@Testament2222 almost many guitarisst in a certain phase if he is progressing (exception- a vague term) subconsciously uses pitch axis..
but as @jspartacus said , the above video is very vague for people who are thinking that they have figured out what pitch axis is with this 2 min video.
Guthrie is guessing it wrong, it's about the different modes over a certain key (pitch). Look on youtube for satriani pitch axis and you will find Joe explaining himself. For example going from A myxolydian to A phrygian in one song. The A remains, the mood totally changes.
So, he doesn't understand Pitch Axis. The theory is that, given a common note, there are certain KNOWN progressions that can work over that note. It is the OPPOSITE of knowing what notes can work over a particular chord. Contrary to what Govan says here, experimentation is not necessary: Satch has already mapped out the possibilities and has a formula. Going back 20+ years through his many instructive articles, Satriani explains it in-depth.
@raphaeljsn the difference is these aren't in the same scale - they just share the root notes. As long as one note is always there, it doesn't matter what chord you play. That's what he's saying.
I started doing this when i first started playing and didn't know and still don't about scales or chords. I couldn't tap very well, so I started to tap on different strings using the same open string to make the drone note. So keeping on the A with 1 or 2 note and tapping on the next string to make the 5th or 7th or 3rd, you get these arpeggiated sounds while not picking and you can play them in any order and they sound sweet. So I wouldn't think Joe(which is my name too) Thought about it much.
@jacknarcotta The difference is that it goes through different modes keeping one note as the root of each mode eg. A Dorian, A Lydian, A Phrygian, back to A Dorian. It is similar to having a pedal note, but specific in that it uses modal variation instead of diatonic varation. Hope this helps!
if you switch from ionian to aeolian through relative intervals, um... I hate to be a bummer here, but technically you're switching from major to minor. no offense!
start in aeolian maybe blues scale if thats your sound, change to dorian, then to mixolydian, youve now drifted from minor to major and when youre familiar with it, it can sound great, then from mixo to lydian or inion do what you want, pedal point allows you to change keys under the same bass, very cool stuff
NOOOOOOOOO joe definitely came up with that tapping lick based on the varying modes. one of the ideas of pitch axis theory is that certain chords exemplify the modes (eg m7 for aolian or dom7 for mixolydian). what joe does is he's tapping the chords of various modes, all with the same tonic.
I figured this out by myself a few weeks ago before I even heard of it and I thought I was a musical genius. Now I feel like a musical genius just cause I was thinking along the same lines as Govan and Satch. Now if only I had a billionth of the talent of these guys, it would be worth something :(
The entire concept is not to simply change chords, but to change modes. Like going :I7-II7/I-I7: Would go :Mixolydian-Lydian-Mixolydian: The chords are only there to emulate the modes, so you could actually go like : IVmaj7 - iii min9- I7: (Idk, just made the progression up off the top of my head to prove a point)
@crucifyme88 he isnt calling satch a liar. he is hinting towards the fact that a seasoned player such as joe probably doesn't conciously sit and think now I will compose something using pitch axis theory. it is somethng which is ingrained in his playing and he has the ability to explain the concept as pitch axis theory.another example would be any scale or mode. once you have it internalized, you are not thinking about scales and modes as you play...only music
@andymcguitar you don't even have to be a GREAT MUSICIAN for that though. You just need the mindset that music isn't a math problem or a philosophy lecture
@crucifyme88 I don't think he's calling Joe a liar, just saying that he wasn't necessarily overly conscious of going into the theory of pitch axis at the time of writing it. He was still entitled to go into detail about the theory of how it works in interviews.
I thought it was where you use a progression of scales or chords based upon the same root note; like A Ionian followed by A Lydian followed by A Mixolydian. I could be wrong though!
@twothirdsrasta No your spot on matey. As long as you hit say the A string as a drone or pedal tone then you can expand into different modes or unrelated chords in A which are not in the same key.It gives a sense of unpredictability.
Pitch axis is a complicated name for something soooo common
MrAlexGTV 3 days ago
for once, guthrie doesn't quite get it right.. weird.. i don't know how to feel at this moment...
firstgearlead 5 days ago
I was doing this the whole time and had no idea what it was...
EpictheEpicest 1 week ago
Lol, better explanation than any 3 page website about PAT on the internet.
SkillerGuyVids 1 week ago
leaving it up to the player is so much better than telling a player what to do
timrocket2 2 weeks ago
what a mind...love this guy.
lilnetty2 2 weeks ago
Guthrie at the start of this video stated he thinks, therefore he wasnt sure, pitch axis isnt something Guthrie uses as much as guys like Satch. =]
F4TB0Y69 3 weeks ago
@Testament2222 almost many guitarisst in a certain phase if he is progressing (exception- a vague term) subconsciously uses pitch axis..
but as @jspartacus said , the above video is very vague for people who are thinking that they have figured out what pitch axis is with this 2 min video.
TheXPrisoner 4 weeks ago
Guthrie is guessing it wrong, it's about the different modes over a certain key (pitch). Look on youtube for satriani pitch axis and you will find Joe explaining himself. For example going from A myxolydian to A phrygian in one song. The A remains, the mood totally changes.
CantDoThatOnStage 1 month ago 3
@CantDoThatOnStage That's the impression I've always had as well.
guitarz333 1 month ago
@CantDoThatOnStage It's the same thing. Satriani explained it in terms of melody and Guthrie in terms of harmony, but it's the same concept.
panamanian911 1 week ago
Wow. Guthrie knows Joe's mind better than Joe! amazing!
TruthSurge 1 month ago 3
So, he doesn't understand Pitch Axis. The theory is that, given a common note, there are certain KNOWN progressions that can work over that note. It is the OPPOSITE of knowing what notes can work over a particular chord. Contrary to what Govan says here, experimentation is not necessary: Satch has already mapped out the possibilities and has a formula. Going back 20+ years through his many instructive articles, Satriani explains it in-depth.
jspartacus 1 month ago
trollin on J Satch haha
Mo7Vsta 1 month ago
Check out a track called Lie by Dream Theater, the end solo uses this theory.
Testament2222 1 month ago
@Testament2222 Great song!
gnryeah 2 weeks ago
Sounds like he's talking about pedal tones.
WyattTheGuitarist 2 months ago 6
MORE HELPFUL? YOU SPEAKING IS BEST THING IVE EVER HAD IN MY LIFE
GUTHRIE GOVAN 4EVER <3
detroidxl 2 months ago
cool didnt know this was like a theory
cris931609 2 months ago
my god every time I hear this guy talk I think he's a genius
jiri1991 3 months ago 6
isn´t it the same of scales? i didn´t understand
raphaeljsn 3 months ago
@raphaeljsn the difference is these aren't in the same scale - they just share the root notes. As long as one note is always there, it doesn't matter what chord you play. That's what he's saying.
playingforbritain 1 month ago
I started doing this when i first started playing and didn't know and still don't about scales or chords. I couldn't tap very well, so I started to tap on different strings using the same open string to make the drone note. So keeping on the A with 1 or 2 note and tapping on the next string to make the 5th or 7th or 3rd, you get these arpeggiated sounds while not picking and you can play them in any order and they sound sweet. So I wouldn't think Joe(which is my name too) Thought about it much.
024leoj 4 months ago
Haha, not a lot of guitarists can call bullshit on Satch. JK. Great lesson though!
Quikfingers 5 months ago 4
pitcth axis ......ever heard of pedal notes?
darkenedmindband 5 months ago
@darkenedmindband Agreed on this... Guthrie even says it's like pedal notes (@ 1:27). So... what's different?
jacknarcotta 5 months ago
@jacknarcotta The difference is that it goes through different modes keeping one note as the root of each mode eg. A Dorian, A Lydian, A Phrygian, back to A Dorian. It is similar to having a pedal note, but specific in that it uses modal variation instead of diatonic varation. Hope this helps!
Chippie0703 4 months ago 2
@Chippie0703 well- erm-
if you switch from ionian to aeolian through relative intervals, um... I hate to be a bummer here, but technically you're switching from major to minor. no offense!
:X
ShadowLancer128 4 months ago
@ShadowLancer128 thats his point.. do this;
start in aeolian maybe blues scale if thats your sound, change to dorian, then to mixolydian, youve now drifted from minor to major and when youre familiar with it, it can sound great, then from mixo to lydian or inion do what you want, pedal point allows you to change keys under the same bass, very cool stuff
MrMu5iQ 4 months ago
He's like Sean Connery with long hair.
bobby12756 5 months ago
@bobby12756 Hahaha holy crap I see it !
Scracar 4 months ago
I read the whole wikipedia page on it and was like o.O
Then I saw this vid and the guy explains it in 1:30... possibly the most helpful 1:30 video I've ever seen.
ThePugnaciousAnt 6 months ago
I always used Pitch axis theory to find out what key im in, cant be without it, but just came naturally.
1madaboutguitar 6 months ago
i think there couldnt be any simpler explonation i thought it was something really complicated but he just explained it in the simplest way
Harvester66633 6 months ago
how is pitch axis different than a pedal point?
returnofthejazz 6 months ago
so...just sit there,,,pick a pedal note....think ,,,,then just play..
tabotabojayar 7 months ago
hagrid, did you loose weight?
dopeypickles 7 months ago 9
NOOOOOOOOO joe definitely came up with that tapping lick based on the varying modes. one of the ideas of pitch axis theory is that certain chords exemplify the modes (eg m7 for aolian or dom7 for mixolydian). what joe does is he's tapping the chords of various modes, all with the same tonic.
Jivesey1 7 months ago
gotta love those unconnected chords
finchvincent 7 months ago
This guy is good. Fuck it, he exists, he's God.
gnrcr 7 months ago
he's made a powerful enemy there.
legatrix 7 months ago
i like how hes only on for 1:36 and basically concludes he "knows fuck all" and they still feature him XD
petervsthechicken 7 months ago 3
I figured this out by myself a few weeks ago before I even heard of it and I thought I was a musical genius. Now I feel like a musical genius just cause I was thinking along the same lines as Govan and Satch. Now if only I had a billionth of the talent of these guys, it would be worth something :(
AriClark93 8 months ago
He's such a humble guy yet so great at what he does, why aren't there more people like him.
HOUCEMATE 8 months ago
DUDE WTF theres humor in every vid i cant stop watching these XD
machinesway0x3 9 months ago 4
Thumbs up if licklibrary had 666 videos when you watched this
Som1onu2be 9 months ago
we must go to the sourceeeeeeeeeeeee!! xaxa :P
Asixtirids 9 months ago
he should be in politics he keeps not really answering the questions and still you're happy with what he tells you
GregoMorgan 9 months ago 7
haha that smile at the end reminded me of 'the moon' from the mighty boosh
ZurabMelua 10 months ago 3
this guys super fuckin intelligent
astralfarts 10 months ago
lol he's dissing satch's writing
happyapple248 10 months ago
he seems to not be so fond of satch boogie and joe satriani in general. its kinda funny
wagatabuchunga1 10 months ago 6
Yeah I have had it explained a tiny bit different to this, but the same concept at the core,
Sxrule 1 year ago
jesus plays guitar!
SirFightsalot 1 year ago
I'm just wondering if rotosound strings are worth trying out on my electrics?
guitar15243 1 year ago
@guitar15243 Personal Preference question FTL
strNpwrKC 1 year ago
@guitar15243 yes Rotosound are well worth trying on your electrics. And acoustics.
JacarandaMusic 11 months ago
so goddamn well spoken :)
BostonWidowers 1 year ago
Not of this earth is a great example of a song doing this :D
Guitareben 1 year ago
The entire concept is not to simply change chords, but to change modes. Like going :I7-II7/I-I7: Would go :Mixolydian-Lydian-Mixolydian: The chords are only there to emulate the modes, so you could actually go like : IVmaj7 - iii min9- I7: (Idk, just made the progression up off the top of my head to prove a point)
bebeard17 1 year ago
you might have oversimplified the concept a bit.
zyxomma1 1 year ago
Satch Bewwwgie
TheRealAchilleZ 1 year ago
I think thats how i write music. I just fo with whatever chords sound good, I don't think of it much.
Shun101010 1 year ago
damn Guthrie talks so freaking intelligently. He's like a professor of guitar and music.
wslx0195 1 year ago
doesn't seem like a big Satriani fan ... I'm with him on that
flowerdrop1 1 year ago
@flowerdrop1 lol big assumption based on predetermined beliefs me thinks
jonw82 1 year ago
Rad
Mesa4Life 1 year ago
@crucifyme88 he isnt calling satch a liar. he is hinting towards the fact that a seasoned player such as joe probably doesn't conciously sit and think now I will compose something using pitch axis theory. it is somethng which is ingrained in his playing and he has the ability to explain the concept as pitch axis theory.another example would be any scale or mode. once you have it internalized, you are not thinking about scales and modes as you play...only music
andymcguitar 1 year ago
@andymcguitar you don't even have to be a GREAT MUSICIAN for that though. You just need the mindset that music isn't a math problem or a philosophy lecture
AOCRkid 1 year ago
@crucifyme88 I don't think he's calling Joe a liar, just saying that he wasn't necessarily overly conscious of going into the theory of pitch axis at the time of writing it. He was still entitled to go into detail about the theory of how it works in interviews.
TearTheRoofOff 1 year ago
Pitch axis learned in 1.30 mins, so yea that was helpful Guthrie
PackAPunchify 1 year ago 156
@PackAPunchify you're a pretty fast learner... now's the time for exploring ;)!
str4to 6 months ago
Comment removed
noHOPEyo 1 year ago
very cool idea, thanks whoever asked that question, i had no idea this kind of idea existed
beenozoar 1 year ago 87
JESUS
gemini51212 1 year ago
Geez those chords sound amazing linked together !
Danger05Productions 1 year ago
that was very helpful!!!!
BlazeandGrave 1 year ago
I thought it was where you use a progression of scales or chords based upon the same root note; like A Ionian followed by A Lydian followed by A Mixolydian. I could be wrong though!
twothirdsrasta 1 year ago 2
@twothirdsrasta No your spot on matey. As long as you hit say the A string as a drone or pedal tone then you can expand into different modes or unrelated chords in A which are not in the same key.It gives a sense of unpredictability.
frannyp46 1 year ago
mmkay pitch axis, open a string chord progression got it thanx
F4TB0Y69 1 year ago
haha govan youre the man
NickMercurio 1 year ago