's voice was unbelievable that night! I think thats because it was very early in the tour and his voice had not been ravaged by three concerts a week. A must see very very good live version!!
newradfan9 3 years ago
goose bumps on 3:28 awesome, ''u are the reason why the opera is in me''. well hey i still got let u kow a house just dont make a home, don't leave me here alone''!!! , great dedication for a father, i miss my dad as well bono
americanpitbull04 3 years ago 4
The edge is using a Rickenbaker 330/12 Fireglo model guitar in this video.This particular guitar is one of his favourites!
Soh2k8 3 years ago
Mejor version en vivo de una cancion que me hace sentir emocion, eriza mi piel...
gcv5 3 years ago
very good and emotionally song...
does anyone know what guitar has edge in this song?
0PLITS0 3 years ago
Electric
Junije1 3 years ago
I mean what kind of electric guitar...
0PLITS0 3 years ago
It's a 1960's Rickenbacker 12-string, and trust me it's a 12-string. It has six standard tuners and six slotted head stock tuners that you can't see from the front.
If you want a similar sound without the huge price tag you can try something like a $350 Dean Boca, they have a little more power than a Rick though.
NsHatch 3 years ago 4
very very thanks man!!! :) I've been searching for so long time, and I couldn't find it... Thanks!!!
0PLITS0 3 years ago
This is the best performance of that song I've ever seen. It makes me cry...
honysia 3 years ago
BRILLIANT
sabien2578 3 years ago 3
The song Lemon is about his mom too.
Franckdatankpart2 3 years ago
what a voice what a bloke
tom134luv 3 years ago 2
yeah i know...i forgot to mention that one
234711 3 years ago
nice contrast among the songs dedicated to his parents(mom: Tomorrow and Mofo)
234711 3 years ago
maybe this is one of the best liveacts of this song.great lyrics....this song makes me always cry.i hope they record more songs like this one
Ziminho19 4 years ago 2
a very sad, emotional song...
234711 4 years ago
jesus.....what a performance..
andrewf2 4 years ago 8
fantastico vi amoooooooooooo
giovanni840 4 years ago
First time i see him singing this song with glasses.
utubehifi 4 years ago 2
It's the first time they ever played it live (I believe), he only took his shades off for the Vertigo Tour ones. Although at the Milan concert he left them on.
ToulacAxeHand 4 years ago
Maybe as a band. I'm sure the first time it was ever performed live in any form was at Bonos father's funeral in 2001. Not sure how it was performed though but Bono did sing it at Bob's funeral.
Hallucination 4 years ago 2
Aye I knew that, he's sang it many times before but not with U2, I'm sure on one of the fan-clips of the Elevation Tour he murmurs bits of "Sometimes" after With or Without You.
He alaways says he ahs bits of lyric floating around his head :P
Bono is such a great song writer :-)
ToulacAxeHand 4 years ago 5
Absolutely one of the most beautiful songs I've ever heard. Stirs the heart and reached deep into my soul. Sending this to my Dad.
tootsnslick 4 years ago
i think it's verry hard for bono to sing this song but is awesome his dad will be happy
jelle2310 4 years ago 3
i'd love to hear this song in concert, it's such a great tune and so meaningful at the same time
audiodane 4 years ago
My favorite song, from my favorite album. Their work just keeps evolving. Brilliant. No other word necessary. Bono opens his soul about our fathers. And the Edge's melody-- a tapestry of genius. Watch his DVD interview. He's got so much humility describing his creative process for this masterpiece. He makes the world proud.
jws63 4 years ago
very personal song for bono but it somehow transcends the meaning of it to a lot of people. awesome lyrics and guitar. nice vocals for bono and edge together.
rands72 4 years ago 3