I´m glad that someone covers Led Zeppelin. Why should it be so prohibited? If noone plays their music it will die away. Go Dolly! (But that male voice is not on her album, who has sabotaged the song).
It's really nice, superimposing Dolly's original singing with your rendition, it does achieve that duet feel. :) Though there were parts that sounded as if you were late in breaking into a note or verse by a second, the video and your rendition is still very good :) Great job!
I liked everything excpet the banjo. I did not dislike the banjo. But I think it was played a bit conservatively for this song. This song screams for an all out banjo solo. I can hear it in my head. I just wish I could play it.
i love this song, dolly parton always had a amazing and beautiful voice, tuffy i love your voice also, it's wonderful , you should do the other song she sings also, knocking on heavens door, it's another song i love of hers, well, i love all her songs, god bless,
This is bold brave and beautiful!!! Great work!!! Its wonderful to hear this fresh rendition. I love the song so much its great to hear your spin on it. I LOVE IT!!!
I love the original and I think Dolly version is just beautiful.Enjoyed Da Listen.Your You Tube Bro.~ Larry Killam of Facebook group Songwriters Unite AKA Yrral Mallik of Songramp.
me ah gustado, los instrumentos las voces todo increible, y aquellos que comentan con ofensivas, podria llamarles ignorantes, donde un musico, es quien interpreta una piezza pero el MUSICO le da su toque artistico, sino todo el mundo seria una monotonia; no te fijes en esos comentarios y a seguir adelante, que esta pieza esta incrible, felicitaciones!
thank you for your response above an translation below:
woow! superb interpretation! I ah liked, the instruments the voices all incredible one, and those that comment with offensives, podria to call to them ignorant, where a musician, is the one who interprets one piezza but the MUSICIAN gives its artistic touch him, but a everybody serious drabness; you do not pay attention to those commentaries and to follow ahead, that this piece this incrible, congratulations!
Hmm...If one had never heard of the original song, this version would be still be hauntingly memorable. It definitely could be used as a song during the credits of a good southern ghost story! Banjo and all! Dolly's voice sounds eerily magical here.
Hmmm...if one had never heard or had known of the original, this version would be hauntingly memorable for sure. Could definitely be used as the credit song in a good southern ghost movie! Banjo and all!
thats not a bad cover. of course dolly parton and led zeppelin dont fit together, so everybody thinks this is treason and must be bad but Jimmy Page commented positively on this version. He really liked the gospel choir at the end.
I admire Dolly's courage and confidence to cover the song, but she just can't seem to rebound the mysterious power Led Zeppelin had when they recorded this. Nice try for a valiant effort.
I have heard many covers of this song, however this is not one that I will recommend to anyone. I didn't even believe my friend when he told me she did this, and I ended up here hoping it wasn't true. Classic song in the original form, but it loses something when someone tries to make it a country music song. The phrase "Keep on rockin' in the free world" was not said to include fiddle music.
For whatever it's worth, Jimmy Page actually said that he liked Dolly Parton's cover of the song, saying that it added something interesting to the song.
I'm always dismayed when I read a post comparing one version of a song to another. I think you really have to let each version stand on its' own merit and judge it as that. And there IS that old saying "If you can't say something nice....." you know the rest. An example of two great versions of the same song are Willie Nelson and Dave Matthews versions of "Grave Digger". Both can be found here on youtube. Check them out.
To all that say 'how can she cover this song': whitney houston and more has covered her songs so why shouldn't she? she is a very talented singer and does covers that actually changes the song to another genre, not that easy but she manages to do it.
As you may know or have seen I delete the vulgar uncalled for comments. The way I see it is if you dont have anything nice, considerate or in a postive form such as positive criticism then its best you just dont say anything... the ones who have left vulgar an repulsive remarks.. it onlyshows your intellect.. in other words go back to suckin on your baby bottle your not ready for the world yet
There are two different songs called "Stairway to Heaven". The other was done by Neil Sedaka, who co-wrote it with Howard Greenfield. Neither is particularly Dolly's style, but I would consider the Sedaka one to be closer than this one. Doing a song from a Brill Building writing team wouldn't be new to her - Her first big crossover hit, "Here You Come Again", was written by Barry Mann and Cynthia Weil.
This cover is pathetic, the solo is sung over by her just yelling stairway to heaven. The banjo's player's creativity in the solo is completely drowned because (as a solo female singer) she can't allow instrumentals.
Stairway to heaven can be covered, and covered well, however by shouting stairway to heaven it removes subtlety and ruins the solo - regarded as one of the best solos in music.
strange someone marked this message as spam... there is no spam content in this comment post:
"some folks just cant believe a song can be done other ways.. an they are so set in their ways... course some "cant sing" or do any better so they criticize others for the fact that they resent others try an they cant"
This gurl has a very nice voice, but I don't think she really hit it here...
I don't think people should try to cover classic rock songs if they aren't classic rock artists themselves. Well they can try, but unless it's good, don't release it lol. :P
I think its so FUNNY that someone come to listen to this , posted a nasty comment an had bad smart comments to say but yet THEY added the video to their own favorites video log ... LMAOOOOOOOOOOOOO !! some intelligence there I tell ya. As for their remarks to me.. well its like this these are MY videos an I can do what I choose to with them. If you dont like it dont listen an dont comment. You know how to X out a window dont you? To all others- THANK YOU !!
some folks just cant believe a song can be done other ways.. an they are so set in their ways... course some "cant sing" or do any better so they criticize others for the fact that they resent others try an they cant !!!
As you may know or have seen I delete the vulgar uncalled for comments. The way I see it is if you dont have anything nice, considerate or in a postive form such as positive criticism then its best you just dont say anything... the ones who have left vulgar an repulsive remarks..it only shows your intellect..in other words go back to suckin on your baby bottle your not ready for the world yet
This is a good cover, I realise she wasnt trying to beat led zeppelins version, I personally think its not a bad cover... Led zeppelin obviously do it better then anyone else could, because they actually written it :)
When I heard Stairway To Heaven was on here covered by Dolly Parton, I thought "You have to be joking"! Haunting is the word I think sums this up. And it IS very clever. Love the bluegrass tinge as well. To say I'm surprised is the understatement of the year! Nice!!!
As you may know or have seen I delete the vulgar uncalled for comments. The way I see it is if you dont have anything nice, considerate or in a postive form such as positive criticism then its best you just dont say anything... the ones who have left vulgar an repulsive remarks.. it onlyshows your intellect.. in other words go back to suckin on your baby bottle your not ready for the world yet
I dont get it, whats trying to be accomplished here? I can understand making a cover version but they even changed the lyrics too. The video doesnt seem to have much realavence to the lyrics either which makes things a little confusing.
thank you 1fan... some folks just cant believe a song can be done other ways.. an they are set in their ways... course some cant sing or do any better so they criticize others for their resenting that others try an they cant.. As for you Aaron .. noone was trying to beat LZ.
hi! very nice singing indeed. is there any chance to see the video in a better quality? I'd love to.
assa123assa123 3 months ago
I like Dolly Parton rendition of the Led Zeppelin classic. Being a huge Zep, I bought this album when it came out, because I like Country too.
I didn't care for the duet mix.....sorry.
You have a good voice, but I didn't hear harmony
KingTrucker 11 months ago
I´m glad that someone covers Led Zeppelin. Why should it be so prohibited? If noone plays their music it will die away. Go Dolly! (But that male voice is not on her album, who has sabotaged the song).
frknGeraniaceae 1 year ago
This the only permitted interpretation of this opus with which I grew up.
I fell in love instantly. What for a woman! Thank You from CH :-)
MegaHalodri 1 year ago 4
I love your voice, you sounded great singing long with Dolly's Stairway to heaven.
Melanie28521 1 year ago 2
LOVE THIS VERSION!!! MORE,MORE!
marraca60 2 years ago
this song touches me
michaelhman 2 years ago
I don't know quite what to make of this.
Her cover of "Shine" is really good, but this just doesn't seem right, for some reason.
Claymore5by5 2 years ago
It's really nice, superimposing Dolly's original singing with your rendition, it does achieve that duet feel. :) Though there were parts that sounded as if you were late in breaking into a note or verse by a second, the video and your rendition is still very good :) Great job!
caitianlong 2 years ago
I liked everything excpet the banjo. I did not dislike the banjo. But I think it was played a bit conservatively for this song. This song screams for an all out banjo solo. I can hear it in my head. I just wish I could play it.
k1773r37f 2 years ago
Great job tuffers!
maggiemay90909 2 years ago
i love this song, dolly parton always had a amazing and beautiful voice, tuffy i love your voice also, it's wonderful , you should do the other song she sings also, knocking on heavens door, it's another song i love of hers, well, i love all her songs, god bless,
unbreakablenerds 2 years ago
ANOTHER USER BEING BLOCKED FOR SENDING ME NASTY MESSAGES WHICH I HAVE FORWARDED ALL COMMENTS AN PRIVATE MESSAGES TO YOUTUBE: USER> tamelanj
Tuffymuffin69 2 years ago
WHO IS SINGING WITH DOLLY?
blessedandforgiven 2 years ago
@blessedandforgiven ...it sounds like Townes VanZant
of Pancho and Lefty , Marie and other cool songs
ron891 1 year ago
I don't really like this one, but at least they didn't butcher it like some others did.
Mentality16 2 years ago 3
It takes all kinds to make a world! Ignore the idiots. Beautiful song and video.
robinreneesmith 2 years ago 15
This is cool and Im sure it has the blessing of Paige Jones and Plant and mine also
BreakerSizzle 2 years ago 7
ANOTHER USER BEING BLOCKED FOR SENDING ME NASTY MESSAGES WHICH I HAVE FORWARDED ALL COMMENTS AN PRIVATE MESSAGES TO YOUTUBE: USER> tamelanj
Tuffymuffin69 2 years ago
This is bold brave and beautiful!!! Great work!!! Its wonderful to hear this fresh rendition. I love the song so much its great to hear your spin on it. I LOVE IT!!!
mechanicalvalve 2 years ago 2
I love the original and I think Dolly version is just beautiful.Enjoyed Da Listen.Your You Tube Bro.~ Larry Killam of Facebook group Songwriters Unite AKA Yrral Mallik of Songramp.
lps45s8tracks 2 years ago
An enjoyable version of a great song really.
Alough I prefer Led Zeppelin's version
This version is probably the best cover in my oppinion anyway.
Gameglitcha 2 years ago 3
always a inmature brat in every crowd.. so sad there parents didnt raise them any better everyone..
recent blocks an reported to officials due to (and/or) vulgarity an threats:
SerialKiller2012
eatyourkix
Tuffymuffin69 2 years ago
woow! magnifica interpretacion!
me ah gustado, los instrumentos las voces todo increible, y aquellos que comentan con ofensivas, podria llamarles ignorantes, donde un musico, es quien interpreta una piezza pero el MUSICO le da su toque artistico, sino todo el mundo seria una monotonia; no te fijes en esos comentarios y a seguir adelante, que esta pieza esta incrible, felicitaciones!
Desde la paz, B.C.S.
nehekhama 2 years ago
thank you for your response above an translation below:
woow! superb interpretation! I ah liked, the instruments the voices all incredible one, and those that comment with offensives, podria to call to them ignorant, where a musician, is the one who interprets one piezza but the MUSICIAN gives its artistic touch him, but a everybody serious drabness; you do not pay attention to those commentaries and to follow ahead, that this piece this incrible, congratulations!
Tuffymuffin69 2 years ago
I hate the banjo [2]
Uma merda merda...
erickplant 3 years ago
In its literal meaningthat I looked up...it says it is usually considered vulgar wording (swear words? ) should i ignore,block an report you too?
Tuffymuffin69 2 years ago
I very much enjoyed this version of the song. I have always liked all of Dolly Parton's covers of other songs.
I am truly sorry that you have been getting so much grief for posting this song. Neither you nor the song deserve it.
Take care of yourself.....
thespian15 3 years ago
thank you so much for your response.. your comment is well taken.. thanks
Tuffymuffin69 3 years ago
You are welcome.
thespian15 3 years ago
Love Dolly's version, but this one is odd. Better listen to the album.
ericnruss 3 years ago
I hate the banjo
brainac0cult 3 years ago
anything Dolly does is totally awesome!!!!
ixlovexmyxkids 3 years ago
Courageous and ridiculous
123jozef 3 years ago
Hmm...If one had never heard of the original song, this version would be still be hauntingly memorable. It definitely could be used as a song during the credits of a good southern ghost story! Banjo and all! Dolly's voice sounds eerily magical here.
123isito 3 years ago
the you need to listen to the original I have it as well.
BoomBoomStockings1 3 years ago
Please everyone listen to the video response below the video before you post your comments Thank You !
Tuffymuffin69 3 years ago
I am glad you finally posted a video response son. Their are some ignorant an rude people out there.
peachysue 3 years ago
why would I need to listen to the original? I have all of them..an many different versions.
Tuffymuffin69 3 years ago
Hmmm...if one had never heard or had known of the original, this version would be hauntingly memorable for sure. Could definitely be used as the credit song in a good southern ghost movie! Banjo and all!
123isito 3 years ago
very weird....
iguana900 3 years ago 2
rock on Dolly
crosley63 3 years ago 2
thats not a bad cover. of course dolly parton and led zeppelin dont fit together, so everybody thinks this is treason and must be bad but Jimmy Page commented positively on this version. He really liked the gospel choir at the end.
plerimest 3 years ago 4
Funny but i dont like it but thanks for uploading
670Kiester 3 years ago
I like it, not as much as Led Zepellin's version but I still like it.
Menalipa68 3 years ago 2
at the very least, she's got guts
swirlyfishcake 3 years ago 2
I admire Dolly's courage and confidence to cover the song, but she just can't seem to rebound the mysterious power Led Zeppelin had when they recorded this. Nice try for a valiant effort.
imbluz 3 years ago
I have heard many covers of this song, however this is not one that I will recommend to anyone. I didn't even believe my friend when he told me she did this, and I ended up here hoping it wasn't true. Classic song in the original form, but it loses something when someone tries to make it a country music song. The phrase "Keep on rockin' in the free world" was not said to include fiddle music.
samuraichihuahua 3 years ago
parton just has the highest voice! it seems that a harmony would be impossible with her!
this version is ok... the origional is way better
AlexAndKatie1622 3 years ago
She DID ruin the solo.But the cover is interesting and I like when artists try something different instead of doing a 100% clone of a cover.
JakubK666 3 years ago
man!!!! i love this version n d one tat done by apocalyptica.this is great altho the video is not rly satisfy me.
sleepyheart003 3 years ago
ne fun here
cOnNIiElicIoUs 3 years ago
For whatever it's worth, Jimmy Page actually said that he liked Dolly Parton's cover of the song, saying that it added something interesting to the song.
jloder01 3 years ago
I'm always dismayed when I read a post comparing one version of a song to another. I think you really have to let each version stand on its' own merit and judge it as that. And there IS that old saying "If you can't say something nice....." you know the rest. An example of two great versions of the same song are Willie Nelson and Dave Matthews versions of "Grave Digger". Both can be found here on youtube. Check them out.
walkshe 3 years ago
i don't feel so good.
onebobtwo 3 years ago
To all that say 'how can she cover this song': whitney houston and more has covered her songs so why shouldn't she? she is a very talented singer and does covers that actually changes the song to another genre, not that easy but she manages to do it.
StraightTalkPlease 3 years ago
As you may know or have seen I delete the vulgar uncalled for comments. The way I see it is if you dont have anything nice, considerate or in a postive form such as positive criticism then its best you just dont say anything... the ones who have left vulgar an repulsive remarks.. it onlyshows your intellect.. in other words go back to suckin on your baby bottle your not ready for the world yet
Tuffymuffin69 3 years ago
This version makes me very unhappy...
mehedmb 3 years ago
There are two different songs called "Stairway to Heaven". The other was done by Neil Sedaka, who co-wrote it with Howard Greenfield. Neither is particularly Dolly's style, but I would consider the Sedaka one to be closer than this one. Doing a song from a Brill Building writing team wouldn't be new to her - Her first big crossover hit, "Here You Come Again", was written by Barry Mann and Cynthia Weil.
rslitman 3 years ago
does she actually have the balls to cover zepplin
does anybody?
ryansajedi 3 years ago 14
well i read that robert plant and jimmy page said that she's the only one who understands this song.
StraightTalkPlease 3 years ago
@ryansajedi She was not bad but cant say i care for the other..Dolly can sing anything
George6360 11 months ago
This cover is pathetic, the solo is sung over by her just yelling stairway to heaven. The banjo's player's creativity in the solo is completely drowned because (as a solo female singer) she can't allow instrumentals.
Stairway to heaven can be covered, and covered well, however by shouting stairway to heaven it removes subtlety and ruins the solo - regarded as one of the best solos in music.
johnpoulain 3 years ago 6
strange someone marked this message as spam... there is no spam content in this comment post:
"some folks just cant believe a song can be done other ways.. an they are so set in their ways... course some "cant sing" or do any better so they criticize others for the fact that they resent others try an they cant"
Must be someone who has no knowledge of the term
69tuffymuffin 3 years ago 5
dolly parton doing zepplin?
AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!
i love it.
psycedeliccorn 3 years ago
Awesome
PaulieRomanov 3 years ago
This gurl has a very nice voice, but I don't think she really hit it here...
I don't think people should try to cover classic rock songs if they aren't classic rock artists themselves. Well they can try, but unless it's good, don't release it lol. :P
OwnerOfALonelyyHeart 3 years ago
Anyone else notice that the video is Live's Heaven from the album Birds of Prey?
pclemins 3 years ago 3
good catch! :-)
dav10631 3 years ago 2
Nice use of the video for the Live song, Heaven ;)
pclemins 3 years ago 2
its wierd hearing dolly parton singin this but that banjos pretty badass
kosherdiah 3 years ago 4
I think its so FUNNY that someone come to listen to this , posted a nasty comment an had bad smart comments to say but yet THEY added the video to their own favorites video log ... LMAOOOOOOOOOOOOO !! some intelligence there I tell ya. As for their remarks to me.. well its like this these are MY videos an I can do what I choose to with them. If you dont like it dont listen an dont comment. You know how to X out a window dont you? To all others- THANK YOU !!
Tuffymuffin69 3 years ago
some folks just cant believe a song can be done other ways.. an they are so set in their ways... course some "cant sing" or do any better so they criticize others for the fact that they resent others try an they cant !!!
Tuffymuffin69 3 years ago
there are worse songs out there.. this isnt that bad-... but nothing special
mirrencorin 3 years ago
Plant stated in an interview that he liked this cover
athensmdm 3 years ago 6
can you link me to it please?
Gameglitcha 3 years ago 2
Everone should listen to the version from Live & Well, the end is truly amazing!
penetreramera 3 years ago 3
Once again I will post this:
As you may know or have seen I delete the vulgar uncalled for comments. The way I see it is if you dont have anything nice, considerate or in a postive form such as positive criticism then its best you just dont say anything... the ones who have left vulgar an repulsive remarks..it only shows your intellect..in other words go back to suckin on your baby bottle your not ready for the world yet
Tuffymuffin69 3 years ago
yeah, that song is magic, but I don't like that people are doing covers on that song.
ottyotta 3 years ago
the first rule in rock n' roll!! No covers on stairwat to heaven!!!
ottyotta 3 years ago 3
theres been alot of covers, no one can find the magic that led zeppelin had with that song
Gameglitcha 3 years ago 4
Dolly can do no wrong in my eyes. Minors2001 has this described well, HAUNTING.
tpmh37 3 years ago 5
This is a good cover, I realise she wasnt trying to beat led zeppelins version, I personally think its not a bad cover... Led zeppelin obviously do it better then anyone else could, because they actually written it :)
Gameglitcha 3 years ago 4
actually uncoverable
heanzi 3 years ago
I hate that version of the song.
But the video is very well done - congrats on that :)
pizt 3 years ago
When I heard Stairway To Heaven was on here covered by Dolly Parton, I thought "You have to be joking"! Haunting is the word I think sums this up. And it IS very clever. Love the bluegrass tinge as well. To say I'm surprised is the understatement of the year! Nice!!!
minors2001 4 years ago 5
As you may know or have seen I delete the vulgar uncalled for comments. The way I see it is if you dont have anything nice, considerate or in a postive form such as positive criticism then its best you just dont say anything... the ones who have left vulgar an repulsive remarks.. it onlyshows your intellect.. in other words go back to suckin on your baby bottle your not ready for the world yet
Tuffymuffin69 4 years ago
wow
its pretty wierd
she sings it beautifully but its so strange to hear the song this way
tgluvdcouch5 4 years ago 4
not at all what i was expecting, good stuff!
thedundrumrapist 4 years ago 5
I dont get it, whats trying to be accomplished here? I can understand making a cover version but they even changed the lyrics too. The video doesnt seem to have much realavence to the lyrics either which makes things a little confusing.
MikeGraystone 4 years ago 3
thank you 1fan... some folks just cant believe a song can be done other ways.. an they are set in their ways... course some cant sing or do any better so they criticize others for their resenting that others try an they cant.. As for you Aaron .. noone was trying to beat LZ.
Tuffymuffin69 4 years ago
i like it
dollypartons1fan 4 years ago 3