The original is without a doubt my most favorite holiday special ever. Half of it was because of the actual storyline itself and the other characters. The other half was because of the miser brothers. I mean this special wasn't that great because my standards were set really high already. Honestly though, I just think it is great to see old characters come back to life after a long time. So even though this one wasn't awesome, I still enjoyed it. I just wish they made them look right.
the original is the greatest christmas classic ever created and this could be the worst thing i have ever seen... a song that tells u to respect your brother, dont fight, and do what they want to do not to mention the horrible narration, awful creativity, and just a terrible plot... my dad grew up watching the original, i grew up watching the original, and i hope to god my kids get to do the same and arent stuck with this
I think they should have just left the classic "The Year Without a Santa Claus" . The Original is SO much better. Mrs Claus is amazing in the original but in this one, she is so bad. If you haven't seen the original, see it! Don't watch this one!
Me, too. Although it's of course not as memorable as the original 'Year Without a Santa Claus,' I still thought it was a funny, likable Christmas special.
They should make an 'Ultimate Edition' DVD of 'YWASC' which would include the original version, the live- action version from 2006, and 'Miser Brothers' Christmas.'
haha i loved the flashback thing :P i wish the full flashback at the beginning was there :( the part where you see the fire spark hit snow miser :P it was soo cute the flashback :P thnx for sharing i lvoed this!! even if it wasn't the same as the other one its was cute whyat they did with the whole mother nature thing im glad they decided to add mroe to it :)
@Bijou42 Well for Snow misers voice, the guy who played him died (Sadly). However, they could have found some one with a similar voice. As for Mrs. Claus I totally agree. I wish they brought Iggy back too.
I agree--Dick Shawn is sadly no longer with us, but I still dunno why they had to make such drastic changes to him. He was my favorite in the original. I'd have hired Michael McKean. He did well in the live-action version. I also missed Iggy, Jingle & Jangle, etc. The whole 'Nature family gathering' concept was interesting. But since the North Wind (who was jealous of Santa like Jack Frost envied Frosty)'s territory obviously overlaps Snowy's, he shouldn't have been the automatic replacement.
@Bijou42 They couldn't mess Heat Miser up too much because they were actually able to get GeorgeT S. Irving (and Mickey Rooney!) back, at least. But their presence just makes you miss Shirley, Dick, and the rest of the original cast even more. >.<
@Vernydog92 Haha, I actually like this song...and Mrs. Claus even sounds all right singing it for the most part...but you're RIGHT, that song is perfect too. :0
Ik this is a heart warming moment....but I love how Snowmiser can hide behind the skinniest tree ever.....
222lostgirl 5 months ago
I love this song and brothers and sisters should be friends
rougeandgambit3D 6 months ago
The original is without a doubt my most favorite holiday special ever. Half of it was because of the actual storyline itself and the other characters. The other half was because of the miser brothers. I mean this special wasn't that great because my standards were set really high already. Honestly though, I just think it is great to see old characters come back to life after a long time. So even though this one wasn't awesome, I still enjoyed it. I just wish they made them look right.
cakecrumb095 1 year ago
the original is the greatest christmas classic ever created and this could be the worst thing i have ever seen... a song that tells u to respect your brother, dont fight, and do what they want to do not to mention the horrible narration, awful creativity, and just a terrible plot... my dad grew up watching the original, i grew up watching the original, and i hope to god my kids get to do the same and arent stuck with this
rangerfreak616 1 year ago
I think they should have just left the classic "The Year Without a Santa Claus" . The Original is SO much better. Mrs Claus is amazing in the original but in this one, she is so bad. If you haven't seen the original, see it! Don't watch this one!
Cheeiro753 2 years ago
I liked ot better when they piss each other off. them being friends disturbed me. -_-
malachailover678 2 years ago 2
I like to think that after the movie, they piss eachother off again and they turn back into their usual selves.
DaWeaselFreak 3 years ago 4
It's soooooo cute when they are babys!
Ishcoa 3 years ago 4
Okay, I've been filled with hatred for this special, but I'm no longer the evil Winter Warlock...
If I had little kids this would be fun and enjoyable for them.
But as for me, I'm a selfish adult. I WANT MY OLD HEAT & SNOW MISER BACK! WaaaaaaHHHHHH!
SeeItAndBelieve 3 years ago 7
me too!
meganlikepie56 2 years ago
I really like that song. *sniff* I almost cried watching that part. :")
Anyway, the movie is well done. I like it. ^_^
SuperNintendoKid123 3 years ago 4
Me, too. Although it's of course not as memorable as the original 'Year Without a Santa Claus,' I still thought it was a funny, likable Christmas special.
They should make an 'Ultimate Edition' DVD of 'YWASC' which would include the original version, the live- action version from 2006, and 'Miser Brothers' Christmas.'
Adamguy2003 3 years ago 2
haha i loved the flashback thing :P i wish the full flashback at the beginning was there :( the part where you see the fire spark hit snow miser :P it was soo cute the flashback :P thnx for sharing i lvoed this!! even if it wasn't the same as the other one its was cute whyat they did with the whole mother nature thing im glad they decided to add mroe to it :)
Xx0xc4rlyx0xX 3 years ago 2
The original Mrs. Claus could sing way better than this wanna-be Claus!
Livesindreams5 3 years ago 3
I watched this special and enjoyed it. It is nice to see the Miser Brothers get along.
StellaMagic37 3 years ago 2
For some ungodly reason I opted to watch this movie...
and a part of me died inside.
tbsigma4life 3 years ago 3
why can't they just make mrs. claus the way she looked in the first one!
cakecrumb095 3 years ago 3
Because the first one came out in 1060 something. Plus this was made by a differnt company.
animefannorrie 3 years ago
Ask that for EVERY character
phantompersian 2 years ago
@cakecrumb095 I don't know why they opted to make most of the characters so different. Especially Mother Nature, and Snowy's voice......
Bijou42 1 year ago
@Bijou42 Well for Snow misers voice, the guy who played him died (Sadly). However, they could have found some one with a similar voice. As for Mrs. Claus I totally agree. I wish they brought Iggy back too.
cakecrumb095 1 year ago
I agree--Dick Shawn is sadly no longer with us, but I still dunno why they had to make such drastic changes to him. He was my favorite in the original. I'd have hired Michael McKean. He did well in the live-action version. I also missed Iggy, Jingle & Jangle, etc. The whole 'Nature family gathering' concept was interesting. But since the North Wind (who was jealous of Santa like Jack Frost envied Frosty)'s territory obviously overlaps Snowy's, he shouldn't have been the automatic replacement.
Bijou42 1 year ago
@Bijou42 They couldn't mess Heat Miser up too much because they were actually able to get GeorgeT S. Irving (and Mickey Rooney!) back, at least. But their presence just makes you miss Shirley, Dick, and the rest of the original cast even more. >.<
Bijou42 1 year ago
MY EARS!!!!! THEY'RE BLEEDING!!!!
HeidiTheCat 3 years ago
You know what...get rid of Mrs. Claus and put the Brother, My Brother song in from Pokemon the first movie.
Vernydog92 3 years ago
You know what's scary? That would actually work really well!
GlobalsoftPirka 3 years ago 3
Now that I think of it...it would...ha!
Vernydog92 3 years ago
@Vernydog92 Haha, I actually like this song...and Mrs. Claus even sounds all right singing it for the most part...but you're RIGHT, that song is perfect too. :0
Bijou42 1 year ago
Sooo cute but I swear...Mrs. Claus CAN'T SING!!
Vernydog92 3 years ago 2
The original voice actor couldn't come in because the original passed away a long time ago.
Ed2Bobobo 3 years ago 3
Yeah...I know...I just wish they didn't have the character sing...instead have a pre-recorded song in there.
Vernydog92 3 years ago
they were so cute as babies!!
milkygoodness 3 years ago 5