@awesomezain77 there's a prohibition on music but they also use to sing nasheeds with the a drum being played so some scholars say the reason why nasheeds are halal is because they didn't use musical instruments other than a drum and others say it's because the content of the nasheeds was halal. So you can go with one of two opinions that music is halal as long as there are no instruments other than the drum or you can say it's halal as long as the content isn't haram.
All my practicing Muslim brothers, mute the video at the beginning so that you don't have to listen to the music in the background and then just read.
And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e.music, singing, etc.) to mislead (men) from the Path of Allah without knowledge, and takes it (the Path of Allah, the Verses of the Qur'an) by way of mockery. For such there will be a humiliating torment (in the Hell-fire).
@hamzasheikhz@hamzasheikhz Music is natural get over your self. Also only Allah swt knows what the prophet muhamed salalahu alyahi wasalam said. You devert your ways to the Quran and only this perfect book of non other than the most hight the great. Allah!
@Fadumapuma wow, dude..u cant deny the hadith and the verse from the Quran..if u don't believe on Hadith thn i'm sorry ur not Muslim..MUSIC IS FITNAH, IT'S HARAM!
"The Messenger (pbuh) of Allah (SWT) said, "Some people of my Ummah will drink wine, calling it by other name than its real name, merriment will be made for them through the playing of musical instruments and the singing of lady singers. Allah will cleave the earth under them and turn others into monkeys and swines.
"Say (O Muhammad), "No one in the heavens and the earth knows the future except God. They do not even perceive how or when they will be resurrected." 27:65
So-called Hadiths of which I don’t know if to believe or not.
"The prophet said : "Do not write down anything from me except the Quran. Whoever wrote other than that should delete it." [Sahih Muslim, Book 42, Number 7147, also Ahmed, Vol. 1, Page 171]
"And remember (O you the members of the Prophet's family, the Graces of your Rubb), that which is recited in your houses of the Verses of Allah and Al-Hikmah (i.e., Prophet's Sunnah -- legal ways, so give your thanks to Allah and glorify His Praises for this Qur'an and the Sunnah).'' (33:34)
"And whatsoever the Messenger (Muhammad (PBUH)) gives you, take it; and whatsoever he forbids you, abstain (from it)". (59:7)
"Nor does he speak of (his own) desire. It is only a Revelation that is revealed.'' (53:3,4)
"Say (O Muhammad (PBUH) to mankind): `If you (really) love Allah then follow me (i.e., accept Islamic Monotheism, follow the Qur'an and the Sunnah), Allah will love you and forgive you of your sins". (3:31)
@algerianchief & others: peace. during the time of the prophet, pbuh, apart from delivering the message of God, which is the Quran, he also played the part of the leader, as such, muslims at that time had the obligation to follow his leadership. it is absolutely dumb to conclude that it was the prophet's duty or even ability show practical examples of every possible scenario for rest of time, Quran explicitly claims that it is the guidance and criteria, & it has all examples, and.. cont...
you denying the sunnah is putting you at risk of coming out of the folds of islam my friend, Ie kuffr, I will give you the benifit of the doubt that you are ignorant, so I advise you to study the science of the hadith.. mean while ponder on the following verses:
@algerianchief ..cont.. Quran explicitly claims that it IS the guidance and criteria, & it has all examples, and NOTHING HAS BEEN LEFT OUT OF IT. It is absolutely astounding, how dumb and arrogant of 'muslims' to ignore explicit claim of the Quran for sole authority for guidance, and to concoct and uphold this fairy tale system called the hadith and sunnah which in essence competes with God's authority. Naudhubillah.
Ok no need for the hadith books right? Ok soo how did you learn how to pray?? it doesn't say in the quran how many raqaats each salah is, neither does it say the wordings to use, so could you please clarify for people how you learned that?
@algerianchief , ok, why don't YOU show me all the hadith references on which YOU base your salah? I want from start to finish of every single detail of YOUR prayer.
Who wrong or right is matter. But Koran is more important in our life and Hadith are where Muhammad doing that good for us are written. Some hadith been faken by some evil people. We didnt sure it TOTAL sin or not. What should you guys end is a conflict between Syiah and Sunnah. ㅂㅂ
Narrated Abu Amir or Abu Malik Al Ashari that he heard the Prophet saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of *Musical Instruments*, as lawful. Allah will destroy them during the night and will let the mountain fall on them,(And its a very long hadith)
[Sahih Al-Bukhari Vol.7 Hadith No.5590] THE END :-)
@onlinefriend4ever So you belive this hadith over the Quran, which says (interpretation of Quran 45:6) "These are the ayaths of Allah, which we recite to you with truth. Then in WHICH HADITH after Allah and his ayaths will they belive?". And there are other similar verses in the Quran. Bro / Sister, we all want to follow the true religion, please open your heart and mind to the message of the Quran, i.A. you will see that the Quran is the only source of guidance and Hadiths are a corruption.
You cant follow just quran without Hadith's of Prophet Muhammed(pbuh).
Allah have told us in the Quran he has completed our religion for us,And also will guard it from coruption,The teaching of Allah and his Rasul(saw)can never get corrpted.
You cant follow just Quran without hadith,Islam is not just Quran,Islam is Quran and Hadith's of Prophet(pbuh).
Where do it say in the Quran HOW 2 OFFER SALAH? HOW TO DO HAJJ? HOW MUCH CHARITY TO GIVE?
@onlinefriend4ever So you believe in this hadith over the Quran which says (interpretation of 45:6) "These are the ayaths of Allah, which we recite to you in truth. Then in WHICH HADITH after Allah and his ayaths will they belive?". We all want to follow the true religion, please open your heart and mind to the simple message of the Quran, insha Allah you will see that Quran is the only guide, and that the hadith system as a whole is corruption and deviation from the true religion. -Peace.
I ask everyone to ponder the Quran, it explicitly claims that it IS the only guidance and criteria, and that it is complete, protected, and is a mercy. WHY WOULD THE MERCIFUL GOD LEAVE MUSLIMS AT THE MERCY OF TOTALLY CORRUPTABLE SYSTEM OF HADITHS? (and provan corrupt by the very people who uphold them, as they themselves class them as 'authentic', and 'fabricated' and various degrees inbetween).
Glory be to God, from what they associate as parners with him!!!
Jazak Allah for the nice video 93Omair. Masha Allah, the internet is providing a forum for all those sensible Muslims to fight against the hijackers of religion, who have for centuries corrupted and packaged and re-packaged 'islam', and have made it into so many sects, that is far from the simple and beautiful deen God sent down.
@NWONoWorldOrderNWO OK Relax I forgive, Scholars never open Quran all they do is justify hadiths with ambiguous translations from Quran. They don't realize that you don't have to be a super-intelligent man to understand quran
@NWONoWorldOrderNWO can you please just show the quran to that "Imam"? I mean the verse I mentioned. And record the video and post it here. That would be interesting
@NWONoWorldOrderNWO Well, the problem is don't reply them the way they reply to you. Be different from them. I went to numerous Hadither forums. Whenever I asked them that did you even read the Quranic verse 6:114? They just shifted to another topic and started to use words like kaafir, etc. After reading Quran I literally hate all these "Islamic" Scholars for misleading anyone.
@NWONoWorldOrderNWO I never said music is haram. There is nothing in Quran against it. However you think just using the word "fuck" makes you cool. But offending someone for no reason is a good reason for not calling you a muslim.
@NWONoWorldOrderNWO I got my life when I discovered Quran instead of hadith. I got my life by opening the quran and finding the answer to "How do you find details of prayer" question. You are the real kaffir. Read the verse 6:114. You are a threat to yourself.
Salam Alaikum, very impressive video. However, I disagree with author concerning the Hadith being corrupted. Important part of this video message is if one convinces someone else to be disobedient to Allah Subhana Wa Tala using the "nice talk and good manners", does that make "nice talk and good manners" prohibited?
Salam Alaikum brother. Thank you for this excellent example. Glorious Quran IS our FIRST reference. Also, as Muslims we must show respect for authentic Hadith. There are generations of righteous people who dedicated their lives to gather the documents about the life of our beloved prophet Muhammad (S.A.S).
When we have example where Hadith forbids something that is not forbidden by Quran, I believe there might be a misinterpretation of Hadith itself or even a corruption of that particular part of Hadith (not whole Hadith).
However I think that rare examples like this must not make Muslims go away from Hadith as this is our SECOND reference.
The THIRD reference is our scholars. If the SECOND or THIRD reference contradict to Glorious Quran, naturally we stick with Glorious Quran. Yet, it is important to pay respect to Sai Hadith too.
@SuperDedara I respect their enthusiasm, they might had good intentions but it is NOONE's business to explore it. Quran is our only reference only. If we have quran we don't need hadith. Are you gonna use primary school textbook when you have an encyclopedia? Definitely not
@MegaMrname .. so to you the QURAN is like a PRIMARY SCHOOL TEXT BOOK??? another insult on the QURAN huh? you guys are really good at insulting ALLAH.. the Quran and the Prophet Mohammad..
please tell me what has this Bukhari gang of 6 perverts offered you which ALLAH can not deliver..
@QuranVsHadith Arhgg why are you misunderstanding me? I am a muslim just like you. I don't believe in any hadith. Please don't judge me before reading all my comments. I am muslim, not hadither
@QuranVsHadith You're welcome, by the way realizing the tricks of "scholars" was the turning point in the understanding in islam. they use emotions "where to put my hands" bullshit to lead us astray. Where are you supposed to put your hands while praying? They need to take pre-introductory anatomy course...
@NaBjE11 I swear to god You are claiming that you cannot pray using quran only without reading for it. There are more than 50 verses showing how to pray. The modern sunni prayer is full of useless additions.
No emotional sentences, no baseless things, only quranic verses with references. If you don't believe pick up quran and check it out. I am sure you wasted your life using hadith books when there is QURAN
@NaBjE11 you are lazy, the video in my reply mentioned lots of things. You are brave "enough" to claim quran is incomplete. This is just one verse 17:78:
"Establish prayer at the decline of the sun [from its meridian] until the darkness of the night and [also] the Qur'an of dawn. Indeed, the recitation of dawn is ever witnessed."
17:79: "And from [part of] the night, pray with it as additional [worship] for you; it is expected that your Lord will resurrect you to a praised station."
@NaBjE11 Can you show me the verse where it says music is haram?
Are you gonna tell me the "idle tales" verse? Does God know less than you? He could have used music if it needed. Idle tales are narrations, and other things, it can be even hadiths. And let's assume that there is music used instead of idle tales. Still music is not haram because the rest of the verse says "in order to mislead people". So can use music not to mislead people. Get up, grow up, educate yourself.
The Day of Resurrection draws near, None besides Allah can avert it, (or advance it, or delay it). Do you then wonder at this recital (the Qur'an)? And you laugh at it and weep not, Wasting your (precious) lifetime in pastime and amusements (singing, etc.). So fall you down in prostration to Allah, and worship Him (Alone).
The Day of Resurrection draws near, None besides Allah can avert it, (or advance it, or delay it). Do you then wonder at this recital (the Qur'an)? And you laugh at it and weep not, Wasting your (precious) lifetime in pastime and amusements (singing, etc.). So fall you down in prostration to Allah, and worship Him (Alone).
Ignore MegaMrname - Hadith rejectors should be ignored!
He is someone that will adjust verses to suit his desires. This particular desire of his is listening to music. He is clearly too weak to stop it, like so many others have done. It's not easy, but it can be done.
Read the Biography of our beloved Prophet (SAW) and you will read Allah (SWT) made the prophet faint twice, to avoid his blessed ears from hearing haram music. Many other ahadith exist and some also say a verse of the Qur'an.
@IslamTheLoveOfMyLife Hey Did you even read a quran once in your life??? You are dumb. I am sorry, no offence. I literally SAW reference concerning praying. You just don't follow quran you worship hadiths.
@IslamTheLoveOfMyLife Instead of looking stupid GO AHEAD get QURAN. Then come here, YOU WILL HATE HADITHS AND ALL THESE "GREATEST SCHOLARS". GOOD LUCK
@IslamTheLoveOfMyLife Hahahahaahahahahah I NEVER LISTEN to music. Not because it is "forbidden" Just because I don't like music. But it doesnt mean it is forbidden. Sorry I have to expose you. You do to much fictinal-stereotyping. Get a life
Anyone, Please do not be scared of Quran. Do not worry it will not assault/hit/strike/kick/torture/eat you. Just read it. So are you thinking that if there were no hadith collectors Prophet's job would be incomplete? No, these are people just did mistake when trying to look cool. As If someone wants to convert Islam. He says shahadah first. Then tries to collect hadith from little by little to learn to pray? You are just too lazy to read Quran! Hadiths can be good, but most of them are a JOKE
@IslamTheLoveOfMyLife I am proud to know that people like you are among this ummah. May Allah reward you.
Just a thought for the people who say that the hadith are not valid. In the quran we are told to pray. Does that mean we can pray any way we like? Can we pray like the people of other religion by offering humans as sacrifice? It says that we should pay zakat. Does that mean we can give it any way we want and that we can pay any amount and let that be the fulfilling of our duty?
SALAH IS CLEARLY A MUSIC,HOW CAN ANYONE HERE PROHIBIT MUSIC? SALAH IS UNDENIABLY A MUSIC IT HAS MELODY,HARMONY AND RHYTHM.IT IS QUITE UNDERSTANDABLE THAT IDLE TALES MENTIONED IS SEEN IN THE TRENDS OF SOCIETY LIKE FADS,FASHIONS AND CRAZE JUST LIKE IDOLATRY,NO MUSLIM SCHOLAR HAS EVER UNDERSTAND MUSIC,HOW COULD THEY REJECT IT?
@missmillionmaker iF I say Candy is Haram are you just goin to believe that easily? of course you will look for the reason. Now I will Ask you Why Tamborine is Halal? what makes it Halal compare to other Music Instruments?WAs it just beacuse it approves by the Prophet pbuh when girls has welcomed him?then it would follow that Muhammad is A Sex-Maniac?But I dont think so.If Muhammed appreciates Duff Why not for other Instruments?or I will give you easy question why Duff is halal & bonggo is not?
@mayergenuiseprincess stupid example , "If I say candy is haram" . Are you even a muslim ? There are hadiths that mention duff is allowed on Eid, weddings, and when one who has been away returns. And who are you that I should listen to because you say something is haraam. The prophet Mohammed(Peace be upon him ) himself said in a hadith that it is haraam , I dont need any one like you to tell me what is right or wrong.
@IslamTheLoveOfMyLife Nope. Theres only one idiot here and I'm sure we all know who that is.
Sunnis today remain stagnant in their beliefs. Theres no moving forward and thats why Sunni Islam is stuck in the dark ages aka the 8th century when ahadith collections were compiled by various Persian Imams.
Also I've replied to you numerous times before on this video but you always run away. If you want, lets start again, starting from why ahadith are barbaric, retarded, illogical, anti-women etc.
And whoever OBEYS ALLAH AND THE MESSENGER - those will be with the ones upon whom Allah has bestowed favor of the prophets, the steadfast affirmers of truth, the martyrs and the righteous. And excellent are those as companions. [4:69]
And abide in your houses and do not display yourselves as [was] the display of the former times of ignorance. And establish prayer and give zakah and OBEY ALLAH AND HIS MESSENGER. Allah intends only to remove from you the impurity [of sin], O people of the [Prophet's] household, and to purify you with [extensive] purification. [33:33]
The bedouins say, "We have believed." Say, "You have not [yet] believed; but say [instead], 'We have submitted,' for faith has not yet entered your hearts. And if you OBEY ALLAH AND HIS MESSENGER, He will not deprive you from your deeds of anything. Indeed, Allah is Forgiving and Merciful." [49:14]
@rahilhabib Is this is a joke? Obey Allah and his messener. Does this mean follow hadith?
I follow Quran it is haqq. What is hadith? one of the five pillars of Islam? NO! Referenced in Quran? No! Believe me I was believing hadiths. But I just asked myself where is it even recommended? Hadiths are not from messenger. If it was they wouldn't be "updated" OK "God has sent you this book FULLY DETAILED". Why do these dumb people tell hadith are "how-to-do-it"? Get some common sense. Then reasoning
@MegaMrname u say hadith have no ties to islam but what about scholars who have studied the hadith and declared their authenticity tracing to the prophet pbuh
@skatetennis123 I show you an example: Sahih Bukhari is written on 9th century. You say it is authentic then it means that islam between 7th and 9th century was "incomplete"? Who gave scholars authority to "investigate" his sayings? Why do we need "these" scholars to investigate sayings? Does Quran say that wait 200 hundred years for Bukhari for Islam to be completed? Get some sense in your head (no offence)
They are doing just as the various ahadith told us they would do. Trying to make the haram into halal, to please thier desires in dunya. The same way an alcoholic will say "one drink is ok" - Not only that, they are doing it on Youtube so they can lead others astray.
@IslamTheLoveOfMyLife ANd you think you are being a "cool" guy buy giving an Islam an ascetic image? I never drunk never smoked, never fornicated with one word always stay away from thing which are haram. But you sir think that by claiming anything you want as "haram" will make you cool... No it wont
@IslamTheLoveOfMyLife It seems you are blindly following what "majority" does. Please watch this video youtube.com/watch?v=YbOxyNp8sok&feature=fvwrel :-)
Music is haram is Islam,,he who says otherwise is rebel against allah and the prophet(saw),,The quran is only to be explained by the prophet(saw)...I dont wich sufi u've read but mutah marriages are forbidden is Islam as well. Dont know what kind of rules u came up with by urself.
WRONG! You can't interpret the Qur'an yourself! You MUST follow the opinions of the prophet Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wassalam, his companions, the tabi'i, and the tabi'i tabi'een. THEY were the ones who were there when the Qur'an was revealed so they understood its context WAY better than we do! Yes, Allah subhanahu wata'ala's laws may be clear but we may not understand them still! We are only humans after all and our imaan is definitely not up to par with those who were before us!
If you accept ahadith, then it is haram. That is clear. If you deny ahadith (Which takes you out of the fold of Islam) then some "modern" wishy-washy Muslims would say it is lawful.
@islamictvdotcom The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Among my ummah there will certainly be people who permit zinaa, silk, alcohol and musical instruments…” (Narrated by al-Bukhaari ta’leeqan, no. 5590; narrated as mawsool by al-Tabaraani and al-Bayhaqi. See al-Silsilah al-Saheehah by al-Albaani, 91).
I ll challenge everyone here those who says Music is Haram, DEFINE WHAT IS MUSIC first. call any scholar, call your Naik. Hey Mr.Naik debate here, I know you dont know Music, You are rejecting a thing you dont know. everybody!!! WHAT IS MUSIC???
ok this is a very touchy subject an may Allah forgive us..i am muslim myself..i write songs becoz i enjoy it but on the other hand i know that der are alot of things in life which we enjoy but are no good for us.... i feel that music has a message an that message can be evil or good but they say instruments can change your heart which i do believe..they course us to experience different emotions ...is music haraam?? i will never know
@TheCardz17 I agree with you.please visit my video too I defend that Salah is even a music.I am very absolute i this thing.Salah itself has a melody, and anything that has melody comes out naturaly a harmony and any melody runs a particular rhythm.
@teedonster2 How Could you say Music is Haram when Salah itself is a Music? thats Undeniable fact. SALAH IS A MUSIC regardless of any reference Qur`an,Bible,Tanakh, Hadeeth, Tafseer, Vedas.
-Non-Muslim:Music student from Conservatory Who Heared Salah as he passed by; strange!but thats a Music, still it was a music.
-Muslim who Study Music; Music is Not Haram ,after all I realized Salah is Music.
-Muslim who hate Music but study music for the sake of knowing the Truth: Ohh i reaized that even Salah is really really a music,but i need to Accept that it is Haram(a forcible matter for him,No faculty of reason is needed)
@teedonster2 "This video is dumb" - baseless accusation.
What do you mean influenced by the west? Music has existed for 1000s of years across all continents and cultures and still does. The only country where music is scarce is Saudi Arabia due to the idiotic Mullahs that run the country.
There's no verse in the Quran that forbids music. Did you even watch the video?
@teedonster2 Err no. Bukhari et al prohibits music not the Quran. If music was indeed so terrifingly bad, then the Quran would have said so (which would have been highly illogical) since music has existed for milleniums.
Please don't compare Zina and murder in the same league as music. Music is a blessing from Allah, a work of art. Never could it be forbidden in al-Furqaan.
And the only muslims who are "wishy-washy" are those that believe poetry is haram (Sahih Muslim 28:5611) or that the Prophet allowed temporary marriage for the Sahaba Sahih Muslim 8:3243 + Sahih Muslim 8:3252 - these ahadith paint women as sex objects)
If you are interested in more absurd ahadith, then PM me :)
@e17jack Those Ahadith regarding Temporary Marriage was later abrogated by other Sahih Ahadith. Mutah was one of the Pre-Islamic practice and in the early days it was allowed like many other things such a Alcohol, Gambling. But slowly they were abrogated. Anyway are you saying these Ahadith are fabricated?
@ByChoiceMuslim Did you read the ahadith? In them Muhammad ALLOWS the SAHABA to practise Mutah marriage while they were travelling. He could have easily prevented them.
Anyway, I'm not going to go into the absurdity of verses abrogating other Quranic verses as it's a long subject.
And yes many ahadith a fabricated. The Quran speaks against the following of other ahadith. Sayings found within the 6 main Hadith books (Sahih Sittah) themselves contain absurdity i.e examples I posted above.
This usually occurs during puberty (around 11-15), but can also occur before that, such as occurred with ‘Isa (as), upon birth. Therefore, you COULD marry at any age. Nearly never, however, would this be at the "mature" (18+) phase. I would say, wiki up the word "mature", and become mature.
Yes, I did read it, but not only that, i.e. I also understood what I read.
From (4:6) it can clearly be understood to imply that you can marry when the age of marriage is reached, which is when you find “sound judgment” in the partner. “Sound judgment” simply means that you can think logically and judge between matters.
For the sake of the sunna/islam, this video should either be deleted, or it deserves a lot of thumbs down.
Bukhari :: Book 7 :: Volume 69 :: Hadith 494
Narrated Abu 'Amir or Abu Malik Al-Ash'ari:
that he heard the Prophet saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical instruments, as lawful."
that he heard the Prophet saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical instruments, as lawful."
@e17jack I follow the Sunna brother, I hope you do too. I don't follow any scholars, never, only the information they provide, if it is, verified, to be the sunna.
@1submittingtothe1God I follow the only Sunnah that is mentioned in the Quran - Allah's Sunnah, the Quran.
And no I don't follow the manmade Sunnah aka "Muhammad's Sunnah" that was founded and authorised by Sunni scholars. It was verified by Sunni scholars 200 years after the death of Muhammad.
Some really deluded Sunnis here. Idle talk does not mean music LOL no matter how you try to justify it.
The word translated to "Idle Talk" in 31:6 is "Hadith". Hadith does not mean music. Talk about ignorance and purposely distorting quranic words
"And from the people, there are those who accept baseless narrations (Hadith) to mislead from the path of God without knowledge, and they take it as entertainment. These will have a humiliating retribution" (31:6)
According to islamic professors and their translation, i.e. Dr Muhammed Taqi-ud-Din Al-Hilali and Dr. Muhammad Muhsin Khan, "Lehwel Hadeeth" is translated as "idle talks". The two, even noted that this refers to both music and singing and other such things which are characterized as being "idle". Music can be categorized as "idle" because it is not overall important or beneficial for us. Besides that, please read this following hadeeth completely...
@e17jack Narrated Abu 'Amir or Abu Malik Al-Ash'ari:
That he heard the Prophet saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical instruments, as lawful."
@1submittingtothe1God idle talk does not only mean music. it actually refers to any kind of conversation or words that are vain. in bukhari there are also hadith where prophet Muhammad (s.a.w) allowed singing in the day of the eid and weddings. so u cant really say its haram but u can say its makruh.
No, brother, did you even read the hadeeth yourself? It is as follows:
Narrated Aisha:
Abu Bakr came to my house while two small Ansari girls were singing beside me the stories of the Ansar concerning the Day of Buath. And they were not singers. Abu Bakr said protestingly, "Musical instruments of Satan in the house of Allah's Apostle !" It happened on the 'Id day and Allah's Apostle said, "O Abu Bakr! There is an 'Id for every nation and this is our 'Id."
@1submittingtothe1God Yes bro, it doesnt matter. We all know its haram for women who have reached puberty sing in public. The matter here is the Prophet (S.AW.) allowed them to sing and play instrument because its the day of the eid.
@syazwankhan Good brother, I'm pleased with you. But this was the matter however, maybe you forget, because look at the title of the video. It is not very specific then I think.
In fact, if so, what you say, then I can tell you this:
There is no point to mention that singing is permissible for young kids because:
ANYTHING IS PERMISSIBLE FOR PEOPLE BELOW PUBERTY
By the way, the capital letters are used for emphasis, not to point out anger or such.
@1submittingtothe1God Yes anything is permissible for kids, but according to our deen, we have to educate our kids and make them practice Islam since young. The purpose of this hadith is to show that Islam is not narrow, Muslims are allowed to sing and play some instruments on the day of the eid as long as the lyrics are halal.
@syazwankhan It is very true, brother, that we have to educate our kids aright. I agree upon that entirely. But then you changed direction, by saying that it is allowed to sing and play instruments for Muslims, in general, thus. This is incorrect, I showed you the hadeeth. They were NO SINGERS, musical instruments are haram as well, which I showed with the other hadeeth. The only exception is that a *KID* can do that, on the 'eed, because it is 'eed (feast) so they left them to continue instead.
Another example of this same principle, is that Aisha, who was 9, was allowed to play with dolls, which is haram, but the prophet left her because she was, as I said, she was 9.
@syazwankhan No, girls reach puberty at the age of 11ish so or 13, earlier than boys, yes. However, it does not mean that if the prophet (saw) married her and she was not an adolescent, yet, that it is haram. You can marry at any age, however, sexual intercourse must be done only after puberty.
@1submittingtothe1God Lol! So I can marry a one year old kid and have sex with her after she hits puberty! Unfortunately many retarded mullahs agree with you.
According to ahadith, Muhammad married a 6 year old girl and had sex with her at the age of 9.
The Quran says only mature people can get married. 9 year old girls (let alone 6 year olds) are not mature. According to ahadith, Muhammad was a pedophile and you and many other Sunnis try to justify it.
How can you pray, if this is not described in detail in the quran? Where does it say Muhammed had intercourse with her on her 9th?
If you think about what I said, it makes sense. You don't even understand what marrying means. You probably only consider it to be about sexual intercourse.
You are lost.
The messages that I sent you on your profile should make it clear to you to follow the Sunna! Surely, you lost yourself.
DISLIKED. DISLIKED.
HeatSeakingMouse 4 days ago
can anyone tell me any hadith or quranic verse saying that music is haram or halal? plzz
awesomezain77 1 month ago
@awesomezain77 there's a prohibition on music but they also use to sing nasheeds with the a drum being played so some scholars say the reason why nasheeds are halal is because they didn't use musical instruments other than a drum and others say it's because the content of the nasheeds was halal. So you can go with one of two opinions that music is halal as long as there are no instruments other than the drum or you can say it's halal as long as the content isn't haram.
discolimonade12 3 weeks ago
@awesomezain77 قول رسول الله _صلى الله عليه وسلم_: "ليكونن من أمتي أقوام يستحلون الحر والحرير والخمر والمعازف..."
suparmohammed1997 3 weeks ago
@suparmohammed1997 err what language are u speaking?
awesomezain77 3 weeks ago
@awesomezain77 Arabic!!!
suparmohammed1997 3 weeks ago
@awesomezain77 "There will be among my ummah people who will regard, silk, alcohol and musical instruments ..." here's the translation
suparmohammed1997 3 weeks ago
All my practicing Muslim brothers, mute the video at the beginning so that you don't have to listen to the music in the background and then just read.
Asemahdi3 1 month ago
this video is based upon own thinking,,, so therefore not accepted
hasan1429 1 month ago
Surah Luqman, Verse # 6
And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e.music, singing, etc.) to mislead (men) from the Path of Allah without knowledge, and takes it (the Path of Allah, the Verses of the Qur'an) by way of mockery. For such there will be a humiliating torment (in the Hell-fire).
hamzasheikhz 1 month ago
@hamzasheikhz @hamzasheikhz Music is natural get over your self. Also only Allah swt knows what the prophet muhamed salalahu alyahi wasalam said. You devert your ways to the Quran and only this perfect book of non other than the most hight the great. Allah!
Fadumapuma 1 month ago
@Fadumapuma wow, dude..u cant deny the hadith and the verse from the Quran..if u don't believe on Hadith thn i'm sorry ur not Muslim..MUSIC IS FITNAH, IT'S HARAM!
hamzasheikhz 1 month ago
"The Messenger (pbuh) of Allah (SWT) said, "Some people of my Ummah will drink wine, calling it by other name than its real name, merriment will be made for them through the playing of musical instruments and the singing of lady singers. Allah will cleave the earth under them and turn others into monkeys and swines.
Ibn Ma'jah Vol.5 Hadith No.4020
hamzasheikhz 1 month ago
@hamzasheikhz
QURAN
"Say (O Muhammad), "No one in the heavens and the earth knows the future except God. They do not even perceive how or when they will be resurrected." 27:65
So-called Hadiths of which I don’t know if to believe or not.
"The prophet said : "Do not write down anything from me except the Quran. Whoever wrote other than that should delete it." [Sahih Muslim, Book 42, Number 7147, also Ahmed, Vol. 1, Page 171]
yourfriendbest123 1 month ago
"And remember (O you the members of the Prophet's family, the Graces of your Rubb), that which is recited in your houses of the Verses of Allah and Al-Hikmah (i.e., Prophet's Sunnah -- legal ways, so give your thanks to Allah and glorify His Praises for this Qur'an and the Sunnah).'' (33:34)
algerianchief 2 months ago
"(And) if you differ in anything amongst yourselves, refer it to Allah and His Messenger (PBUH)". (4:59)
"He who obeys the Messenger (Muhammad (PBUH)), has indeed obeyed Allah.'' (4:80)
"And verily, you (O Muhammad (PBUH)) are indeed guiding (mankind) to the Straight Path (i.e., Allah's Deen of Islamic Monotheism):. (42:52)
algerianchief 2 months ago
"And whatsoever the Messenger (Muhammad (PBUH)) gives you, take it; and whatsoever he forbids you, abstain (from it)". (59:7)
"Nor does he speak of (his own) desire. It is only a Revelation that is revealed.'' (53:3,4)
"Say (O Muhammad (PBUH) to mankind): `If you (really) love Allah then follow me (i.e., accept Islamic Monotheism, follow the Qur'an and the Sunnah), Allah will love you and forgive you of your sins". (3:31)
algerianchief 2 months ago
@algerianchief
Taken out of context. This verse is about the spoils of war etc. Please read the verses ahead and following,
Please dont "manipulate" verses just to prove a point. Fear God.
yourfriendbest123 1 month ago
@algerianchief & others: peace. during the time of the prophet, pbuh, apart from delivering the message of God, which is the Quran, he also played the part of the leader, as such, muslims at that time had the obligation to follow his leadership. it is absolutely dumb to conclude that it was the prophet's duty or even ability show practical examples of every possible scenario for rest of time, Quran explicitly claims that it is the guidance and criteria, & it has all examples, and.. cont...
FairGoF 1 month ago
you denying the sunnah is putting you at risk of coming out of the folds of islam my friend, Ie kuffr, I will give you the benifit of the doubt that you are ignorant, so I advise you to study the science of the hadith.. mean while ponder on the following verses:
algerianchief 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@algerianchief ..cont.. Quran explicitly claims that it IS the guidance and criteria, & it has all examples, and NOTHING HAS BEEN LEFT OUT OF IT. It is absolutely astounding, how dumb and arrogant of 'muslims' to ignore explicit claim of the Quran for sole authority for guidance, and to concoct and uphold this fairy tale system called the hadith and sunnah which in essence competes with God's authority. Naudhubillah.
FairGoF 1 month ago
Ok no need for the hadith books right? Ok soo how did you learn how to pray?? it doesn't say in the quran how many raqaats each salah is, neither does it say the wordings to use, so could you please clarify for people how you learned that?
algerianchief 2 months ago
@algerianchief , ok, why don't YOU show me all the hadith references on which YOU base your salah? I want from start to finish of every single detail of YOUR prayer.
FairGoF 1 month ago
i totally agree with the point ur making!!!!
thnx i just watched a video that says music is haram and his points where not conceivable at all!!!!!!
im not saying all music are good duh cause musics with bad language is bad!!!!
nargesf 2 months ago
Who wrong or right is matter. But Koran is more important in our life and Hadith are where Muhammad doing that good for us are written. Some hadith been faken by some evil people. We didnt sure it TOTAL sin or not. What should you guys end is a conflict between Syiah and Sunnah. ㅂㅂ
DeDanielAOM 2 months ago
Narrated Abu Amir or Abu Malik Al Ashari that he heard the Prophet saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of *Musical Instruments*, as lawful. Allah will destroy them during the night and will let the mountain fall on them,(And its a very long hadith)
[Sahih Al-Bukhari Vol.7 Hadith No.5590] THE END :-)
onlinefriend4ever 2 months ago
@onlinefriend4ever So you belive this hadith over the Quran, which says (interpretation of Quran 45:6) "These are the ayaths of Allah, which we recite to you with truth. Then in WHICH HADITH after Allah and his ayaths will they belive?". And there are other similar verses in the Quran. Bro / Sister, we all want to follow the true religion, please open your heart and mind to the message of the Quran, i.A. you will see that the Quran is the only source of guidance and Hadiths are a corruption.
FairGoF 2 months ago in playlist Hadith prohibitions
@FairGoF Your lost,Seriously your misguided...
You cant follow just quran without Hadith's of Prophet Muhammed(pbuh).
Allah have told us in the Quran he has completed our religion for us,And also will guard it from coruption,The teaching of Allah and his Rasul(saw)can never get corrpted.
You cant follow just Quran without hadith,Islam is not just Quran,Islam is Quran and Hadith's of Prophet(pbuh).
Where do it say in the Quran HOW 2 OFFER SALAH? HOW TO DO HAJJ? HOW MUCH CHARITY TO GIVE?
onlinefriend4ever 2 months ago
@FairGoF Not all hadiths are evil, but it cannot go against the Qu'ran, or else it'd be false.
It's gotta be backed by the Qu'ran.
Qu'ran first, then hadith.
foz77 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@onlinefriend4ever So you believe in this hadith over the Quran which says (interpretation of 45:6) "These are the ayaths of Allah, which we recite to you in truth. Then in WHICH HADITH after Allah and his ayaths will they belive?". We all want to follow the true religion, please open your heart and mind to the simple message of the Quran, insha Allah you will see that Quran is the only guide, and that the hadith system as a whole is corruption and deviation from the true religion. -Peace.
FairGoF 2 months ago in playlist Hadith prohibitions
I ask everyone to ponder the Quran, it explicitly claims that it IS the only guidance and criteria, and that it is complete, protected, and is a mercy. WHY WOULD THE MERCIFUL GOD LEAVE MUSLIMS AT THE MERCY OF TOTALLY CORRUPTABLE SYSTEM OF HADITHS? (and provan corrupt by the very people who uphold them, as they themselves class them as 'authentic', and 'fabricated' and various degrees inbetween).
Glory be to God, from what they associate as parners with him!!!
FairGoF 2 months ago in playlist Hadith prohibitions
Jazak Allah for the nice video 93Omair. Masha Allah, the internet is providing a forum for all those sensible Muslims to fight against the hijackers of religion, who have for centuries corrupted and packaged and re-packaged 'islam', and have made it into so many sects, that is far from the simple and beautiful deen God sent down.
FairGoF 2 months ago in playlist Hadith prohibitions
thank you for the wonderful video.. PEACE.. its time to EXPOSE Hadithers of what they actually are PERVERTS
QuranVsHadith 2 months ago in playlist Hadith prohibitions
@NWONoWorldOrderNWO May Allah help you, I feel ashamed of these people who call themselves muslims yet throwing dirt at Islam
MegaMrname 2 months ago
@NWONoWorldOrderNWO OK Relax I forgive, Scholars never open Quran all they do is justify hadiths with ambiguous translations from Quran. They don't realize that you don't have to be a super-intelligent man to understand quran
MegaMrname 2 months ago
@NWONoWorldOrderNWO can you please just show the quran to that "Imam"? I mean the verse I mentioned. And record the video and post it here. That would be interesting
MegaMrname 2 months ago
@NWONoWorldOrderNWO Well, the problem is don't reply them the way they reply to you. Be different from them. I went to numerous Hadither forums. Whenever I asked them that did you even read the Quranic verse 6:114? They just shifted to another topic and started to use words like kaafir, etc. After reading Quran I literally hate all these "Islamic" Scholars for misleading anyone.
MegaMrname 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@NWONoWorldOrderNWO I never said music is haram. There is nothing in Quran against it. However you think just using the word "fuck" makes you cool. But offending someone for no reason is a good reason for not calling you a muslim.
MegaMrname 2 months ago
Comment removed
MegaMrname 2 months ago
@NWONoWorldOrderNWO I got my life when I discovered Quran instead of hadith. I got my life by opening the quran and finding the answer to "How do you find details of prayer" question. You are the real kaffir. Read the verse 6:114. You are a threat to yourself.
MegaMrname 2 months ago
Salam Alaikum, very impressive video. However, I disagree with author concerning the Hadith being corrupted. Important part of this video message is if one convinces someone else to be disobedient to Allah Subhana Wa Tala using the "nice talk and good manners", does that make "nice talk and good manners" prohibited?
SuperDedara 2 months ago
@SuperDedara Greetings, Dear brother please read the verse 6:114. It literally says that. GOD REVEALES HIS MESSAGE IN A FORM OF A BOOK.
Not hadith, not "narrations" not any other crap.
MegaMrname 2 months ago
@MegaMrname
Salam Alaikum brother. Thank you for this excellent example. Glorious Quran IS our FIRST reference. Also, as Muslims we must show respect for authentic Hadith. There are generations of righteous people who dedicated their lives to gather the documents about the life of our beloved prophet Muhammad (S.A.S).
SuperDedara 2 months ago
Comment removed
SuperDedara 2 months ago
Comment removed
SuperDedara 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@MegaMrname
When we have example where Hadith forbids something that is not forbidden by Quran, I believe there might be a misinterpretation of Hadith itself or even a corruption of that particular part of Hadith (not whole Hadith).
However I think that rare examples like this must not make Muslims go away from Hadith as this is our SECOND reference.
SuperDedara 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@MegaMrname
The THIRD reference is our scholars. If the SECOND or THIRD reference contradict to Glorious Quran, naturally we stick with Glorious Quran. Yet, it is important to pay respect to Sai Hadith too.
JazakAllah.
SuperDedara 2 months ago
@SuperDedara I respect their enthusiasm, they might had good intentions but it is NOONE's business to explore it. Quran is our only reference only. If we have quran we don't need hadith. Are you gonna use primary school textbook when you have an encyclopedia? Definitely not
MegaMrname 2 months ago
@MegaMrname .. so to you the QURAN is like a PRIMARY SCHOOL TEXT BOOK??? another insult on the QURAN huh? you guys are really good at insulting ALLAH.. the Quran and the Prophet Mohammad..
please tell me what has this Bukhari gang of 6 perverts offered you which ALLAH can not deliver..
QuranVsHadith 2 months ago in playlist Hadith prohibitions
@QuranVsHadith Arhgg why are you misunderstanding me? I am a muslim just like you. I don't believe in any hadith. Please don't judge me before reading all my comments. I am muslim, not hadither
MegaMrname 2 months ago
@MegaMrname .. I Apologize in that case.. your comment did sound kinda bad... maybe you were being sarcastic.. in that case ..I misunderstood..
Again I apologize..
Peace
QuranVsHadith 2 months ago
@QuranVsHadith You're welcome, by the way realizing the tricks of "scholars" was the turning point in the understanding in islam. they use emotions "where to put my hands" bullshit to lead us astray. Where are you supposed to put your hands while praying? They need to take pre-introductory anatomy course...
MegaMrname 2 months ago
@MegaMrname Then how would you know when to pray how many rakaahs?hadj?the 5 pillars of islam ha?
NaBjE11 2 months ago
@NaBjE11 I swear to god You are claiming that you cannot pray using quran only without reading for it. There are more than 50 verses showing how to pray. The modern sunni prayer is full of useless additions.
MegaMrname 2 months ago
@MegaMrname check the channer quranvshadith.
No emotional sentences, no baseless things, only quranic verses with references. If you don't believe pick up quran and check it out. I am sure you wasted your life using hadith books when there is QURAN
MegaMrname 2 months ago
@MegaMrname what time? other things wich we know from the hadith explain that?
NaBjE11 2 months ago
@NaBjE11 you are lazy, the video in my reply mentioned lots of things. You are brave "enough" to claim quran is incomplete. This is just one verse 17:78:
"Establish prayer at the decline of the sun [from its meridian] until the darkness of the night and [also] the Qur'an of dawn. Indeed, the recitation of dawn is ever witnessed."
17:79: "And from [part of] the night, pray with it as additional [worship] for you; it is expected that your Lord will resurrect you to a praised station."
MegaMrname 2 months ago
@MegaMrname I didnt say qoran is incomplete you just made that put,stop thinking ffor me.
NaBjE11 2 months ago
@NaBjE11 Ok, If you believe Quran is complete and self-consistent, then why the hell do you need hadith? Quran forbids hadith
MegaMrname 2 months ago
@MegaMrname elbachar i said even in the koran it says music is haram
NaBjE11 2 months ago
@NaBjE11 Can you show me the verse where it says music is haram?
Are you gonna tell me the "idle tales" verse? Does God know less than you? He could have used music if it needed. Idle tales are narrations, and other things, it can be even hadiths. And let's assume that there is music used instead of idle tales. Still music is not haram because the rest of the verse says "in order to mislead people". So can use music not to mislead people. Get up, grow up, educate yourself.
MegaMrname 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@MegaMrname The Noble Qur'an - An-Najm 53:57-62
The Day of Resurrection draws near, None besides Allah can avert it, (or advance it, or delay it). Do you then wonder at this recital (the Qur'an)? And you laugh at it and weep not, Wasting your (precious) lifetime in pastime and amusements (singing, etc.). So fall you down in prostration to Allah, and worship Him (Alone).
NaBjE11 2 months ago
@NaBjE11 Right know you asked "what time?"
Then where to "put" your hands. Then how many times to blink.
Why are you afraid of obeying Quran. What did Bukhari offered you that Quran didn't? Bukhari is just a human being.
MegaMrname 2 months ago
@MegaMrname Oke lets see what the Qoran has to say about this
The Noble Qur'an - An-Najm 53:57-62
The Day of Resurrection draws near, None besides Allah can avert it, (or advance it, or delay it). Do you then wonder at this recital (the Qur'an)? And you laugh at it and weep not, Wasting your (precious) lifetime in pastime and amusements (singing, etc.). So fall you down in prostration to Allah, and worship Him (Alone).
NaBjE11 2 months ago
@NaBjE11 youtube.com/watch?v=0m__Xmw9b4o
MegaMrname 2 months ago
Ignore MegaMrname - Hadith rejectors should be ignored!
He is someone that will adjust verses to suit his desires. This particular desire of his is listening to music. He is clearly too weak to stop it, like so many others have done. It's not easy, but it can be done.
Read the Biography of our beloved Prophet (SAW) and you will read Allah (SWT) made the prophet faint twice, to avoid his blessed ears from hearing haram music. Many other ahadith exist and some also say a verse of the Qur'an.
IslamTheLoveOfMyLife 2 months ago
Comment removed
IslamTheLoveOfMyLife 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@IslamTheLoveOfMyLife
Just to futher add, the Prophet (SAW) was made to faint before Prophethood was given to him.
IslamTheLoveOfMyLife 2 months ago
@IslamTheLoveOfMyLife Hey Did you even read a quran once in your life??? You are dumb. I am sorry, no offence. I literally SAW reference concerning praying. You just don't follow quran you worship hadiths.
MegaMrname 2 months ago
@IslamTheLoveOfMyLife Instead of looking stupid GO AHEAD get QURAN. Then come here, YOU WILL HATE HADITHS AND ALL THESE "GREATEST SCHOLARS". GOOD LUCK
MegaMrname 2 months ago
@IslamTheLoveOfMyLife Hahahahaahahahahah I NEVER LISTEN to music. Not because it is "forbidden" Just because I don't like music. But it doesnt mean it is forbidden. Sorry I have to expose you. You do to much fictinal-stereotyping. Get a life
MegaMrname 2 months ago
@IslamTheLoveOfMyLife
Just like you say "haram music" and not "music"
SuperDedara 2 months ago
Music is forbidden
islamictvdotcom 3 months ago
@islamictvdotcom
No it is not. Keep your foolishness to yourself. Reading hadith and listening to your stupid mulla is "forbidden"
Revert to Quran, Islam and the concept of One God. You are lost.
NobleSavage1919 3 months ago 7
@NobleSavage1919 You deserve 100000E1000000 thumbs ups. Too bad I only have one account. Sorry
MegaMrname 2 months ago
we dont need tafseer or bible or Qur`an in this matter, Salah is even a Music how could you prohibit a thing that your even doing it?
ThePeaceshalomsalam 3 months ago
Anyone, Please do not be scared of Quran. Do not worry it will not assault/hit/strike/kick/torture/eat you. Just read it. So are you thinking that if there were no hadith collectors Prophet's job would be incomplete? No, these are people just did mistake when trying to look cool. As If someone wants to convert Islam. He says shahadah first. Then tries to collect hadith from little by little to learn to pray? You are just too lazy to read Quran! Hadiths can be good, but most of them are a JOKE
MegaMrname 3 months ago
he only knows the future from what God tells him right
skatetennis123 3 months ago
@IslamTheLoveOfMyLife I am proud to know that people like you are among this ummah. May Allah reward you.
Just a thought for the people who say that the hadith are not valid. In the quran we are told to pray. Does that mean we can pray any way we like? Can we pray like the people of other religion by offering humans as sacrifice? It says that we should pay zakat. Does that mean we can give it any way we want and that we can pay any amount and let that be the fulfilling of our duty?
thedude2000zify 3 months ago
SALAH IS CLEARLY A MUSIC,HOW CAN ANYONE HERE PROHIBIT MUSIC? SALAH IS UNDENIABLY A MUSIC IT HAS MELODY,HARMONY AND RHYTHM.IT IS QUITE UNDERSTANDABLE THAT IDLE TALES MENTIONED IS SEEN IN THE TRENDS OF SOCIETY LIKE FADS,FASHIONS AND CRAZE JUST LIKE IDOLATRY,NO MUSLIM SCHOLAR HAS EVER UNDERSTAND MUSIC,HOW COULD THEY REJECT IT?
mayergenuiseprincess 3 months ago
@mayergenuiseprincess Do you even know what music is ??? Salah doesnt include any musical instruments so your wrong.
missmillionmaker 3 months ago
@mayergenuiseprincess
Salah is music? LOL. I've heard it all now!!
IslamTheLoveOfMyLife 3 months ago
There are hadiths from the prophet telling us music is haraam. duff is fine though.
missmillionmaker 3 months ago
@missmillionmaker youtube.com/watch?v=YbOxyNp8sok&feature=fvwrel
MegaMrname 3 months ago
@missmillionmaker iF I say Candy is Haram are you just goin to believe that easily? of course you will look for the reason. Now I will Ask you Why Tamborine is Halal? what makes it Halal compare to other Music Instruments?WAs it just beacuse it approves by the Prophet pbuh when girls has welcomed him?then it would follow that Muhammad is A Sex-Maniac?But I dont think so.If Muhammed appreciates Duff Why not for other Instruments?or I will give you easy question why Duff is halal & bonggo is not?
mayergenuiseprincess 3 months ago
@mayergenuiseprincess stupid example , "If I say candy is haram" . Are you even a muslim ? There are hadiths that mention duff is allowed on Eid, weddings, and when one who has been away returns. And who are you that I should listen to because you say something is haraam. The prophet Mohammed(Peace be upon him ) himself said in a hadith that it is haraam , I dont need any one like you to tell me what is right or wrong.
missmillionmaker 3 months ago
@missmillionmaker Prohphet Mohammed (pbuh) told not to write anything from him except Quran.
+ Hadiths are not valid documents. It has no ties to Islam.
MegaMrname 3 months ago
@MegaMrname
What an idiot you are. Really have shown yourself up. Using Qur'an only, please tell me how to pray and how many rakat. Thanks
IslamTheLoveOfMyLife 3 months ago
@IslamTheLoveOfMyLife Nope. Theres only one idiot here and I'm sure we all know who that is.
Sunnis today remain stagnant in their beliefs. Theres no moving forward and thats why Sunni Islam is stuck in the dark ages aka the 8th century when ahadith collections were compiled by various Persian Imams.
Also I've replied to you numerous times before on this video but you always run away. If you want, lets start again, starting from why ahadith are barbaric, retarded, illogical, anti-women etc.
e17jack 3 months ago
@IslamTheLoveOfMyLife You are the idiot because you deem our book imperfect, facebook.com/topic.php?uid=189861496262&topic=15312
There are ways to pray without hadiith you and other idiots don't recognize it.
WHERE DOES IT SAY IN QURAN TO FOLLOW HADITH OR SO-CALLED SUNNAH. YOUR SO-CALLED HADITH AND SUNNAH MUST BE QURAN ONLY
MegaMrname 3 months ago
@MegaMrname you want daleel? here you go:
And whoever OBEYS ALLAH AND THE MESSENGER - those will be with the ones upon whom Allah has bestowed favor of the prophets, the steadfast affirmers of truth, the martyrs and the righteous. And excellent are those as companions. [4:69]
rahilhabib 3 months ago
@MegaMrname you want more daleel? here you go:
And abide in your houses and do not display yourselves as [was] the display of the former times of ignorance. And establish prayer and give zakah and OBEY ALLAH AND HIS MESSENGER. Allah intends only to remove from you the impurity [of sin], O people of the [Prophet's] household, and to purify you with [extensive] purification. [33:33]
rahilhabib 3 months ago
@MegaMrname more?
The bedouins say, "We have believed." Say, "You have not [yet] believed; but say [instead], 'We have submitted,' for faith has not yet entered your hearts. And if you OBEY ALLAH AND HIS MESSENGER, He will not deprive you from your deeds of anything. Indeed, Allah is Forgiving and Merciful." [49:14]
follow the Haqq if you are truthful
rahilhabib 3 months ago
@rahilhabib Is this is a joke? Obey Allah and his messener. Does this mean follow hadith?
I follow Quran it is haqq. What is hadith? one of the five pillars of Islam? NO! Referenced in Quran? No! Believe me I was believing hadiths. But I just asked myself where is it even recommended? Hadiths are not from messenger. If it was they wouldn't be "updated" OK "God has sent you this book FULLY DETAILED". Why do these dumb people tell hadith are "how-to-do-it"? Get some common sense. Then reasoning
MegaMrname 3 months ago
@MegaMrname so tell me, how do YOU obey His messenger?
rahilhabib 3 months ago
@rahilhabib Muhammed delivered Quran. His message was Quran. So following Quran = Obeying messenger. So simple.
Hadith can contain a good information. If I can back hadith up with Quran then I believe it. Otherwise not.
OK can you please tell me, There is a Quranic verse telling that "THIS book is fully detailed" So why do you make hadith obligatory?
MegaMrname 3 months ago
@MegaMrname
Are you stupid? Without hadith, how do you know how many rakat to pray? And so many other things?
You hadith rejectors are absolute nutters.
"Obet Allah and His Messenger" (SAW)
From ahadith we find orders from RasulAllah (SAW)
IslamTheLoveOfMyLife 2 months ago
@rahilhabib If I must believe in hadith then HADITH= ALLAH and HIS MESSENGER.
Sorry, I'm too open-minded for you to poison me with bullshit.
MegaMrname 3 months ago
@MegaMrname so do you reject muttawatir hadith, then?
rahilhabib 3 months ago
@MegaMrname u say hadith have no ties to islam but what about scholars who have studied the hadith and declared their authenticity tracing to the prophet pbuh
skatetennis123 3 months ago
@skatetennis123 I show you an example: Sahih Bukhari is written on 9th century. You say it is authentic then it means that islam between 7th and 9th century was "incomplete"? Who gave scholars authority to "investigate" his sayings? Why do we need "these" scholars to investigate sayings? Does Quran say that wait 200 hundred years for Bukhari for Islam to be completed? Get some sense in your head (no offence)
MegaMrname 3 months ago
@missmillionmaker
They are doing just as the various ahadith told us they would do. Trying to make the haram into halal, to please thier desires in dunya. The same way an alcoholic will say "one drink is ok" - Not only that, they are doing it on Youtube so they can lead others astray.
IslamTheLoveOfMyLife 3 months ago
@IslamTheLoveOfMyLife May Allah guide them ! Inshallah! The best to do is to pray for them :)
missmillionmaker 3 months ago
@IslamTheLoveOfMyLife ANd you think you are being a "cool" guy buy giving an Islam an ascetic image? I never drunk never smoked, never fornicated with one word always stay away from thing which are haram. But you sir think that by claiming anything you want as "haram" will make you cool... No it wont
MegaMrname 3 months ago
@IslamTheLoveOfMyLife Please watch the link I sent you :-) It is the answer to your question: How to pray without hadith.
Second please let me ask a question:
1) Why do you think that Quran is imperfect
2) Prophet (PBUH) told not to write anything from him except quran
3) Why do you trust a person who lived 200 years after prophets death? Did Allah authorize him to investigate prophet's sayings?
I will really appreciate your answers
MegaMrname 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@IslamTheLoveOfMyLife It seems you are blindly following what "majority" does. Please watch this video youtube.com/watch?v=YbOxyNp8sok&feature=fvwrel :-)
MegaMrname 3 months ago
Islamic nashed is alright that is without any musical instruments.
But music is 100% haram
Satan uses music to indoctrinate you.
The music industry is full of satanic people.
DDFF232 3 months ago
@DDFF232
Well said bro
IslamTheLoveOfMyLife 3 months ago
Music is haram is Islam,,he who says otherwise is rebel against allah and the prophet(saw),,The quran is only to be explained by the prophet(saw)...I dont wich sufi u've read but mutah marriages are forbidden is Islam as well. Dont know what kind of rules u came up with by urself.
5jama 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Giving up Music is soo easy!
Just delete all your songs on your IPOD and put Qur`an in it.
Always ask yourself, Listen to Allah`s (S.W.T.) words or a singer.
The hard part for me was telling people I don`t listen to music.
213Algeria 4 months ago
WRONG! You can't interpret the Qur'an yourself! You MUST follow the opinions of the prophet Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wassalam, his companions, the tabi'i, and the tabi'i tabi'een. THEY were the ones who were there when the Qur'an was revealed so they understood its context WAY better than we do! Yes, Allah subhanahu wata'ala's laws may be clear but we may not understand them still! We are only humans after all and our imaan is definitely not up to par with those who were before us!
triadsaint48 4 months ago
In My Eye's The Shayke's Are Banin Music Because Of Masonry
TheBlockOneOne 4 months ago
I am still confused. There are some hadith that seem to support it and one that says people will say it is halal.
islamictvdotcom 4 months ago
@islamictvdotcom
If you accept ahadith, then it is haram. That is clear. If you deny ahadith (Which takes you out of the fold of Islam) then some "modern" wishy-washy Muslims would say it is lawful.
IslamTheLoveOfMyLife 4 months ago
@islamictvdotcom The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Among my ummah there will certainly be people who permit zinaa, silk, alcohol and musical instruments…” (Narrated by al-Bukhaari ta’leeqan, no. 5590; narrated as mawsool by al-Tabaraani and al-Bayhaqi. See al-Silsilah al-Saheehah by al-Albaani, 91).
triadsaint48 4 months ago
I ll challenge everyone here those who says Music is Haram, DEFINE WHAT IS MUSIC first. call any scholar, call your Naik. Hey Mr.Naik debate here, I know you dont know Music, You are rejecting a thing you dont know. everybody!!! WHAT IS MUSIC???
ThePeaceshalomsalam 4 months ago
@ThePeaceshalomsalam Uh instruments?
NaBjE11 4 months ago
@NaBjE11 Instruments are music, But wouldnt mean if theres no Instrument it is not a music.Music is not just limited to Instrument
ThePeaceshalomsalam 4 months ago
ok this is a very touchy subject an may Allah forgive us..i am muslim myself..i write songs becoz i enjoy it but on the other hand i know that der are alot of things in life which we enjoy but are no good for us.... i feel that music has a message an that message can be evil or good but they say instruments can change your heart which i do believe..they course us to experience different emotions ...is music haraam?? i will never know
TheCardz17 4 months ago
@TheCardz17 I agree with you.please visit my video too I defend that Salah is even a music.I am very absolute i this thing.Salah itself has a melody, and anything that has melody comes out naturaly a harmony and any melody runs a particular rhythm.
ThePeaceshalomsalam 4 months ago
Comment removed
ThePeaceshalomsalam 4 months ago
this video is dumb, music is forbidden in islam, dont be so influenced by the west!
teedonster2 4 months ago
Comment removed
ThePeaceshalomsalam 4 months ago
@teedonster2 How Could you say Music is Haram when Salah itself is a Music? thats Undeniable fact. SALAH IS A MUSIC regardless of any reference Qur`an,Bible,Tanakh, Hadeeth, Tafseer, Vedas.
ThePeaceshalomsalam 1 second ago
ThePeaceshalomsalam 4 months ago
@ThePeaceshalomsalam music is forbidden in islam, im starting to doubt if your even a muslim
teedonster2 4 months ago
Reactions About Salah is a Music
-Non-Muslim:Music student from Conservatory Who Heared Salah as he passed by; strange!but thats a Music, still it was a music.
-Muslim who Study Music; Music is Not Haram ,after all I realized Salah is Music.
-Muslim who hate Music but study music for the sake of knowing the Truth: Ohh i reaized that even Salah is really really a music,but i need to Accept that it is Haram(a forcible matter for him,No faculty of reason is needed)
ThePeaceshalomsalam 4 months ago
@teedonster2 "This video is dumb" - baseless accusation.
What do you mean influenced by the west? Music has existed for 1000s of years across all continents and cultures and still does. The only country where music is scarce is Saudi Arabia due to the idiotic Mullahs that run the country.
There's no verse in the Quran that forbids music. Did you even watch the video?
e17jack 4 months ago
@e17jack islam prohibits music, so i follow it.
teedonster2 4 months ago
@teedonster2 Err no. Bukhari et al prohibits music not the Quran. If music was indeed so terrifingly bad, then the Quran would have said so (which would have been highly illogical) since music has existed for milleniums.
e17jack 4 months ago
@e17jack you a muslim or not?
teedonster2 4 months ago
@teedonster2 Yes...thats why I'm commenting here...
e17jack 4 months ago
@e17jack
Zina has also existed since day one. So has murder. Does this make it lawful?
IslamTheLoveOfMyLife 4 months ago
@IslamTheLoveOfMyLife No.
Please don't compare Zina and murder in the same league as music. Music is a blessing from Allah, a work of art. Never could it be forbidden in al-Furqaan.
And the only muslims who are "wishy-washy" are those that believe poetry is haram (Sahih Muslim 28:5611) or that the Prophet allowed temporary marriage for the Sahaba Sahih Muslim 8:3243 + Sahih Muslim 8:3252 - these ahadith paint women as sex objects)
If you are interested in more absurd ahadith, then PM me :)
e17jack 4 months ago
@e17jack Those Ahadith regarding Temporary Marriage was later abrogated by other Sahih Ahadith. Mutah was one of the Pre-Islamic practice and in the early days it was allowed like many other things such a Alcohol, Gambling. But slowly they were abrogated. Anyway are you saying these Ahadith are fabricated?
ByChoiceMuslim 4 months ago
@ByChoiceMuslim Did you read the ahadith? In them Muhammad ALLOWS the SAHABA to practise Mutah marriage while they were travelling. He could have easily prevented them.
Anyway, I'm not going to go into the absurdity of verses abrogating other Quranic verses as it's a long subject.
And yes many ahadith a fabricated. The Quran speaks against the following of other ahadith. Sayings found within the 6 main Hadith books (Sahih Sittah) themselves contain absurdity i.e examples I posted above.
e17jack 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@e17jack Are you Muslim?
ByChoiceMuslim 4 months ago
This usually occurs during puberty (around 11-15), but can also occur before that, such as occurred with ‘Isa (as), upon birth. Therefore, you COULD marry at any age. Nearly never, however, would this be at the "mature" (18+) phase. I would say, wiki up the word "mature", and become mature.
Assalam Aleykom
1submittingtothe1God 5 months ago
Yes, I did read it, but not only that, i.e. I also understood what I read.
From (4:6) it can clearly be understood to imply that you can marry when the age of marriage is reached, which is when you find “sound judgment” in the partner. “Sound judgment” simply means that you can think logically and judge between matters.
1submittingtothe1God 5 months ago
For the sake of the sunna/islam, this video should either be deleted, or it deserves a lot of thumbs down.
Bukhari :: Book 7 :: Volume 69 :: Hadith 494
Narrated Abu 'Amir or Abu Malik Al-Ash'ari:
that he heard the Prophet saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical instruments, as lawful."
1submittingtothe1God 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
MUSIC IS HARAM
Bukhari :: Book 7 :: Volume 69 :: Hadith 494
Narrated Abu 'Amir or Abu Malik Al-Ash'ari:
that he heard the Prophet saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical instruments, as lawful."
1submittingtothe1God 5 months ago
Despite saying that, most Sunnis on this video will ignore my comment and go back to obeying their scholars like sheep.
e17jack 5 months ago
@e17jack I follow the Sunna brother, I hope you do too. I don't follow any scholars, never, only the information they provide, if it is, verified, to be the sunna.
Assalam Aleykom
1submittingtothe1God 5 months ago
@1submittingtothe1God I follow the only Sunnah that is mentioned in the Quran - Allah's Sunnah, the Quran.
And no I don't follow the manmade Sunnah aka "Muhammad's Sunnah" that was founded and authorised by Sunni scholars. It was verified by Sunni scholars 200 years after the death of Muhammad.
Wa'alaykum asalam.
e17jack 5 months ago
@e17jack The Sunnah of the Quran COMMANDS YOU TO FOLLOW THE SUNNAH OF THE PROPHET!
Assalam Aleykom inshaAllah
1submittingtothe1God 5 months ago
@e17jack The Quran is from Allah, written by MAN. The Hadeeth is from the Prophet (saw), written by MAN.
You are confused.
1submittingtothe1God 5 months ago
Some really deluded Sunnis here. Idle talk does not mean music LOL no matter how you try to justify it.
The word translated to "Idle Talk" in 31:6 is "Hadith". Hadith does not mean music. Talk about ignorance and purposely distorting quranic words
"And from the people, there are those who accept baseless narrations (Hadith) to mislead from the path of God without knowledge, and they take it as entertainment. These will have a humiliating retribution" (31:6)
This is a much better translation.
e17jack 5 months ago
@e17jack Assalam Aleykom brother,
According to islamic professors and their translation, i.e. Dr Muhammed Taqi-ud-Din Al-Hilali and Dr. Muhammad Muhsin Khan, "Lehwel Hadeeth" is translated as "idle talks". The two, even noted that this refers to both music and singing and other such things which are characterized as being "idle". Music can be categorized as "idle" because it is not overall important or beneficial for us. Besides that, please read this following hadeeth completely...
1submittingtothe1God 5 months ago
@e17jack Narrated Abu 'Amir or Abu Malik Al-Ash'ari:
That he heard the Prophet saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical instruments, as lawful."
Hadeeth: Bukhari :: Book 7 :: Volume 69 :: Hadith 494
Wa aleykom Assalam
1submittingtothe1God 5 months ago
THE VIDEO TITLE IS FALSE!
PROVEN BY:
Sura Luqman 31:6 (those who listen to idle talk for them is a humiliating torment)
Bukhari :: Book 7 :: Volume 69 :: Hadith 494 (we were warned that people will attempt to make music halal)
SPREAD THIS MESSAGE, TO SPREAD THE DEEN AND PREVENT CORRUPTION!
1submittingtothe1God 5 months ago
@1submittingtothe1God idle talk does not only mean music. it actually refers to any kind of conversation or words that are vain. in bukhari there are also hadith where prophet Muhammad (s.a.w) allowed singing in the day of the eid and weddings. so u cant really say its haram but u can say its makruh.
syazwankhan 5 months ago
@syazwankhan singing is not the same as music.
Abdullah2009 5 months ago
@Abdullah2009 bro, singing is a part of music. the Prophet (s.a.w) allowed singing and playing instrument at the day of the Eid and weddings.
syazwankhan 5 months ago
@syazwankhan Assalam Aleykom,
No, brother, did you even read the hadeeth yourself? It is as follows:
Narrated Aisha:
Abu Bakr came to my house while two small Ansari girls were singing beside me the stories of the Ansar concerning the Day of Buath. And they were not singers. Abu Bakr said protestingly, "Musical instruments of Satan in the house of Allah's Apostle !" It happened on the 'Id day and Allah's Apostle said, "O Abu Bakr! There is an 'Id for every nation and this is our 'Id."
1submittingtothe1God 5 months ago
@1submittingtothe1God Yes bro, it doesnt matter. We all know its haram for women who have reached puberty sing in public. The matter here is the Prophet (S.AW.) allowed them to sing and play instrument because its the day of the eid.
syazwankhan 5 months ago
@syazwankhan Good brother, I'm pleased with you. But this was the matter however, maybe you forget, because look at the title of the video. It is not very specific then I think.
In fact, if so, what you say, then I can tell you this:
There is no point to mention that singing is permissible for young kids because:
ANYTHING IS PERMISSIBLE FOR PEOPLE BELOW PUBERTY
By the way, the capital letters are used for emphasis, not to point out anger or such.
Contrarily, I am pleased to share with you.
1submittingtothe1God 5 months ago
@1submittingtothe1God Yes anything is permissible for kids, but according to our deen, we have to educate our kids and make them practice Islam since young. The purpose of this hadith is to show that Islam is not narrow, Muslims are allowed to sing and play some instruments on the day of the eid as long as the lyrics are halal.
syazwankhan 5 months ago
@syazwankhan It is very true, brother, that we have to educate our kids aright. I agree upon that entirely. But then you changed direction, by saying that it is allowed to sing and play instruments for Muslims, in general, thus. This is incorrect, I showed you the hadeeth. They were NO SINGERS, musical instruments are haram as well, which I showed with the other hadeeth. The only exception is that a *KID* can do that, on the 'eed, because it is 'eed (feast) so they left them to continue instead.
1submittingtothe1God 5 months ago
Another example of this same principle, is that Aisha, who was 9, was allowed to play with dolls, which is haram, but the prophet left her because she was, as I said, she was 9.
1submittingtothe1God 5 months ago
@1submittingtothe1God but I thought Aisha has reached puberty when she was 9 and the Prophet consummated the marriage with her at that age?
syazwankhan 5 months ago
@syazwankhan No, girls reach puberty at the age of 11ish so or 13, earlier than boys, yes. However, it does not mean that if the prophet (saw) married her and she was not an adolescent, yet, that it is haram. You can marry at any age, however, sexual intercourse must be done only after puberty.
I hope this clarifies it.
1submittingtothe1God 5 months ago
@1submittingtothe1God Lol! So I can marry a one year old kid and have sex with her after she hits puberty! Unfortunately many retarded mullahs agree with you.
According to ahadith, Muhammad married a 6 year old girl and had sex with her at the age of 9.
The Quran says only mature people can get married. 9 year old girls (let alone 6 year olds) are not mature. According to ahadith, Muhammad was a pedophile and you and many other Sunnis try to justify it.
e17jack 5 months ago
@e17jack How do you dare speak like that!!
AND YOU SAY YOU FOLLOW THE QURAN?!
How can you pray, if this is not described in detail in the quran? Where does it say Muhammed had intercourse with her on her 9th?
If you think about what I said, it makes sense. You don't even understand what marrying means. You probably only consider it to be about sexual intercourse.
You are lost.
The messages that I sent you on your profile should make it clear to you to follow the Sunna! Surely, you lost yourself.
1submittingtothe1God 5 months ago
@e17jack And where does it say IN THE QURAN, that ONLY MATURE PEOPLE CAN MARRY?
1submittingtothe1God 5 months ago