@BadassBigBoss If you think about war then yes. ALL leaders have to be mass murderers in war. Unless you want to capitulate without fighting for independence.
@SovietLenin1 You seem to not know the mans psychology. He was a devoted fanatic to war, which is why, unlike the sphere that surrounded him, he found himself excited when both WW1 and WW2 started and did not spare hesitation from doing a set of risky, life costly things that were sometimes not even that necessary amidst the war. Hell, the man even supported the use of gas on rebelling tribes.
@youpon1000 Trotsky was never the leader of USSR. Lenin was since 1917 up until his stroke in 1923. Stalin was for more than 20 years, up until 1952(he died the year after). Long live both of them.
@metalorixos But to be fair, Trotsky was largely in charge of the military during the Russian Revolution, right? Although I can get where you're coming from.
Personally, I agree with youpon, it should have been Lenin.
to be honest well i don't count them stalin to be a mass muderer but he had to kill many people because the german army was advancing on him so he had to kill many people to save his country so it wasent his fault that he is a mass muderer cause he wouldent just let the Nazis just walk into russia.
You can't sy that Peter the Great and Stalin weren't great leaders. The sorry fact is Stalin was a mass murderer. But Peter the Great wasn't. I think you simply hates Russia. You can't blame Russians for Stalin and communism!
You can't say that Stalin and Peter the Great weren't great leaders. They were charismatic and they managed their country well, too. The sorry fact is Stalin was a tiran and mass murderer. I think some of you simply doesen't like Russia. But it is a normal country! You can't blame Russians for Stalin and communizm!
@dasmysteryman12 But he certainly didn't invent many of the things they claim he did. The whole 'military rank based on merit and skill, not nobility' thing? Genghis Khan invented it first.
@69Kambash64 that was done all the time, it was no invention. All people are saying is he brought it to first use in that nation (or at least reintroduced it)
@kacknoobdeluxe just so you know, almost every single person who was killed by "Stalin" was actually ordered and signed off by Kruschev, a much MUCH worse man
@kacknoobdeluxe actually, they both ain't mass murders lol ))) Todays Putin's so called democracy killed more ppl then these two greatest rulers of Russia. Please see wiki Demography_of_the_Soviet_Union (also it's russian version - where more data on the graph)
@kacknoobdeluxe You remind me of Hellen Maud from the Simpson,the wanna-be Mother Teresa when she starts with her "Ohoho... Please! Won't somebody please think of the children?" bullshit.
While Hitler killed most people per capita (of all the conquered territories), Stalin himself was responsible for the deaths of about 50 Million people!
@Zylo587: Stalin was a dictator, but the Axis was a military pact formed by fascist dictatorships with capitalist economies, and any socialist state like the USSR or Mongolia would've never been accepted, because its ideology was in total opposition to the other members, and in consequence, no, he was not "technically a member of the axis". He was just an imperialist hungry-for-power ruler who converted the Soviet Union from a socialist workers' state to a profit-driven authoritarian state!
I'd play with Lenin more than with any world leader ever, but until they add him in one of the games in the series, I guess I'll have to settle with other leaders... Stalin is not really better than Catherine or Peter, cause he stalled the democratic revolutionary progress and killed millions of people, including former Bolsheviks, in order to subdue the country to his dictatorship.
@ironbrickstudios Listen to the Iranians. "Death to Dictators." There is no motivation for a King to be good. While some where, they were mostly ineffective power-grubbers who sent millions of loyal followers to their deaths in wars that accomplished nothing.
@leopoldvonhabsburg Most don't think of Stalin the same as Hitler because he fought against the Nazis, thus being labeled a "good guy". People don't pay attention to what was happening Russia afterwords save for the Cold War.
in a way thats wrong in a way its true. The amazing thing is how well a typical westerner responds to propaganda. during WW2 america released pro-stalin posters with the slogan "Uncle joe". and afterwards? he was a villian. the thing is people usually CHANGE their opinion on him and it corresponds perfectly with the intended propaganda. He did harsh things, but no harsher than most western leaders who we're told are heroes.
@leopoldvonhabsburg Its a game called Civilization, the point of the game is to play with all the famous world leaders, besides that, the Civilization leaders are cartoony and silly, Chairman Mao is actually pretty nice, he asked me if i wanted to sing Kumbaya to him when we met.
Странно что они не захотели добавить Гитлера ,видимо время еще не пришло .
EstRumata 1 week ago
FUCK YOU PETER FOR SPYING AND STEALING ALL MY TECH!
SuperKingLetsPlays 3 weeks ago
@SuperKingLetsPlays There is an option to enable "NO_ESPIONAGE"
Guillidan 1 week ago
But I have nothing against Russia in general.
leesditeensgoed 4 weeks ago
I hate Stalin, he's a bastard!
leesditeensgoed 4 weeks ago
The original name of this track is "Ey, ukhnem!" ("Yo, heave ho!", The Song of the Volga Boatmen).
MrOakenshield 1 month ago
@MidasRK1 So Churchill was also a mass murder!? D:
SovietLenin1 2 months ago
@SovietLenin1 He was actually.
BadassBigBoss 1 month ago
@BadassBigBoss If you think about war then yes. ALL leaders have to be mass murderers in war. Unless you want to capitulate without fighting for independence.
SovietLenin1 1 month ago
@SovietLenin1 You seem to not know the mans psychology. He was a devoted fanatic to war, which is why, unlike the sphere that surrounded him, he found himself excited when both WW1 and WW2 started and did not spare hesitation from doing a set of risky, life costly things that were sometimes not even that necessary amidst the war. Hell, the man even supported the use of gas on rebelling tribes.
BadassBigBoss 1 month ago
@BadassBigBoss That part i know. I just forgot the part about the tribes.
SovietLenin1 1 month ago
@SovietLenin1 Mhm. So what is your view on Churchill?
BadassBigBoss 1 month ago
@BadassBigBoss I will say in exception of the tribals he was a good man. Did you know some of the tribals ended up being UK's best soldiers?
SovietLenin1 1 month ago
@SovietLenin1 Nope, did not know that.
BadassBigBoss 1 month ago
Love how it's volga boatmen.
Briggsismyname 2 months ago
They should have Lenin or Trotksy instead of Stalin as leader..
youpon1000 2 months ago
@youpon1000 Trotsky was never the leader of USSR. Lenin was since 1917 up until his stroke in 1923. Stalin was for more than 20 years, up until 1952(he died the year after). Long live both of them.
metalorixos 2 months ago
@metalorixos But to be fair, Trotsky was largely in charge of the military during the Russian Revolution, right? Although I can get where you're coming from.
Personally, I agree with youpon, it should have been Lenin.
fizzypopism 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
if they put stalin in game why didn't thery put Hitler for Germany then ? I mean Stalin killed alot more people than Hitler
skuterixas91 2 months ago
Best theme of Civ IV.
Neriyahu 3 months ago
This sounds like a song i heard before...
SovietLenin1 3 months ago
@SovietLenin1 it's the Volga Boatman Song.
Ascensiam 3 months ago
@Ascensiam Thanks for reminding me!
SovietLenin1 3 months ago
They should have Stalin as a playable prime minister.
BgKnoccoutGangstaDre 3 months ago
to be honest well i don't count them stalin to be a mass muderer but he had to kill many people because the german army was advancing on him so he had to kill many people to save his country so it wasent his fault that he is a mass muderer cause he wouldent just let the Nazis just walk into russia.
123killlerz 3 months ago
@123killlerz Well if you dont take killing millions of Russians as a mass murdering then you must be crazy! >.>
SovietLenin1 3 months ago
@SovietLenin1 Im just saying
darkman1461 2 months ago
You can't sy that Peter the Great and Stalin weren't great leaders. The sorry fact is Stalin was a mass murderer. But Peter the Great wasn't. I think you simply hates Russia. You can't blame Russians for Stalin and communism!
MrLambadus 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You can't say that Stalin and Peter the Great weren't great leaders. They were charismatic and they managed their country well, too. The sorry fact is Stalin was a tiran and mass murderer. I think some of you simply doesen't like Russia. But it is a normal country! You can't blame Russians for Stalin and communizm!
MrLambadus 3 months ago
Comment removed
MrLambadus 3 months ago
in Soviet Russia Stalin & Peter Love You
j4pinkler 3 months ago in playlist Civ 4
A georgian bandit with little compassion in the clothes of a dictator. The song pulls that off perfectly.
BadassBigBoss 4 months ago
anyone who ties bush.....into a debate about who did what in WW2 is a fucking idiot
THIRDSHOCKARMY 4 months ago
@MidasRK1 George W Bush is mass murderer too.
Pvjinflight 4 months ago
@Pvjinflight You don't know shit.. And I hated Bush.
ubentu 4 months ago
@ubentu As if you knew better about your own country, yank!
BadassBigBoss 3 months ago
Stalin=Genghis Khan with a telephone
LeopardFixJeopardy 4 months ago
@MidasRK1 Well great military leaders commit mass murder in the battlefield. At least, most of them do.
dasmysteryman12 5 months ago
@MidasRK1 In a way, yes.
dasmysteryman12 5 months ago
mass murder glorification here ?
Oo
kacknoobdeluxe 5 months ago
@kacknoobdeluxe You know theme is also the theme of Peter the Great. And he isn't a mass murderer.
dasmysteryman12 5 months ago 16
@dasmysteryman12
i meant Stalin ^^ . Of course, Peter was a honorable leader.
kacknoobdeluxe 5 months ago
@dasmysteryman12
i meant Stalin . Of course, Peter was a honorable leader.
kacknoobdeluxe 5 months ago
@dasmysteryman12 You don't know how St. Petersburg was built :)
sharadowasdr 2 months ago
Comment removed
Getoverhere 2 months ago
@dasmysteryman12
Ain't a mass murderer? LOL
LHateseeker 1 month ago
@LHateseeker Well Stalin was more known for being a mass muderer than Peter was.
dasmysteryman12 1 month ago
@dasmysteryman12 But he certainly didn't invent many of the things they claim he did. The whole 'military rank based on merit and skill, not nobility' thing? Genghis Khan invented it first.
69Kambash64 2 weeks ago
@69Kambash64 Qin Shi Huangdi, and probably many other people before him.
threepoint14159265 1 week ago
@69Kambash64 Um...Russia was one of the Khanates.
Guillidan 1 week ago
@69Kambash64 that was done all the time, it was no invention. All people are saying is he brought it to first use in that nation (or at least reintroduced it)
Gunnarr123abc 1 day ago
@kacknoobdeluxe just so you know, almost every single person who was killed by "Stalin" was actually ordered and signed off by Kruschev, a much MUCH worse man
ARussianHat 3 months ago
@kacknoobdeluxe Hey! nobody minds glorifying Churchill.
Oppetsismiimsitsitc 3 months ago
@kacknoobdeluxe All mass murderers are in fact glorified heroes in history ^_^ .
sharadowasdr 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@kacknoobdeluxe actually, they both ain't mass murders lol ))) Todays Putin's so called democracy killed more ppl then these two greatest rulers of Russia. Please see wiki Demography_of_the_Soviet_Union (also it's russian version - where more data on the graph)
Getoverhere 2 months ago
@kacknoobdeluxe mass moroner, go count how many Indians you killed
Checkingokop 1 month ago
@kacknoobdeluxe You remind me of Hellen Maud from the Simpson,the wanna-be Mother Teresa when she starts with her "Ohoho... Please! Won't somebody please think of the children?" bullshit.
didi89s 1 month ago
why did they put that dick stalin in the game?
JordyJimenezPosada 6 months ago
@JordyJimenezPosada Because they wanted, the could have added Hittler on the game.
Grmonaco 5 months ago
@Grmonaco oh yea in tha past civ 3 i think he was also in the game right?
JordyJimenezPosada 4 months ago
@JordyJimenezPosada Yep, Stalin was in the past versions of civ.
Grmonaco 4 months ago
While Hitler killed most people per capita (of all the conquered territories), Stalin himself was responsible for the deaths of about 50 Million people!
Atvishees 6 months ago
AAAAAAAAAAA! MOTHERLAND!
GordonFleaman 6 months ago
stupid that most people dont know this song was used already in civilization 1
MidasRK 6 months ago
Did I just hear The Song of the Volga Boatmen at 1:52?
TechieWidget 6 months ago
@TechieWidget The whole thing is The Song of the Volga Boatmen.
Socialist96 6 months ago
@Zylo587: Stalin was a dictator, but the Axis was a military pact formed by fascist dictatorships with capitalist economies, and any socialist state like the USSR or Mongolia would've never been accepted, because its ideology was in total opposition to the other members, and in consequence, no, he was not "technically a member of the axis". He was just an imperialist hungry-for-power ruler who converted the Soviet Union from a socialist workers' state to a profit-driven authoritarian state!
Vict0r1984 7 months ago
I'd play with Lenin more than with any world leader ever, but until they add him in one of the games in the series, I guess I'll have to settle with other leaders... Stalin is not really better than Catherine or Peter, cause he stalled the democratic revolutionary progress and killed millions of people, including former Bolsheviks, in order to subdue the country to his dictatorship.
Vict0r1984 7 months ago
@ironbrickstudios Listen to the Iranians. "Death to Dictators." There is no motivation for a King to be good. While some where, they were mostly ineffective power-grubbers who sent millions of loyal followers to their deaths in wars that accomplished nothing.
Zylo587 7 months ago
the classic theme beginns at: 0:00 the renaisiance theme beginns at 1:30 the industrial theme beginns at: 2:50
derstaemezocker 7 months ago 18
@leopoldvonhabsburg no hitler is (imperialistic, agressive)
derstaemezocker 7 months ago
how do you play as stalin in civ iv ???? i cant, imean i can only choose between cathrin and peter...
iRadiatedBox 8 months ago
@iRadiatedBox Stalin is in the Warlords expansion pack
dasmysteryman12 8 months ago
@dasmysteryman12 thanx for replying man!
iRadiatedBox 8 months ago
@iRadiatedBox Install the Beyond the Sword Expansion
Guillidan 6 months ago
@Guillidan thanx
iRadiatedBox 6 months ago
I was disappointed when they didn't add Stalin to Civ5, who the hell wants to play as Cathrine?
TALOS7887 8 months ago 4
@TALOS7887 Everybody, because she's the greatest/ Stalin is too modern anyways.
Citylife10 8 months ago
@TALOS7887 peter is better because he has the better bonus in this game
derstaemezocker 7 months ago
@leopoldvonhabsburg Most don't think of Stalin the same as Hitler because he fought against the Nazis, thus being labeled a "good guy". People don't pay attention to what was happening Russia afterwords save for the Cold War.
DoomSprite236 8 months ago 19
@DoomSprite236
It is interesting how Nazi and western Propaganda go hand in hand when its about the Soviet Union.
revolutionary1948 7 months ago
@DoomSprite236 He invaded Poland alongside Hitler and the Slovak Puppet state. Until Hitler attacked him, he was technically a member of the Axis.
Zylo587 7 months ago
@DoomSprite236 Yes, but remember that both of them created their own ideologies, which made them dictators.
Guillidan 6 months ago
@DoomSprite236
in a way thats wrong in a way its true. The amazing thing is how well a typical westerner responds to propaganda. during WW2 america released pro-stalin posters with the slogan "Uncle joe". and afterwards? he was a villian. the thing is people usually CHANGE their opinion on him and it corresponds perfectly with the intended propaganda. He did harsh things, but no harsher than most western leaders who we're told are heroes.
fluffyzhangfei 4 months ago
@fluffyzhangfei Well Stalin was about as bad as Hitler, not saying that yankees were good either.
Pvjinflight 4 months ago
@DoomSprite236 waht washappening, dimwit, go read a real book on history
Checkingokop 1 month ago
@leopoldvonhabsburg Its a game called Civilization, the point of the game is to play with all the famous world leaders, besides that, the Civilization leaders are cartoony and silly, Chairman Mao is actually pretty nice, he asked me if i wanted to sing Kumbaya to him when we met.
chairincarnate 8 months ago
it would be great to have gaddafi and hitler XD
SuperThecrap 9 months ago
i mean that the last section is the best part, because it made me think of post-Soviet Russia
jianfongyaw 1 year ago
I knew it
jianfongyaw 1 year ago
Stalin's part sounded more optimistic and hopeful than Peter's murky track
jianfongyaw 1 year ago
@jianfongyaw Stalin and Peter have the same theme in the game.
dasmysteryman12 1 year ago 2
I know, but I mean that their versions of the theme is different
jianfongyaw 1 year ago
how do u get stalin?!?!
brettsworld99 1 year ago
@brettsworld99 Get Civ IV Warlords
OnionMan 1 year ago
@OnionMan is that its own game or an expantion pac?
brettsworld99 1 year ago
@brettsworld99 It's an expansion pack. There's two expansion packs and one spin off.
Civ IV Warlords
Civ IV Beyond the Sword
Civ IV Colonization is the spin off.
OnionMan 1 year ago
@OnionMan ah, so how may i ilegaly download these expantion pacs?
brettsworld99 1 year ago
@brettsworld99 torrentz
aljoshabre 1 year ago
@aljoshabre oh, thank you, i hope they work over here, im kinda not in my own country atm
brettsworld99 1 year ago
@brettsworld99 If you get BTS, you get all the civs and leaders from warlords.
TriangleGenix 1 year ago
@brettsworld99 I paid to download my expansions. They were only 15 bucks each.
OnionMan 1 year ago
@OnionMan hmmm, i went on a currency converter and i cant find bucks, so what it is in my money? (england)
brettsworld99 1 year ago
@brettsworld99 By bucks I mean CAD (Canadian Dollars). Try converting CAD to Pounds?
OnionMan 1 year ago
@OnionMan 15.00 Canadian dollars = 9.65 British pounds sterling, :) thanks eh, :D
brettsworld99 1 year ago
@brettsworld99 Nngh. Hate that stereotype but have fun my friend. Cheers.
OnionMan 1 year ago
The music is from "Volga Boatmen"
Cicano83 1 year ago 15
@Cicano83 Yes, I know that already...
dasmysteryman12 1 year ago
@dasmysteryman12 the music is from "volga boatmen"
radicalaceshasbrin 1 year ago
creepy .__.
2:57
ElChrisman99 1 year ago