Who Will Buy from Celebrate Oliver

[RukiaFujioka]

Isn't the girl in the white from Celtic women?

[TheRpj1234]

I totally agree with you, smartsingingurl.

[Katelovesglee]

I'm in a local production if Oliver and it's only a small town so most of the performers aren't professional. But to be honest... I prefer them to this. This is beautiful but it seems so fake ( yeah I know it is but it's not natural) and the Rose seller is only like 17 but she has an amazing sweet voice, the milkmaid is 16 and she's brilliant and the strawberry seller is barely 15 and her voice is powerful! And sure we have a knife grinder who's only 11 and he's fantastic!

[smartsingingurl]

@Katelovesglee Hey sorry, I hit the wrong button. Yeah, a local theatre did a production of Oliver!, and it was amazing. A lot of kids and people who haven't have a lick of singing lessons or anything can put professionals to shame. So I really like your comment, but I knida hit the down button. Soooo sorry for that. But you are right.

[arrotogenital]

beautiful! beautiful! beautiful! viva la oliver! viva la Charles Dickens

[musicgeek311]

this is gorgeous

[necromanzer52]

I'm playing the knife grinder in my school's production.

Wish me luck.

[Syonixx]

Wow, the rose sellers voice is one of the most beautiful i have heard, and she looks stunning to. Her voice also reminds me alot of Julia Roberts in the style she sings and the way she reverberates and uses her breath while singing, espically at 0:46!

[sorchathingy]

erm why isnt the flower girl singing her part.... its so stupid

and there are ment to be like 5 milkmaids.... this is nothing on the origoinal

[slythysophia]

@sorchathingy

Perhaps you only watched the movie, which actually departed rather dramatically from the original musical in many ways, but there is actually only "supposed" to be 1 milkmaid...at least that's how the music was written. Maybe instead of focusing on how it doesn't fit *your* idea of how it should be, you could try to appreciate it as its own individual performance with individual merits.

[dylantiger2]

is oliver a m/f?

[nickylibera]

@dylantiger2 a male

[computer5892]

@dylantiger2 have u ever watched the film?

[dylantiger2]

@dylantiger2 Yes, I have been in the show twice. I'm asking about the performer who played the role:)

[KayKay114]

My dear lady, you are a sweet red rose ^^

[riftintimeandspace]

The Choirboys <3

[vitoa111]

love this song

[veerlejemima101]

Hayley rocks! xD she's so gorgeous! <33

[CptJackSparrowLove]

My god! The chord at 1:40 - 1:49! I get chills everytime I hear it! And the guy is awesome, though I do not know who he is.

[LStevens123191]

@CptJackSparrowLove I completely agree with you on that

[urworstnightmare123]

wow, aled jones is still brilliant.

[gpaine123]

The Milkmaid is Haley Westernra, I was at the recording ofthis show

[cosmoscamprocks]

the milkmaid is from celtic woman!!!!

[FunkyGunkMunkeys]

The blonde "milkmaid" one kind of looks like taylor swift

[pollypoo10]

the boy that plays oliver is kinda bad. but its still awesome!

[LolaWoods]

Really? I think he's got a very clear, well-trained voice, if a little irritating.

[Kaileo1]

...and there's Hayley Westenra!

[artfuldodger12]

the person who plays Oliver, he looks like AnnaSophia Robb....with a hat....when she was a little younger

[ChoFrog09]

Wow, you're right

[XosisterbearXo]

the knifegrinder is a really good singer.

[SweeneyToddFanatic2]

whoah...you're right

[LucyCannibleyones]

what you mean aled jones? he is amazing

[Kat101991]

That's Aled Jones...he started out as a really famous boy chorister and then kept on singing even when his voice broke. You can see him in a lot of videos with a group called Libera as well as his own videos from songs he has recorded.

[Sibadibdoo2]

wow I just LVOE the choirboys!

it gave me such a shock when I saw them on here!

[savblogs1]

I am the Milk Maid in my school production...

cos our production is oliver!!

[AmiraTamran]

the kid playing oliver looks like Anna Sophia Robb!!

[x3xAnImEYuNax3x]

they do dont they

[idigcows]

hahaha that's a boy

[LittleWhiteShoes]

isn't the milk maid that hayley girl (sp?)?? she was in celtic woman 2 i think...??

[witherwings14]

IT IS!!

[LittleWhiteShoes]

i just KNEW it!!

[AnglOsAxOn2]

You all seem to know each other lol

Just watched this and absolutely loved it!

Well done on a great performance.

[90pinkbird]

R those the chourboys? From tears in heaven or somehting?

[Marthinjo09]

yes that was them!

[xRxUxBxYx]

amy is really good!!

wow, who knew she could sing like that?!

[VeritasSeek]

I could listen to the Rose seller sing all day! Her voice is as gorgeous as her face. Milk maid's brilliant too.

[nowonderitsneverland]

isnt the milk made hayley westerna from celtic woman??

[witherwings14]

IT IS!!!

[pix042]

Not sure who it is but you can watch the whole of Celebrate Oliver on Google videos. It was a BBCTV special from 2005.

[theaterzmylife]

Hayley is AMZING!

[francescamusical]

haley is so pretty. :)

[bakuganfan1234]

i have a question that girl who plays oliver is that a boy or girl

[VeritasSeek]

It's a boy. Hard to believe, eh? lol

[YouCantPullMeDown16]

his name is Joseph McManners

[no1phantomfreak]

the milk one is hayley westenra...she is an amazing singer

[gonsloog]

that is very good i like the woman singing about the milk

[Sapphire848]

When I first saw this, I thought Joseph was a girl, but once I fond out who he was, I've become a big fan. I love Hayley, she's an amazing singer, Aled is also one of my favourites. I've listened to the choir boys a few times- wonderful voices, and Amy is very good, too.

[JessieJay13]

i thought it was a girl too! but he's so good!!

[bcnprods]

aw that was beautiful

[scootyscoot4]

Amy Nuttall has a beautiful voice and is one of the most versatile performers of today. Her soprano voice carries the song here, yet in Cabaret she sings songs which would be well below many other soprano's range and sings them brilliantly.

[predat44]

She does actually say ''Who will buy, its just that she says it very quick

[octaves13]

Did you notice that the rose seller says "Will you buy ma sweet red roses"? but she has a great voice.

[mevionline]

Beautiful voices!!

This is Amazing T.T

Wonderful =D

[AdolfKreutzberg]

You're right.

[kazuhiko23]

I love this song, very nice

Many thanks This goes to my favorites.

Regards^^^_

[TheGeekWearsPrada]

I remember in London last year, there was this guy trying to sell the 'Big Issue' mag. He was singing 'Who will buyyyyy, my boring Big Issuuuuuue' to this melody! If I'd had any change I'd have bought one to reward him for his originality.

[JessieJay13]

lol, that's hilarious!!

[BecciBarham1993]

very good you all sing so beautiful xxxxx

[Rach4evaRox]

the singer who is singing about sweet red roses is Amy Nutall (she used to bein Emmerdale)!

The milk singer is the pure of Hayley Westenra!!

Both very good singers!

[ArcheryChat]

ok, he is english, he trys too hard

[luvsmovies79]

I think he's adorable.

[medicenastor]

I really think the milk'girl is from celtic women, and those three boys are choir boys...

[medicenastor]

is the milk's girl from celtic women?????

I really think is she!!

[Mayaiskoolieeo]

The girl who was singing about the milk was pretty

[fateforgotten]

I do not think Joseph McManners is very good for the part

[Mayaiskoolieeo]

he has really nice eyes

[franj1]

this oliver is crap

[ArcheryChat]

it's because he isn't american or english. he sounds german sometimes

[barraghirl]

these songs are better than the oliver! in 1968 well some of them are

[witchhat]

Beautiful, but I miss the rush into the big dance and up tempo part.

[brguest123]

This is an amazing song!!!

I'm playing the artful dodger at my school...and while im so excited to play him, im sad i cant be a part of this song!

this song is beautiful!

[0broadway0baby0]

Oliver kind of looks like annasophia robb.

[sinead612]

wot that mean

[0broadway0baby0]

he looks kind of like the actress annasophia robb. she was in because of winn dixie and samantha.

[margolin5]

that's exactly what i just thought. if you watch Where is Love especially.

[0broadway0baby0]

me too! definately in where is love.

[raindropkiss7]

this is the best thing ever!

[Tomboytilyrox]

Olivers a boy his name is Joseph Mcmanners

[FamousGreg122]

Way not as cool as the movie or the original.

[omentothepreps]

why are they waering modern costume?>

[aaah1]

They did this song so beautifully, way better than the movie.

[AnatomyGirl987]

who has a toothache? is the oliver a girl

[frenchprincess24]

When was this?

[Mindda]

frenchprincess24, if you look around you will find the answers to half your questions. The title of the song? - look at the name given at the top as the name of the video. When was it? - look at my answer to the same question 3 months ago. Info re the singers? - look at the info given by nickylibera at the top......

[frenchprincess24]

I asked that really long ago, and I had the answers to the questions long time ago!

[Mindda]

According to the dating here, you asked 3 weeks ago and only one answer was posted. I was just suggesting that the answers to questions are often already there, and you may as well look around the site first before asking things!

[frenchprincess24]

Sorry then.

[frenchprincess24]

What is the title of this song?

[mizzfit24601]

Who Will Buy?

[frenchprincess24]

Who is the boy who sang at 1:55?

[frenchprincess24]

Does anyone has this MP3 song?

[Sqid101]

That could be created from the video, although it gets a bit involved.

[frenchprincess24]

i see, Thanks!

[billygillxxx]

they are fabulous...except the choirboys

[jbreyer]

beautiful - thank you kindly for the post!

[RandomFreakyGirl]

This was ok ... but I'm still for the original.

[crunchychip]

Where is this from?

[Mindda]

This was from a show on British TV Christmas 2005 called "Celebrate Oliver".

[contrarymotion]

Who's oliver?

[Mindda]

Do you mean who is singing as Oliver? if so - it is Joseph McManners

[frenchprincess24]

The boy who sings at the end.

[MarieLeah]

I was slightly disappointed that the action was masked by them standing without motion... I dont understand why they didnt dress them up and get them doing the routeen. I love this song but it wasnt the best version Ive heard of it.

[xeddieizzardx]

I like Amy better than Hayley, Amy doesn't have the typical Soprano voice - she sounds so much nicer.

[virginiawaldron]

Simply beautiful voices.

[billy1983yes]

Is this recorded on some DVD? If so, what is the name of the DVD?

[nickylibera]

No, It was on TV once. I can't remember when though.

[Mindda]

It was on about Christmas / New Year last year

[pianoguy1988]

That part totally did NOT do justice for the Choirboys. I like patrick's voice better than Josephs.

[Tracy137]

Fantastic!

[bestpi]

spectacular!

[laylagypsy]

Ooh, beautiful! Thanks for putting it up, I love it!

[gingyhaz]

Aww i watched this at new years brings back memories also reminds me of xmas...

[fatgirlgrobie]

that man has a great voice

[kribusjoe]

Well I think that Hayley is MUCH better than Amy... Her voice is cleaner.. And yes no doubt that it's Aled...

[eveningthought]

Amy's album is pretty nice but alot of the times she doesn't get on top of her notes which annoys me. She sounds great here though.

[operaticxingenue]

i knew that was Amy! but Hayley singing screw it up! I'LL BUY YOUR FREAKIN' MILK THEN POUR IT DOWN YOUR FREAKIN' SHIRT! lol! i like Amy...but HAYLEY? OMFG!

[Sqid101]

At least Hayley is singing in tune! ;-)

[Sqid101]

At Least Hayley is singing in tune!

[operaticxingenue]

True but that doesn't make up for the fact that she has horrible vocal technique.

[Sqid101]

Millions of singers who would give there left arm to be as successful as she is, so a horrible vocal technique is a good thing. She does look a bit odd in that vid. As though she has toothache or something. She's just done Maria in the latest version of West Side Story, so you can see some more bad technique there.

[broadwaymelody33]

:) Sqid101 is my new favorite person.

I would give my left foot to suck that much ;) lol

[Sqid101]

Well, it's not her fault that she has toothache. Actually, they all have a strange vocal technique except the woman in red and she's out of tune. So there you are!

[broadwaymelody33]

I knew she had a toothache. I still think she's amazing though

(I was being sarcastic about her sucking in my last commment, just to let you know ^_~ )

[Sqid101]

I thought you meant that I was sucking... I don't know if she has toothache or not. She does look different somehow. But I don't think her technique is that unusual. Her breath technique may not always be perfect. But you could probably say that about many singers.

[Sqid101]

On second thoughts, I'll take that back. Amy is a beautiful girl and sings wonderfully!

[Mindda]

The other female singer is Amy Nuttall, once of Emmerdale fame! And it absolutely is Aled Jones. He has a great voice, and can sing a wide variety of types of song

[billy1983yes]

This is absolutely beautiful!!

Btw is the guy really Aled Jones? Coz I have his CD, he does not sound that "strong baritone voice" in the CD. I really doubt is that the same person~

[nickylibera]

Yes it is Aled Jones. It's just the way the song is sang so he makes it sound like it should.

[hunter1989de]

of course it is Aled Jones!

[billy1983yes]

Haha I just wanna make sure, coz he is too good and I just can't believe he is this good :) This made me think he is even better than I thought.

[kribusjoe]

who's the last one???

[nickylibera]

Joseph McManners

[kribusjoe]

No I ment the last woman... one of them is Hayley Westenra but who is the other???

[nickylibera]

I can't remember!! sorry.

[kribusjoe]

ok.. never mind... It's not important, but the song's great:-)

[gingyhaz]

Isn't she Catherine some1?

[hunter1989de]

Do you mean the boy? It is Joseph McManners

[Lomakil]

Amy Nuttall