Added: 5 years ago
From: MikkiiLea
Views: 297,364
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (471)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Wow! I actually like this. Hate if you want. I could care less.

  • Josh Groban has his positive points, but like other people he shouldn't be allowed to cover certain songs. It didn't make my ears bleed but listening to him sing this after enjoying it for years by Linkin Park is like listening to britney spears trying to sing Nirvana. Linkin Park does it best and the rest should just leave it that way.

  • Love.

  • This is awesome. 

  • i liked his version....

  • I think this would be a great first dance song for a December wedding. I'm seriously considering it.

  • @MaryTheresa1986 Really? This song is so depressing. He's singing about loneliness. He's saying December is his time of the year because it is the end, where everything dies. Not really much of a wedding song IMO.

  • I know it's not December,but this song is so beautiful and also touching to my soul. It's beautiful.

  • this song is making me depressed

  • I can't even find this version on itunes wtf

  • can't stop listening to this. so excited to see him live nexk week!

  • Youve called the vid ''My Decemember - Josh Groban'' - Yet you have 'Grobin' at the beginning of the video.. Hmm

  • i love Linkin park's vertion, but this one is much, MUCH better.

  • This version is much better! Totally love it fab!! XD

  • This version is so amazing

  • Linkin parks version is better

  • Ohhh God forgive me my sins !!!!!!!!!!

    I have killd 3 persons in my army time !

    I dream about this every single day in my lifetime and it destroys me !!!!!!

    I cant forgive myself !!!!

    I wanna kill myself right now i have my loadet Glock17 gun right next to me but something tels me noooo ! Why ... no .... Oh Lord forgive me my bad sins !!!!! Please !!!!

    My Comrads think im a hero ! But ..... no

    Thats exactly not what i am !!!!!

  • i love this song, and the graphics you put up. everytime im sad i come and watch it, b/c it just explains everything thats usually wrong with me!! its my little vice, and after listening to it i feel ready to reenter society putting on the facade of a happy person

  • Very nice 5*,LOLA

  • josh groban is the best singer ive ever heard but whoever made this video, it's emo as shit....big boo

  • awesome. :)

  • The song was written by Linkin Park in 15 mins for the KROQ calender. Oddly enough it sounds better when they do it.

  • Linkin Park made this song in 2001 for KROQ Christmas, not this wannabe. It also happens to be apart of the Extended Hybrid Theroy album.

  • I realy become weak !!

    I mean why the hell i watch this and listen to this and feel like.... i must cry !?

    I think my tuff years are ofer !..

    Its sooo easy to find a girl for 1 night but its soooooo hard to find the right one for the whole life !!!! Sooooo hard !

  • i feel you.....i believe at times i'm cursed with relationships because every man i've gotten close to breaks my heart:(((

  • it hurts when you put 150% into something...only to get your feelings thrown back at you. I really hear you.

  • :-)

  • There is no ONE person for anyone. That's a scam just like buying a house is a good investment and the stock market is the best place to put your money and there are weapons of mass destruction in Iraq and Jesus loves you but if you don't send money to the guys on TV you will burn in hell and on and on and on.

  • well said

  • haha nice try

    it's linkin park

  • To you Chuck

  • Josh Groban pwns!

  • Josh groban is awesome. Especiallt this song. GO JOSH!

  • I'm not realy a big fan of Linkin Park, but I absolutly LOVE this song! The most amazing part is that I think this song is built on only TWO chords! That should've been boooooring, but it's not!

  • great video:((((((((

  • great rendition

  • wow i love that josh did a remix to my favorite linkin park song!

  • Where did you find this version? I've been looking everywhere for it and can only find the version that has both him and Linkin Park.

  • Lovely voice and an amazing video!!!!

  • he sings nice but its an original linkin park so they do it better =]

  • my friend's ringtone is My December by Linkin Park . . I really think both versions are ok, but personally i like this one but i'm not saying that one or the other is better in any way, that is just my opinion. love this song!

    God is a God of Wonders

  • meH, I kinda' like Linkin Park's version better.

    THis one's not half bad though.

  • I like it when they fused the songs in remix.

  • why do some of you even compare them about whos better?they are two totally different muscians!they are both great artists to the generes they cater to!its like me telling you that that classical music is better than hip hop(a.k.a.SHIT!!!)there is no point to an agument like that!!!but know that i do love these two REAL ARTISTS!!!thank you LINKIN PARK AND JOSH GROBAN!for the great gift of your music and voices!!!

  • Very good cover ^_^

  • This is by far my favorite song from linkin park. and the fact that one of the greatest singers of this time did a remix of this song. was AWESOME!

  • I can't say which one is better because both of them are amazing! But there are amazing in two different ways. They both show very powerful emotions through the song which is why I love it so much! Beautiful!

  • Chester is the best ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Josh is good, but Chester is the best/ love him^_^

  • I LOVE linkin Park + i really like josh groban

    josh's is good, but chester is AWSOME!

    But i LOVE this song + both versions :):)

  • I have to say, both versions have their up points, Both can make you "feel" the song in so many ways but I have to admit I like Josh's version more.

  • The man has wonderful voice:) Great song! Have a nice december from Poland:)

  • Josh and LP are both great on this song, and they obviously respect each other if Josh chose to cover it and Linkin Park didn't have a problem with him covering it... so it's pretty petty to argue back and forth about who's better.

  • the live at the greek one is better...

  • Yeah, I have listened to both Josh's version and Linkin Parks version and they are very different. They are both good, but Josh wins hands down. His voice is so pure. When he sang this song at the Verizon Center in DC his voice just took me to another place. He is one of the best live concert singers I have seen. He was even good in an open air concert at Nissan Pavillion.

  • I really love this song, even tho this might sound weird, but I like how its depressing..but one thing I dont like is that whenever I listen to it, it makes me think of my ex,whos in the Marines, and I always cry...

  • Yes. His name is spelled wrong.... :-(

  • lol not to b picky or nythng...but u misspelt his name on the vdo ...in the bgeinning

    but great cover!!

  • I don't wanna twist anyy hairs...

    but I love this version a lot more(:

  • Love jg but Chester pwns

  • whats the pic at 2:50?

  • Sorry, Josh fans. Chester wins on this song!

  • I totally agree. This isn't the best song from Josh Groban.

  • He does a very beautiful cover :)

  • is this song on a cd?

  • It's wonderful ^.^ Some may disagree, but I think Linkin Park is a little bit better

  • to me, both are different. I guess it depends on what you are looking for

  • Yeah, I think so too, but I just love Chesters voice ^-^

  • This is so beautiful and well done. It is portrayed as a work of art and not some drivel depressing note like caseen seems to misunderstand. I love it!

  • I found this song as a mash up - Josh Groban with Linkin Park. Simply beautiful. Even though the Josh part gets faded out towards the end of the song, I had it as one of my wedding songs.

  • I like this version!

  • wow CasEen thats cold as fuck you faggot.. there is alot of depressing pictures in here no lie.. im glad your putting it in a video tho instead of keeping it inside

  • Yeah I like this version of him.......its sound classical rock and its blending is amazing..I like Josh's voice, its so deep and masculine !

  • Josh Groban is a complete package.....Gosh, is he an angel ???

  • This is beautiful

  • So it's not the same as Linkin Park's version, but it's pretty darn good for a classical artist's cover of a rock balled.

  • or maybe how much he sucks them... @ peckerface

  • its a loveble song

  • linkin park dose this song too, both are good, very different, I like joshes more

  • LINKIN PARK IS MUCH BETTER

  • I love that violin solo at the end a whole lot. Almost as much as Josh's voice.

  • Do you pronounce his name as Josh Gorban?

  • achhhhhhhhhhh Śliczna piosenka, niesamowity głos...

  • I love this song! Such emotion and feeling in it, I almost cry when I hear it. Dosen't hurt that he owns the voice of love.

  • He did not *steal* it. He got permission from LP to cover it.

  • 5 stars worth!!!

    Thanks!

  • Good Song, and I LOVE Josh Groban, and the Linkin Park version is good too. FYI: you spelled Josh Groban wrong on the first slide, you spelled it Josh GrobIn. Good video.

  • haha yeah i thought that was interesting as well. : )

  • who came up with this first? LP or Josh?

  • Linkin Park ;)

  • I've always loved Josh's voice... and I've always loved this song... it reminds me so much of my shitty life... (in a beautiful manner) :D

  • I love Josh Groban & I love Linkin Park. I love both versions!

  • i love this song ,, it reminds me of my boyfriend who i miss so much.. he past away last year and it still feels like yesterday.... my babe i hope i see u soon.. great song

  • Aww, I'm so sorry :(

  • May you find some one to fill the void in your heart yet never forget the one you lost.

  • Aww... I sorta feel your pain, a fraction of it.

    This was the last song me and my girlfriend listened to, before she broke my heart and moved.

  • awe... its always hard to lose a loved one .. however they leave us.. i think what makes it so dame hurtful is not knowing why? ...

  • incredible...is he the composer of those songs?if yes,he is a genius

  • wow fit!!! didnt no he did this! love him and linkin park. and the lonliness pictures go with the song, theyre so cute! and sad lol

  • nice job ....!!!

  • Wow, Linkin Park did this song, but he did a really good cover his voice works with the song. Defently beautiful.

  • Hon, are you depressed?

  • hmmm i agree with goth... i think some one is lonley <.<

  • i LOVE it i LOVE It :)

  • Does anyone know if Josh officially released this some one? I'm a new fan so any info appreciated. :)

  • Josh's studio version of My December was only released on the "Internet only" 17-track limited edition of his album Closer, which has been sold out for several years and goes for over $100 used (yeah, I said used) on ebay. Getting hold of a copy takes patience and big money. Barring that, there's a live version on the Live at the Greek DVD, which is far easier to aquire.

  • The emo pictures kinda ruin it.... but this song, and Josh Groban are heaven.... ^_^

  • wow josh groban's version is amazing! except for the video... so emo and depressing! god, smile! it won't hurt!

  • of course its a lonely song,

    its meant to show how much you need your othe 1/2.

    Its a brilliant take on the original, and should make you thankful for all of the brilliant people in your everyday life, cause you never know when they could just disappear

  • i love both versions, josh´s and the original from linkin park. and i have all cds from both. so it´s hard to decide what version is better, both are great.

  • I LOVE this song!!!! It's so amazing!

  • For some reason when I hear this song I think of the person that I love

  • I like how he sings

  • @ Rregiooo

    Me 2 man me too...........

  • I like how he songs

  • No, I think the way he sings it is very good, but that's own opinion.

  • Wow i don't like how he sings it. I'm not saying he's a bad singer, but not the right song for him. LP does it much better.

  • i think LPs version is the best ever.....this one is okay...

  • what is most sad is that this vid. got such a low views!? Love it, and yeah its LP org, and they are both amazing (:

  • i think someone is lonely >.> lol

  • amazing slide show..good job

  • The strings at the end give me goosebumps!! wow...

  • the picture at 1:18 is the MOST depressing picture I have EVER seen!!!!!!!

  • but it is a lovely pic

  • yeah k i think JG does this sooooo much better. can't really say biased, cuz i like linkin park too..but the LP version sounds like he's whispering, and..his voice just doesn't fit it right. josh gives it a type of richness.

  • I agree with you, thefaeripath. (and before anybody says I'm biased: I have more LP cd than JG cds.)

  • thank you!! =)

  • I love Josh Groban and also Linkin Park. But I like this song more when LP performs it.

  • ç_ç it's so beautiful...

  • damn this is a good song

  • i think that the video would be better captured with the LP version, but i still like josh G

  • its been 3 days n i can't stop listening ... help

  • That was amaaaaaaaazing!!! i agree that Chester and the band and Josh should do a duet OMG, that was.....i dnt know how to even describe it :O :D xxxxx

  • Linkin Park = Farther better ;)

  • Linkin Park = FAR BETTER

  • So sad!

  • Josh groban and linkin park really need to consider a duet...i mean chester creepy/sad voice, mike rapping and josh deep voices...OMG the whole thing would be a hit....love both covers!!!

  • love the song <3 its awesome! don´t care about if its Linkin Park or Josh Groban (: they are both just amazing...

    Great video too,love the slide at 3.03...

    They are all nice.

  • december should be happy!

  • december is tragic for SO many people.  LISTEN to these lyrics, and even more, read the video. Tragedy can be a beautiful call to compassion and love...

  • The violin orchestra in the end does it all...

    But each version has its own uniqueness that makes it beautiful. GO JOSH! GO LINKIN PARK!

    Love you both so much ^3^

  • I totally agree The violins at the end, does ti all and the Linkin Park version too is awesome they should do a collaboration it would be so great!!!

  • Josh has the better voice, hands down.

    Both versions of the song are good. One really can't be better than the other because while they are technically the same song, they are entirely different.

  • this is a copy version???

  • it's called a cover... -___-;

  • yea, the real song was done by Linkin Park

    Josh Groban is doing a cover for that song. Both songs are beautiful and done really well.

  • yeah but it's really weird how i like a different rendition than the original, cuz it's not really me. then again, once i've heard or seen something, even if it's not original, i can't see anything else being better. =) but i think it's regardless in this case. JG rox.

  • He does it pretty good, but nothing beats the original by Linkin Park, it's still pretty good ;)

  • man this song makes me cry

  • great video!!!

  • This crushes LP's version

  • ♥

  • This song is so powerful.

    It's abosolutely amazing.

    I love both the Linkin Park version and this.

    There's no question which one is better -

    they're both beautiful in their own way.

  • josh is gud, but chester will alwayz be the best at singing this song no matter wot.

  • good spelling!