Kanye West-Heartless live in NYC

[darrisrobins]

KANYE CAN NOT DANCE BUT WHEN HE DOES FUNNIEST SHIT EVER!

[ZOMGitsRex]

He's using autotune for a reason people.....

[dipsetalldayox9]

thats gangstaaaaa!!!

[wiltisdabest]

Wow he really can't sing but that was more like rap singing like what DMX and qtip though q-tip can actually sing this is the one time i can say im actually better then an artist at singing anyone could do what he just did and a good majority probably better

[PeterWasAFlutist]

Good pitch? Vocal quality? What are these things of which you speak?

[PeterWasAFlutist]

Good pitch? Vocal quality? What are these things of which you speak?

[Cutterxx4]

Great lyrics!, great song! HORIBLE vocals by kanye. hes like Jay-z, no vocals and sounds like shit.

[jac3d]

jajaj without autotune

[dehfunnykid]

without autotune he isnt as shitty as people say actually hes not bad i might even say i wish i could sing like him :]

[TheBilliamaire]

gay fish

[911collectcall]

-.- ouch

[snowblownplaya]

....WITHOUT AUTOTUNE...

[laymoneyyy]

kanyee is the greatest

dope bape shirt

[bobiolik]

I agree, he can't sing without autotune

[jenna1257]

This makes me happy. Got to be the best pound for pound singing in the world. he's gone from Rapping to Singing its awesome.

[RobinErikssonz]

i love this version more then the original and kris alles version .........................

this is amazing =)

[Dzony41]

original and kris alles version

wTf?

u mean kanye's original version or what?

heartless is his own song :O

[RobinErikssonz]

i mean i like this version more live then the tv version ^^

[Dzony41]

oh...ok then =))

[TJ2029]

i like the semi singing/rapping verses without autotune. but the chorus... use autotune

[hwakok94]

Shut up. he cant sing

[jliu101]

believe it or not I love this version

[cashykid]

is that common

[obriensimo]

wtf

[tinothat]

its pretty good seeing that he just started singing on his songs atleast he is trying sumthin new trying to step his game up i got respect for him

[wackmaster5000]

this sucks dick

[jenova94]

lol this guy sucks balls live the song is ok but hes soooo shit w/out his autotune

[Miissy1704]

like the music :D

[iwatchhotfuzz]

I bet all the people on here who are hatin have never seen him live. His live shows are better than anything I have ever seen in my entire life.

Besides, he doesnt use auto tune when he does a full show unlike this which is one song.

Point being - see him live before you comment bitches

[kyleauger09]

yea and he fails it without the auto tune, thats showing he should stick to rap.

[skyline462]

no disrespect and i like his songs ....stick to RAP lol

[julesryan12]

BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! YOU CANT SING!

[LegoStudios1000]

SWEEEEEET

[firzennet1]

he can't even sing the song. The chorus (only hard part of the song), where he says a "to a women so heartless" ,its always changed, cause he can't sing the real shit.

[kimkenw]

he looks like a spastic on stage..........

[NYCbrownman1]

NYC sawn 4 life

[camron360]

who makes that jacket/windbreaker want one..

[lilparker9]

LRG. LOOK the trade is LRG

The same like Lil Wayne... I wanted on 2 but you can only buy this in the united states or from the internet directly from U.S. sucks.. but this jacket is nice

bless. Fredo

[gh0st7]

no autotune/vocoder on his vocal... he can't sing! what's the point in recording stuff you can't sing live, because it was all brushed up by sound engineers?

[isaiasisahomofag]

stfu, he still sells, and rocs crowds of 20,000 plus! when you can do that then go talk some shit. and he performs with mic autotune now so =P

[NYCbrownman1]

Yea I know he discraces his song in my home. bt I like it when it is edited by the sound engineers

[stringbean555]

The song is awesome, but he really isnt good at singing live, and its defenitley not the cell phone that has his voice sound so bad

[chigozie96]

that

shirt is dope

[dinosruleearth]

that SHIRT rocks

[blackman202221]

1 cover ur mouth with ur hand

2 make a wish into it

3close your hand make it into a fist

4 hold ur fist to ur heart for 5 sec. 5 send this to 3 more video

6 torrommorww will be ur best day ever

[TheBlackDelorian]

looks like a skinny suge knight on backing vocals lol

[hhiikkbbnnmm]

1 cover ur mouth with ur hand

2 make a wish into it

3close your hand make it into a fist

4 hold ur fist to ur heart for 5 sec. 5 send this to 3 more video

6 torrommorww will be ur best day ever

[maagdalena122]

I love him ^^ but he's really can't sing xD

[brian2553]

This was recorded on fuckin cell phone,its not good quality..If you see his Vh1 Storytellers you'll realize what he's capable of.

[jesusfreakjosh337]

Seriously. I love Kanye's new stuff.... but it sucks live.

[brian2553]

kanye live is awesome..obviously you havent seen his Vh1 storytellers,this video is on a fukn cell phone.

[shewontdie07]

its a sad day when you have to use autotune to sing worth a shit, and autotune just sounds like ass anyway

i definitely see the gills

[seryibaran]

Oh, my cat! I like the song but pleeeeaz don't you ever dare sing live.

[dualitystruggle]

I think I see the gills!

[tomniv]

no wonder he autotunes so much on the record

[pimpinpinkking]

this sounds horrible and sure its a good song on the fricken radio!!! not live its horrible as u can see

[TripLeSh0t]

eh. Watch the other live footage. With the Autotune enabled.

[webkinzplays101]

ughh. . .

[psyhcoman]

Hnan101 is right go listen to a music vid thn to this u can tell he effen uses a program to make himself sound good =( he such a dumbass!!!!!

[Hnan101]

he sucks..... he computerizes his voice so it sounds good .... that is why he frikik sucks omg what a retard

[Rickaka1]

The beat only is genius,+Kanye =A Masterhit!

[Prison112]

a lot of people do that and they are popular idiot

[Hnan101]

shut the hell up ok

[Prison112]

learn to word Your sentences. Ok? Thanks.

[123bamtobam]

ya but alot of people who do that can actually sing decently!

he uses auto tune cus he cant sing for shit.

[inlonging]

the reason people are making negative comments about his singing is because he goes about blustering on about how great he is, insulting other artists, and THIS is what he sounds like? we are incredulous.

[gohantaro]

i guess he realized he can't sing and uses a harmonizer to stay in key on other live versions that I seen. I like this song but he really murdered this live version.

[blahmeandu]

Kanye West really cannot sing. haha

People have to stop defending him for openly admitting to not being able to sing. It takes zero effort to use autotune, especially in the manner he does.

[the1viet]

lol u stalking me??

[the1viet]

lol he can't sing

[l7ehr4mb0]

lol your gay

[punkprincess8181]

Kanye West can fosho sing,

it's just much better not livee.

[inlonging]

that's because in the studio it's manipulated into sounding the way it does on the CD

[shreddar56]

he was trying to win his girl back

[wcunes]

Tired of negative comments fuck people give Kanye credit... dude lost his mother... this is tight!

[inlonging]

dude lost his mother, so that means he can sing?

[YouKnowWho64]

why not?

[inlonging]

Because it's completely unrelated. Just because someone dies doesn't mean I automatically gain a physical ability...especially when there are so many videos proving the exact opposite as far as his so-called abilities. The only time he sounds good it was either studio recorded (meaning, manipulated) or he's hiding behind an auto-mike (again, manipulated vocals)

[YouKnowWho64]

he never said he could sing, he does it cuz its something he wanted to do, he even said in an interview that he was a bad singer

and u clearly know nothing about the music industry

[inlonging]

clearly.

oh wait, let's clarify, i completely disagree with the music industry and american public since i can't comprehend how artists like this are so popular.

[iSmil3yi]

Ew Kanye West can NOT sing live.

[wellsm3]

wow...now i know why half his songs half that electric sound to it....to cover up the fact that HE CANNOT SING...AT ALL. Kanye is one of the worst on stage performers ive ever seen, especially considering how cocky he his. i just lost a lot of respect for this guy

[aj33zy]

in one of his interviews he says that he cant sing theres nothing wrong with that...he is well aware of that fact and thats the purpose of his autotune

[irockgracie]

i know man i man when he sung love lockdown live it was pritty bad and i thought that that was really bad till i saw this... i know he can sing but just not in concert and i was hopeing that he was like sick or something in that last concert.... (tear falls) me and my bff LOVED him soo much we call him our brother now hes r EX brother

[inlonging]

omg this doesn't sound like the recorded version thats for sure.

[dacksomnia]

Actually, No. Wack is wack. This is wack.

[dacksomnia]

Kanye lost his mind. But, I guess I still got his back?

[NcHaley]

This Sucks, The voice changer is better with him, this is sucks BAD... Im serious...

[Jewelsisamazing]

i herd that he sux live but this is pretty good but lil wayne is still my man :)

[Thelindal]

gooooooooooooooooooo kanye best artist alive

[jon316t]

I AREED 100% KANYE IS KING

[SleepyR3PTILE]

lol we are being sarcastic right? hehehe

[edenmachy]

he sucks live

[08lwatkinson]

wow u get very close to him must of bin great u lucky bastared!!! LOL

[quail145]

i think everyone is high and drunk at the concert. probably sounds pretty damn gooooood

[toledo343]

haha..i agreee.

X)

[FooshFreak607]

haha! You're probably right XD

[u2Parv]

i prefure the rele  it dnt sound gd wen its live

[apersn]

aight man his auto tuned songs are much much better....i can sing this betta than him but hees still pretty cool so stop hatin people

[rosdeon]

yall quit bein green at least he started singin live and left the auto tune at home.

[poodlelova]

He sucks ass! He's a ass on the stage and in real life! LOL! I don't care if he is a rapper or not, he can't sing worth a damn. They must have to remix his voice in the studio a lot!

[MapleCombat74]

i doubt you can sing any better. go up on the stage in front of millions and we'll see how good you sing!!!

[TwilightFan2233]

k he sucks not being mean or anything but i dnt think he could even pass for american idol

[tbd]

I don't understand why people hold him up to a vocalist's standards. He is just singing as an artist, not a vocalist. He's singing for emotion, not technical merit. I personally need the emotion and the technical does very little for me--it's insipid, uninspired, and generic (think: Kelly Clarkson, as someone mentioned AI auditions.)

[RachentProductions]

i know he sucks at singing without his machine that make him half decent

[mama0312]

i can sing heartless better than him!

[peastpeastpeast]

Yup, it sounds differentely from cd version (because of autotune) but you must admit, that kanye improved as a singer.

Sorry guys if you didn't understood me, I talk lithuanian much better :D

[Crazychicken224]

TERRIBLE!!!!!!!! STOP TRYING TO RIP OFF UR OWN VERSION OF T-PAINS JAMS. HE SOUNDS LIKE MOUNTAINS OF SHIITT! why would kanye do this he has lost all of my respect cuz there is no way in hell that i is gonna buy this niggaz album

[Compooky121]

:face palm:

[XxSternchenxX8]

He´s a rapper he doesn´t have to sound good singin ;)

But it´s great he still does it live respects for that :)

[Chilliepop]

holy jesus lord mother of fuck.....he couldnt even pass the auditions for american idle..no no, he couldnt pass the auditions for the auditions for the audtions for american idle. those studio people must have committed suicide tryin to patch up his voice for the cd...

[Cannakenn408]

Kanye i love you man but just record yo singing please 4 real cause you cant sing in real life homie one love BTCK

[KillerQueenRalphe]

i like it when its fixed up on the CD..

he made a fool of himself!

wait, he always does live

[crzyhan10]

whats autotuned???

how do they make him sound so good on the album if he sucks soooo bad on stage

[bizziedome]

autotuned makes his voice into that Robotic tone its the same thing which T-pain uses in all of his song that motherfucker made alot of money out of that shit DAMN!!!

[mrgrimm25]

why has there to be a douchebag on the side yelling "new york city!"

[ngiazac18]

kanye west cant sing

[pyroblast3000]

poeple he is not a singer he is a rapper of course he is gonna sound off live jeeze lol

[hpwizard09]

wow people, calm down! he's a rapper not a singer, so the fact that he was using an autotone on his cd doesnt matter. he just decided to do something different with this album because that's just the kind of artist kanye is; but i will repeat he's a rapper not a singer, so he's not supposed to sound good "singing" live! lol

[WootyWooty13]

Whats auto tune?

Wow im dumb...

But hey I didnt make a fool of myself in front of a bunch of people..

[tmarty7]

his autotune want on :s

[SunriseBaby43]

This is what gets me. There are so many truly talented artists out there wanting to make a career in what they are supposed to be doing like singing and they make a star out of someone like this. Just goes to show how screwed up this world really is. This man couldn't carry a tune in a bucket! Although, I do like the song.

[ASHandTTfilms]

he should stick to lip syncing...but whatever i love his songs...in studio :P

[xblackholesun]

this was okay. not a very good preformance but whatev

[GNRalltheway]

he much better in recording studio ;)

but'

he is amazing

[jcamp4690]

it's cause he uses auto tune u dip shit

[shapek31]

i love this song ... kanye 4eva

[sandra80ny]

im a concert attending whore! This was one of the best! Personal and Quaint Venue! Loved it!

[lgr5570]

new york

[woodini6969]

what other songs did he do?

[woodini6969]

this was in LA or new york?