@Penfoldsmith maybe it's not only the germans who have to learn from their past (as other nations should do, but often fail) but perhaps also the older generations should learn that todays germany isn't nazi germany although people like to keep the old stereotypes and that nobody playing or marching there is responsible for anything what happened in the past!
Good taste or bad taste aside, even a defeated nation has the right to honor its war dead. Forget about grudges and remember that young men from several nations died here, miles from home in the middle of mankind's cruelest phenomenon, not for the sake of democracy or national socialism but because of the fault of their own governments. Regardless of what sins our forefathers may have committed, they have paid for whatever debts they owe. All men are absolved in death, so let them rest.
This hymn is from a time long before Hitler. It's text obviously is in stark contrast to everything the Nazis were about. I still wish Germany to be a place of freedom, justice and rule of law ("...Recht und Freiheit..."). So I proudly sing our natoinal anthem into the faces of anyone of totalitarian beliefs!
This is what I was upset about, because I also saw the crowd cheering to the Band at La Fiere and in town of St.-Mère-Eglise. There are always individuals that don't agree on certain things. I also spotted some German very right individuals, that when I was talking to them had very strange ideas. I told them to f*** off and return to Germany, as no one needs them around here.
The soldiers were born a long time after the war and are part of NATO and many of them served alongside with their French, Canadian, British, American, Dutch, ... comrades in Afghanistan, Kosovo ans else where.
The old people just have to get along.
We are one EU and we all have to accept it.
When Mitterand and Kohl were able to become friends, why can't the rest of us do the same.
If Allied and German Veterans become friends why can't the St.-Mère locals?
@Penfoldsmith maybe it's not only the germans who have to learn from their past (as other nations should do, but often fail) but perhaps also the older generations should learn that todays germany isn't nazi germany although people like to keep the old stereotypes and that nobody playing or marching there is responsible for anything what happened in the past!
ScallySkinMaster 1 month ago
@Penfoldsmith
Oh yes! the ever lasting song of the bad-bad germans. Can no more hear that
b.........t of all these good-good-non-german people arround the world and cannot
agree with you:
Was living in Normandy >5 years (between 69 and now) have french children
there (Carentan) and never felt or saw in more than 40 years there what you
saw in 5 minutes. B.t.w., I was also in St.M.E that very day.
seibelstein 4 months ago
Good taste or bad taste aside, even a defeated nation has the right to honor its war dead. Forget about grudges and remember that young men from several nations died here, miles from home in the middle of mankind's cruelest phenomenon, not for the sake of democracy or national socialism but because of the fault of their own governments. Regardless of what sins our forefathers may have committed, they have paid for whatever debts they owe. All men are absolved in death, so let them rest.
dannyboyj644 4 months ago
respects on ALL soldier fallen on this ground! No respect for islam invaders in our coutrys! THINK ABOUT THAT!
watisna 4 months ago
It's the same hymn-like in the second world war!
Hitler, and all the shit ...
We need a new German national anthem!
TheSovietEnd 6 months ago
@TheSovietEnd
This hymn is from a time long before Hitler. It's text obviously is in stark contrast to everything the Nazis were about. I still wish Germany to be a place of freedom, justice and rule of law ("...Recht und Freiheit..."). So I proudly sing our natoinal anthem into the faces of anyone of totalitarian beliefs!
OLord77 4 months ago
@Penfoldsmith
You are right when you say, that you saw this.
...Bad taste...
This is what I was upset about, because I also saw the crowd cheering to the Band at La Fiere and in town of St.-Mère-Eglise. There are always individuals that don't agree on certain things. I also spotted some German very right individuals, that when I was talking to them had very strange ideas. I told them to f*** off and return to Germany, as no one needs them around here.
OmahaBeachMartin 10 months ago
@Penfoldsmith
The soldiers were born a long time after the war and are part of NATO and many of them served alongside with their French, Canadian, British, American, Dutch, ... comrades in Afghanistan, Kosovo ans else where.
The old people just have to get along.
We are one EU and we all have to accept it.
When Mitterand and Kohl were able to become friends, why can't the rest of us do the same.
If Allied and German Veterans become friends why can't the St.-Mère locals?
OmahaBeachMartin 10 months ago 6
@OmahaBeachMartin
Dude, it is important to get over things. These comrades did the right thing. Vive la fraternite!
Nogger86Germany 3 months ago
holy formation batman...my arm was hurting for holding a salute for 6 songs...lol
jsheptock 1 year ago
Why are they playing the German National Anthem? Do they have something to celebrate? I think it is so inappropriate.
WoNNoHaVeS 1 year ago
They played all national anthems, I just put this one online.
OmahaBeachMartin 1 year ago