@colacentral He's got a great voice and all, but covers of Will's songs really don't carry the same emotion that he's able to deliver. Imagine anyone else performing something off of Black Sheep Boy. It really wouldn't be the same.
@gladtobeback01 That's actually a guitar made for children! he bought it somewhere in Germany, then he normally tunes it higher i think. I saw it in a pitchfork interview with him i believe.
Might there be some benevolent soul who could refer me to the mp3s of these Stand-Ins covers ?
I know someone had mentioned the message boards but no dice. I can rock out to this piece. Listening to this version on the subway would certainly increase the number of strange looks I already get.
Well, for the -People- who do. The Hipsters lose the awesomeness they gain by listening to music like this by being horrible, obnoxious, annoying Hipsters.
I really like your stuff .....great sound and melody. wouldn't mind your thoughts on some of my stuff. I'm just getting over bronchitis so my vocals sound a bit rough but it was my only time to record
Wanna know what I see? I see two talented guys trying to outdo each other to see who can singer louder, longer or with more enthusiasm. One of these guys is wicked stoned, as well, guess which? Hint:It's the guy gyrating like he has Parkinson's/
I love this version even more than the album version. A.C. Newman's vocals are incredible, and I love hearing Will sing in that low register. It would be perfect if it included the banjo from the album
I used to like metal a lot, but I realized there were expressions that metal didn't cover. This band, along with many other amazing ones, cover all those bases.
5. why be a dick, ppl obviously enjoy this music as you enjoy metal, we dont come raving to you about "dont listen to lamb of god cus you cant hear a word they sing" i love metal myself but dont appreciate your low wit and bad banter.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
how is it impressive when he stole the chord structure from 'leroy likes spaceships' outright, from our own Wilco-produced single?! the proof is on the pudding! take some singing lessons- better yet, DONT SING IF YOU ARENT A SINGER. im outraged!
To be fair, Will is singing the verse that Jonathan Meiburg sings on the album. It's a lower tone than he usually sings. He tried to sound to much like Jonathan, I think, instead of sticking with a more comfortable vocal range.
Yeah I agree with BeagleGuitar...Will Sheff kind of ruined this. It may be his song, but that doesn't mean he performed it well, nor does it mean he is not a great songwriter
Your really going to sit there and ssay that will is a bad song writer? Have you listened to any of their CDs? Will usually sings the lead vocals but if you knew anything about this CD and why its called "The Stand-ins" you would get this version of the song. Everything they have done has been amazing and Will Sheff is highly reguarded as a great song writer by so many people. Shut up.
Yeah Will can't pull off Meiburg's deeper register, but as with so many Sheff songs it's deeply felt. Plus its fun to hear AC's take on Will's vocals.
what does A in A.C. Newman stand for? i know C stands for Carl. just curious.
this is great because i love both these people severely, but its true, Will's voice just isnt suited that low. jonathan meiburg's voice on the original is just Perfect.
Interesting comment. I think you mean to say he doesn't sound right singing the second vocal. It's HIS song, so I think it's safe to say that his voice is made for this song -- just the lead vocal.
This is brilliant, A.C. Newman sings so good.. Amazing. And as always Will writes lyrics like it's the easiest thing in the world (and it sure isn't). Cant wait to see Okkervil live when they come to Stockholm in October! :)
Amazing song, amazing performance, amazing album, amazing band. Possibly not my favourite Okkervil River album but it's undoubtedly a grower! Seeing them in Manchester in November :D!
i love this song, and cant wait to see you in omaha nebraska on the 13th. ive been looking forward to this since the day you announced you were coming
Amazing. Big fan of both of them... personally, I think Will Sheff is possibly the best singer/songwriter in music today. Saw Okkervil live a little while back and they're coming back to town soon. Can't wait!
Will really likes singing the part he sings in this video, but the part A.C. sings (and Will sings it on the record) compliments his voice so much better. Still great.
Love the juxtaposition. It's like when Emmylou Harris and Mark Knopfler collaborate: such totally different voices, but put together it's just freaking amazing...
It feels like there is a roar of applause missing from the end.
Floydthefuckbag 5 days ago
I don't like Will's voice until he starts singing with AC Newman.
BajFult 3 months ago
This is the best song I've listen in years, simply.
juanshitojuanshito 4 months ago 2
Will Sheff should just pass his songs on to AC Newman.
colacentral 5 months ago
@colacentral He's got a great voice and all, but covers of Will's songs really don't carry the same emotion that he's able to deliver. Imagine anyone else performing something off of Black Sheep Boy. It really wouldn't be the same.
dontlightmeonfire 2 weeks ago
am listening to this on average 5 times a day for the last week... falling in love with that bearded fellas voice x
joe14888 7 months ago
Two of the best. Thanks for the video
steveege 7 months ago
is it just me or does sheff's guitar look too small for him?
gladtobeback01 8 months ago 3
@gladtobeback01 That's actually a guitar made for children! he bought it somewhere in Germany, then he normally tunes it higher i think. I saw it in a pitchfork interview with him i believe.
Antics79 3 weeks ago
hÎ_í_féÉl_sÒ_løÑËlý_tõÐÂY
LunaoGraceji276 8 months ago
Might there be some benevolent soul who could refer me to the mp3s of these Stand-Ins covers ?
I know someone had mentioned the message boards but no dice. I can rock out to this piece. Listening to this version on the subway would certainly increase the number of strange looks I already get.
clavidor12121 9 months ago
Comment removed
ItssStephen 1 year ago 4
@ItssStephen
Well, for the -People- who do. The Hipsters lose the awesomeness they gain by listening to music like this by being horrible, obnoxious, annoying Hipsters.
ammiscemo 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I really like your stuff .....great sound and melody. wouldn't mind your thoughts on some of my stuff. I'm just getting over bronchitis so my vocals sound a bit rough but it was my only time to record
FlagsGone 1 year ago
Comment removed
OmgAKROMA111 1 year ago
2 of the greatest modern day songwriters. Carl is a god to me. I will watch this a thousand times.
thebatdad71 1 year ago 2
i have not got the words
poada2008 1 year ago
lovely!
DaniGoesWonderland 1 year ago
fucking the one my friends
poada2008 1 year ago
Wanna know what I see? I see two talented guys trying to outdo each other to see who can singer louder, longer or with more enthusiasm. One of these guys is wicked stoned, as well, guess which? Hint:It's the guy gyrating like he has Parkinson's/
wiseguy400 1 year ago
I love this version even more than the album version. A.C. Newman's vocals are incredible, and I love hearing Will sing in that low register. It would be perfect if it included the banjo from the album
MitchellFranklin 1 year ago 3
saw will sheff live. he killed it.
ccarajoo 2 years ago
This is beautiful. :)
VladekMeyer83 2 years ago
I still think The Stand Ins was a massively underrated album.
NicoleKidA 2 years ago 28
Okkervil are by far up there as one of my favourite live bands. I completely adore them :))
ronaglows 2 years ago 4
I used to like metal a lot, but I realized there were expressions that metal didn't cover. This band, along with many other amazing ones, cover all those bases.
Vaiseoquan 2 years ago 6
5. why be a dick, ppl obviously enjoy this music as you enjoy metal, we dont come raving to you about "dont listen to lamb of god cus you cant hear a word they sing" i love metal myself but dont appreciate your low wit and bad banter.
agorah 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
1. they are not very talented guitarist
2. one sounds like a girl.
3. the other sounds like he feels sick, and like napoleon dynamite..
4.Listen to metal
mattlandrigan 2 years ago
fuck metal
iwantmymoneybackk 2 years ago
4 questions;
1. Yeh?
2. And?
3. So?
4. What?
taxi909 2 years ago
I fucking love that !!
poada2008 2 years ago
epic duo!
avamarie111 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
how is it impressive when he stole the chord structure from 'leroy likes spaceships' outright, from our own Wilco-produced single?! the proof is on the pudding! take some singing lessons- better yet, DONT SING IF YOU ARENT A SINGER. im outraged!
SigEdForever 2 years ago
what?
FenderFanatic 2 years ago
shopped
rajerino 2 years ago
Two of my favorite bands. Awesome to see.
MadAshSamuels 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
AgentScorpio 2 years ago 5
OMG LOL, "forget about the performance... what color is the paint"... u joker!!!
Jazkren 2 years ago
To be fair, Will is singing the verse that Jonathan Meiburg sings on the album. It's a lower tone than he usually sings. He tried to sound to much like Jonathan, I think, instead of sticking with a more comfortable vocal range.
NoRegretsForOurYouth 2 years ago 5
Will Shef is a damn fine singer!
NoRegretsForOurYouth 2 years ago 4
this is true, but he hasn't got much on jonathan meiburg. no one does.
higerto11 2 years ago 2
This is still a great song, but Will just paled in comparison to A.C. Newman in the solo pieces. But when they're singing together it's awesome.
momobono 2 years ago 5
Yeah I agree with BeagleGuitar...Will Sheff kind of ruined this. It may be his song, but that doesn't mean he performed it well, nor does it mean he is not a great songwriter
We just agree this was a poor performance.
Great tune, just Project man!
amaveal 2 years ago
Disagree, Sheff isnt singing in his regular key, its a bit deeper than normal.
And this is a great performance, just different
DivisibleByZer0 2 years ago
great! newman man
dennisvandoorn177 2 years ago
This version is much more powerful than the other for Jagjaguwar release.
juanshitojuanshito 2 years ago
i think newman is the best stand in for the stand ins project (; i love this cover! newman's vocals is devine!
sprstkr 2 years ago
! my friend and i covered this at lunch :)
eoipa 2 years ago
Ya me 2 ;)
tk2195 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Wow, acoustic stuff like this really exposes the lack of songwriting ability, balls, feel, youname it, doesn't it?
socrates1818 2 years ago
Comment removed
al3x515 2 years ago
Your really going to sit there and ssay that will is a bad song writer? Have you listened to any of their CDs? Will usually sings the lead vocals but if you knew anything about this CD and why its called "The Stand-ins" you would get this version of the song. Everything they have done has been amazing and Will Sheff is highly reguarded as a great song writer by so many people. Shut up.
al3x515 2 years ago 3
I love Will Sheff. Fuck you, leave Will alone!
ultimateairhead 2 years ago
whoa.
FenderFanatic 2 years ago
This is goosebumps amazing
sincerelycynical 2 years ago
Please post your "Take on me" cover from Starbucks Sweetheart CD. PLEASE! PLEASE! PLEASE! That has to be one of the best covers I have ever heard.
romero1981 2 years ago
Comment removed
Nicollto 2 years ago
Great job.
mcart144 2 years ago
Will Sheff sounds really gay when he sings
beagleguitar 2 years ago
Is AC Newman on the CD version too? Where can I find a recorded version of this?
sylvanloc 2 years ago
what r the chords for this version?
eoipa 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
SO FUCKING BEAUTIFUL AND BRILLIANT
eoipa 2 years ago
absolutely amazing.
championofidiots 3 years ago
FUCK YEAH!
bdeaner 3 years ago 3
this is so cool. thank you so much.
iamamericana 3 years ago 2
LOVE IT!!
icecreamheadache13 3 years ago 2
OOooh sounds good.
Bekah47 3 years ago 2
awesome
superhansa 3 years ago 2
Great cover! And Will, you're the man. Much love to Okkervil and their beautiful fans.
Spindlework 3 years ago 3
This is good, but my favorite part of "Lost Coastlines" is maybe Jonathan Meiburg's vocals, which Will can't quite pull off.
crynyd 3 years ago
Yeah Will can't pull off Meiburg's deeper register, but as with so many Sheff songs it's deeply felt. Plus its fun to hear AC's take on Will's vocals.
GayBreal 3 years ago
love love love love love.
my genius at the apple store who helped me with my laptop looked like ac newman.
trafficjammed 3 years ago
awesome!!
zero15541554 3 years ago
what does A in A.C. Newman stand for? i know C stands for Carl. just curious.
this is great because i love both these people severely, but its true, Will's voice just isnt suited that low. jonathan meiburg's voice on the original is just Perfect.
hopelessdreamr 3 years ago
Allan. A.C. Newman's full name is Allan Carl Newman.
DarkAvenger280 3 years ago
newman is the man.
blake71837 3 years ago
brilliant
eburn 3 years ago
Wills voice was not made for this song.
hachachachacha 3 years ago
fact.
cobstawordup 3 years ago
Um...
Um...
Interesting comment. I think you mean to say he doesn't sound right singing the second vocal. It's HIS song, so I think it's safe to say that his voice is made for this song -- just the lead vocal.
bobfenster 2 years ago
Okay. But if you knew what I meant why did you bother bringing it up?
hachachachacha 2 years ago
I said I THINK that's what you meant. If I was wrong, then your comment would have been really nuts.
bobfenster 2 years ago
Stupendous!
Reedmylips7 3 years ago
I don't know how they can make so many good solid songs.
davidrochman 3 years ago
seriously!
livinginavideo 3 years ago
Just awesome... for so many reasons.
tecno44 3 years ago 2
I just came acrossed you guys and i love this song! Thanks for making "real" music..
BrianlRomig 3 years ago 3
I have a huge man-crush on Will, but his voice is definitely not suited for that part. Otherwise, loved this performance.
vietrmx 3 years ago 14
Hahaha, that is perfect wording for this, Good job.
kachimint 3 years ago
I LOVE this!
the ending is great.
stillxlight 3 years ago
Two of my favourite musicians of all time, squished together in one tasty aural treat!
desensitisation 3 years ago 3
i actually like this version better.
moejoe2112 3 years ago
will's guitar looks tiny lol
peterofantioch 3 years ago
I thought i was imagining it!
lostcoastlines 3 years ago
(the tininess of wills guitar)
lostcoastlines 3 years ago
it says video no longer available! what do i do i want to see?!?
norlofsky 3 years ago
The harmonies are soo good!!!!!
blackcatstudiosny 3 years ago
I love the motown bassline in this song. My favorite song of the album.
RyanNakur 3 years ago
This is brilliant, A.C. Newman sings so good.. Amazing. And as always Will writes lyrics like it's the easiest thing in the world (and it sure isn't). Cant wait to see Okkervil live when they come to Stockholm in October! :)
OkkervilSwimmer 3 years ago 3
I can't express how much I love this.
rustycamino 3 years ago 2
wow, i think i have a man crush on will sheff
BrilloPad71 3 years ago 6
This is so great!!
kaitlingrace 3 years ago
Muy buen tema, hacen buena dupla, felictaciones! una melodía muy original.
juanshitojuanshito 3 years ago
suuuuuuuper!!!!!!!!!!!
suzuky46 3 years ago
Wonderful!
mateus2 3 years ago
Amazing song, amazing performance, amazing album, amazing band. Possibly not my favourite Okkervil River album but it's undoubtedly a grower! Seeing them in Manchester in November :D!
DeadFaces14 3 years ago
Great song, but what else did you expect from Okkervil River.
Will Sheff is singing in quite a deep voice here; interesting. I thought he has a tenor voice, but this is a deep baritone.
charms2 3 years ago
Sheff's singing the lines that were originally sung by Jonathan Meiburg on the album. Might explain the "tenor voice".
What else do we expect indeed!
deevism 3 years ago
i love this song, and cant wait to see you in omaha nebraska on the 13th. ive been looking forward to this since the day you announced you were coming
nickyt0teh0destroyer 3 years ago
Oooh. This is fantastic. :)
kerstea 3 years ago 2
Such a good cover. Makes me feel like I'm floating.
HI5forJazmine 3 years ago 3
We did it while actually floating...check out our cover in the video responses. We had a great time.
NachoPalacho 3 years ago
sheesh. i love will sheff. ace.
diNOpoWERvids 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
dumb
jarchri 3 years ago
you sure are
2zednik0 3 years ago
As great as it is, I prefer the version that he and Jonathan Meiburg sing, as it's what the songs about in the first place...
corskier 3 years ago 5
Amazing. Big fan of both of them... personally, I think Will Sheff is possibly the best singer/songwriter in music today. Saw Okkervil live a little while back and they're coming back to town soon. Can't wait!
paternzen 3 years ago 12
yeah i agree :D
Wil Sheff is fantastic! I love him :)
love this song and this version is really good.
can't wait till the album comes out.
danigranny 3 years ago 2
This is fantastic! They played Ithaca together in the spring and I guess Carl and Will really must have hit it off
strummer47 3 years ago 3
The hookiest of hooky hooks has hooked me. I can't stop listening to this song!
2zednik0 3 years ago 4
will sheff makes me melt...a.c newman is basically just the rainbow sprinkles on my quivering nerd sundae.
did that make any sense?
Jesusismothra 3 years ago 13
THE ALBUM IS SO AMAZING.
LOVELOVELOVELOVELOVELOVE.
will sheff ftw.
laviebonne 3 years ago 5
Will really likes singing the part he sings in this video, but the part A.C. sings (and Will sings it on the record) compliments his voice so much better. Still great.
SAToastmaker 3 years ago 2
that's a lot of la's
lovin the song though
fernloft 3 years ago
The covers will be available as MP3's at some point, yes? Possibly another mixtape?
Yes?
livebackwards 3 years ago 2
Superb...really really good. Now, can you top that? Andrew Bird on a future cover???
liarliar00 3 years ago
awesome. i've always loved ac newman's vocal talents, he can really belt out those lyrics. this came out really great...
malignifier 3 years ago
This is amazing. Can't wait to see Okkervil River in September!
waffuru2 3 years ago
So Beautiful!
kayceethekat 3 years ago
briiiiilliance de luxe.
ironseaisa 3 years ago
Amazing choice of "stand-in". I can't wait for the new album!
Jasonllester 3 years ago 2
Love the juxtaposition. It's like when Emmylou Harris and Mark Knopfler collaborate: such totally different voices, but put together it's just freaking amazing...
RambleRose 3 years ago 2
good choice on a.c. newman, they sound great together.
pinkroboot 3 years ago 2
Simply great!
w3stfa11 3 years ago 2
the day i discovered this song i played it 90+ times on repeat. can't wait for the album!
Kakie22 3 years ago 3
Beautiful, just beautiful.
It's already one of my favorite Okkervil River songs.
flakemusic86 3 years ago 2