You're missing the point. My 2 favorite bands are Yes and Genesis. I also played in tribute bands for both, so I know about odd time signatures. It's all down to taste, so I'm not here to insult your taste. What I am saying is that if you take PT, they rely more on melodic structure and feel w/ odd time thrown in. The melody isn't compromised whereas in DT LeBrie live is constantly off key and struggling and the music is near robotic at times. Different tastes is all.
@stevedrums ............These guys are huge Rush fans and do quite well...................And ruin their own songs??......................You Stevedrums, are not capable of carrying Portnoys stick bag...........or even Looking at Manginis stick bag for that matter!....Just about everyone has played tuvers/or in cover bands................and if you have you know you did not play every song NOTE for NOTE...........Oh yea, what did you come here for?
@mikeybbdrummin Whether I can carry his "bag" isn't the issue at all, so leats leave the 16 year old high school mentality off to the side, shall we? Having chops doesn't make one a legend. Originality does. There is absolutely nothing original about Portnoy's playing. Not one iota. Mangini - whom I didn't even mention - is a unique talent. The difference between the "math rock" they play compared to bands like Porcupine Tree is that PT has feel and melody. DT has none of that.
@stevedrums ..You came to a vid of a band you don't even like to talk crap about them??...no, that's not 16 year old behavior...Portnoy's style has not changed much over the years.but he still has a style that's been copied for years now....yes they love their progressive over the top playing....How would you know about what DT doesnt have if you don't listen to them.. and Studio drummers aren't legends because of originality.....its cause they have great feel and time.....Originality comes last
@mikeybbdrummin Some bands do Rush justice, so I mistakenly thought that they might. I have listened to them, obviously otherwise how else would I be able to opine about them? Look, they've been very successful in what they do. However, I just happen to believe that they don't say very much. Playing a million notes for the sake of doing it, doesn't say anything. You can disagree. It's a free country.
@stevedrums ...True........Playing a bunch of notes cause they can is no different then P. Tree, Spocks Beard, Rush and so on playing odd time signatures just cause they can............I guess it works for what the are doing whether it's fast slow, off time or whatever.................if thats the case, jazz should be dead w/all the playing that goes on!
Hate to Fuss and Bother You, monkey, but here's a banana two peels away from a bite. To be fanged within us all. Owl rock Scissors bat Paper birds of prey.
This is one of there better spot on Rush covers. They take there songs and make them there owen most of the time but this song and Tears are my favs for Rush covers
MY FAVORITE SONG BY RUSH AND ITS COVERED BY MY FAVORITE BAND!!
MrMarcKozma 4 months ago
You're missing the point. My 2 favorite bands are Yes and Genesis. I also played in tribute bands for both, so I know about odd time signatures. It's all down to taste, so I'm not here to insult your taste. What I am saying is that if you take PT, they rely more on melodic structure and feel w/ odd time thrown in. The melody isn't compromised whereas in DT LeBrie live is constantly off key and struggling and the music is near robotic at times. Different tastes is all.
stevedrums 4 months ago
Can't they just concentrate on ruining their own songs and leave other people's songs alone?
stevedrums 6 months ago
@stevedrums ............These guys are huge Rush fans and do quite well...................And ruin their own songs??......................You Stevedrums, are not capable of carrying Portnoys stick bag...........or even Looking at Manginis stick bag for that matter!....Just about everyone has played tuvers/or in cover bands................and if you have you know you did not play every song NOTE for NOTE...........Oh yea, what did you come here for?
mikeybbdrummin 4 months ago
@mikeybbdrummin Whether I can carry his "bag" isn't the issue at all, so leats leave the 16 year old high school mentality off to the side, shall we? Having chops doesn't make one a legend. Originality does. There is absolutely nothing original about Portnoy's playing. Not one iota. Mangini - whom I didn't even mention - is a unique talent. The difference between the "math rock" they play compared to bands like Porcupine Tree is that PT has feel and melody. DT has none of that.
stevedrums 4 months ago
@stevedrums ..You came to a vid of a band you don't even like to talk crap about them??...no, that's not 16 year old behavior...Portnoy's style has not changed much over the years.but he still has a style that's been copied for years now....yes they love their progressive over the top playing....How would you know about what DT doesnt have if you don't listen to them.. and Studio drummers aren't legends because of originality.....its cause they have great feel and time.....Originality comes last
mikeybbdrummin 4 months ago
@mikeybbdrummin Some bands do Rush justice, so I mistakenly thought that they might. I have listened to them, obviously otherwise how else would I be able to opine about them? Look, they've been very successful in what they do. However, I just happen to believe that they don't say very much. Playing a million notes for the sake of doing it, doesn't say anything. You can disagree. It's a free country.
stevedrums 4 months ago
@stevedrums ...True........Playing a bunch of notes cause they can is no different then P. Tree, Spocks Beard, Rush and so on playing odd time signatures just cause they can............I guess it works for what the are doing whether it's fast slow, off time or whatever.................if thats the case, jazz should be dead w/all the playing that goes on!
mikeybbdrummin 4 months ago
intro is cygnus x-1: the voyage, yyz, tom sawyer.
GhostofPerditions 8 months ago
a little YYZ in the intro, too.
Rush is amazing!
rubey09 9 months ago
My Yearbook quote...Love this song so much...Its Rush
Tod661 10 months ago
Hate to Fuss and Bother You, monkey, but here's a banana two peels away from a bite. To be fanged within us all. Owl rock Scissors bat Paper birds of prey.
Along my ass, for the ride on the talons?
SuperMegaUberGenius 10 months ago
Maybe he does say tay idk lol hard to tell, its like he says both!
CrawfordDrummer 1 year ago
@CrawfordDrummer said tic toc in atomic, perhaps
SuperMegaUberGenius 10 months ago
3:20 Great cover but its Nie-eve-uh-tAY, not Nie-eve-uh-tee :P lol makes the song
CrawfordDrummer 1 year ago
I wonder if we could get an interview put up on You Tube - between DT, Rush & Maiden explaining the interaction between the bands.
Wag2112 1 year ago
They tried... but no one can do like Rush can!
linuxjl 1 year ago
I love this song I love RUSH good cover
vitolo2 1 year ago
This would do Rush proud any day!
Xanaseb 1 year ago
nice, but, reffering to the description, I don't hear them play Lakeside Park or The Body Electric,
Ovningskora 1 year ago
@Ovningskora
6:10 portnoy plays the intro drum fill to lakeside park
6:20 the intro to the body electric
RushRulesRock 1 year ago 3
whose come to slay the mother fuckin dragon. big respect to both bands
Yamah12a 1 year ago
a great song to cover. it was definitely not one of their biggest hits and it is a truly amazing song. glad someone remembers the classic :)
mrskeithmoon 1 year ago
Damn sexy guitar solo!!!!
camarowish 1 year ago
good band but biggest rush copyers in the world
VenumosFate 1 year ago
they cover rush not because they try to copy, but because rush was one of their biggest idols
biloxi1314 1 year ago
@VenumosFate DAMN RIGHT!!!
MY DREAM CAMEFINALLY TRUE AFTER I SAW THE THREE CANADIANS AT THE NATIONAL STADIUM IN CHILE!!!
rettersp 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@VenumosFate DAMN RIGHT!!!
MY DREAM CAME FINALLY TRUE AFTER I SAW THE THREE CANADIANS AT THE NATIONAL STADIUM IN CHILE!!!
rettersp 1 year ago
my 2 bands of my life....Rush and DTheater.....
santyrush 2 years ago 2
This is one of there better spot on Rush covers. They take there songs and make them there owen most of the time but this song and Tears are my favs for Rush covers
KcuFeM2 2 years ago
This is absolutely a great cover! I have this song from DT when they mixed it with "la villa strangiato". Even greater!!!
jaapverouden 2 years ago
sweet
Ilovehamsters1231 2 years ago 2
WOW !
Thanx !
5 stars and favs.
K2K3Y 2 years ago 5
One of my favorite Rush song...great DT cover!
YYZSoHoYYZ 2 years ago 9