I think Marvel Comics should have left the saga as it was without adding the later explanation about the phoenix force and all that. I remember when I was a kid and reading her tragedy in Uncanny X-Men #137 and being genuinely moved to tears because her death was final at the time. It wasn't supposed to be like a soap opera, like oops, she isn't really dead after all, it was just a bad dream. Blah.
@WoodLawnHills Well if its any consolation, no character is dead forever. I remember picking that issue up at the local drug store when it came out. I was supposed to take a long bike ride with friends that day, but I said forget it I gotta read x-men! Jim shooter sure did hose things up by demanding her death for wiping out a planet of aspargas people.
Interestingly enough -- originally the Phoenix wasn't a cosmic entity psionically linked to Jean Grey, she *was* Jean at the very peak of her powers. But due to the events of the Dark Phoenix Saga, the only way the creators could bring Jean back was to separate Phoenix from Jean. I'm not going to explain the Dark Phoenix Saga -- that's too long a story to tell here.
Yeah. The original plan was to have Jean depowered but retain the possibility of the Dark Phoenix returning. Thus they could bring back Jean and the Dark Phoenix for future storylines. If Claremont hadn't decided to have the Dark Phoenix destroy an *inhabited* solar system, they might have done so successfully. But Shooter felt the punishment was too light for what was essentially genocide. *That's* why he wanted Jean to pay the full price or else be cleared of the crime.
I think Marvel Comics should have left the saga as it was without adding the later explanation about the phoenix force and all that. I remember when I was a kid and reading her tragedy in Uncanny X-Men #137 and being genuinely moved to tears because her death was final at the time. It wasn't supposed to be like a soap opera, like oops, she isn't really dead after all, it was just a bad dream. Blah.
WoodLawnHills 9 months ago 2
@WoodLawnHills Well if its any consolation, no character is dead forever. I remember picking that issue up at the local drug store when it came out. I was supposed to take a long bike ride with friends that day, but I said forget it I gotta read x-men! Jim shooter sure did hose things up by demanding her death for wiping out a planet of aspargas people.
thugie1 9 months ago
can some one pleas explain to me the Wight Phoenix?
spjhs112 2 years ago
Interestingly enough -- originally the Phoenix wasn't a cosmic entity psionically linked to Jean Grey, she *was* Jean at the very peak of her powers. But due to the events of the Dark Phoenix Saga, the only way the creators could bring Jean back was to separate Phoenix from Jean. I'm not going to explain the Dark Phoenix Saga -- that's too long a story to tell here.
Belle Book
BelleBook 2 years ago
Right, thanks to jim shooter who was the editor-in-chief at the time who said jean had to die for wiping out that planet of 'asparagus' people.
thugie1 2 years ago
Yeah. The original plan was to have Jean depowered but retain the possibility of the Dark Phoenix returning. Thus they could bring back Jean and the Dark Phoenix for future storylines. If Claremont hadn't decided to have the Dark Phoenix destroy an *inhabited* solar system, they might have done so successfully. But Shooter felt the punishment was too light for what was essentially genocide. *That's* why he wanted Jean to pay the full price or else be cleared of the crime.
Belle Book
BelleBook 2 years ago
@BelleBook so where does the Mkran crystal fit in...???
augustofendor 1 year ago
I loved the backup stores.they where simple but thay added soo much to the read I wish they would do somthing like that again
ikey1555 2 years ago
this brings me back
boxintypex 2 years ago