I've been digesting their albums for just a couple of months now. If this is their weaker stuff than that's very impressive. I just put their whole catalog on shuffle and i'm good.
I get it, you all want your hipster cred for liking a band that got mainstream cred before they were known by the mainstream. But they are still the same band and haven't changed at all. They still have the same soul they had in the beginning. This is not the band to play the "gee they sold out card." They still have it.
@tenaciousE21912 dont get me wrong, i love the gritty blues garage rock sound that they've became known for but at the same time i love the diversity/variety of music they have crafted. To go from the sound of the first 3 albums to brothers is a beautiful thing to me. They've made a great transition from one style of music to another, unlike many artists whos tried that and failed epicially (i.e. lil wayne attempting to do rock music...YIKES!!) and i welcome that as long as the music is good:)
@blackkeychucktown I know that. when i said the 1st three albums im referring specifically to The Big Come Up, Thickfreakness and Rubber Factory cause those albums were the most bluesy & raw. Magic Potion was more of a straight up rock out album and Attack & Release was more alternative sounding, so thats why im referring to the 1st three when comparing them to brothers.. I hope i cleared that up for you?
I can't believe you guys. The Keys are evolving and getting BETTER! Their songs, while not as raw, are great songs. Well produced, sound great, good lyrics, good riffs, great voice. They haven't changed in any way and still play the old stuff. You have to evolve in the music business. The Keys are one of the very few examples of bands who have done so without selling out or sacrificing quality for mainstream appeal.
@tenaciousE21912 thank you! i dont get why some of these long time black keys fans & critics alike are acting like brothers is the worst thing ever made when its really not. It has soul & the quality of music is THERE but its soulful in a funk rock-ish ol school R&B-soul kind of way and because it aint the same usual gritty blues rock stuff that means its terrible. If it were any other band that made the brothers albums i bet these same critics would have nothing negative to say about it.
..or they were just trying something new because they didn't want to be playing the same old thing and make an album that sounds exactly the same as all their other albums.
@resonancecascade89 I forget who said this, some famous bluesman. I think it was Willie Dixon. "blues is the roots: everything else is the fruits". The Black Keys are just producing fruit now haha. I mean, it all sounds spectacular, but it's just not as raw anymore. they'll go back though. I hope...
Just cant listen to enough of this band, I listen to metal religiously but this shit has moved me towards blues and bluegrass, so simple but sounds so fukin awesome
holy shit this is the High Noon? I've played on this stage!!i! I wish i would have known that the Black Keys had set foot there. now it makes things even more special :)
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
this drummer sucks. i mean hes decent but compared to the drummer he is covering, its too weak. beefheart's drummer was creative and so put together some native american and african style grooves with blues form on Safe as Milk. This guy is even fucking up the stop time. Dont get my wrong, Im thankful beyond belief that they have the taste to know what song to try to cover, I just have a feeling it wasnt the drummers idea!
Coming from a Beefheart/John French fanatic: Patrick Carney is the perfect drummer for the Black Keys. In this version of the song, it's all about the raw passion, the explosion of drums and guitar after each verse. Dan and Pat are tight, and the song is fucking unstoppable.
Unbelievable! This is Junior Kimbrough & RL Burnside resurrected. Today only Alvin Youngblood Hart has this amount of soul. These youngsters are among THE BEST ever.
Comment removed
PatMurph245 2 months ago
I've been digesting their albums for just a couple of months now. If this is their weaker stuff than that's very impressive. I just put their whole catalog on shuffle and i'm good.
TheElectricCentaur 5 months ago
I get it, you all want your hipster cred for liking a band that got mainstream cred before they were known by the mainstream. But they are still the same band and haven't changed at all. They still have the same soul they had in the beginning. This is not the band to play the "gee they sold out card." They still have it.
tenaciousE21912 5 months ago
@tenaciousE21912 dont get me wrong, i love the gritty blues garage rock sound that they've became known for but at the same time i love the diversity/variety of music they have crafted. To go from the sound of the first 3 albums to brothers is a beautiful thing to me. They've made a great transition from one style of music to another, unlike many artists whos tried that and failed epicially (i.e. lil wayne attempting to do rock music...YIKES!!) and i welcome that as long as the music is good:)
yugang08 3 months ago
@yugang08 they made 5 full length albums before brothers
blackkeychucktown 2 months ago
@blackkeychucktown I know that. when i said the 1st three albums im referring specifically to The Big Come Up, Thickfreakness and Rubber Factory cause those albums were the most bluesy & raw. Magic Potion was more of a straight up rock out album and Attack & Release was more alternative sounding, so thats why im referring to the 1st three when comparing them to brothers.. I hope i cleared that up for you?
yugang08 2 months ago
@resonancecascade89 hey man, if you like the keys then you like the keys, what ever they do
aer0smith1 5 months ago
@aer0smith1 I was gonna say..onward and upward...they still are the same "kind" of musicians.
SCRex0472 5 months ago
это круто!!!
реально!!!
парни так держать)))))
MrIgnatenkov 6 months ago 2
I can't believe you guys. The Keys are evolving and getting BETTER! Their songs, while not as raw, are great songs. Well produced, sound great, good lyrics, good riffs, great voice. They haven't changed in any way and still play the old stuff. You have to evolve in the music business. The Keys are one of the very few examples of bands who have done so without selling out or sacrificing quality for mainstream appeal.
tenaciousE21912 6 months ago
@tenaciousE21912 LOLOL...
sheadude6778 5 months ago
@tenaciousE21912 thank you! i dont get why some of these long time black keys fans & critics alike are acting like brothers is the worst thing ever made when its really not. It has soul & the quality of music is THERE but its soulful in a funk rock-ish ol school R&B-soul kind of way and because it aint the same usual gritty blues rock stuff that means its terrible. If it were any other band that made the brothers albums i bet these same critics would have nothing negative to say about it.
yugang08 3 months ago
@resonancecascade89 that's what happens when they tell you here's a couple million and a recording studio
j5tj 7 months ago
@j5tj
..or they were just trying something new because they didn't want to be playing the same old thing and make an album that sounds exactly the same as all their other albums.
cockardo 7 months ago
@resonancecascade89 i could not agree more. ok it's a good album, brothers. yeah, if considered as if it was their first
maximof 9 months ago
Comment removed
tiemyshoes92 9 months ago
Telecaster!!!
rockhardrockfan 9 months ago
@resonancecascade89 I forget who said this, some famous bluesman. I think it was Willie Dixon. "blues is the roots: everything else is the fruits". The Black Keys are just producing fruit now haha. I mean, it all sounds spectacular, but it's just not as raw anymore. they'll go back though. I hope...
Colin2720 9 months ago
@resonancecascade89
best comment ever made on any bk video
cjohnson22463 10 months ago 6
Just cant listen to enough of this band, I listen to metal religiously but this shit has moved me towards blues and bluegrass, so simple but sounds so fukin awesome
leadbelly1981 10 months ago
tell you mr ugly, he didnt look like you, fucking awesome
timj41 10 months ago
hellllll yeaaaaa
BLOOJaah 10 months ago
CAPTIAN BEEFHEART COVER GOD WHAT A GREAT BAND
Youngroe1 11 months ago
Comment removed
Bazirker 1 year ago
holy shit this is the High Noon? I've played on this stage!!i! I wish i would have known that the Black Keys had set foot there. now it makes things even more special :)
Swashbukkles 1 year ago
what tuning is he playing in???
amickrocker 1 year ago
@amickrocker Standard tuning in Em pentatonic maybe tuned a little flat.
knipester2007 1 year ago
i prefer the beard
Floorwalker1337 1 year ago
i think i've liked this song more than once
enthnd03 1 year ago
black keys and beefheart. thats the shit
spinnact 1 year ago
I think the world would explode if this guys ever jammed with the white stripes
Profy00 1 year ago
Another beefheart one yeah!
56oldssuper88 1 year ago
if these guys had never met i would have killed myself
yourmomsplacenta24 1 year ago 12
rofl that guy who shouts Break it down! its timed perfectly hah
ZappaMaskReplica 1 year ago 6
I think Dan used to look so cool, when he played Telecasters and had no facial hair.
Omie789 1 year ago 8
@Omie789 i think he played a vintage teisco
blackkeychucktown 1 year ago
BAD ASS
fs07 1 year ago
Faceeee MEEELLLLTTTTTT
mjchopper54 1 year ago
If you like this cover, their cover of The Beatles' "She Said She Said" is pretty awesome as well.
ahsgreenwave 1 year ago
love the cover!
kanibalis 1 year ago
DAN IS FATHER OF JESUS
danceian 1 year ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
came here from beefheart-found nothing
phillfoote 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Robert Pete Williams (born 1914), author of Grown So Ugly
Covered in 1967 by Captain Beefhart and his Magic Band (arrangement by Ry Cooder)
This cover was then recovered by The Black Keys in 2004
You can like best whichever version you want but Robert still did it first and just him and a guitar.
george383 2 years ago
Nice tone from the tele
MrLedzepp88 2 years ago
so fucking great
BigFrikinCookie33 2 years ago
BEEFHEART!
vitorbelfort 2 years ago 2
2:16 yeah!
flortega85 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i think i just died a little bit Nothing is Sacred Anymore =(
klummp 2 years ago
@klummp
This is sacred.
telepylus111 2 years ago 3
that was truly EPIC
InstinctBlues3 2 years ago
For just wo guys, the are MIGHTY!
FourteenInTheMAking 2 years ago 2
great performance...
zang99 2 years ago
Hey, I'm c. johnson too! Neat.
Also, he looks sooo different without his beard...
marinecam 2 years ago
*slow clap*
mrgooders 2 years ago
Dan, you're such a cutie - and now we can actually see your face, finally!
litappleblossom1314 2 years ago
This is really old....sorry
GV14982 2 years ago
Damn it, this is the Wisconsin show I missed shortly after discovering the Black Keys cuz I was still a minor.
Amnesiac197 2 years ago
long life To Rock 'n' roll xD
nirvomind 2 years ago 2
Dan is so unbelievably hot : |
CitizenKerry 2 years ago 2
even with the huge beard?
ryandude1994 2 years ago 4
Not as much with the huge beard but it's still all good :)
CitizenKerry 2 years ago
dude, ESPECIALLY with the huge beard.
naran13 2 years ago 3
YES
deatheater459 2 years ago
Gosh, that was a good live version.
skippyriddle 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
fucking awful
TheClugger 2 years ago
This is a Beefheart cover, is it not?
SergeantShred 3 years ago
Yes!
stopthrm 3 years ago
original is by robert pete williams.
beefheart was a cover aswell
kieran09 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this drummer sucks. i mean hes decent but compared to the drummer he is covering, its too weak. beefheart's drummer was creative and so put together some native american and african style grooves with blues form on Safe as Milk. This guy is even fucking up the stop time. Dont get my wrong, Im thankful beyond belief that they have the taste to know what song to try to cover, I just have a feeling it wasnt the drummers idea!
willwkrueger 3 years ago
correction. u suck.
gergface21 3 years ago 4
haha agreed.
its not a beefheart original anyway.
kieran09 3 years ago
Coming from a Beefheart/John French fanatic: Patrick Carney is the perfect drummer for the Black Keys. In this version of the song, it's all about the raw passion, the explosion of drums and guitar after each verse. Dan and Pat are tight, and the song is fucking unstoppable.
yanzi420 3 years ago 3
my favorite black keys song
asgRYAN 3 years ago
what tuning is he using?
guitardude454 3 years ago
standard eadgbe
SurfingKnife 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
captain beefheart can suck my fuckin balls, Black Keys kick ass!
ShowYaHowtaHusl 3 years ago
sorry, but you're wrong :)
KERAKAO 3 years ago
woot
josiesezlol 3 years ago
my god that's amazing... this song is constructed so well! fucking love black keys!!!
ajk1989 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Fergie's way better than these guys
JimiyDoorsHamelech1 3 years ago
WHAT? ARE YOU SHITTING ME?
captross07 3 years ago
man this is an awsome version
pls24 3 years ago
this is the best live version of this song I've seen yet.
bhmskim 3 years ago
Have you all heard the original version? any Captain Beefheart fans out there? Listen to him, its fking amazing.
ms1146 3 years ago
captain beefheart doesnt origianlly do thhis song...its an old traditional bues song
shamrocks89mink 3 years ago
Have you heard The Black Keys Cover Captain Beefheart
outlawbluez 3 years ago
these guys got soul
imbaman1337 3 years ago 41
@imbaman1337 Had soul. They lost it. This stuff was honest, "Brothers" is just to make more money.
CicconeYouth04 4 months ago
@CicconeYouth04 Your opinion man, but Brothers still has soul. It really does.
TheMorozovChannel 4 months ago
@CicconeYouth04 You really need to listen to Brothers again. It had plenty of soul. "Unknown Brother" for example
RealOutOfSight 2 months ago
i cant wait for lolapollooza this year
stokkaboy 3 years ago
they are the best band right now..
dunnyd 4 years ago 4
No, they are the best band EVER.
doodmandood777 3 years ago 26
LOVe them!!!!!! they are so great!!!! so are the beatles!
morneau333 4 years ago
Any band that covers Captain Beefheart is amazing.
MirrorImaged 4 years ago
Don Van Vliet covered it from Robert Pete Williams.
george383 4 years ago
Unbelievable! This is Junior Kimbrough & RL Burnside resurrected. Today only Alvin Youngblood Hart has this amount of soul. These youngsters are among THE BEST ever.
mojoelem 4 years ago 3
Their best performance of this song I've seen
vrv1020 4 years ago
love how dan's hair moves!
xSoundlessx 4 years ago 2
it just means he'll be bald by the time he is 45 or so... lol but gangster sound!
nivek0270 3 years ago