Ok, I think Syesha is going to be in the top two. I think Simon said she was going home because he knew people were going to react by voting for her. I think Brooke is going too. If you look at dialidol Syesha and David Cook got the most votes. Brokke the least.
I definitely agree that the judges comments actually do matter, unless its staged written like Paula proved tonight. After Michael Johns was eliminated in the top 8, and Kristie Lee Cook lasting so long, i honestly am starting to believe the show rigged
Jamie ... what in heavens name are you talking about???? ... David A. sang the verses to the songs but also made it his own at the same time. They only have 1.5 minutes to do the song too ... so what are you talking about???
Here's why I don't want David Cook to win. Because if you look at past seasons, a lot of people (Chris Daughtery, Elliot Yamin) who are not typical "pop" singers do better if they don't win, cause then they won't have to put out a cheesy AI idol, like Bo Bice did, that was SO not him. David Archuleta is American Idol material. David Cook will hopefully not win so he can make his own album and call his own shots.
Come on, Paula was reading what the producers told her to say and she accidentally read the comments for Jason's second song. It's obvious! She was READING. That's why it got so awkward and uncomfortable. Usually when she messes up, Simon and Randy just laugh and make fun of her relentlessly. There was a definite "oh sh*t she really messed up" vibe with everyone there. They were tough on Jason because they are trying to get him out. It was obvious tonight with their scripting. It wasn't fair.
I agree that the 2 davids are in the final. With that being said David Cook is head and shoulders above Archuletta in talent. I just started watching AI a little last year but this year I haven't missed any of the shows. But Archuletta's fan base could pull him through. But Archuletta sounds too predictable every week.
I don't know who you are, but I agree with what you said about the show tonight - it was very strange and felt too rushed. I don't agree about the David's though. Cook moans the first half and screams the second. Archuleta is soothing all the way through. Just my opinion. The fact that he's younger just makes him all the better.
I agree, nadi1010 ... cook is soooo overrated and what's worse ... the judges and AI producers are pimping pimping pimping him up ... it's sickening ... makes you want to throw up .... and he is so full of himself.
They are "beating up" on Jason Castro because he has a huge voting fanbase & AI is afraid Jason will give David A. some competition. His songs were both beautiful--unnecessary negative comments from judges. ALSO, these comments are clearly scripted ahead of time-we now have proof-due to Paula's blunder, she had not even heard him sing the second song.
I agree with you comments.. and yeah it was pretty weird the show tonight!. ehm, I also think cook is going to win [even tho i dont like him]b/c his sound is more modern than archuleta and archie is still a little bit green and at this point I can see all of them with a recod deal so who cares if they win or not lol. most of them will get signed! thats my opinion
i am voting for Brooke. I love her!!! Her voice is so original...people obviously like the common and don't give things that are different or new to them a chance.
Brooke was amazing tonight. First song, not great, but the second, one of the best of the night. Jason's time to go!
Totally agree. Brooke, bye bye. I am tired of her sound. She's a bit cheesy too, when she plays guitar. And tonight's piano, she was cheesy when she was trying to get into it. Syesha best female for several weeks, but people get tired of the gorgeous, powerful, dark diva. She may be in trouble. Jason is my favorite, but he may go. I think his fans will pull him through another week. Maybe 2, But I don't think he deserves to be there past next 2 wks based on ability. I think D Cook will win.
i love brooke!
DancerPrincess97 2 years ago
you finally got one right :(
i miss brooke already. she was so great and gorgeous!
jessibop 3 years ago
1st rd sy da 2nd sy da brooke goes
stevenash1386 3 years ago
they were not too hard on jason. NOT. he sang ok, but that's the thing, top 4 material? definitely not. i'm appalled he has come this far
qg6ff 3 years ago
Brooke looks amazing compared to Jason! He needs to go! same boring thing every week, it puts me to sleep, and thats not a good thing!
ice56200 3 years ago
Ok, I think Syesha is going to be in the top two. I think Simon said she was going home because he knew people were going to react by voting for her. I think Brooke is going too. If you look at dialidol Syesha and David Cook got the most votes. Brokke the least.
Thanks for your reviews guys!:)
nadi1010 3 years ago
yeah and if they put her in the bottom 2, then we all know it is rigged
qg6ff 3 years ago
I agree with what you said about Jason Castro.
thenextprimeminister 3 years ago
syesha for the top 2
huholah 3 years ago
I really enjoy your reviews :)
I think Cook is miles ans miles better than Archuleta. He was amazing tonight.
MyNameIsLizi 3 years ago
brooke goes
stevenash1386 3 years ago
1st rd david a sy 2nd sy david a
stevenash1386 3 years ago
I definitely agree that the judges comments actually do matter, unless its staged written like Paula proved tonight. After Michael Johns was eliminated in the top 8, and Kristie Lee Cook lasting so long, i honestly am starting to believe the show rigged
loufreakind 3 years ago
Jamie ... what in heavens name are you talking about???? ... David A. sang the verses to the songs but also made it his own at the same time. They only have 1.5 minutes to do the song too ... so what are you talking about???
Jem3783 3 years ago
Here's why I don't want David Cook to win. Because if you look at past seasons, a lot of people (Chris Daughtery, Elliot Yamin) who are not typical "pop" singers do better if they don't win, cause then they won't have to put out a cheesy AI idol, like Bo Bice did, that was SO not him. David Archuleta is American Idol material. David Cook will hopefully not win so he can make his own album and call his own shots.
nadi1010 3 years ago
Come on, Paula was reading what the producers told her to say and she accidentally read the comments for Jason's second song. It's obvious! She was READING. That's why it got so awkward and uncomfortable. Usually when she messes up, Simon and Randy just laugh and make fun of her relentlessly. There was a definite "oh sh*t she really messed up" vibe with everyone there. They were tough on Jason because they are trying to get him out. It was obvious tonight with their scripting. It wasn't fair.
jmiklane 3 years ago
No-what I think happened was she read both of the comments-one for David Cook, then Jason Castro. She just got confused.
nadi1010 3 years ago
I agree that the 2 davids are in the final. With that being said David Cook is head and shoulders above Archuletta in talent. I just started watching AI a little last year but this year I haven't missed any of the shows. But Archuletta's fan base could pull him through. But Archuletta sounds too predictable every week.
drdent7 3 years ago
I don't know who you are, but I agree with what you said about the show tonight - it was very strange and felt too rushed. I don't agree about the David's though. Cook moans the first half and screams the second. Archuleta is soothing all the way through. Just my opinion. The fact that he's younger just makes him all the better.
Valzee002 3 years ago
David Cook is SOOO overrated! He just screams!!
I might be ready for Brooke to leave, but I think Syesha will go.
nadi1010 3 years ago
I agree, nadi1010 ... cook is soooo overrated and what's worse ... the judges and AI producers are pimping pimping pimping him up ... it's sickening ... makes you want to throw up .... and he is so full of himself.
Jem3783 3 years ago
They are "beating up" on Jason Castro because he has a huge voting fanbase & AI is afraid Jason will give David A. some competition. His songs were both beautiful--unnecessary negative comments from judges. ALSO, these comments are clearly scripted ahead of time-we now have proof-due to Paula's blunder, she had not even heard him sing the second song.
Userwright 3 years ago
i totally agree! where did paula's comment for jason's second song came from? hmmm... anyways i voted for jason 20 times. hope he makes it through.
lnclemente 3 years ago
I hated the format because the songs were cut so short. Can we please vote Paula off?
sinawava42 3 years ago
I agree with you comments.. and yeah it was pretty weird the show tonight!. ehm, I also think cook is going to win [even tho i dont like him]b/c his sound is more modern than archuleta and archie is still a little bit green and at this point I can see all of them with a recod deal so who cares if they win or not lol. most of them will get signed! thats my opinion
vickyvicks0 3 years ago
no brooke was so good tonight
jessibop 3 years ago 2
Brooke was the chosen vote for the worst last week. I don't know why people waste their time, but it helps give her votes.
RowanPrincess 3 years ago
why is she still in it? who is voting for her?
BandOnTheRun87 3 years ago
i am voting for Brooke. I love her!!! Her voice is so original...people obviously like the common and don't give things that are different or new to them a chance.
Brooke was amazing tonight. First song, not great, but the second, one of the best of the night. Jason's time to go!
Halessayshi 3 years ago
Totally agree. Brooke, bye bye. I am tired of her sound. She's a bit cheesy too, when she plays guitar. And tonight's piano, she was cheesy when she was trying to get into it. Syesha best female for several weeks, but people get tired of the gorgeous, powerful, dark diva. She may be in trouble. Jason is my favorite, but he may go. I think his fans will pull him through another week. Maybe 2, But I don't think he deserves to be there past next 2 wks based on ability. I think D Cook will win.
RowanPrincess 3 years ago
i agree i like the judges comments and the format did not work I belive the reason they did that was becuase of time
dxc5698 3 years ago