Scotland The Brave in Edinburgh (Bagpipes)

[sonerbihan]

Ach ! untidy fingering, erratic rythm, how can he dare playing in a public place ?

That' s as poor a performance that it makes me sad, what a poor image of my beloved instrument

Jean Michel

[Dancergirl62697]

He played way too fast and messed up alot.

[Khirad]

This piper could never make it in even a grade1 band without us drummers throwing our sticks at him to keep him in time. I must say I hate it when they rush this at warp speed too, but if they want to do it that way, I can keep up with a simpler setting. Pipers' loss.

[h68819]

he played way to fast at some parts no time keeping here

[johnmarshall007]

Every video on youtube of a piper from Edinurgh is completely horrible...it's completely sad. It's obvious to me that this guy is too old, and he doesn't have the strength to hold a tune anymore, so he rushes through every note just to feel like he finished a song - a practice I'll admit I employed when I was eleven years old. That said, every youtube video of a piper from glasgow or even ENGLAND for that matter is much better...Edinburgh piping needs some new blood apparently

[Probablyacowtbh]

Oof, poor bastard. It's almost as though he just noticed his cock was hanging out whilst playing.

[MrRubberduckiejoe]

his timing is shite

[MrRubberduckiejoe]

his timing is shite an its miles to fast 

[MegaPiperboy]

he needs a bit of work but not to bad

[fergusond100]

he's shite at playing

[strokemacat]

lol poor!!

[CarlingHoover]

Keech

[camsylbill]

the scots monument is in the back

[NCOProductions]

Isn't doing too well but oh well, he's makin money.

[Wehrfuehrer112]

damn !!!

[piper540]

someone didn't spend enough time on the practice chanter..

go back onto that and learn everything from day 1.

[themanofhi]

not good im just learning to play though so i cant do any better

[NorthLimitation]

Is that guy having a stroke while playing? What's with the sudden spasm arrangements of all the grace notes?

[TheMetalPenguin]

I must say this piper is not very good.

[finnbarrhagan]

@TheMetalPenguin he just earned at least three pounds in one minute nine seconds, the only reason your not paid less is because it would be illegal...

[solidmidget]

he was using the wrong grace notes. it sounded sloppy. i love this classic song, but it sounded like he was a new, and nervous, piper. and i do have a right to say this and i also know what i'm talkin about. i play the pipes.

[jud82145]

playing way too fast

[danodoolen1]

the bagpipes remind me of the homeland

[travett1001]

Thats in front of the Walter Scott Monument i think..I was there summer 08

[jay19xxx]

Pig Fucking, that is what your daddy did when he porked your mother, Cunt. The only thing soothing about your instrument is when you shove it up your ass and blow, oh wait a minute that is exactly the noise I was trying to avoid. Fuck you fagot Scott, dominated by queer Englishman paying homage to a dumb cunt in London. Jump of a cliff and for god's sake don't breed. Cunt.

[paperlanterns98]

What version of Scotland the Brave was that?!?

Too many embellishments?

At any rate... why would Jay come to bagpipe video to insult bagpipes. Talk about insecurity! No one cares what you think.

[Chow2Productions]

What the heck? How can people have such idiotic conversations over a great thing like Scotland's national anthem played on the pipes?

[jcarlson2007]

if you are actually 40 years old i am lmao right now

[masterglitch55]

this would be beter if he didnt stop in between the tune i also play the pipes there hard but just keep workin at 5stars

[unionfallen]

he needs some work...slow down those notes that should be held atleast twice as long as he's giving them...poor timing

[precisionkick1]

So immature.

[masterglitch55]

stfu you retarted and well you dont know what your talking about dumbass

[Kward107]

That doesn't even make sense. It would be hard before i came in your face. Idiot

[Kward107]

I'm just pointing you your apparent inability to figure out human functions that's all. It's not my fault you have no comprehension about anything

[jcarlson2007]

you seriously need to get the heck off of youtube, do you honestly think anyone cares about what you have to say

[superfly1292]

Ya i saw him a few weeks ago 2 what a prick

[precisionkick1]

So immature.

[canuckflyboy]

That guy needs to be sorted out!

[soonjiek86]

i juz saw him today

[John146GodsWIll]

You know whats funny? I was in Edinburgh last week and he is still in that same spot across from Princes Street Mall

[eragihresah]

I've been in edinbrugh 1 year b4 and he was stiil there...

it's HIS corner... ;-D

[Hendi1993]

@eragihresah ive also seen this guy this summer :D

[dorbie]

There are actually two tunes played. First he plays "Scotland the Brave" then he plays "Rowan Tree". His timing is a bit off in parts.

[HighlandPiper1485]

his tempo is all over the place at around 103 the chanter cut out

[the1nonlyjim]

haha at 00:19 he was too busy checking out the woman he messed up , great song though

[sniff001]

Yeah his timing is a bit off but I couldn't play that myself. I can see the Scott Monument in the background. Went up that a week ago today whilst on holiday in Scotland.

[PipeMajor11]

yup you might say scotland the brave rowan tree, but id say timing is way off things are played wrong, and worng rythm...keep trying

[Myunderpants]

scotland the brave.

gret song, though the piper unfortunetly has horrible timing.

[benten1144]

nevermind

[benten1144]

whats the name of this song

[dorbie]

There are two tunes, see my other post.

[Darrenritchie]

sounds all a bit weird to me.

[bmxdude073]

i want to play the pipes

then play them in my church

that wuld be COOOOOOL

great vid and great song

[Dogface4life91]

Now I'm not trying to be a dick or anything... it was good except your playing it wrong..

You missed a bunch of notes, and maybe get a new reed.. i seriously am not trying to be a dick I'm not criticizing anything, i'm just trying to help you.

[eragihresah]

GLAD TO HEAR IT...

cheers ;-)

[RumpIeteazer]

I love this song!!!!! I've been looking for it for ever!!

[fedecuco]

good one