That is too jolty... plus people if you want to learn this song... Andy Mckee himself made a tutorial for this song. look that up. what better way to learn a beautiful song than from the master himself?
Left hand is WAAAAAAAAAY off. I didn't watch this vid until I saw your tutorial and I was like, "What? Melody isn't 'on -beat' here! The 'beat' is the same all the time!". So I just had to watch this, and now I hear that it is waaaay wrong. Your good anyways, its just the 'beat' that is wrong.
this is fantastic, and better than i can play it, but the 3rd and 4th bass hits in the main riff should be an 8th later than they are. they end up syncopated against the right hand instead of dead on.
Heh, I think you have to be ADHD or somethin' to play the way Andy Mckee, Don Ross, or Phil Keagey play, 'cause you've got to keep a bass, melody, and percussion all at the same time in a single song on a single guitar. . .guess I have a pretty good head-start then. =P
This is not negative feed back, Mainly because i'm still in the middle of learning this song (Well just the bit after the verse thing - 0:45 to 1:00 that's the only bit I'm learning) But, You're hammer on's (2nd 5th and 7th threat on E and A) during 0:16 and 0:31 you're doing it a bit to quick, Think of it as when you're about to hammer on... You should do it a beat after you did it in this video. Pretty good i must say.. I'll record mine sometime and show you what i mean. Much love.
great how to's bro. simple enough for beginers to understand and specific enough to where we all know what the hell we are doing! XD lol but play a tad bit slower. its like lifting weights. if you do it to fast, its not helping anything. constructive critisisim! :D you did an amazing job though!
Also I owe you my balls in payment of your tutorial, I've been watching it again and again for the past 5 hours and still can't get through the first part of the song so rushed or not, this cover is fucking great.
awesome dude!! i got a few things to talk about, but all the other people commented about what i was going to say as a fellow musician. one thing i MUST say is that those headphones look awesome!! what are they? and also, your tutorials are legitimately the best tutorials i have EVER watched!! YouTube and off youtube too!! great job dude
1 crit only. the 5th and 7th tapped bars arnt coming on the off beat like they should be. You are playing them on the off beat at the same time as the melody (19 sec)... the melody should come first. really good keep it up. :)
one one crit. the tabed bar on the 5th and 7th fret arnt on the off beat like they should be. your playin them at the same time as the melody which should come first. kepp it up
After the drumming intro your playing it wrong. you bar the fith and tap the 6th on G at the same time and its the same with the bar on the 7th and tap the 6th on the G, you're supposed to hit them at the same time, your supposed to bar the 5th and 7th one note early and then tap the 6th and continue with the song. watch andy play it and youlll what i mean. if your still confused im talking about from 0:18 to 0:25
brilliant quality and good playing but your timing on the bass-hammerons in the chorus is different from andys play. he always hammers them on a downbeat, 4 on the floor, you do 2 downbeat-hammerons on the 2nd fret, then you do a upbeat-hammeron on the 5th a half beat too early and a upbeat hammeron on the 7th. propably it was your intention to do it like this, idk.
You definitely had your own interpretation of his song. And I must admit it's pretty fast. But hey, I give you props for learning it. I'm learning it right now, and it is soooo difficult to play!! Thanks for sharing. :]
you're so great dud.i'm so impress. i'm so thankful that you made a tutorial of this wonderful song.. it's very helpful for me because i really try hard to learn that song. Where did you buy you're guitar? it's so nice. may i have one? heheh just kidding.
Congratulations , this is the way to sound , working to hard , so you need to equalice the final sound , cose is to brilliant but bery good , see you .
@klearlykahmerican people learn how to play and become better players and songwriters when they actually learn the tune. By doing this you can make up your own stuff. Nice how you throw someone into all those categories. Where are your songs? Do you actually play an instrument? You shouldn't be so angry and bitter.
@klearlykahmerican LETS SEE YOU PLAY IT. ARE YOUR EYES OPEN? ALMOST HALF OF YOUTUBE IS PLAYING COVERS OF OTHER PEOPLE SONGS. Good day to you, asswipe.
Nice Guitar! It's an Ibanez no? There's the tree of life on the neck, same thing on the Steve Vai Signature Guitar. What did u pay for it? I'm looking to buy the same. How do u like that guitar?
I'm new to youtube and decided I would check out the happenings, I came across you playing guitar. Being a guitar player myself, i appreciated your sound. I'll check out the rest now. stretch
Eh It it a good effort Andy I was not feeling insulted... I'm gonna buy that same guitar today a can hear your guitar's slight twang and bluegrass pitch... it sounds like what I am lookin for....
Honeslty this is pretty good, you gotta admit. So what if it's fast? If it sounds freaking good then I'd give'm 5 Stars. I am learning it from this video for my guitar class.
the hammered chords with the left hand and the first tapped note of the melody with the right hand in the first part aren't supposed to be on the same beat. andy doesn't play them at the same time like you're doing
I saw your tutorial, and it helped a great deal in order for me to play it. In fact, it only took me only a day to learn the entire song structure.
Thanks a lot!However, I realized that the rhythm on the verse part is always off beat, never played on the beat, as you explained on the tutorial. Perhaps that'll perfect your performance!
dude u got it all wrong...the part when u play both the chord and the plucking at the same time is not it..the plucking comes slightly before the chord hammers on
hey cappi666! ur a really good player, but this seems to be your only guitar cover. Upload some new stuff, I would personally love to check them out : )
your tutorials have helped me SO much! I am ussually, to impatient to take time to learn somgs like these, but yu made it easy for me. Thanks a ton!!!
this guy is so incredible.. me im a hot headed guy im not capable teaching and im really not good at it, but with his tutorial helps me to be patient ^_^
yeah good work, the tutorial vids helped loads ta, but like Ghiltzisme (2 months ago) said be gentle with it, its not a race!... but that was posted 2 months ago so you probably nail it now, fair one matey keep it up.
lol you go so fast, is more slowly the song sometimes you go so faster. and you have to type more good your fingers, it sounds bad. but good job to learn the song.
Comment removed
ooOBrightOoo 1 month ago
Comment removed
ooOBrightOoo 1 month ago
Really great cover. The only criticism I have is that the third and fourth bass parts in the main section are an eighth after the melody.
cavehobo1 2 months ago
holy shizzle mate, this is amazing!
bushwa83 5 months ago
nice boaa :)
Rek999999999 5 months ago
That is too jolty... plus people if you want to learn this song... Andy Mckee himself made a tutorial for this song. look that up. what better way to learn a beautiful song than from the master himself?
Groundbrawl 6 months ago
Left hand is WAAAAAAAAAY off. I didn't watch this vid until I saw your tutorial and I was like, "What? Melody isn't 'on -beat' here! The 'beat' is the same all the time!". So I just had to watch this, and now I hear that it is waaaay wrong. Your good anyways, its just the 'beat' that is wrong.
DiViNiTY1337 6 months ago
Is there a face in there somewhere?
corvettecentral 10 months ago
You need to work on your left hand buddy
andysbrother1 11 months ago
very good..and tks for the lessons... but you forgot so many harmonics, almost all of then... why didn't you used it?
carlimaguiar 11 months ago
amazing
xsniper89x 1 year ago
how much ur guitar?
antizicoh 1 year ago
@antizicoh
thomann.de/de/ibanez_aw40ece_dvs.htm
xsniper89x 1 year ago
great job man! it is not an easy song to play, but it is very rewarding
musicman4YaEh 1 year ago
Good, but not that feeling...
In Andys version you can touch his feelings...
XxChEqQaxX 1 year ago
nice work!
check out my cover of drifting! keep it up =D
chillguitar94 1 year ago
GREAT.... Playing Drifting rushed means that youve really got it down.. keep it up bro!!!
drsodan 1 year ago
this is fantastic, and better than i can play it, but the 3rd and 4th bass hits in the main riff should be an 8th later than they are. they end up syncopated against the right hand instead of dead on.
BurdeeProductions 1 year ago
WHERE IS THE GROOVE MAN ?
nobody play this song like him....
relax, and work..... ;p
zouz55 1 year ago
i can follow part 1 and the beginning of part 2. but how the fuck are you doing the next parts. big up man !
roellpeterss 1 year ago
Comment removed
MrMcferro 1 year ago
it was really awesome!!
LeoBrazil89 1 year ago
Heh, I think you have to be ADHD or somethin' to play the way Andy Mckee, Don Ross, or Phil Keagey play, 'cause you've got to keep a bass, melody, and percussion all at the same time in a single song on a single guitar. . .guess I have a pretty good head-start then. =P
theawesomesara 1 year ago
thank you so much dude i can play it all!!!
time to go get my di*k wet! lol jk dont need the guitar for that
deathbyzza420 1 year ago
This is not negative feed back, Mainly because i'm still in the middle of learning this song (Well just the bit after the verse thing - 0:45 to 1:00 that's the only bit I'm learning) But, You're hammer on's (2nd 5th and 7th threat on E and A) during 0:16 and 0:31 you're doing it a bit to quick, Think of it as when you're about to hammer on... You should do it a beat after you did it in this video. Pretty good i must say.. I'll record mine sometime and show you what i mean. Much love.
Frickenlickengood 1 year ago
great how to's bro. simple enough for beginers to understand and specific enough to where we all know what the hell we are doing! XD lol but play a tad bit slower. its like lifting weights. if you do it to fast, its not helping anything. constructive critisisim! :D you did an amazing job though!
cobaltw 1 year ago
haha your playing it wrong bud.
you taught me how. so we made the same mistake
suchpimpness 1 year ago
You made me buy that guitar!!! :D
Recharte 1 year ago
do another cover made because its gr8 !! only slow it down a little because its not the spped that makes it a beautiful peice its the altogether sund
arronmiddlemiss1 1 year ago
Amazing cover compared to most that I've seen.
Also I owe you my balls in payment of your tutorial, I've been watching it again and again for the past 5 hours and still can't get through the first part of the song so rushed or not, this cover is fucking great.
That's again for the tutorial!
guitayrplaya 1 year ago
Nice work, but tune your guitar better next time you post something(!)
AsmundSO 1 year ago
Good, but I think you should the harmonics a little bit harder.
Also on the part after the intro, you kinda play the rhythms a bit wrong when you hammer the 5th and 7th.
But other than that it's really good :)
YuchanSaurusRex 1 year ago
丁寧でわかりやすいし綺麗な音が出ていると思います!!
しょっぱなと最後のベース音のタイミング(timing)がズレてますよね??
レッスンの時からズレてましたがまさか最後の演奏までズレていたとは。
徹底的な勘違い?でもこの人の出す音は優しい音なので凄く好きです。
dafadafrer 1 year ago
those flowers in the edge of the guitar really look like the ibanez jem's :P
pekisi 1 year ago
i'm thinking of buying this guitar soon ... would you say it has more of a cheerful tone or a more somber tone ?
calmicky 1 year ago
awesome dude!! i got a few things to talk about, but all the other people commented about what i was going to say as a fellow musician. one thing i MUST say is that those headphones look awesome!! what are they? and also, your tutorials are legitimately the best tutorials i have EVER watched!! YouTube and off youtube too!! great job dude
AnderUnplugged 1 year ago
youve got one too many pats of the guitar in the first part, pretty wrong sounding immediately
jaygnap 1 year ago
1 crit only. the 5th and 7th tapped bars arnt coming on the off beat like they should be. You are playing them on the off beat at the same time as the melody (19 sec)... the melody should come first. really good keep it up. :)
mrchu2 1 year ago
one one crit. the tabed bar on the 5th and 7th fret arnt on the off beat like they should be. your playin them at the same time as the melody which should come first. kepp it up
mrchu2 1 year ago
Perfect
SatanicXblood 1 year ago
good but watch the timeing
alilmetalkid 1 year ago
not bad actually... but please, remove those bracelets before recording.
barrf02 1 year ago
After the drumming intro your playing it wrong. you bar the fith and tap the 6th on G at the same time and its the same with the bar on the 7th and tap the 6th on the G, you're supposed to hit them at the same time, your supposed to bar the 5th and 7th one note early and then tap the 6th and continue with the song. watch andy play it and youlll what i mean. if your still confused im talking about from 0:18 to 0:25
AttilaWMC 1 year ago
brilliant quality and good playing but your timing on the bass-hammerons in the chorus is different from andys play. he always hammers them on a downbeat, 4 on the floor, you do 2 downbeat-hammerons on the 2nd fret, then you do a upbeat-hammeron on the 5th a half beat too early and a upbeat hammeron on the 7th. propably it was your intention to do it like this, idk.
DaDooM88 1 year ago
u play so much good ..
but the guitar sounds like BZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ !!
psppoy 1 year ago
the bass line does not hit at the same time as the hammer ons. its a little bit wrong in that section....
halohater9 1 year ago
really nice. What do you think of the AW40 guitar? Is it a good buy?
Arttuonline 1 year ago
timing is all wrong......on the power chords....whats with the headphones?????
halohater9 1 year ago
@halohater9 it is so he can hear what he sounds like
fenderstrat707 1 year ago
Very good, the rhythm is interesting, and simply original, not wrong. Howgh!
MultiParasite 1 year ago
Very nice cover!you did the bass notes, and the overall rythm of the song quite rushed, you may want to relax a bit :) nice anyay!
digitwiz 1 year ago
Your timing is brutal...
hotpinkpaul 1 year ago 15
your rhythm is wrong in the "verse" but good otherwise
wattsy1000 1 year ago
i learned it using your tutorials, now go watch my cover :P!
ZacharySmith22 1 year ago
amazing but i think it´s a bit fast
xXwarstuserXx 1 year ago
very good lesson! :) I teach this. GREETINGS from Poland. Joł! ;)
kali2114 1 year ago
You definitely had your own interpretation of his song. And I must admit it's pretty fast. But hey, I give you props for learning it. I'm learning it right now, and it is soooo difficult to play!! Thanks for sharing. :]
yaffytaffy12345 1 year ago
please don't play like a chick....
BrotherBagel 1 year ago 3
good job! check out my version
aurback 1 year ago
you're so great dud.i'm so impress. i'm so thankful that you made a tutorial of this wonderful song.. it's very helpful for me because i really try hard to learn that song. Where did you buy you're guitar? it's so nice. may i have one? heheh just kidding.
thanks dud. I'm Jhenward from Philippines.
JhenBualat 1 year ago
helped me out a lot with your tutorials thanks
but the only mistake you made was that the 2 5 and 7 line is actually all off beats
Vpain90009 1 year ago
Congratulations , this is the way to sound , working to hard , so you need to equalice the final sound , cose is to brilliant but bery good , see you .
elmestra 1 year ago
your timing around 17 seconds is off. your slaps slow down. the tapped notes arent on the same beat as the bass notes.
DustD91 1 year ago
@DustD91 At least he played it... show us your one.
TheNameisSpeed 1 year ago
i learned this song in 4 or 5 hours and i can play it pretty well
Copilot24 1 year ago
lets hear it copilot
pheelux 1 year ago
Dude, you were not on tempo, you kept speeding up, and you don't hammer on the power chords until after you hit the bottom notes.
matthewkasulka 1 year ago
I have those headphones too, they sound really nice, lots of bass ;) cool stuff
MaybeYesNo90 1 year ago
Nice but it keeps changing tempo.
IXconnorXI 1 year ago
Good but seems a little rushed
alecnguyen35 1 year ago 43
Nice job man. I know It would take me ages to learn that.
diamonddust22 1 year ago
little tiny bit fast but that was pretty good mate well done :) x
pollypowell 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Man you rock. It must be so hard to break down Andy's song and play it for yourself. Copying people's work is so original.
Take your Brit-goth-emo-asian-punk shinanigans elsewhere.
@Stretch836...this is why copycats don't deserve credit. Look up Andy Mckee, the person who wrote the fucking song.
klearlykahmerican 2 years ago
@klearlykahmerican people learn how to play and become better players and songwriters when they actually learn the tune. By doing this you can make up your own stuff. Nice how you throw someone into all those categories. Where are your songs? Do you actually play an instrument? You shouldn't be so angry and bitter.
diamonddust22 1 year ago
@klearlykahmerican it funny how jealously can lead up too.
kbedard55 1 year ago
@klearlykahmerican LETS SEE YOU PLAY IT. ARE YOUR EYES OPEN? ALMOST HALF OF YOUTUBE IS PLAYING COVERS OF OTHER PEOPLE SONGS. Good day to you, asswipe.
TheNameisSpeed 1 year ago
Nice Guitar! It's an Ibanez no? There's the tree of life on the neck, same thing on the Steve Vai Signature Guitar. What did u pay for it? I'm looking to buy the same. How do u like that guitar?
Slowhand1981 2 years ago
see video discription...
wijnand55 1 year ago
OMFG!!
D133GO 2 years ago
the bass notes do not hit at the same time with your right hand...doesnt it sound a lil wierd to you.....
halohater9 2 years ago
I'm new to youtube and decided I would check out the happenings, I came across you playing guitar. Being a guitar player myself, i appreciated your sound. I'll check out the rest now. stretch
Stretch836 2 years ago 2
Nice cover, although isn't that the AW40 ECE as its electro-acoustic? Although its colour seems lighter than the RDV...?
AndyHayward1989 2 years ago
Gotta love the HD 485's
Airsoftfun371 2 years ago 2
great job dude..
I've learned this song from your tutorial..
but may b you can fix the "on-beat & off-beat" part of your "Part II" video.
Overall.. NICE..
see my video response..
p0t0ngrambut 2 years ago
lol not bad to fast, but yeah the tutorial u gave, clearly sums it all up ^_^ any way
nice going
LeonLight13 2 years ago
yeah
his cover contains many errors.. ^^
feriz12 2 years ago
nice playing ;-)
your guitar looks like my AW 40 ECE Resonant Dark violin lol
Skulldron 2 years ago
nice try
cant compare to the feeling andy plays it with
but nice technique
FredyM101 2 years ago 2
Eh It it a good effort Andy I was not feeling insulted... I'm gonna buy that same guitar today a can hear your guitar's slight twang and bluegrass pitch... it sounds like what I am lookin for....
RedzKapay 2 years ago
Honeslty this is pretty good, you gotta admit. So what if it's fast? If it sounds freaking good then I'd give'm 5 Stars. I am learning it from this video for my guitar class.
dylansladefield 2 years ago
Cut your hair, hippy
jroose14 2 years ago
a little fast but ok
Inf3rn027 2 years ago
the hammered chords with the left hand and the first tapped note of the melody with the right hand in the first part aren't supposed to be on the same beat. andy doesn't play them at the same time like you're doing
suemusicdown 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Hehe..You should watch Andy before you post those learning videos
turbosolan 2 years ago
pretty perfect
QymLym 2 years ago 2
I think it Sounds good fast,
Zman200111 2 years ago
ur as good as he is!
Spairtain117 2 years ago
I saw your tutorial, and it helped a great deal in order for me to play it. In fact, it only took me only a day to learn the entire song structure.
Thanks a lot!However, I realized that the rhythm on the verse part is always off beat, never played on the beat, as you explained on the tutorial. Perhaps that'll perfect your performance!
kentokanazawa 2 years ago 2
dude u got it all wrong...the part when u play both the chord and the plucking at the same time is not it..the plucking comes slightly before the chord hammers on
Ralteman 2 years ago
not really wrong, i think its just the beginning rhythm.
kentokanazawa 2 years ago
who cares
tzcxgfyt 2 years ago
Yes! Ralteman is right! I can play this song, and this guy plays it wrong...
turbosolan 2 years ago
its better then you can play it
colbertnation982 2 years ago 2
hey cappi666! ur a really good player, but this seems to be your only guitar cover. Upload some new stuff, I would personally love to check them out : )
Andorably 2 years ago
great job!!! a little fast, but no big deal.
your tutorials have helped me SO much! I am ussually, to impatient to take time to learn somgs like these, but yu made it easy for me. Thanks a ton!!!
MusCabINi 2 years ago
slow it down brah! otherwise good
ledhead213 2 years ago
This is really great! i´m trying to learn this song right now and your tutorials have really helped. Thanks for making it easier! ^-^
spybarn 2 years ago
this guy is so incredible.. me im a hot headed guy im not capable teaching and im really not good at it, but with his tutorial helps me to be patient ^_^
great job man impressed
5handz 2 years ago
A bit fast - but really really amazing.
Im currently following your impressive tutorials and cant wait to play as well as you!
Keep it up (y)
wilfredisback 2 years ago 22
awsome man thanks for teaching this song
fishingtrojan 2 years ago
too fast!!! where's the interpretation??
rufycappellodipaglia 2 years ago
too fast, but still very impressive.
darthruune 2 years ago
Very well played technically, but musically lacking rhythm.
meangreen4321 2 years ago 2
thats amazing dude... awesome rendition!!! 5/5
alfalfasprout69 2 years ago
yeah good work, the tutorial vids helped loads ta, but like Ghiltzisme (2 months ago) said be gentle with it, its not a race!... but that was posted 2 months ago so you probably nail it now, fair one matey keep it up.
Denmaaan 2 years ago
yeah it is too fast but the his video on how to play the song is really good
pissoff456 2 years ago
slow it down a little bit!
shnap012 2 years ago
the bass line is wrong, but good work on the hole song :]
byveris 2 years ago
Song name????
Btw. beautifull played buddy :)
Duryodhana 2 years ago
I think it's only Drifting...
Kusmanex 2 years ago
"Drifting"
Jboogiemusic 2 years ago
watch mine.. :)
johnzenluke 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Nice man!
Check out my performance!
AlastairOD 2 years ago
thats a beautiful guitar
danwatson4556 2 years ago
muito bom, só o tempo que realmente ficou muito fora, rápido demais em algumas partes e lento demais em outras...
mas ficou bem mais legal do alguns outros covers q vi por aqui...
toad182 2 years ago
mann thats brilliant
skidood7393 2 years ago
lol you go so fast, is more slowly the song sometimes you go so faster. and you have to type more good your fingers, it sounds bad. but good job to learn the song.
dvdcobrador 2 years ago 2
what is a Groovetubes Fatfinger?
Angealolo 2 years ago
Is it a medical condition that some bassist get if they dont warm up?!
tensago 2 years ago
a clamp that you put on the headstock to increase the mass of the guitar; and therefore, the sustain
gtrtuben 2 years ago
just need the timing of the chords and the tapping right and it will be great!
also if you use something other than a mic or change the mic placement that would help the thin sound
h4ngwak 2 years ago
está errado o tempo, idiota!!
cade a noção ritmica?
skiba13 2 years ago
good but you're timing the bar chords wrong during the first part after the intro
laaarsas 2 years ago 2
omg =O
you've got some skillz right there ^^
MrManson94 2 years ago 3
nice work but be a more gentle. your doing things too fast and your losing a little rhythm. but you did a great job
Ghiltzisme 2 years ago
that is just FUCKING SICK!! 5 stars from sweden
niclashbg 2 years ago
awesome
webinz123 2 years ago 3
beautiful guitar...great job...andy mckee is very difficulf for do his cover...learn nakagawa san!!!!!! XD
roytek444 2 years ago
Great playing. Perhaps tone needs a little compression to pick out some of those softer notes? Good work fella!
JoJo72X 2 years ago
It was a little fast, but otherwise great job :) Just slow it down a mite :D You have a real talent there, sir :) Keep up the great work!
FalseSympathy 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Nice job man!
Check it out my and my friend did a dual on Drifting :D
/watch?v=W5YTA3oMH-o
Or go to my profile to see :D
stebbifreakout 2 years ago
wow great work, so aweome
LedZeppelinPage 3 years ago
That, Sir.
Was amazingly epic
HerzH 3 years ago