Added: 3 years ago
From: rotk2006
Views: 29,169
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (211)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • the original is way better than the american version

  • the original is still the best. the actress is not that sassy enough

  • Comment removed

  • while I liked this movie too, I'd have to say the original was better.

    I wonder if they'll ever have a remake of windstruck. I liked that movie too.

  • i'm an asian and i've never been a fan of asian movies except japanese horror! ha! jap horror movies are scary as heck!

    anyway, i'm not a fan because korean movies are full of overacting characters and over the top corny scenes. movies here in the philippines are always about love and use song titles as movie titles. YUCK. and finally, it's always the same loveteams! why??? i'm so sick of 'em people who are glued together!

  • if u find tht korean guy is a loser tht means he is a good actor. being loser is precisely the point of tht character. apparently u dunno enough bout the movie to giv tht comment.

    my view may be biased bt the original is a classic. and so far i hav nvr seen remake of a classic thts as good as the original.

  • I WASN'T TALKING ABOUT THE GUY, DUDE.

  • movies dont have to be realistic or "believable" to be good, thats why the original is so much better and thats why its called a "movie"

  • plus, jesse bradford is sooo fine while that korean guy's lips were so hard to look at.

  • i actually like this better than the original. i found it hard finishing the korean version in one sitting because their acting was sooo annoying! it's over the top! i've never seen REAL people behave, act, and make such facial expressions as the lead characters.

    however, it was funny. it was a great comedy movie. but i'ma have to say that the remake was more romantic. from the beginning i had this warm feeling and i enjoyed the movie a lot.

  • so who dies in the end?

  • no one

  • lol!

  • im not feelin ds version...d korean ver is wayyy better....

  • i m guy n...usually guys don;t watch korean movie..but..i don;t know y i love (my sassy girl) so much..however . aabt dis movie remake it sucks..

  • korean version is better...The guy's personality seems different, he is too cheesy in his dialogue while the korean leading man seems clumsy and shy

  • yup i agree..korean version (the original one) much..much..much better..

  • This movie is horrible, the Korean version was much better.

  • One would not have the full appreciation of the original movie if you don't know how to read korean.  The difference between these two movies is vast. English just can't portray a third of the deeper meanings found in the original movie and that's why they made the movie the way they did: To suit audience. People from America will like this American remake. Too bad, without having a background on korean culture/language, they won't fully understand how the original is so good.

  • i love the theme song...who sung this?

  • my god. its a disassssssssssssster!

  • its nice when yu make a remake of something that kinda sucked in the first place like batman... and make it realllyyy good... but yur not suppose to make something realllyy good and remake into something shitty... tsk tsk shame on yu guys

  • the original was a classic. some things should just be left alone. They have taken a cinematic masterpiece and turned it into a pile of mushy corny crap. May they rot in hell. and if they even think of trying to remake windstruck I will personally hunt down the director a kick his ass.

  • WTFFFFFFFFFFF

  • For me, the movie is actually kinda nice! Im not comparing both versions...But I like this remake too!

  • LOL, that was disgusting, i felt a little embarrassed watching that...

  • i threw up a little watching this.

  • MAN THIS MOVIE FUCKEN SUCK! I DON'T GIVE A DAMN IF YOU SPAM OR W/E..SOOOO STUPID HOW THEY MADE AN AMERICAN VERSION..I JUST GOT DONE WATCHING IT AND IT FUCKEN RETARDED! DON'T FUCKEN MAKE REMAKES OF GOOD MOVIES YOU ASSWIPES! LEAVE IT THE WAY HOW IT WAS..THE ACTORS AREN'T EVEN IN TO THEIR FEELINGS!! MAN, if you haven't seen the KOREAN version which is the original then go watch it..don't waste your precious time watching this fucken shit! I'M SORRY BUT THIS MOVIE FUCKEN SUCK SHIT

  • just watching this trailer makes me not want to watch the original ever again

  • what?

  • one word. wtf????

  • u are right. this movie is not as good as korean version.

  • the movie is now showing in the philippines. will check it out! i hope it doesn't suck as it look on the trailer...

  • man, watch the original better.....its more deep and funny and meaning ful....alot of my friends cry cos they get emotional....its soo romantic....but u have to watch and undstand y...1st time i watch it, it was ok....but second i got it and it was unbelievably good!

  • if the americans wants to remake an asian movie, i hope they will give it justice...korean version of my sassy girl is still the best!!!!

  • The rip-off version is never as good as the original.

  • How many of these negative comments would we have if the name of the film weren't "My Sassy Girl?" Much fewer, I daresay. In my opinion, it's not as bad a film as everyone here is making it out to be. Rather, it's getting a nasty reputation not because people actually were turned off by the quality, but, rather, because people feel offended because they feel that this remake is sacrilegious toward the (oh-so-holy) original.

    Don't flame me. Not dissing the original. Just making an observation.

  • yeah! I so agree with you! Its not that bad as what other people think...I think it was actually nice and funny! An the casts were great! Both actors played their parts well and for some reason the guy in this remake is kinda good-looking than the one in the original...no offense to the fans but that's my opinion...

  • I agree, thank you. I quite enjoyed this movie and I've seen the Korean one.

  • haha looks so bad xD

  • This will not do the original justice... I can already tell. If this version doesn't totally suck ass, I will be very surprised. VERY surprised....

  • why don't you actually watch it before you say this?

  • Because the trailer contains sufficient material the the many shortcomings of this compared to the original are self evident. If this is the best they can cut into a 2:30 spot, and I can already feel my stomach churning at the injustice this pieces does, I'm uncertain that I could bear the full feature length of this.

    Also, if you read my comment carefully, you'll notice that I've left room for the possibility that it won't utterly fail.. if and when I decide it will actually be worth my time.

  • KOREAN VERSION is definitely the best. The concept is there but the execution of the characters are off. Elisha was not able to pull off the craziness of Ji Hyun. The original is always the best!!!!

  • I believe the time, effort, and budgets dedicated for this film wasn't enough and they picked the wrong leads for this film. All i can say for this film is - Good luck.

  • they look so much older than the korean actors...and the girl doesnt look half as cool XP

  • Hollywood is able even to make the best movie into a disaster!!!

  • This is so stupid, they just truned a totally good, funny movie into a retarted crap movie like other asian movies like; the eye, shutter, and grudge

  • NOOO

    THIS IS CRAP!

    korean version is the best.

  • by the way fhouse13... who sang it? thank you very much!!!

  • BTW guyz! i Know you don't like the Movie but, can i ask what's the title of the song in the last part. Im sooo... in love with that song! LOL thanks guyz!! ill check this comment every single time. thanks!

  • what's the title of the song on the last part of the trailer..?

  • oh never mind...it's 'waiting for you'...

  • what's the title of the song on the background..?

  • the korean version is much better than this.!.

  • stupid! I wont even bother to watch it anyone that has seen the real "my sassy girl" wouldn't waste their time watching this.

  • the "sassy-ness" of my sassy girl works for asian cultures, because the idea of an authoritative woman is still prevalent here (and it's acceptable). that doesn't translate well in the american culture.

    do you get what i mean?

  • what's the title of the song at the end of the trailer???

  • waiting for you...

  • the original is so much better than this crap... the trailer's horrible! and i'm betting the movie's way worse...

  • yeah, the movie slightly lost its funniness. the guy doesn't really look like an under treated fool and the girl isn't much of an authoritative girlfriend...

  • honestly, i don't feel anything special about this remake but i am still looking forward for this film..

  • i am frm India...nd I just saw My saay Girl...that is the Korean version...with the help of subtitles i watched the movie...really great..

    nd this looks pathetic...it just so american..even the hitting doesnt seem hard or funny...if trailer is like this...God knows how the movie is going to turn out

  • LMAO LMAO LMAO.

    dam americans!

  • garbage!

  • Seems like they totally forgot to make it funny. But then again that Korean humor doesn't translate over to American humor.

  • i agree! the korean version is waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa­aaaaaaaay better!

  • ugh .. im so disappointed.. y must they do a remake of this korean movie.. argh.. .. n it seems like they r basically doin the exact same thing to.. O_O..dissapointment..

  • korean version was really great! hope this one too...

  • what a dull remake. the original version is way better.

  • I feel like throwing up a bit.

  • just a bit??? no way... really want to throw up..goosh my eyes

  • korean version is better!!!!

  • elisha cuthberth is hot !! georgeous!

  • Aren't they a bit old?

  • i'm a huge fan of the original korean version. but i'm still looking forward to watching the american remake. don't go to the theatres expecting the "exact" same things. that just makes it predictable and boring. i suggest going into the theatre expecting an american take on the story. just enjoy it.

  • this is bull y they gotta take ideas that the koreans did and remake them. insult. just like the lakehouse. not cool.

  • OMG this isnt happening ==''

    the only part that had the same feeling as the original korean movie would be the part where she's beating him with the wooden sword....dude this movie looks depressing...SUPPOSE TO BE HUMOUROUS!!! hell depressing colours aswell

  • the original one which is the Asian My Sassy Girl is way better, have more humor, and more way the best!!!

  • doesn't have the same feeling as the original. it doesn't seem like she's sassy

    (def-1. Rude and disrespectful; impudent.

    2. Lively and spirited; jaunty.

    3. Stylish; chic:). she just seems crazy.

    it also doesn't seem as funny as the original,

  • haha I expect that this movie is worth to see~~I see Orginal My sassy girl so many times~ so I want to see different version~

  • hahaha looks like this movie is getting trashed into oblivion by everyone, no surprises there. We all know this is going to be very inferior. I'll probably watch this just to laugh at it as it fails and Jun Ji-hyun is sooo much prettier than whoever that blonde girl is, this sucks =[

  • Im gonna go pay 8 dollars to watch the remake of this epic movie and then complain for a week about how bad it sucked i guarantee it

  • Oh no! I cant believe they made a remake.. it will never be as good as the original!

  • O MAH GOD...!!! I can't believe....!!!!! they COPIED frm KOREAN MOVIE.. it's the same story.... the whole story is as same as the KOREAN MOVIE.....!!!!!!!

    it's kinda wierd...

  • It is such a real shame and travesty.

    The producers of this remake should be hanged for crimes against humanity.

    What are they gonna do next? Ruin another cult film like "battle royale"?

  • i hate when america try to remake asian drama... never as good.. this was lik my favorite movie ever,,, grrrrr....they re gonna make it suck

  • I died a little inside when i watched this trailer ]':

    Why cant they just leave the original alone

  • Man, this movie is going to be nowhere near as good as the original Korean version! Saw that movie about 6 or 7 years ago.  It was great. I smell another Hollywood remake disaster.

  • This actually looks a lot more faithful to the original movie than I thought it would be.

    Which might be a problem, just cuz there's certain things that work better in a Korean context than in American culture, and vice versa.

  • All I can say is that, Hollywood can no long make any movies. That is why they bother to just go and remake or make up stupid films.

    Remake such as; My Sassy Girl (WTF...), One Missed Call, Shutter, The Eye, The Grudge, Bangkok Dangerous, and Infernal Affair.

    If they can't remake, they just make a weird movie just for money.

  • its not good....

  • The original version i far better than this one. Its not even close!

  • HAHAHA WTF

  • possibly the worst film in the history of time.

    it's like the time when starbucks started selling chinese mooncakes in China.

    what the hell is hollywood doing?

    i want to vomit, literally.

  • i didn't really like the original one but i'm thinking the remake would be a disaster! Koreans are naturally funny and can make anything into a comedy. Though i think Adam Brody and Rachel Bilson could pull this off :)

  • I do love cameron diaz or drew barrymore to be the sassy girl... but still I love jesse for the role, I first saw him in "clock stopper" when I was a kid and "bring it on 1" when I was a teenager... ;p

  • Rachel Bilson!!! Thank you... I agree with you that this is a train wreck waiting to happen, but I just couldn't help racking my brain for anyone in Hollywood who might pull this off... now I can sleep. :)

  • omg when will it be shown?elisha is way to sexy for the role and not that sassy...

  • i hope they dont change the plot to make it MORE too western..

  • I hope the next movie they will remake is my most favorite korean movie

    "100 days with mr.arrogant".... bwahahahahahahahahahahahahaha!­!!!

  • r they going to remake it?

    *lol* that was hella funny!

  • well it's possible, they just have remaked "jenny and juno"... it's possible if they remake "100 days with mr.arrogant"..

  • I hope they'll make it wholesome! I'm an asian but, let's just give them a chance you know!!! but still the original one is better!!

  • I hate it. I hope americans would just stop making shitty remakes of asian films. I just hope that with this peopleget interested in the original film and watch it. It's getting boring that they can't come up with new ideas and just have to ruin wonderful films. I won't spend a single cent on this.

  • ... geezus guys, have an open mind.

    it doesn't look terrible, and i think it might actually be really good. when thinks are remade they aren't meant to be done frame for frame, other wise they would have just released the original. the point is to give it some new flair. other countries remake other movies too, it's not all that serious.

    just give it a chance guys, don't be so bitter about it

  • Yeah, I think I'm gonna agree with itendtoflail...

    I mean, I'm an Asian too, but tell you what, the Korean Version is soooo beautiful that it made me cry... The Hollywood Version is not yet been shown.. Let's give it a chance... So let's wait if it's going to suck or if it's going to be just okay...

    But I know the Korean Version will stay original and better among us... So, good luck for the Hollywood Version...

  • That is true what you said about remakes not being meant to be done frame by frame, and it is soo true that there are some good and really bad remakes out there. But is that 'new flair' just showing Elisha Cuthebert prancing around in cute clothes and making her being hot the center of the film? This piece of shit looks like it takes away the importance of the film, not focusing on its original concept. I was surprised by Elishas acting however; but the movie looks like a diluted piece of crap.

  • my god....this just really pisses me off

  • NO with a passion

  • I hope the next american remaker gets hit by lightning and dies alone on a forgotten island and gets hold of some tainted cheese in the same room with wolverine who's high on angel dust!! (accept scorsese)

    what I want to say is, if you can turn it into an oscar winner, give it a shot, otherwise, if its going to suck, atleast let it be your own idea!

  • i'm american i must say americans make good movies when they stick to making their own movies but not remakes of other countries movies its true watch the korean version before watching this flop movie and you'll see why and i'm not asian by the way

  • pathetic idiot...

  • You Cant be serious, solidstud...???

  • Americans have been doing horrible at making foreign to american remakes. They should have stopped after "The Ring". I'm not even going to waste my money on this. I'll just wait for the torrent. So I'll give it three words: "It will flop."

  • I LOVE MY SASSY GIRL! I'm surprised they changed the actors to make it American, when is it coming out?

  • another remake????

    whats da matter hollysh*t???

    run of ideas???

  • that is awful

  • How to ruin a perfect movie. Way to go americans dumbasses.

  • i agree and i'm american omg no just no i love the korean one why can't they just do what they did to crouching tiger hidden dragon just put subtitles man why keeping makin horrible remakes and why does she have blonde why can't she have brunette hair or black why is it always blonde xD and she's not really pretty she's average looking what a waste of film i guess they can't make good movies anymore so they decide to remake movies

  • nooooooooooooooooo

    But I'll watch it anyways just to see the differences and then watch the original again so that I can appreciate the original even more.

  • man..this does not look as good as the original...

  • AHHHH je suis dégoutéeeeeeeeeeeeee du remake qu'ils ont fait de l'un de mes films préférés this version suck!!!!!! The Korean version is much more fun and original and the choice of the actors is bad!!!!

    SEE THE ORIGINAL VERSION of kwak jae-jong!!!!!!!!

  • Oh God... x_x

  • wtf, why wud every1 says this movie sucked?is it bcoz elisha post herself as violent, is the point of making d "remake" better by making it more violent?you guys makes me sick, elisha cuthbert is awesome.

  • its not just because of elisha. its the WHOLE thing that sux!!!

  • How can I get the original movie?

  • Ruining a classic. dicks.

  • ughh.... i hate american remakes. i guess hollywood running outta ideas....

  • your right they are running out of ideas here is a list of a lot of American remakes of Asian Movies

    The Eye

    The lake house

    The Departed (okay movie not as good as internal affairs)

    GODZILLA

    and now My Sassy Girl

  • don't forget jenny and juno (juno)

  • Wait what Juno is not a remake. It won the academy award for best ORIGINAL Screenplay. even if it is a remake it's a very good one. and whats jenny

  • jenny & juno is a korean movie. the writer of Juno did say that she didnt take her ideas from that movie, its just that the whole teen pregnancy thing is similar. the difference is the boy's name is juno and the pregnant teen is jenny.

  • Really. are you by any chance asian knowing all this. is jenny & juno better than juno because juno will be hard to beat for me i loved that movie and ellen page looks so cute

  • seems cool. i wont pay to watch this though..original is always the best.

  • its not that i have anything against Korean to American movie remake but the original 'My Sassy Girl' should've stayed that way.

  • What a disaster!!! the remake will ruin everything!!

  • LOL wtf is this?... But hey!... Don't stop there yet "hollywood"... buy a remake contract to the Taxi series... Please do... the heck... why not even do a remake of "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon"!

  • based on the trailer, it comes short to what is expected.  i still love the first one.

  • Ugh..completely disappointed. :/ This remake looks like it's going to suck.

  • WHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAT?!?!?!? THEY RUIN MY SASSY GIRL!!!! omg that's GAAAY. the actors SO don't fit the description .. *sigh another good asian movie ruined -______-;

  • NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!Ji-­hyun!!why do they take you away?!!

  • remakes are yuck...

  • Disappointed!!!

    if they just released the original in the US with subs....

  • Crazy women are so much fun - until they start attacking the guy. Then the guy leaves and the girl gets even crazier...

  • She's not pretty enough. He's not dorky enough. They're not adorable enough. It's not funny enough.

  • Disappointed!

  • Disappointed!

  • What are they trying to do? This is a horrible remake, horrible! Must they ruin another perfectly good Asian movie? What's next, a remake of "Windstruck".

    This American actors and actresses can not compare to the original cast.

  • Damn you Hollywood!

  • way to ruin a classic. this remake looks so lame.

  • I just noticed an inconsistency on the poster.

    the tagline says that "the girl your mother warned you about."

    isn't it that male protaginist's mother in the original is really pursuing him to date the girl because the girl's boyfriend just died? and knowing that the mother is actually forcing him at the end is quite a twist to me [in the original.of course.].

    if americans tend to overloook such mistakes, no wonder they fail bringing the original a new style.

    does anyone agree?

  • Know your facts. The woman at the end was his aunt, not his mom.

    His mom scolded him in the middle saying about his aunt wanting him to meet a girl.

  • this is piece of shit. wtf is wrong with that fatass friend of his?

  • crap ! nothing beats the korean version.

    Hollywood! ! leave the asian films alone.

  • i hope they have the high heels.. hahaha..

  • THE KOREAN VERSION IS SOOOO MUCH BETTER!! THAT GIRL DOESNT PORTRAY THE PART AS WELL!!!!! AND THE KOREAN ONE IS SOOO MUCH CUTER.. SLAPPING? PSHH.. THE FLIKING PART IS FUNNIER... WATCH THE KOREAN ONE!!!

    yeah.. i tootlly agree about the slapping part!!! they better not butcher this movie.. and if they even try to copy windstruck.. arghh..!!

  • oh god. this is nothing like the korean movie at all. my sassy girl is my favorite movie of all time, in any language. i really really hope the movie is actually better than what the trailer seems to show. the girl is not sassy at all, and the guy is not goofy. the craziness and the goofiness of the 2 leads made the movie what it was. and why did they have to change the slapping scene on the subway? that was the funniest scene in the orig, imho. too bad america totally missed out on the original

  • ugh...judging by the trailer, i think the american version sorta lost the gist of the original one. i mean the girl here isn't even half as sassy as the korean actress!

  • jeon ji-hyun made the korean film a classic and i hope this is better then other remake, like the eye, pulse, one miss call, etc. i am wondering what name (if an) are they going to call the girl in the americn verison?

  • nothing beats the original :-).

    but i'm still gonna watch this movie...

  • I can't watch this I am so fucking pissed that there is another crappy american remake...geez butcher another fucking movie please

  • let me add... culture difference... thats why we should not do a 100% comparison from this remake from the original.. its obvious in the original, jeon ji-hyun is too violent.. not applicable for the american version.. -_-; hahaha!

  • Why!? Are you saying asians are violent!? Are you saying americans are so peaceful in their world!? You just spat in my face and I take what you said as an insult!!! Just accept the fact that Elisha can't act!!!

  • i think im going to watch this. i cant say whether this is good or not since i havent seen this yet.. at least we have to give it a chance before making a negative critic right? remakes are good but it doesnt necessarily mean that it should surpass the original but if it did, then the better.

  • wow!! its so unbelievable!!! i love this original also the character jeon ji-hyun. this is my all time favorte movie. and now it has a english version... shax!!! and the character is elisha cuthbert, am man when the first time i saw her in the movie of "the girl next door" i've been stunned of her beautiful looks! well, if elisha can read this comment i would say, I LOVE YOU! but i know its imposible. she's all i want in my life!! of course she's imposible though.

  • wow!! its so unbelievable!!! i love this original also the character jeon ji-hyun. this is my all time favorte movie. and now it has a english version... shax!!! and the character is elisha cuthbert, am man when the first time i saw her in the movie of "the girl next door" i've been stunned of her beautiful looks! well, if elisha can read this comment i would say, I LOVE YOU! but i know its imposible. she's all i want in my life!! of course she's imposible though.

  • wow!! its so unbelievable!!! i love this original also the character jeon ji-hyun. this is my all time favorte movie. and now it has a english version... shax!!! and the character is elisha cuthbert, am man when the first time i saw her in the movie of "the girl next door" i've been stunned of her beautiful looks! well, if elisha can read this comment i would say, I LOVE YOU! but i know its imposible. she's all i want in my life!! of course she's imposible though.

  • fack my life.

  • elisha doesn't have that ruthless edge that made the original so funny.

  • wtf

  • it already looks like it's not as good as the original. I'm still going to watch it though..

    But it's not going to replace the original. :P